The Register Home Page

* Posts by doublelayer

11806 publicly visible posts • joined 22 Feb 2018

Now that China has all but banned cryptocurrencies, GPU prices are falling like Bitcoin

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: I am no lover of the Chinese political system

There is already such a digital currency. It is your current currency. Transactions in it usually go over electronic means unless you decide to use cash. They don't need to reinvent each part of the digital transaction system which already exists. At most, they could build a government-backed system which allows those who do not like or cannot afford to use the electronic services of banks to do the same things, but that's all that is needed. A system similar to cryptocurrencies doesn't offer much that the existing electronic transaction system doesn't already do unless you want to avail yourself of the pseudonymity or lack of regulation that actual crypto does. If you want government backing, you don't want those things.

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Phew that was close!

"I think you'll find that the Euro is backed by quite a number of armies, including one with nukes."

No, it's not. It is used by countries with armies but that's not the same thing. The original point, that it is not the power of an army which gives currency value, is still correct. Some of the world's worst economies have powerful armies. North Korea has had to reissue its currency, wiping out all their citizens' wealth (they don't care) because their currency isn't worth much. They have the strongest army by size of nation in the world, the fourth largest in absolute terms, and they also have nukes. It isn't doing their Won any favors. The power of a fiat currency is based on trust of the institutions which handle it. The central banks of the EU, UK, and U.S. are generally trusted, so their currencies are strong. The only connection to their army would be if they were being invaded, but most countries with weak currencies aren't experiencing that because of an active military threat.

To CAPTCHA or not to CAPTCHA? Gartner analyst says OK — but don’t be robotic about it

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Captcha.

"Just pick a random question from a large collection of general knowledge things. It would take spectacular effort to parse such things."

I hate captchas too, but it would be hard to parse the answer to that kind of question if it weren't easy to look up in a database. Questions with single answers could be easily answered automatically: "What is the capital city of Argentina", for example. More general knowledge questions might have multiple possible answers and/or regional variations "What is the food item produced by slicing potatoes and frying them". Also, if you don't have too many of them, someone can take the whole test and program bots with known answers.

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Unfortunately no.

"Because another thing that doesn't parse CSS is a screen reader for the blind. Such a system would auto-determine any such user is no longer Human & lock us out."

This is wrong. Screenreaders do parse CSS and obey it, or rather the browsers do and the screenreader obeys them. Mark something as display:none and the screenreader won't see it. It doesn't work for just making the font really small, but otherwise it will.

However, even if that wasn't the case, that doesn't doom the option. I've used such fields for basic spam protection before and I have a setup for those who don't use CSS. It just includes a warning that the box below should not have anything written in it if you expect me to read your submission. If people can see the box, they can also see the warning. It won't protect you against someone targeting your page, but for the casual bot, it works.

'Lots of failed startups came out of Campus': Google axes London hub because startup scene 'doesn't need' another 7 floors of workspace

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Coffee and Power

"Just wondering why we can't find desks and tables for people to drop in and do stuff. Perhaps charge a 'badge fee' towards insurance and costs &c."

Mostly because the owners of those buildings are hoping for long-term renters to return and put a business there, and they don't want to manage the complexities of lots of people who don't pay much. Not that that logic is perfect or ends well, but it's usually what they're thinking. I suppose someone else could try setting up that as a business and carry the risk if people don't show up, but I don't want to do it and I'm guessing you don't either.

Space is one of the hardest parts of certain startup-style experiments as it's the most expensive and can't be obtained cheaper by working hard. The good news for tech-related startups though is that, unlike a lot of others, the early steps don't have to be done in an expensive space. I've likewise seen plenty of spaces which would be optimal for very small businesses or community uses, but it's not going to happen without someone to handle the bill.

Mayflower, the AI ship sent to sail from the UK to the US with no humans, made it three days before breaking down

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: "Artificial Intelligence": oxymoron. Used by morons known as Artificial Intelligentia.

I find this quote the best of the ones posted:

“The question of whether Machines Can Think... is about as relevant as the question of whether Submarines Can Swim."--Edsger W. Dijkstra

Exactly. In that it's mostly about the definition of "think" or "swim". Submarines do go underwater and move through it, so does that count or not. Likewise, certain programs can do things which in a human require intelligence and using methods not expressly written by the programmer, but does that constitute thinking? It's a question best answered by philosophers, so before they come along let's run away.

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Discrimination

"How can this possibly be legal?"

A good question, but the one which comes to my mind is how can this possibly be useful? Most illegal or unethical things that businesses do at least seem to have some benefit to somebody--more profitable, more profit right now and then it's someone else's problem, less regulation, etc. What is the expected benefit of the development funds thrown away on this? It seems to have no purpose whatsoever even if we assume somebody willing to make everyone else miserable.

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: "With no one onboard to fix it"

For a vehicle which has a lot of maneuverability and a lot of warning about obstacles, two days is not a very long time. It's not like a car which needs to spend a lot of its time on correctly navigating and not hitting things. It's not the AI's fault that something mechanical broke, but there's one good reason to have engineers on ships whenever they're used.

Amazon says it's all social media's fault for letting fake review schemes thrive

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Time to ditch Prime...

My technique is to sort by review length. I have to do it manually, but I find that's the most useful way. Someone who writes a long review is either giving a great amount of detail about the product or repeating so much marketing sludge that it can be identified in five seconds. What is most annoying are the "Works great would buy again" reviews or the slightly longer version where they identify what the product is but still don't say anything.

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Accounts *accused of* being fake

Probably they are. It's not unusual for companies who handle billions of accounts and millions of fraud reports to operate automatically. Sometimes they'll have an automatic check before banning, sometimes they'll have a good appeal process. Sometimes they won't tell you how or why anything happened and there's nothing you can do about it.

Open-source projects glibc and gnulib look to sever copyright ties with Free Software Foundation

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Why assign copyright?

Indeed it was, and I'm sure he did his best to ensure the FSF could enforce their license. When they instituted that policy, the license hadn't been thoroughly tested, and therefore they wanted to take every effort to make sure it would work. Among those was the assignment of copyright--if the FSF owned it all, then they could change to something else if the GPL proved flawed when the courts looked at it. I have no objection to that plan when it was instituted, nor do I object to continuing to assign copyrights to the FSF.

What I do object to is the idea that this is required for the GPL to have legal significance. Unlike 1990, the GPL has been tested in court and it works. Non-GNU projects have verified that it works without copyright assignment, with Linux being the most famous example. Hence my statement that, if the project leads choose to change the policy, it won't harm the freedoms allowed by the GPL. That doesn't mean I think it should happen, just that it can without collapsing. The responses to this have included a dearth of detail, yet are very vigorous. Perhaps the adherents of the FSF haven't considered what the GPL is for, but they seem to think it's a house of cards which will be useless without the FSF. The people who wrote it were smart enough that it isn't.

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Why assign copyright?

No, they don't. I've already commented on why above. What they will have is the same style of protection which the Linux kernel has had for almost all of its existence, which has been fine.

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Why assign copyright?

I am not an expert lawyer, but neither is Stallman. Maybe neither of us is worth anything.

Or maybe, since I do write code and license it, and I have read up on the licenses, and I might decide whether or not to use certain licenses or assign copyrights, my opinion and those of the people like me who also write the code involved has some value after all.

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Why assign copyright?

The license already does that. An author who releases something as GPL can't unilaterally change the license because they've already released it. They can release it under a different license if they wish, and they can refuse to send the code to you anymore under the GPL. If anyone else has a copy though, they can edit it or publish it without limitation.

The issue with the people who pulled packages wasn't that the code couldn't be resurrected. The issue was that people were downloading the package and the downloads broke. Similar to what would happen if you were pulling something from a public server I ran and I shut it down. All they had to do was change the download location to somewhere where the packages could be found and things worked again.

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Why assign copyright?

The point is that the FSF retains the ownership they already have, so they could enforce the copyright on that without having to own the rest. Diluting the copyright doesn't impact their ability to enforce the license because they own some. It also enables others should one of them choose to do it.

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Why assign copyright?

In practice, this is not required to pursue copyright claims. An owner of some of the copyright has a claim to litigate copyright violations of the entire thing, but if that argument is deemed insufficient, they can litigate the parts they own, without which the rest doesn't work, and obtain the same result. Having multiple copyright holders can help here because the FSF itself wouldn't have a monopoly on deciding whether some use was acceptable or not, so people considering violating would have to stick to the GPL more clearly.

I agree that the FSF is likely to continue to enforce the licenses as they already have done--Stallman is not the kind of person who would want more lax licensing. Still, I don't think the policy is at all necessary, so if projects choose to change the policy in order to indicate their feelings about unrelated FSF decisions, I see no harm in it.

Tim Cook: Sideloading is a disaster and proposed App Store reforms would harm user privacy and security

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: User's best interest?

Developers pay $99 per year to be able to post apps. Even at the lowest price tier offered by public cloud, that's approximately 1.15 TB of bandwidth, and most apps are small and get compressed even more. Apple moves a lot of data and doesn't have to use public cloud, meaning their bandwidth is a lot cheaper. They're bandwidth bill will be fine.

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: It wouldn't be for people who like to tinker

That's completely unrelated and you know it. Firearms have the potential to hurt people and few other uses. The balance between defense uses and attack uses is the only argument involved in whether they should have them. Running code on your personal phone doesn't let you kill people. Please don't waste our time with that.

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: The Walled Garden

There are firewall apps for IOS. I use Lockdown Privacy, which is free, open source, but limited to blocking things (custom blocklists work). If you want more control, there are apps which allow it. As long as you're willing to grant the app VPN privilege, it can inspect and modify your traffic. I disagree with Apple on many things, but this critique isn't correct.

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: It wouldn't be for people who like to tinker

Three points about that possibility:

1. Privacy under Apple's system is optional. An app can request that a user give them permission to collect data and a user can say yes. It's defaulted to no, but nothing prevents Facebook from running a media campaign telling people to say yes. If such campaigns actually work, Facebook doesn't need this to continue tracking.

2. Apple can still enforce privacy by actual protection. Blocking identifiers, locking down permissions, etc. If they do that as they have done it with the existing permissions, then a sideloaded app won't be able to circumvent privacy protection any more than one signed by Apple. Once again, it will come down to asking the user to allow something, which already is an option. In addition, the OS can institute its own information campaign by way of warning messages at every step of the process: "If you enable external app installations, they may have security risks.", "You are installing an app known to track your activity and weaken your privacy", "The app you have installed could be dangerous, but you have one more chance to delete it before we launch it".

3. If a user wants to run something insecure or just unapproved by Apple, is there a reason we should deny them the right to do it? They bought the device. They own it. Why shouldn't they be allowed to run code on it without Apple's approval?

GPRS-era mobile data encryption algorithm GEA/1 was 'weak by design', still lingers in today's phones

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Are you in for a laugh?

Is this some sort of graph theory thing? Why are you posting article links in the comments when we can read both articles? If they have something to do with each other which you want to point out, say so and detail what the purpose is.

Biden to Putin: Get your ransomware gangs under control and don’t you dare cyber-attack our infrastructure

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: People who live in glass houses ...

It's not sixteen specific entities, but sixteen classes of targets. They could still do some things to better secure them, but it's at least hundreds of individual targets, E.G. different parts of the nationwide water system.

Intrepid Change.org user launches petition to make Jeff Bezos' space trip one-way

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Remember, don't be mean

Yes. The person either believes in a flat earth or is pretending to. Just as they either believe in dangerous 5G chips or pretend to. Hence my wondering whether this is a joke or whether the person is actually that crazy.

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: poor phrasing ?

If you believe in a flat planet, then those who disagree with you are denying your flat earth belief. The petitioner either believes in that or is pretending to, so calls people deniers when they believe in the facts. It seems to be correct phrasing of a crazy idea to me.

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Remember, don't be mean

It's not the joking about harm I'm talking about. Read the text of the petition. There's not much of it, and it doesn't really talk about his failings or even the results. It's a mash of conspiracy theories only.

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Remember, don't be mean

When I read the headline, I thought this would be a poor-spirited attempt at a joke. Having read the text of the petition, I'm not so sure anymore. Sure, it's the kind of thing a fifteen-year-old trying to be funny without watching what actually funny people do might write, but unfortunately there are people who say the same sort of thing in absolute seriousness.

Cuffed: Ukraine police collar six Clop ransomware gang suspects in joint raids with South Korean cops

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Suspects

Transfer of technology? There's none of that. Ransomware isn't high tech. It's just a lot of effort at breaking in, installing it, and getting the payment out. Writing the software isn't particularly complex.

Russia and Ukraine don't like one another, but Russians and Ukrainians could easily participate in a criminal group without earning the government's attention. As long as that group isn't helping Ukraine's government, Russia doesn't have a reason to want to hurt them. In fact, they do have a reason to like that as they can blame some of the cybercrime problem on Ukraine.

Western Australia rushes out legislation after cops access contact-tracing data to investigate serious crimes

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Maybe a sense of proportion is needed

I partially disagree. Your core point is important and I've made a similar one, but I take exception to this part:

"The reason isn't to protect the privacy of the users - all of us, I am sure, would completely agree that that privacy should be breached (with appropriate court orders, of course) to investigate very serious crime."

In general, yes it should. With a mandatory tracking system, no it shouldn't. I wouldn't have agreed to have a mandatory tracking system forced on everybody by a court order before, and that reality doesn't change now that there is a system in existence. It would have been unacceptable in 2019 if they decided that, for public safety, they wanted a log of everyone's position. It is not acceptable in 2021 either.

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Years ago ...

The parallel is not exact but is worth some consideration. The issue with the CIA's action in Pakistan, at least the issue right now, is that people are refusing vaccination because they don't trust those authorities who provide it and say it is needed. A similar loss of trust elsewhere may cause a similar backlash. I.E. Western Australian citizens think the app is only there to track their movements without reason and refuse to install it, actively attempt to break it, or launch an organized protest (I think each of those actions would be justified in such a situation). This would destroy any benefit of the app.

Not only would you not have the data for police investigations, you wouldn't have it for health investigations either. Worse, building trust takes a lifetime and destroying it takes a week. Even if you don't care about this app, the next thing a mistrusted government says is necessary may be distrusted and opposed because the last time it was used unethically. That could be anything. In Pakistan, it's a COVID jab which means we may soon see an Epsilon variant stemming from a breach of trust over a decade old. In WA's case, nobody knows what it could be. All I know is that you probably don't want to find out in 2029 that people won't do what the WA government says is needed because they don't trust them.

The response to this pandemic and most other societal problems relies on trusting authorities. Where the authorities are trusted to tell the truth, act in the best interests of the people, and be beholden to their wishes, you get stability. Where that trust is eroded, you get risk. Where the trust is flaky, you get dictatorship. Where trust has vanished, you get civil war. It is the responsibility of authorities to maintain that trust by following understandable ethical rules.

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Maybe a sense of proportion is needed

There are criminals out there, and successfully investigating them is the police's job. That's important. However, there are very good reasons we restrict what police can do. Many powers we could give to police because a lot of them are interested in helping all of us are powers which would be very easy to abuse, so we either restrict them (warrants required for searches) or make them entirely illegal (torture a suspect for information).

A mandatory tracking system is an extreme thing, and it only exists because there is a health emergency. If it was an effective tracking system (I doubt its usefulness), then it's important that people remain confident that it won't be abused. Which is worse: a murderer remains on the run a bit longer because police had to use the powers they already had to catch them, but people remain uninfected or the murderer is caught a little sooner (assumes the data is actually useful) and people get infected because they mistrust the app and refuse to use it? I don't have a perfect answer for this, but not only do you have to consider the negative consequences of giving a very invasive tool to the police but you also have to consider the loss of the beneficial effects of the app if any exist.

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Paper sheet

Possibly so they can write it illegibly or accidentally make a mistake. Tracking systems like this don't record who is near someone, so they're blunt tools for tracing possible infection paths.

SpaceX spat with Viasat: Rival accused of abusing legislation to halt Elon's Starlink expansion

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Goes without saying

If that's the case, the solution is to have them changed or removed as fits your/the people's/the politicians' attitude toward regulation. Not just to ignore them. If they were ignored or bypassed by either Spacex or the FCC, then that is a problem.

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Viasat

It depends how many bits end up there. If enough junk was out there, it could make other activities in that orbit problematic. The orbit is small, so if there was enough debris from collisions, other satellites in the area might have to be repositioned frequently to avoid hitting some of it. It's not a long-term risk because the junk will eventually deorbit, but something which makes other activities untenable could still be a risk. That said, I think Spacex has proven to have the ability to perform the required maneuvers, so they can probably avoid collisions if they're held responsible for any failures.

doublelayer Silver badge

Goes without saying

Of course the complaint filed by a rival is intending to weaponize the law for commercial reasons, and of course a company cares more about the environmental problems caused by their competitors than caused by someone unrelated or themselves (note: Viasat operates geosynchronous satellites, so the same complaints don't apply to them). These things are unsurprising and unimportant.

The only important thing is whether the allegations made by Viasat while attempting to set up roadblocks are true. Did Spacex/the FCC manage to circumvent the required environmental approvals? If you sue me because you don't like me and want to make my life difficult, but I actually did something illegal, then I'm still at fault and the suit is still valid.

There was a crooked man who bought a crooked M1 iMac, and we presume they lived together in a little crooked house

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: This is due to monitors being so wide these days...

Yes they do. In fact one of their organizations used to identify itself as "having adherents all over the globe". I'm always wondering if the flat Earth people are running a massive joke which they take far too seriously or if they actually believe it. Nobody could really be this intense about something they can disprove themselves, right? Then I see the magnetic vaccine people and I guess they can.

doublelayer Silver badge

"This is nonsense and you should stop posting it."

Why? Because the user can do it themselves? The article says that involves ripping off the display panel. I'm sure that voids a warranty and is not the easiest thing to put back on. Because it's not problematic to take it in for repair and have someone else rip off the panel? Because, although they probably won't bill you, they are likely either to say it's not covered or give it back with some other defect caused by the invasive repair which is needed to disconnect two external parts from one another. I repaired an iMac for a friend a while ago. Back then, the method for detaching the stand was A) activate latch, B) fold stand in farther to reveal screws, C) remove screws. The choice of assembly is entirely on Apple.

Now I don't think I would really notice and care about the screen being slightly slanted, but I've also not experienced it. If you agree that it is a problem, then the complaints about what it would take to repair are valid. If you don't agree that it's a problem and that's your argument, it wasn't clear from your writing.

Calendly’s new logo perceived as either bog-standard or kind of crappy

doublelayer Silver badge

I think they have a registration system which works kind of like Outlook does inside an organization but for everybody. That way you can schedule something without the email chain of "I'm available on Tuesday afternoons", "I'm not but how is Wednesday", "I could do any time on Wednesday except for 11:00", "How about 10:00", "That works", "Wait, did you mean 10:00 UK or western Europe time", "UK", "Sorry I'm an hour ahead so that's the 11:00 I couldn't make", etc. I don't know if they do anything else though.

UK competition watchdog begins probe into Apple and Google's total domination of the mobile landscape

doublelayer Silver badge

It may result in that, but capitalism as an ideal does encourage competition. The "free market" about which the original poster spoke is based on this idea. I was not intending to participate in an argument about whether capitalism works, just whether the phone market is a free market. It is not.

doublelayer Silver badge

They asked about barriers. That's a barrier. Because most of the time, the driver is written by the component manufacturer to work with an open spec, not by you. That's a real barrier to other OSes, and it's not at all similar to the landscape of computers, where standardization allows most hardware to work because they implement device-specific code on the device and use an agreed-upon standard which is supported by kernels.

Most of the drivers concerned are written by the device manufacturers specifically for Android, not Linux, and they don't give out the specifications needed to write your own. You can, through tedious effort and legal uncertainty, reverse-engineer the component and try to write one, but that's a significant barrier because your competitors just buy the pieces and use the manufacturer's code. That is why I used the PinePhone example. They are using a CPU which is several years old and underpowered compared to modern phones because it's one with Linux support. Despite the fact that Android devices use the Linux kernel, you can't take one and boot mainline on it due to software unavailable for it. Therefore, you are wrong both about who writes drivers and what is currently available for phones.

doublelayer Silver badge

Most answers wrong:

"Is there a barrier to selling a handset with a different OS on it? No": Yes there is. It's expensive. Software drivers aren't written for anything except Android, so you have to write them yourself (see PinePhone for an example of what it takes).

"Is there a 50/50 split in market share between apple and google? No": Irrelevant.

"Can you launch an android device without Google's shiteware on it. Yes": Not if you also make ones with it on, though, because that's a contract violation. You have to only make AOSP devices for the people who want that. That rules out pretty much everybody who exists today.

"Is this free market ecomonics at play. Yes": No, it's unfair restricted market economics at play. Capitalism likes competition. The lack of it is an inefficiency.

"Can you launch your own app store for both OS.... Erm, not so much.": Only clearly write answer here.

Funny how Sir Tim Berners-Lee, famous for hyperlinks, is into NFTs, glorified hyperlinks

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Crazy.

Not with me. I think this and all other NFTs are useless, but I think most physical collection items are also useless and we don't attack those buying and selling, say, a pair of old shoes for scamming each other. We just don't buy them. In my opinion, if someone is willing to buy something worthless and you don't hide what it is or how much it's worth, then that's on them. Honesty is an important part in this, but I haven't seen him make any claims about what benefit the NFT entails--it gives you nothing more than a signed hash, and everyone who is interested has the time to figure that out.

NATO summit communiqué compares repeat cyberattacks to armed attacks – and stops short of saying 'one-in, all-in' rule will always apply

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Dear China,

The countries which have democratic governments don't do most of those things, and where injustices do occur, they can be changed. A lot of them have done those things, and I have repeatedly argued that past injustices do require present atonement, but it's not the same thing. When antidemocratic actions as described occur in those countries, you see activism, protest, and eventually change. That is why your comparison is invalid. Democracies don't have to be perfect in order to have the moral high ground. They just have to be better. They are.

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: NATO Has One Job

I like the spirit, but find me a way to take down the firewall without taking down the entire network. China runs the whole thing on all their domestic networks. You can't easily just cut the firewall rules while keeping all the network routing functions working.

Linux gods at last turn their gaze to Pi 400: Computer-in-a-keyboard receives mainline kernel support with v5.14

doublelayer Silver badge

"Apart from the novelty factor and educational sector, is there a practical user application?"

Only sort of. There are two reasons I can see for using one of these, but neither are very strong. The best one is insulation--this is in a price range where the competition is likely a VM running on a server. That means you're sharing the hardware, although the hardware is better. If you were worried about a vulnerability in the hypervisor allowing someone to access your data, you might want to run your code on a dedicated server. However, this only sort of works because you're still using network storage and the cloud provider of course has access to anything on your disk if it turns out they're malicious. Most people who distrust hypervisors likely wouldn't accept those either. The second reason is software compatibility--if you had something which didn't work right on other Linux distros but did work on a Pi, this would let you run it. That's most likely to be something compiled for ARM which can't be recompiled for AMD64, although I haven't experienced anything of the kind myself.

"Is it cheaper?"

That depends what you're comparing it with. If you need a VM, then this is in the range but more expensive than the low end of the range. However, those VMs usually have different specs--you often get one virtual core at the low end but it's a faster core. The cloudy Pi 4s are pretty good since they have 8 GB of memory. As long as you can live with the slower processor (much slower on single-core, but the four cores make parallelized things work fine), then it could be price competitive.

The AN0M fake secure chat app may have been too clever for its own good

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Criminality

They have been criticized, sued, and some have entered bankruptcy. People protested outside them. They suffered consequences, as they should have. All of them, Purdue included.

Price-capped broadband on hold for New York State after judge rules telcos would 'suffer unrecoverable losses'

doublelayer Silver badge

Hence this part from the comment you quoted:

"[T]he decisions on whether and how much to charge between ISPs as data moves are also decided by those ISPs."

Are you an ISP who wants more money from Google? Refuse to peer with their ISP. Require a paid contract to exchange bandwidth. It's been done before and it's your choice. Just one problem: they will reciprocate. Your data won't be peering to them either. The companies have already done this to most of their contracts and figured out what costs them least, and they employ people whose job is to continue to check those things. If they don't get a contract at all, then that's either Google's problem (users can't reach them, stop paying) or the user's problem (ponder doing something nasty to the ISP management, think better of it, look to see how far they have to move to get another option).

The ISP establishes a contract to the users which states how much data or bandwidth the user can pull down. The user pays the ISP for that in order that the ISP can pay its bills, among which are the equipment they need to pass bandwidth through their network. You're expecting the ISP to be paid twice for the same service when ISPs already have a lot of market power due to their being little or no competition. It's unreasonable.

doublelayer Silver badge

"And then of course there are the other usual suspects. Like Amazon, Google, Facepalm, Netflix, Disney etc who all make collosal sums of money from online activities, but don't really contribute much towards the costs. But that's the thorny subject behind most of the 'Net Neutrality' debate, ie ISPs pay for everything, content providers should be allowed to enjoy their free ride."

Let's take this part, because it's rubbish. The people who send the data pay for the lines and bandwidth they're using to move data out of their servers. The users pay for the lines and bandwidth they use to get the data into their equipment. Both prices are set by ISPs, and the decisions on whether and how much to charge between ISPs as data moves are also decided by those ISPs. So, despite the fact that the ISPs set all the prices and are paid by everybody involved, somehow the people sending data are getting a free ride? Since everybody is paying, the ISPs have the choice to change their prices, which they do often and the direction is always up. Why do they need even more ability to rent-seek on that monopoly?

Pakistan's Punjab province tells citizens to get jabbed or have their SIM card blocked

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Seriously?

"Are there really a majority of commentards supporting ostracisation of people who decide not to have the vaccine? It is a personal choice"

It is a personal choice that puts others at risk. Society frequently makes judgements about what personal choices are considered personal enough that choice should be maintained and which other ones impact others enough that we need to impinge on choice. For example, it may be a personal choice to drive at racing speeds on residential roads, but it is a dangerous enough choice that it is illegal.

I oppose the forceful method Pakistan is using, mostly because I think it is likely to be unproductive. I do not oppose restrictions on those who choose not to have the vaccination without a good reason. I would consider personally ostracizing them--after all, that's another personal choice and that one doesn't harm anyone but them. As I would not like to associate with someone who drives recklessly with disregard to the pedestrians they might kill, I wouldn't like to associate with someone who is willing to let others who can't get vaccinated get infected with a potentially lethal disease just so they don't have to have some muscle fatigue for a few hours.

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Hmm, awkward

Alright, hyperbole in an attempt at mixing my comment with humor wasn't a good idea. I'll state my point more briefly and without embellishment:

I have some sympathy for those who want a forceful approach to vaccinations, but I think it is unethical and unproductive. I view actions of the severity concerned as forceful and thus advise a more diplomatic approach.

Amazon exec's husband jailed for two years for insider trading. Yes, with Amazon stock

doublelayer Silver badge

Re: Got too greedy yet.....

"it is not illegal to short a company to bankruptcy."

You don't short a company to bankruptcy. Shorting a company just means you bet their stock goes down. If it does, they aren't going bankrupt--their investors own the stock, not them. If it goes down, they likely have other problems which could cause them to go bankrupt, but it's not your shorting. Also, the action of shorting doesn't decrease the price. You just hope it does. You are much more likely to go bankrupt while shorting than your target is because being wrong is dangerous.

"Oh and I am still a little puzzled as to why using information about a company is illegal."

Not enough. Using information about a company which others don't have is illegal. Because by doing that, you're benefiting from a situation which others are not in. Imagine that you own some stock in a company, you know that company's failing, but they haven't told other people yet. If you sell before they announce it, you've made money by selling something worthless to someone who didn't know it. That's why it was made illegal. This is subject to disagreement, but that's the reasoning.