* Posts by alain williams

2888 publicly visible posts • joined 29 May 2007

Chinese ambassador to UK threatens to withdraw Huawei, £3bn investment if comms giant banned from building 5G

alain williams Silver badge

Does the Chinese ambassador think ...

that by throwing his toys out of the pram that we will suddenly realise that Chinese companies are super reliable and good partners for important projects ?

I get an image of a 3 year old stamping his feet in temper tantrum.

Face masks hamper the spread of coronavirus. Know what else they hamper? Facial-recognition systems (except China's)

alain williams Silver badge

Rules on face mask design ?

It will be interesting to see if rules are introduced that restrict how face masks are made:

* how big they are, how much of the face they cover

* what patterns can be printed on them. Patterns can confuse recognition systems

Also which countries make the restrictions.

Bill Gates debunks 'coronavirus vaccine is my 5G mind control microchip implant' conspiracy theory

alain williams Silver badge

What if MS had not become dominant ?

It might be sub-standard but it has powered the PC revolution and even the wider IT revolution. Could something better have done that?

It was a product of its time - if MS DOS/Windows had not appeared then something else would have.

I remember SCO ODT was quite nice & better than what MS had some 30 years ago; the unfortunate thing was that it cost far too much for widespread adoption -- because they had licensed many components from elsewhere. Pity.

VMware to stop describing hardware as ‘male’ and ‘female’ in new terminology guide

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Last time I checked ...

If something is stopped then I expect to be able to restart it. I do not expect that if it is killed.

New Google rules mandate Android 'Poundland' Edition, Go, for sub-2GB RAM phones once Android 11 is out

alain williams Silver badge

Does Go come without the non-removable facebook app ?

If so it would be worth going for, as long as it lets me tether my laptop.

Microsoft accused of sharing data of Office 365 business subscribers with Facebook and its app devs

alain williams Silver badge

What about non-business users ?

This article was all about business users, what about home/personal users ? I suspect that Microsoft sold their personal information as well ?

Me: happy to use Libreoffice on my Linux boxes but unhappy to realise that I have likely had my private information harvested from anything that my O-365 using friends have recorded about me.

The GDPR talks about clarity in agreements - but I doubt that most O-365 users are aware. Time for a huge fine from the data protection people.

Nokia 5310: Retro feature phone shamelessly panders to nostalgia, but is charming enough to be forgiven

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Is it 4G, and can it work as a wifi hotspot?

Unfortunately it appears not to and only does 2G. Pity as otherwise it would sound perfect.

Beware: Nokia released a 5310 in 2007 - this is not the same thing, but looks similar.

Everything must go! Distributors clear shelves of ALL notebooks in Q2, even ones gathering dust over last 12 months

alain williams Silver badge

Web cams also

disappear as soon as they hit the shelves.

Trump gloats, telcos weep, and China is furious: How things stand following UK's decision to rip out Huawei

alain williams Silver badge

When politics meets technical decisions

From the point of view of today's technical assessment this is the wrong decision. This assumes a benign China - us techies don't like to think that people are nasty (with a few exceptions).

From a much longer political decision of international geopolitics you might get a different answer: depending on how you value human liberties and your view of Chinese political ambitions.

If our UK politicians have taken a long view I am very pleased at this rare event - irrespective of them being right or wrong. If they are just bending over for Trump - I am not pleased.

UK smacks Huawei with banhammer: Buying firm's 5G gear illegal from year's end, mobile networks ordered to rip out all next-gen kit by 2027

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Logic?

And this is about security you say?

Security has always been the excuse; this is more about trade and politics. Having said that I know little about the latest GCQH report.

UK advertising watchdog raps ruler on O2's hand over misleading ads for iPad and Surface Pro deals

alain williams Silver badge

After 2 wraps in 3 months ...

BT/... should be obliged to have all adverts for the next year approved by the ASA before they run - paying a fee for this.

Attempts to pull the wool should then quickly stop.

Social media giants move to defy Hong Kong's new national security law

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Not only

Sure, but US won't jail you because you said California should go independent

Let me just change a few letters:

Sure, but Spain won't jail you because you said Catalonia should go independent

We need to always worry about erosion of freedom of speech.

alain williams Silver badge

The equation to be evaluated ...

by Google, Facebook & pals is increasingly looking like: China or The Rest of the World. If China pushes too hard they might find themselves cut adrift.

Good from the point of view of preserving freedoms, but this would also increase the isolation of those who live in the totalitarian state that we call China.

I do not know what the answer is.

Remember: it is not just China, other oppressive states also exist.

University ordered to stop running women-only job ads

alain williams Silver badge

Just the academic staff ?

Is there also positive discrimination to achieve an even men/women balance in:

* janitors, gardeners

* security staff

* porters

* buildings/site maintenance

Linux kernel coders propose inclusive terminology coding guidelines, note: 'Arguments about why people should not be offended do not scale'

alain williams Silver badge

Do non African slaves not matter ?

The email includes:

The African slave trade was a brutal system of human misery deployed at global scale.

So: do slaves (past or present) from other places not matter ?

OK: I understand why Dan wrote that - he is reacting to the current brouhaha - but it is easy to lose sight of the bigger picture when under pressure from on group.

July? British government could decide to boot Chinese giant Huawei from the UK's networks by this month

alain williams Silver badge

Huawei should not be the last ...

The Chinese ambassador has been saying that we must not interfere with internal Chinese affairs, but how can we ignore human abuses in other countries ? Should we let Primark ignore working conditions in Bangladesh from where it buys its clothes or slave labour in Chinese prisons ? No: public opinion is making them change.

Likewise: we must not ignore what China is doing to fellow humans.

I have met Uighur Muslims, I know people from Hong Kong - but even if I did not how could I ignore oppression of people even if they are 10,000 miles away ?

We must send a message to Xi Jinping that we do not like the bully that he has become. He is emboldened by their burgeoning economy - so we can express our disapproval by buying less of their goods and services.

Other nations should do likewise: a school ground bully will just dominate/terrorrise one child who stands up to him but if many do he will be defeated.

I recognize that some of the UK's history is not good, but that does not mean that we should turn a blind eye.

China is not the only rogue nation but is, I believe, the most dangerous.

Beijing's tightening grip on Hong Kong could put region's future as an up-and-coming tech hub in jeopardy

alain williams Silver badge

Re: "we need clarity on what the laws will involve before we can decide anything"

I do not think that you understand how dictatorships work.

US govt: Julian Assange tried to recruit hacker to steal hush-hush dirt and we should know – the hacker was an informant

alain williams Silver badge

A lot of effort to get Assange

How much effort is the USA putting in to prosecute those whom he exposed ?

There are DDoS attacks, then there's this 809 million packet-per-second tsunami Akamai says it just caught

alain williams Silver badge

Re: And the next step...

Can Akamai pass the IP addresses from which they got the attack to the various ISP's, so that the ISP's can contact the associated end user and suggest they give their machines a thorough cleaning?

What they need to do is to speak to a few of the ISPs and get traffic logs for some of these PCs. Try to work out the command & control addresses - these are the real ones to chase - not the hapless users running a compromised Microsoft machine. Maybe examine a few of these machine to see what malware they have.

It will be interesting to see who the botnet controllers are: criminals or governments (mind you sometimes they are the same thing).

Ampere smacks the ball over the net, back at Marvell: Our Altra Max cloud processor will have 128 Arm cores

alain williams Silver badge

Quoting speed in GHz ...

does not really allow a good comparison. Especially when different machine architectures are being compared.

SPEC was used a while back - is that still good ?

CERN puts two new atom-smashers on its shopping list. One to make Higgs Bosons, then a next-gen model six times more energetic than the LHC

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Funding

The money that they are asking for is a small fraction of what we give the men in green uniforms.

I know which one I regard as being of better value.

Internet blackout of Myanmar States that are home to ethnic minorities enters second year

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Attempted genocide of the Rohingya

Everyone's inaction is appalling.

IR35 tax reforms for UK freelancers glide through committee stage: D-Day set for 6 April 2021

alain williams Silver badge

Who is paying the right tax ?

After IR35 how many of those consultants will be paying the correct tax ?

I am thinking of those who are working away from home for a few months but cannot claim travel & hotels against tax - if they were doing the same but working for a large company they would have this paid for them by the company which would claim it against income.

Ryzen shine, kids: Huawei buries AMD silicon in latest laptop, hopes to lure 'young professionals'

alain williams Silver badge

Re: 3550U

Considering the lifetime of Laptops is now more like 5 years, this year's CPU will be outdated for 80% of the machines life as well. Additionally, the single thread performance of modern CPUs is no longer growing rapidly.

Your criteria for buying something seem to be "because it is new"; should it not be "it does what I need". You might need a top of the range high powered laptop but I doubt that most people do. This machine would do me nicely except that I would like a smaller screen to fit easier in my ruck sack, I have a large screen at home - I do not need one when out & about.

See: we all have different needs.

If Fairphone can support a 5-year-old handset, the other vendors could too. Right?

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Consumers aren’t being served by Android

The improvements are small increments, nothing revolutionary has really benefited general consumers for years.

Is that not the definition of a mature product: it does what it is supposed to so no major developments are needed ?

When you get a mature product what should happen is that the manufacturers start to compete by providing good prices and service. Most 'phone vendors do not do this.

Adobe about to pull the plug on Creative Cloud freebie 'at-home' access for students

alain williams Silver badge

Are Adobe products the only ones ...

that can be used to achieve what the students are learning ?

If there are alternatives then should the universities not be teaching general principles which is illustrated by using Adobe & other products ?

If they just teach Adobe products then they are delivering training, not education. The result will be graduates who can only work if they have Adobe products - this is not good. Adobe will achieve ever greater lock-in and the competition wither.

If universities teach one product because it is easier - then they are being lazy.

Whose side you on, Nominet? Registry floods .co.uk owners with begging emails to renew unwanted .uk domains

alain williams Silver badge

+1 mythic beasts

I have no affiliation with them other than a happy customer - domain names only.

Huawei's latest smartphone for the UK market costs £1,299. And yes, that's without Google apps

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Privacy

It all depends on who you think will do you more harm.

US senators propose $22bn fund for new fabs on American soil because making stuff is better than designing stuff

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Damn socialists

This is why it is being done through the Defense Department as, presumably, they hope to skate around WTO rules which provide for exceptions on the grounds of national security.

When open source isn't enough: Fancy a de-Googled Chromium? How about some Microsoft-free VS Code?

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Things we turned off

I've gone through about:config and updated the Mozilla URLs in a similar fashion, by munging the end of the hostname.

and there is a lot of them, + google ones & others.

A 99.9% of web users are, I suspect, unaware of these.Thus, surely, they are illegal under GDPR informed consent provisions. I would be very surprised if they did not record the requesting IP (ie user's home) address and various other things - many of which could identify the user, or at least start to.

Another set of GDPR breaking exfiltration of user data are things like google analytics - surely a web site should ask permission first to ask consent which "must be freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous" - no web sites that I know of do so (including El Reg).

However: I doubt that our chocolate box ICO will bother.

Huawei launches UK charm offensive: We've provided 2G, 3G and 4G for 20 years, and you're worried about 5G?

alain williams Silver badge

Re: The bigger issue is rising Chinese power

I always reckoned that we should have helped them move to the Falkland Islands. ½ way between Africa & S America - those enterprising Hong Kong people would have made something big of it.

alain williams Silver badge

The bigger issue is rising Chinese power

What with so much money going there the increasing economic clout gives them increasing political influence and confidence.

A big concern that I have about China is that it will use this power in ways that I do not like, look at the problems of the Uighur Muslims, recent freedom restrictions in Hong Kong, rhetoric about Taiwan, surveillance of their own population, lack of freedom of speech, ... President Xi Jinping cannot be removed at the ballot box which, IMHO, makes him a dictator of what looks like an increasingly totalitarian state. All of that worries me and I think that we should push back before it gets unstoppable.

I am not saying that Western governments do not have their own problems, our imperial past & some of what the CIA have done is shameful, currently heighligthened black problems but at least I could walk down Whitehall with a placard that said "Bollocks to Boris" without ''disappearing''.

I will not deny a certain amount of preferring 'my lot/friends' to another grouping.

One way of slowing them is to not give them so much money: eg by buying European telecomms kit. It would also benefit employment over here and improve supply chain security. I think that this is part of what is behind the Huawei debacle - although our politicians are coy about saying so.

Xiaomi Redmi Note 9 Pro: £250 mobe still able to deliver value in a brutally competitive niche

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Please El Reg ...

If I want Internet connectivity -- I'll switch that on for a few minutes.

The screen: the 'phone is in my pocket for most of the time, screen switched off.

alain williams Silver badge

Please El Reg ...

when you review these things do remember that some of us are not interested in running something like call of duty. We want a 'phone and one of the really important things is battery life.

afforded at least two days' worth of usage between charges

Presumably that was with wifi, bluetooth, GPS, Internet, etc switched on - these are also battery suckers. It would be really useful to be told how long the battery lasts with just 2G/3G switched on. Another time to quote is if you want 4G/5G would be good as well. I do realise that how long depends on local signal strength - so please say that.

Yes: some do want all the services, but some do not.

Smart fridges are cool, but after a few short years you could be stuck with a big frosty brick in the kitchen

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Bimby

Maybe it is rubbish - but she can brag to her mates who will then try to keep up with the Tutkins'!

alain williams Silver badge

Re: A solution looking for a problem

If anyone wants music in the kitchen, they find a laptop and bring it in.

I have a lot of music in my kitchen - I use something that you might have heard of: a 'radio'.

It works really well; super modern - it is a DAB radio. Tuned to either: Classic FM, BBC Radio 4 or Radio 3.

alain williams Silver badge

There are 2 dates on these things

1) the date when it will no longer receive s/ware updates to protect it from the latest drive by attack

2) the date when the servers that it speaks to are switched off

Neither of these is explained in the point-of-sale blurb.

If you ask you might be told of a 'lifetime' - which likely started a year or two ago when the model was released - so what you have left can be quite short.

Quite apart from me not being able to understand *why* I would want something that costs more and blabs personal information to the manufacturer; I would never buy something where (2) those servers were not mine - prolly some R-pi in my house.

Thankfully there will always be a market for cheaper non IoT stuff that will be wanted by those who are not rich enough to be stupid enough to buy these nasties.

Singapore to accelerate digitalisation of COVID-kicked economy

alain williams Silver badge

A good excuse

to be able to track all payments.

80-characters-per-line limits should be terminal, says Linux kernel chief Linus Torvalds

alain williams Silver badge

Re: not the terminal, the punch card

One reason is to stop people having too many levels of indent. Especially helps with an 8 width tab stop as indent.

Nokia's reboot of the 5310 is a blissfully dumb phone that will lug some mp3s about just fine

alain williams Silver badge

Would this be a good 'phone to have ...

when crossing some international borders. "No, I can't login to social media from this 'phone."

But I don't know how long 2G will be enough everywhere.

Surprise! That £339 world's first 'anti-5G' protection device is just a £5 USB drive with a nice sticker on it

alain williams Silver badge

Fine grained control

The device surely contains a Psi circuit that decodes you brain waves to determine your current intentions. It then morphs its protective shield so that you can chat to your analyst or cook your lunch.

Boeing brings back the 737 Max but also lays off thousands

alain williams Silver badge

Re: What will insurance premiums be ?

not room for more undercarriage

Exactly: which is why it should have been redesigned, but that would have taken it out of spec as far as 737 pilots certification - so the pilots would have had to do some training. They were afraid that the training need would have reduces sales - so they pushed the engines forwards which made the plane unstable, so they came up with a software bodge to correct the instability.

Unstable: engines in front of the center of gravity, so more thrust pushes the airplane nose up.

alain williams Silver badge

What will insurance premiums be ?

If/when the 737 MAX takes to the air they are going to need to be insured. How will Lloyds, etc, assess them as a risk ?

It would have been far cheaper for Boeing to have done a proper redesign job and made it higher off the ground when the fitted the bigger engines. The few bob saved on retraining pilots just would not be noticed compared to the consequential loss from by cutting corners. This is what you get when you let bean counters rather than engineers make decisions.

While waiting for the Linux train, Bork pays a visit to Geordieland with Windows 10

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Need a bit of Raspberry Pi action

It's also worth remembering that if you buy (or licence) a product from someone, the law offers you a lot of protection in the event that product doesn't deliver what you requested.

Whoo hooo! When was the last time that anyone successfully sued Microsoft for bugs in their stuff ?

eBay users spot the online auction house port-scanning their PCs. Um... is that OK?

alain williams Silver badge

My firewall - getting updated

iptables -A INPUT -i lo -s 127.0.0.0/8 -d 127.0.0.0/8 -j ACCEPT

It seems that I was naive, I now only allow some connections. Its going to be a pain until I get the rules right.

Contact-tracing app may become a permanent fixture in major Chinese city

alain williams Silver badge

Hong Kong

is the next place where they will want to roll this out. Very useful.

BoJo buckles: UK govt to cut Huawei 5G kit use 'to zero by 2023' after pressure from Tory MPs, Uncle Sam

alain williams Silver badge

Security or politics or economic competition ?

Be slow to take the alleged reasons as being the true ones.

China has grown a lot in economic and political power, it is doing a lot of things that we do not like: interning Muslims, reducing freedom in Hong Kong, internal surveillance, ... and lastly threatening the West's world dominance.

You can either believe that international relationships should be warm & cuddly and all countries work to mutual benefit; or that it is dog eat dog and every country acts to achieve dominance. If you are weak (economically, militarily) then you try to cuddle. If you are strong then countries seem to try to dominate; the USA has done that for years (even before Trump's "America first" policy). China is increasingly trying to dominate.

So how should others react to China's bullying actions ? Do we let it continue and become ever stronger or do we clip its wings ?

It seems clear to me that the Huawei debacle is about clipping China's wings.

The USA cannot just do so, World Trade Organization rules prohibit discrimination between trading partners, but provides exceptions for environmental protection, national security, and other important goals. So a reason needs to be found: security is a good excuse.

If we ban Huawei then Western kit will be bought. This reduces the money that we send to China and benefits Western manufacturers - although, sadly, probably not any British ones -- although Brexit might (maybe) allow the UK government to help such initiatives -- if they can see that clearly.

I leave this to you to decide if stopping Chinese dominance and rebuilding domestic manufacturing (at a price) is a good thing or not.

Google rolls out pro-privacy DNS-over-HTTPS support in Chrome 83... with a handy kill switch for corporate IT

alain williams Silver badge

Who do you want to hide from ?

DoH needs a server to answer DNS queries - that server gets to know a lot about you.

Use normal DNS and your ISP/company can see what you are trying to resolve. Even if you do not use its DNS servers it can sniff the packets as they go by.

If you live in a repressive regime (eg Egypt, China, ...) they can make your ISP hand over your DNS history or change stuff on the fly; so DoH might be good, although they can still see where your IP packets go to.

What about the DoH provider - what does it gain ? Knowledge of all the sites that you visit - good meat to the advertising machine for Google & pals - even when those sites do not run google analytics (or you have blocked the javascript). These DoH providers are subject to the Patriot Act or local equivalent - so, for some, the security is a fig leaf.

Oh - just because you do not think that your regime is repressive does not mean that your government is not snooping on you. DNS over TOR might be an interesting idea.

If you do run DoH then you might be visited by shady men and told to change your browser options - packet sniffing via your ISP will make it obvious if you have taken their 'advice'. So: will you make yourself a target for future visits ?

Could it be? Really? The Year of Linux on the Desktop is almost here, and it's... Windows-shaped?

alain williams Silver badge

Re: If only!

You beat me to it with that comment.

If you want to run MS Windows & Linux on the same machine (plenty of reasons why you might) the only safe way is to run MS Windows under Linux - that way the Linux part remains safe from snooping.

I wonder who might be sponsoring Microsoft to do this work ? How big is the NSA budget ?

You overstepped and infringed British sovereignty, Court of Appeal tells US in software companies' copyright battle

alain williams Silver badge

Should WPL exit the USA ?

If all of its income there is to be garnished by SAS there is little point in bothering.

It will be interesting to see what SAS does. It could go after the USA side of the banks and get an order there. The bank will then have to decide which jurisdiction to obey. Remember these cases where people who left the USA as infants were persued by the USA IRS which forced banks in England to close their accounts, if not the the banks risked penalties of huge fines. IMHO this is international terrorism.