Re: Never gave them my permission
"...now everybody has it."
That's actually an interesting cynical argument I can see soon being argued by defense attorneys. If your data is already out there--and, let's be honest, how many people have been hit by PII breaches more than once?--how much more risk of harm are you really under?
As an analogy: if a ship is irrevocably sinking, how much more damage does drilling one more hole in the hull actually cause?