* Posts by alain williams

2469 publicly visible posts • joined 29 May 2007

Negative Trustpilot review of law firm Summerfield Browne cost aggrieved Briton £28k

alain williams Silver badge

The legal mafia ...

look after their own.

There are plenty of crap solicitors around. Some act so as to increase what they charge you. Others do not seem to know what they are doing, eg when buying a house nothing happens and both sides blame the other for the delay.

There are also some good ones. It is hard to tell the difference until you have been through the case.

150,000 lost UK police records looking more like 400,000 as Home Office continues to blame 'human error'

alain williams Silver badge

Re: rm -r *

No. The rm command is long running. Once it is started it will run until it has removed everything that was asked to remove. Neither does it invoke rmdir, it can do that itself. (All subject to permissions, etc.)

alain williams Silver badge

Re: rm -r *

Surely:

# rm -rf /

alain williams Silver badge

Re: UK Data Protection law and GDPR

In theory backups should be cleaned as well, but in practice that is usually not practical.The important thing here is putting the deleted data "beyond use". So it might still be on a tape/... but it cannot be accessed through normal use/mechanisms.

Four women seek release from forced arbitration to sue Infosys for widespread gender discrimination

alain williams Silver badge

Unfair contracts

Be careful what you sign, contracts aren't just for fun.

Often the first time that you see the contract is after you have accepted the job and told your current employer that you are leaving. If, at interview, you ask for a copy of the contract you will probably be labelled a troublemaker and not be offered the job.

Contracts should be published along with the job advertisement.

The CIA's 'entire' collection of UFO records has been made available for you to sigh at

alain williams Silver badge

If there is nothing there ...

why did the CIA just not hand all of what they had over when first asked ?

Is it part of some CIA mindset ?

What's that you got there, AMD? More Ryzen chips? Yeah, OK, we could do with some of those

alain williams Silver badge

Am I the only one who is confused ...

by the way that these things are described ?

OK: I understand numbers like: frequency, cores, cache but what is the difference between: a desktop processor; a business system processor; a server processor ?

These differences might well be written somewhere but it is not easily found and described in an obvious way.

Also: what is the difference between, say, a Ryzen 9 5980HX and the AMD FX-8150 that is on my desk ? (ignoring easy to understand frequency, cache, cores, ....) I suspect new instructions to help with video decoding, AES (Rijndael encryption), ... but finding mention of these is almost impossible.

This is something that El Reg could explain or point to and would be much more useful than telling me how fast it runs World of Warcraft - or some other game that I have zero interest in.

And: CPU frequency is useless when comparing different architectures (AMD, Intel, ARM, Power, ...) so how about something like SPEC ?

Thou shalt not hack indiscriminately, High Court of England tells Britain's spy agencies

alain williams Silver badge

Re: So presumably they will just carry on as before anyway

I do understand the need to occasionally do something illegal when, overall, it is of benefit to society.

The hard part is keeping them** honest, ie not acting in their own interests or the interests of whoever is powerful today. Judicial oversight can help but the judiciary can be corrupt or naive - we have seen that many times.

What we need is for all to be revealed when a particular investigation/... is done and/or after 20 years or something. It may help to keep some of them** honest - knowing that their acts will be exposed to sunlight, it will also help to phrase future legislation if bounds have been overstepped.

** Whatever "them" means in various contexts.

Your 60-second guide to what Intel announced at CES. Or in 5 seconds: New laptop chips

alain williams Silver badge

I stopped reading ...

when there was mention of Artificial Intelligence which generally precedes a description of snake oil.

TikTok to be hit by a UK class-action-style lawsuit backed by the Children's Commissioner

alain williams Silver badge

Minimum age for contract

In the UK is 7 - but until they reach 18 (the age of majority) they can cancel at any time as it is presumed that they do not understand the implications of entering into the contract.

So: if a minor cancels - will TikTok/whoever have to delete all information that they have learned about the child ?

What about personal information gleaned about someone who has not entered a contract, be they minors or not - think facebook shadow profiles which probably take copies of personal data out side of the UK/EEA which is illegal. Facebook is fighting the Irish data protection authority over this - so it probably does move data out of the EEA.

Others are just as bad or worse, start with Google.

I doubt that many really implement Art. 17 of the GDPR (right to be forgotten)

Brexit freezes 81,000 UK-registered .eu domains – and you've all got three months to get them back

alain williams Silver badge

This is to punish the UK

Something that Michel Barnier has often said that he is not doing ... things like this make it plain that he is as honest as any other politician.

Where in the world is Jack Ma? Alibaba tycoon not seen since October after slamming Chinese government

alain williams Silver badge

And we still do business with China ?

The richer that China gets the more confident that it will be and believe that it can get away with this sort of thing. This case is internal to China, but it is exerting its might beyond its borders.

We are so incredibly short sighted. We think that we are saving pennies but are unaware that we selling our futures. Eg Amazon is entering pharmacy, it will kill much of retail pharmacy in the UK, along that we lose thousands of skilled, well paid jobs replacing them with minimum wage warehouse grunts; Amazon will put our prescriptions into its marketing database and use this to try to sell us more stuff and destroy more other businesses.

Singapore changes the rules and will now use COVID-19 contact-tracing app data in criminal cases

alain williams Silver badge

Is anyone really surprised ?

Especially in an authoritarian state like Singapore.

The same is likely to happen elsewhere. Initially it will only be for "exceptional cases", you know the ones: paedophones, terrorists, drug dealers ... The scope will secretly widen over time.

Julian Assange will NOT be extradited to the US over WikiLeaks hacking and spy charges, rules British judge

alain williams Silver badge

Have those who he exposed ...

as committing war crimes been prosecuted by the USA ? Think of those in the helicopter gunship video.

If it had been British soldiers who did they they would fave faced a trial.

No amount of Glasgow handshaking will revive this borked kiosk

alain williams Silver badge

I see no image

just an instruction telling me to switch on javascript. If they cannot display an image without javascript then they are doing it wrong; either that or they want something else - probably my personal information.

Red Hat defends its CentOS decision, claims Stream version can cover '95% of current user workloads'

alain williams Silver badge

Re: The RedHat corporate spinners won't fix this

Perhaps unsurprisingly, the more complicated your setup and customizations, the more trouble changing is, and the more you will realise the differences.

This is the key and this is why I liked CentOS - I put a lot of work into getting the machine exactly as I want it and, by and large, not have do much sysadmin for 9 years (other than installing completely new stuff).

I have upgraded from CentOS 6 to Debian 10 on my desktop ** most of it was not a problem, some details were hard; over and above running s/ware a decade newer.

** To get a decent desktop manager - which Gnome 3 is not.

NHS trust launches £60m software procurement to improve staffing efficiency

alain williams Silver badge

IR35

I have friends who do temporary work in the NHS, eg a few months pregnancy cover. They were one of the first to be hit by IR35; things like not being able to reclaim travel and accommodation when working at a hospital too far from home for a daily commute. The result is that they are more pickey at what gigs they will accept and are moving away from the NHS.

I suppose that the real problem is that these temporary workers are not donors to the Tory party.

Atlantic City auctions off chance to hit Big Red Button and make grotesque Trump Plaza casino go boom

alain williams Silver badge
Mushroom

Will Trump be tied up in the basement ?

If not then it will not be worth bidding!

Dutch officials say Donald Trump really did protect his Twitter account with MAGA2020! password

alain williams Silver badge

Re: no one has to care what appears on Trump’s Twitter feed ever again

In a month time Trump will be Yesterday's News.

I hope that it stays that way.

They were not the cloud you were looking for, insists Amazon Web Services in unsealed JEDI protest

alain williams Silver badge

███ ███.

I ███ █████ ███-███, ███ ██████!

We take a look at proposed Big Tech regulations in the UK: Heavy on possible fines, light on enforcement

alain williams Silver badge

Need to stop corporate lying

We need something similar that deals with blatant lies and misdirections that many companies come out with. In theory the ASA should deal with this but they seem pretty ineffective.

Rocky has competition as more CentOS alternatives step into the ring: Project Lenix, Oracle Linux vie for attention

alain williams Silver badge

What would I run away from fastest ?

Something from Microsoft or something from Oracle ?

I'll now go & wash my mouth out for even thinking about it!

Taiwanese manufacturer Wistron pegs damage from iPhone factory riot at $7m

alain williams Silver badge

Should we care ?

As long as we get our e-bling, clothes, etc cheaply should we care if workers in other countries are mistreated ?

Someone was arguing with me that "this is how capitalism works - not our concern."

I think that we should care, profit is important but commerce should go further than that. Companies like Primark have slavery statements largely because they began to lose sales, they still need to do more. Action on Uighur forced labour in China is starting.

Apple and other tech companies need to follow suite. Concern for other humans must not stop at national borders.

Up yours, Europe! Our 100% prime British broadband is cheaper than yours... but also slower and a bit of a rip-off

alain williams Silver badge

Speed is not the whole story

but they should also compare the data cap (ie how many GB/month) you get for the monthly fee.

Ad blocking made Google throw its toys out of the pram – and now even more control is being taken from us

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Keep on AdBlocking

- Not using Chrome or any browser based on Chrome

I use Brave when I use Jitsi (I believe that that is safe), firefox for everything else

The three or so people who run Windows 10 on Arm might be glad to know that x64 emulation is in preview

alain williams Silver badge

Better to port ?

Would it not be better to put effort into making it easier to port programs between x64 and ARM and set up multiple repositories for different architectures ?

I have been porting *nix programs between CPU types for over 35 years, it takes a bit of care but is not really hard.

Court orders encrypted email biz Tutanota to build a backdoor in user's mailbox, founder says 'this is absurd'

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Doth protest too much?

Why is the children's commissioner worrying about encryption when there are far more relevant things for her to worry about - things that she could actually do something about.

IMHO it is nothing other than misinformation that she was ordered to utter by someone higher up in the UK government. You know: Trump does not have a monopoly on generating fake news.

Apple appears to be charging Brits £309 to replace AirPods Max batteries, while Americans need only stump up $79

alain williams Silver badge

This is a crime against the planet

More of these things will end up in landfill - increasing Apple's income as a new one is bought, damaging the planet with waste electronics.

This is why a right to repair law is so very much needed.

CentOS project changes focus, no more rebuild of Red Hat Enterprise Linux – you'll have to flow with the Stream

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Erm ...

It is not the company, it is the middle manager who's decision is to buy something. If things go wrong s/he wants to be able to show that they bought the right service/product ... evidence is blah, blah -- the entire purpose is to save their own job.

alain williams Silver badge

Looks like Debian ...

I recently upgraded my desktop from CentOS 6 to Debian Buster as CentOS 8 had Gnome3 as the desktop - Debian gave me the choice of the Mate desktop. So the lack of a desktop that I like has let me avoid having to upgrade twice in 18 months - phew!

It now looks like me and my customers are going to have to go the same way on servers.

Japan pours millions into AI-powered dating to get its people making babies again

alain williams Silver badge
Joke

Alternative AI

Maybe they could encourage use of another sort of AI to produce more babies.

Big Tech's Asian lobby slams Cambodian government's planned National Internet Gateway chokehold

alain williams Silver badge

"business process outsourcing"

This very same Big Tech will happily use this business process outsourcing to increase profits (reduce their costs).

If they were really concerned about citizen's rights then they would threaten to get their outsourcing elsewhere. As they are not one can deduce that their main problem with the Internet chokehold is that it might be used to block some of their web sites.

Apple aptly calls its wireless over-the-ear headphones the AirPods Max – as in, maximum damage to your wallet

alain williams Silver badge

BoM ?

And how little the workers who put them together will be paid.

Pure frustration: What happens when someone uses your email address to sign up for PayPal, car hire, doctors, security systems and more

alain williams Silver badge

Re: I had this...

Got through to Argos who were very good about it ...

That is because Argos are sane guys who have people who you can 'phone/email. Recently I received a set of things in the post from Ebay, opened the package before I realised that it was addressed to Kevin, not Alain, so I could not put back into the post, ... no way to contact Ebay without spending money or registering an account (which I won't do) muppets!

alain williams Silver badge

do-not-reply@some.domain

This is the cause of a lot of problems. Basically it is a company that does not want to perform its due diligence on sending out email. They are trying to bully the rest of the world into operating as they want us to. Why should I do a lot of work because they do not want to pay the cost of doing it themselves ?

As far as I know there is no special legal privilege in such an email address, so I will reply to say "No I do not agree to XXX". I keep a copy of the email that I sent. This is somewhat akin to me sending them paper mail/letter to one of their offices - how they route it internally is not my problem.

FOSS developer survey: Mostly male, employed... and many don't care about 'soul-withering chore' of security

alain williams Silver badge

Other big 'not do' is good documentation

Yes: we all hate it, but without it other will find it hard to use what you write. Others cannot see the inside of your head and grasp what, to you, is completely obvious. This is also a security issue: others might get your creation to work, but not having understood some undocumented subtlety leave some door wide open.

This is not just a problem of FLOSS code.

Some do have excellent documentation, eg jQuery

75% of databases to be cloud-hosted by 2022, says Gartner while dishing on the weak points of each provider

alain williams Silver badge

Heads in the cloud ?

They also noted that Oracle Database on-premises has a reputation for being "expensive and difficult to manage,"

They forgot to add "more secure". You might misconfigure access but if it is only visible from within the organisation then you are less likely to be the next Talk Talk or Equifax.

I know that many software vendors are pushing cloud because they get to charge more fees that way - but not everyone wants cloud.

When it comes to taxing tech giants, America is out, France is in, Canada and Indonesia are going their own way

alain williams Silver badge

Fair taxation

minimum tax bill as a percentage of turnover, not profit

I wish it were that simple. There are many businesses where profit is genuinely very low, either because there is very low markup or their costs are large. The trouble is how to codify in tax law ways of artificial costs - it is easy to see what they are but hard to codify in a way that a smart tax accountant cannot evade.

All the way from shifting profits to Ireland (Microsoft, Google, ...), to inflated royalty fees to subsidiaries in lower tax countries (Starbucks & more), to the business being owned by your wife who lives in Monaco (Philip Green)

UK infoseccer launches petition asking government not to backdoor encryption

alain williams Silver badge

I have signed it

I am telling others to sign it as well.

HP CEO talks up HP-ink-only print hardware and higher upfront costs for machines that use other cartridges

alain williams Silver badge

What is "lifetime" ?

"use of Original HP Ink or Toner for the lifetime of the printer."

Normally a vendor seems to define "lifetime" as "until the next model is out", ie probably a couple of years. What is the betting that for these things "lifetime" will be much longer ?

Ticketmaster: We're not liable for credit card badness because the hack straddled GDPR day

alain williams Silver badge

3rd party Javascript

Blocking that is what noscript is good for. Has the beneficial side effect of blocking facebook, etc.

Unfortunately: some web sites just do not work when I block 3rd party JS - so I usually just go elsewhere. I'll allow JS from a payment processor that I recognise, but rarely much else. When will web developers recognise that they are losing their customers business, or are people like me rare enough for them to not worry ?

US Air Force deploys robot security dogs to guard base

alain williams Silver badge

Electronic sausages ?

You can always distract a real dog with a string of sausages. Is there something equivalent for a robo dog ?

Linux Foundation, IBM, Cisco and others back ‘Inclusive Naming Initiative’ to change nasty tech terms

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Slave vs Master aka rm * ... did that solve anything?

Once 'master' 'slave' loose their meaning as people do not understand them, whatever new words to describe the relationship (eg 'maker' 'doer') will have to be applied to human relationships so that kids can understand history books.

At that point there will be a brouhaha and 'maker' 'doer' will be banned because some people do not like them.

Changing the words that we use is, ultimately, futile.

alain williams Silver badge

What about non-English offensive words ?

All the examples black/master/... that I have seen are English words. What if speakers of other languages complain about terms that offend someone in their language ? Presumably we will have to blacklist those words as well ... oh, errm, I mean add those words to a non-use list.

The important thing is intent: the automotive engineer who, working on brakes, coined the terms: master cylinder, slave cylinder had no intention of alluding one man (sorry: person) being subservient to another.

alain williams Silver badge

Re: What about that special Friday?

What about martial arts where a black belt shows that you have mastered the sport ?

Hard to believe but Congress just approved an IoT security law and it doesn't totally suck

alain williams Silver badge

Support lifetime & abandonment

Many of these things only get updates until the next model comes out; the rest do not get updates at all.

Then there are those that need a fixed server - when that is shut the kit becomes a brick.

These problems must be addressed - probably the best way is by allowing third party firmware -- but that will not happen as the vendors want to keep you locked in and then have you buy new kit.

This is kind of related to what the right to repair people (rightly) want.

Shocking revelations from Huawei-commissioned report: Huawei is good for the UK's economy so don't ban them

alain williams Silver badge

Quote: Mandy Rice-Davies

She says it best "Well they would say that, wouldn’t they?"

OK: it is a slight misquote, but still

Microsoft brings Trusted Platform Module functionality directly to CPUs under securo-silicon architecture Pluton

alain williams Silver badge

My next laptop ?

Does that mean that I will be unable to install Linux on my next laptop ?

Maybe they will say: "not a problem, install it under a Microsoft hypervisor" - in which case all trust is lost anyway.

UK, Canada could rethink the whole 'ban Huawei' thing post-Trump, whispers Huawei

alain williams Silver badge

The reasons have changed from 2 years ago

Back then it was fears that Huawei would spy on us on behalf of the Chinese government. These allegations where probably hyped and are about the same as Cisco does for the USA government.

Today I feel that the argument is changing. China is increasingly being seen to be the bad actor/bully boy [think: Hong Kong, Uighurs muslims, ...] its increasing economic might boosts its confidence that it can get away with bad behaviour. So there is an argument that its economic wings should be clipped before it gets worse. Excluding Huawei is part of that. I am not saying that the West does not behave badly, but I could carry a placard down Whitehall (in London) saying "Bollocks to Boris" and safely go home; I would have a different fate if I carried a picture of Winnie the Pooh in Tiananmen Square -- that difference is important to me.

Two years ago I was saying that we should buy Huawei; today I am inclined against that.

Max Schrems is back... and he's challenging Apple's 'secret iPhone advertising tracking cookies' in Europe

alain williams Silver badge

Price comparison sites

I purposely wipe out all traces of local storage, cookies, browsing history, ... before I go shopping just to prevent the industry trying to leverage anything aabout me in the prices of goods.

Even better: run up a virtual machine and go shopping in a clean browser.

This is what I do when I am comparing prices. See what there is (eg hotels) using a price comparison site and then book a room with the hotel directly -- which saves them the 20% that a comparison site would extract.