Re: Windows style WM ?
KDE, as well as several of the other WMs mentioned, give the user the very flexibility needed to refute Liam's argument about same-old-same-old UIs, and then he proceeds to bemoan how many pre-built start menus it is prepared to offer. Is this is not exactly what he was longing for at the beginning of the article? What, exactly, is your point, Liam? Sure, a distro might come off the installation medium configured for familiarity (we don't want to scare off those new arrivals from Redmond now, do we?), but the capacity to reshape it to your liking is precisely what Windows lacks, that several different Linux WM providers offer.
On the subject of litigation-shy efforts like GNOME, it seems to me that every UI decision that might have been made has been compared to Micros~1 and then followed some obsessive compulsion to do it differently. The result is to me a confusing unfamiliar monstrosity. MS themselves were the subject of the famous Look and Feel lawsuit from Apple in which they argued common sense and won out over an attempt to monopolise UI interfaces.