* Posts by John Savard

2460 publicly visible posts • joined 18 Sep 2007

Hungry? Please enjoy this delicious NaN, courtesy of British Gas and Sainsbury's

John Savard

Dimensional Analysis

The pudding was marked "2 x 150" rather than "2 x 150g", so apparently somebody didn't know the 150 meant 150 grams, failed to input the net weight of pudding in the product... and so, lo and behold, instead of 83 new pence per 100 grams (one third of 2.49 pounds) we get what was shown in the photo.

At least this shows that it isn't because decimalisation has made the arithmetic more complicated rather than less!

You may be distracted by the pandemic but FYI: US Senate panel OK's backdoors-by-the-backdoor EARN IT Act

John Savard

Democrats

Since not all Democrats share Diane Feinstein's position on this bill, isn't it likely to face some difficulty in getting through the House as amended, if at all?

Euro police forces infiltrated encrypted phone biz – and now 'criminal' EncroChat users are being rounded up

John Savard

Re: Matters arising

There was no encryption chip, nor, for that matter, was there any plaintext on the Encrochat servers. The phones were an ordinary phone from a normal Spanish cell phone company.

There was encryption software which communicated through the Encrochat servers.

The Encrochat servers got compromised, sent malware out to the users' phones, and then the malware read plaintext on the phones and sent it to the cops.

John Savard

Re: Honey pot

I can think of one reason why normal people would not use it, the high price tag.

Internet blackout of Myanmar States that are home to ethnic minorities enters second year

John Savard

Puzzled

I really don't understand. Since members of the various ethnic minorities are clearly coming to harm in Burma, why hasn't this been stopped by the United States or other major Western world powers carrying out regime change in Burma to prevent this?

RIP ROP, COP, JOP? Intel to bring anti-exploit tech to market in this year's Tiger Lake chip family

John Savard

Re: ARM equivalent?

And it turns out that IBM has done something in this area for its z/Architecture...

https://patents.google.com/patent/US9891919B2/en

John Savard

Re: ARM equivalent?

Apparently it's called Pointer Authentication, and it was introduced in version 8.3 of the ARM architecture.

Someone got so fed up with GE fridge DRM – yes, fridge DRM – they made a whole website on how to bypass it

John Savard

Solution

Instead of making it legal for consumers to bypass it, they should make it illegal to put this nonsense in products in the first place. Apparently, the voters don't have sufficient control over legislators to bend them to their will instead of that of big corporations. Since they can vote for whomsoever they please, they can fix that.

Remember that backdoor in Juniper gear? Congress sure does – even if networking biz wishes it would all go away

John Savard

Peace and Quiet

Perhaps the NSA has advised Juniper that it can't disclose certain aspects of this matter, due to considerations of national security. Of course, it's a pity they couldn't have also told the Congressmen involved this.

MacOS on Arm talk intensifies: Just weeks from now, Apple to serve up quarantini with Kalamata golive, reportedly

John Savard

As far as I'm concerned, the only acceptable new chip for Apple Macintosh computers, once Apple makes those chips itself, is one that runs 68020/68882 code, PowerPC code, and x86 code, so that it becomes possible for the Macintosh to seamlessly run all Macintosh software ever at full natiive speed. And, yes, that would mean including OS 9 as a component of future releases of OS X.

John Savard

So? What software authors can do with their source code only matters if they do, in fact, choose to do it. Computer owners are limited to the applications that are actually offered for sale at their local computer store.

Of course, Apple could require software companies, as a condition for placing their Macintosh programs on the App Store, to have both versions of their software. But since the Macintosh, unlike the iPhone, does not compel developers to give Apple its 30% cut, even that won't necessarily be decisive.

Ex-Dell distributor in Lebanon ignored ban on suing US tech giant. Now four directors have been sentenced to prison in the UK

John Savard

This is true, but since the defendants and their sales operation are physically in Lebanon, their primary concern would be with abiding by Lebanese law.

This court decision could have the unintended consequence of Dell entirely losing access to the Lebanese market, if its government is sufficiently affronted by an attempt to pre-empt the ability of its courts to decide whether terms in contracts governing businesses in its country are valid or not.

Moore's Law is deader than corduroy bell bottoms. But with a bit of smart coding it's not the end of the road

John Savard

Oh, dear.

I had read claims that the design of the Python interpreter was so advanced, code written in Python ran as fast as compiled code. Apparently that was mistaken.

Legal complaint lodged with UK data watchdog over claims coronavirus Test and Trace programme flouts GDPR

John Savard

Move Fast and Break Things

While one may disagree with the tactics of some Internet companies that fail to respect laws, whether copyright law or laws meant to protect taxi drivers, a pandemic happens to be an emergency, and not moving fast enough means thousands more people will die.

80-characters-per-line limits should be terminal, says Linux kernel chief Linus Torvalds

John Savard

Re: not the terminal, the punch card

And here I was going to mention the 72-column limit for languages like FORTRAN, and what do I see but the first commenter has beaten me to it!

However, this does not mean that Linux Torvalds does not have a point, because not many people are using Linux with 3277 display stations hooked up to their computers.

If American tech is used to design or make that chip, you better not ship it to Huawei, warns Uncle Sam

John Savard

Re: Globalization: Who's fault is that?

There you are then. End unfair competition; only countries with labor laws, health and safety standards, and wages comparable to those in the United States should be allowed to export to the United States. So Americans could buy made-in-Switzerland cellphones, or made-in-France cellphones, but not made-in-China cellphones.

John Savard

Responsible Corporate Citizen?

If Huawei were a responsible global corporate citizen, it wouldn't have got itself into this trouble by exporting American tech to Iran.

But that Huawei is turning to make phones using Chinese technology since American technology is no longer available to it... what else can they do? Roll over and die?

One possibility of what may be expected of them is that they might pay a huge fine and then become subject to U.S. oversight to prove they will never do this again, but presumably this isn't really an option for a number of reasons - not just because the Chinese government wouldn't let them, but because the United States is no longer prepared to give them a second chance.

John Savard

Re: Also Microsoft

If TSMC wants to build fabs that make 5nm chips and 3nm chips, and so on, some of the devices used there come from the United States. So they have to obey these rules, or they will be cut off from the things they need to keep making more modern chips. It is not like China is a bigger market for them than the United States and other Western countries.

Uncle Sam courting Intel, TSMC to build advanced chip fabs on home soil – report

John Savard

Missed Opportunity

There was a short time under the Clinton administration when Russia was friendly with the United States under Boris Yeltsin, and China's sole nuclear-armed submarine was in port for repairs. But we missed the opportunity for a pre-emptive strike followed by regime change in China. Then, with the threat from China eliminated, Russia and India could have given up nuclear weapons - and Pakistan would no longer need them to keep up with India. The world would have been saved from the threat of nuclear war, with all nuclear weapons in the hands of responsible countries - the United States, Britain, and France - and there would no longer have been any threat against Taiwan.

Google is a 'publisher' says Aussie court as it hands £20k damages to gangland lawyer

John Savard

Threshhold

The court ruled that Google became liable because the individual involved had notified it about the article.

But did he send Google proof that the article was misleading?

Without that requirement, Google could be required to conceal search results about people who in fact committed crimes, but against whom charges were withdrawn because the police felt they couldn't get a conviction - some evidence being inadmissible, some witness being un-cooperative, and so on.

That won't promote public safety.

Who's still using Webex? Not even Cisco: Judge orders IT giant to use rival Zoom for virtual patent trial

John Savard

Oh, dear. I'm not happy to hear this, becasue if WebEx has problems that make it almost unusable, then being more secure than Zoom - and Zoom is fixing its security problems, or has fixed them - isn't going to be enough to save it.

John Savard

Headline?

The headline is inaccurate, since here Cisco is not using Zoom instead of WebEx by choice.

Not that I've even heard of WebEx, but it's nice to know a more secure alternative to Zoom is available.

However, a subsequent web search, while it turned up mentions of recent extensions to Skype, and Microsoft's Teams product, seemed to indicate that WebEx was the only major direct alternative to Zoom. However, Jitsi Meet, an open-source alternative, was mentioned.

Register Lecture: Can portable atomic clocks end UK dependence on GNSS?

John Savard

Re: The European Commission and Galileo

True, for that he should have gone to Cambridge instead.

John Savard

Re: Interesting

Given that, instead of putting portable atomic clocks in our smartphones at great expense, why not just put atomic clocks in our cell towers or something? In fact, once one gets an accurate position for every cell tower, it's quite possible that some old-fashioned method of radio navigation, not needing atomic clocks at all, could be used to find one's position without the help of satellites. Although maybe the atomic clocks would still help in rural areas.

Singapore's corona-crushing superhero squad grounded by football fans

John Savard

Outrageous

I think it's highly regrettable that a great song by Rodgers and Hammerstein is prevented from helping humanity by making coronavirus information more accessible due to utterly trivial and irrelevant considerations like this.

Ransomware scumbags leak Boeing, Lockheed Martin, SpaceX documents after contractor refuses to pay

John Savard

Pity

Unauthorized possession of classified military information is a serious crime.

Unfortunately, if these miscreants live in a country hostile to the United States, which would like to get its hands on American defense secrets, it's unlikely that this will help to lead to their prosecution.

Thus, there's an urgent need to make nuclear weapons obsolete, so that the United States can have something better, with which to effect regime change in Russia and China. Then our computers will be safer, because ransomware scum would have no place to hide.

While we're waiting for this to happen, though, Microsoft needs to fix Windows so that things like this just can't happen. If you want to install a disk encryption utility, that should have to happen before Windows boots up - in a special "install mode" of the operating system that you only get into if you want to, something like getting into the BIOS on startup.

Infosys fires employee who Facebooked 'let's hold hands and share coronavirus'

John Savard

Re: Ah, that old chestnut.

Your country has elected Narenda Modi as its leader.

A leader who has interfered with relief efforts for victims of communal violence in Orissa.

A leader who has moved the political landscape in India so that all the parties have to display "nationalism", which means supporting favoring Hindus over other people in India.

So criticizing India is not hostility to the people of India, it is solidarity with the right-thinking people of India who believe in equality.

John Savard

Lockdown in India

Of course, India's national lockdown is also problematic. The grocery stores are also closed. It was not announced in advance, and up to the lockdown, people were repeatedly urged against panic buying. So many people in India will be locked down in their homes for two weeks without enough food.

One result has been mass migration of workers in the cities, going back home to rural areas - on foot.

Theranos vampire lives on: Owner of failed blood-testing biz's patents sues maker of actual COVID-19-testing kit

John Savard

Solution?

Couldn't Italian law be used to force him to share the plans, because saving lives trumps everything? And because the law required him to do this, no lawsuit could be made in italy - against the doctor, but they could always try suing the Italian government.

Of course, the U.S. might threaten trade sanctions for disrespect of intellectual property.

White House turns to Big Tech to fix coronavirus blunders while classifying previous conversations

John Savard

Obvious Reason Why

Well, since accurate information about COVID-19 could possibly indicate that President Donald Trump may have been mistaken about certain things, of course it has to be classified.

Pity impeachment wasn't successful.

Chips that pass in the night: How risky is RISC-V to Arm, Intel and the others? Very

John Savard

Problem?

Indeed, ARM is a bigger threat to Intel than RISC-V. Today, Android is popular in the high-volume categories of smartphones and tablets.

Someday, RISC-V will be popular. But unlike ARM, Intel doesn't need to buy a license for RISC-V. So it could churn out RISC-V chips whenever it felt like it. With all those facilities x86 paid for.

Check Point chap: Small firms don't invest in infosec then hope they won't get hacked. Spoiler alert: They get hacked

John Savard

Obviously people don't want to spend more money than they absolutely have to.

The solution is clear.

Make operating systems completely secure, so that you don't need to buy anything extra.

Severely punish attempts to compromise computer systems, so that no one will dare to try for nefarious purposes. This solution is great, because its costs are borne entirely by the people whose fault it is that we have a problem. (Maybe tax software companies that make imperfect operating systems to pay for the hackers' bread and water while they're in jail.)

Cut off internet and telephone connections to countries that don't fully cooperate in prosecuting hackers, like Russia, China, and North Korea.

Facebook, distributor of deceptive political ads, sues registrar Namecheap over deceptive domain names

John Savard

Obvious

It's clear to me that at least two of the three examples you gave are useful for typosquatting attacks by hackers, to get people to install malware when they think they're logging into Facebook or installing WhatsApp, so it seems to me that Facebook is not trying to stifle sites that criticize it.

Uncle Sam's nuke-stockpile-simulating souped-super El Capitan set to hit TWO exa-FLOPS, take crown as world's fastest machine in 2023

John Savard

Re: This computer, whose name I'm not worthy of saying

Well, our technology isn't anywhere near that advanced. No, for all its power by our standards, I'm sure that Deep Thought would dismiss it as a mere abacus - and, indeed, many orders of magnitude less powerful even than the computer than it had actually so dismissed.

John Savard

Next-Gen?

Supposedly, rather than the next generation of EPYC, it will be using the generation after that. So instead of EUV 7nm+, it will be using 5nm chips. I wonder what the HPC and AI optimizations of the custom EPYC chips are both on this and on the earlier Frontier supercomputer.

US Homeland Security mistakenly seizes British ad agency's website in prostitution probe gone wrong

John Savard

Blackmail

Excuse me? Since the firm was innocent of all wrongdoing, the website should have been returned to it immediately.

Since, instead, Homeland Security retained control of it in order to secure a waiver of damages from the firm, the persons responsible for imposing that condition should face criminal charges of extortion. Pure and simple.

'I give fusion power a higher chance of succeeding than quantum computing' says the R in the RSA crypto-algorithm

John Savard

Que sera, sera

Recently, there have been some very positive announcements about fusion power. And a lot of major corporations take quantum computing seriously enough to invest in it.

This, however, is not to say that Ron Rivest is wrong. Fusion has been ten or twenty years away before. And the challenges of keeping a quantum system isolated from the classical world rise exponentially with its size.

My opinion is that it's not safe to assume quantum computing will work, and it's also not safe to assume quantum computing will not work. Prepare for the worst in both directions.

Apple drops a bomb on long-life HTTPS certificates: Safari to snub new security certs valid for more than 13 months

John Savard

Captive Audience

And, of course, on an iPhone or iPad, you can't simply load another browser that conforms to Internet standards. But you should be able to still do so on a Macintosh, unless there's something I've missed.

Crypto AG backdooring rumours were true, say German and Swiss news orgs after explosive docs leaked

John Savard

Out of Control

I have to wonder why this was leaked.

It's not as if you can call it whistleblowing. This isn't the CIA or NSA doing something that involves monitoring ordinary citizens of the U.S. to create a surveillance state - or even ordinary citizens of other countries. This is eavesdropping on the secret communications of foreign governments, particularly including hostile ones.

I thought that constitutes doing their job. So what is the motive for the leak? To ruin Donald Trump's morning? To make a big spectacle of Trump going after their source that is presumed to be damaging to him electorally?

It would serve the public interest if thie were evidence the CIA and/or NSA were out of control, trying to subvert U.S. democracy. There doesn't appear to be anything of the sort to see here, however.

John Savard

Re: Once again ....

Designing a secure cipher is not that hard, provided it's just a secret-key cipher. Of course, secret-key ciphers without a wy to distribute keys securely are next to useless in today's digital world.

Crazy idea but hear us out... With robots taking people's jobs, can we rethink this whole working to survive thing?

John Savard

Focus

The problem isn't that technology exists. Or even that it is being applied to make things more cheaply, or diminish our burden of labor.

The problem is that some people stop having skills that are badly enough needed that they can use them to bargain for a good rate of pay for their work.

We got into this fix because of the free market system, though. That means we don't want to get rid of it, because it produces technological progress, prosperity, and political freedom. Yet, it seems like anything we do to fundamentally reduce people's dependency on the market value of their labor will come into conflict with the free market system.

Social media notifications of the future: Ranger tagged you in a photo with Tessadora, Wrenlow, Faelina and Graylen

John Savard

Oh, dear

Whatever is wrong with good sensible names like (for boys) Andrew, Charles, Edward, Michael, David, Robert, Anthony... they still seem to be good enough for the Royal Family, after all.

Hey GitLab, the 1970s called and want their sexism back: Saleswomen told to wear short skirts, heels and 'step it up'

John Savard

Surely you mean

the 1960s. It was during the 1970s that we started to discover the existence of sexism, and to address this issue. Just look at the second season of "All in the Family", an American television series inspired by your "Till Death Do Us Part", but made milder for American tastes.

If only 3 in 100,000 cyber-crimes are prosecuted, why not train cops to bring these crooks to justice once and for all, suggests think-tank veep

John Savard

Global Politics

The existence of North Korea, Iran, Russia, and mainland China could be one reason we think that focusing on actually making our computer systems secure, rather than expecting deterrence through criminal law enforcement, is more likely to actually solve the problem. This is quite reasonable, and the real problem is why the computer industry is doing such a poor job of making our computers secure.

Alan Turing’s OBE medal, PhD cert, other missing items found in super-fan’s Colorado home by agents, says US govt

John Savard

Re: The Way We Live Now

The missing coins were replaced with coins of other dates containing the same amount of gold, so the "thief" didn't make the American government any poorer, he prevented the destruction of a numismatic rarity.

This is like the case of the man who vacuumed Apollo space suits, and then later extracted moondust from his floorboards. He was charged with stealing the moondust from the U.S. government, even though everything would have been fine if he just let it be lost.

The rationale in the moon dust case is a bit like the one behind the rules about ivory, to prevent a market for moon dust arising which would endanger scientific research on it - and one way to put this that applies to both cases is that the U.S. government gets to be an absolute stickler about its property rights as a way to prevent people from frustrating its intentions.

John Savard

Re: Inventory

What, your general public would describe a lathe?

Academics call for UK's Computer Misuse Act 1990 to be reformed

John Savard

Wording Mistake to Avoid

We don't want hacking done for paparrazi-like reasons to be defensible in the public interest.

There was a recent column in the Guardian about how the attacks on Harry and Meghan are likely motivated by the fact that the newspapers involved have also been paying large financial settlements to people accusing them of telephone hacking, so far successfully keeping the matter out of the courts. The Royals are less in need of money than most people, so Harry and Meghan pose a danger of making this strategy ultimately fail.

Spanking the pirates of corporate security? Try a Plimsoll

John Savard

Silly Advice

Given that ransomware is a thing, makers of computers and operating systems should design computers so that backup is easy and inexpensive.

Ideally, they should also design computers so that they are secure, and thus virus infections, including ransomware, just can't happen. Oh, but how could you do that? Well, put everything that involves connecting to the Internet in a sandbox. One that really works.

Of course some data coming from outside on the Internet may need to be taken to the part of the computer where the work really gets done, so this connection needs to be made transparent, visible, and controllable.

China tells America, with a straight face, it will absolutely crack down on hacking and copyright, tech blueprint theft

John Savard

The Future of the Deal

While the title of this article is very true, it shouild not be concluded from this trade deal that Trump is a fool.

How can anything be negotiated between the U.S. and China if we automatically assume China won't respect the terms of the agreement?

So while there is good reason not to expect China to reform the practices cited, there is no other way but to begin with optimism. Then, a month or two down the road, when there is some evidence that things are the same as always, there can be a new trade war, this time with real demands for China to take concrete steps even before talks begin.

So instead of thinking of this agreement as giving China a free pass, think of it as the first salvo in Trade War Part II.

Alphabet's 'love rat' legal chief David Drummond ejects after 18 years at web goliath, no golden parachute attached

John Savard

Re: Or Brooks, "It's good to be the king."

Steve Jobs was more indispensible for Apple.

Employers should not facilitate misconduct, and if they do, potential customers may retaliate by going elsewhere. Some people who buy computers or use Internet services are women, who would empathize with a woman abandoned when she is pregnant.

So this kind of personal misconduct is a risk for a company that has to be weighed against other factors. If he had been an assembly-line worker, whose personal life wouldn't be taken as a reflection on his employer's brand, that would also be a different case - therefore allaying fears that we might end up in a state where our employers would be Big Brother, regulating our personal lives.