Re: Fair is fair
And if you believe that you can plait fog
280 publicly visible posts • joined 25 Jan 2018
Except that might be in contravention of FOI depending on what the request stated. If it specified the response in excel then excel it is.
The issue isn't so much excel as people not doing the correct 'admin' prior to sending the response and stripping out extraneous data.
Except it doesn't work like that. If the FOI request was made and specified the response in excel format then they have no choice. Even if the asked for an address to send a physical copy if the requestor says no, I want it in excel they are obliged by law to respond that way
Well it actually does call into question the accuracy of this article (not sure why you went into hyperbole mode about every article ever by this journo) as if they can't get the basics right, the basics that have been the way they are for 20 tears, then how much fact checking did they do to the rest of the article.
Isn't basic accuracy a fundamental reasonable expectation of journalism? Not saying we get it, just that is a reasonable expectation.
You obviously haven't been paying attention as Edwards was very much a lapdog of government and doing everything in his power not to enforce the laws he was responsible for while doing the government's bidding.
He will not be missed by those of us in the Information Governance community as he was a craven egotist who preferred soundbites to actually doing his job. He also had VERY thin skin so anyone who criticised him directly was blocked on social media and regularly gaslighted as being antibusiness etc
No they don't because they don't issue fines, they issue Monetary Penalty Notices which is a subtle but important distinction but hey I have only been doing Information Governance for 20 plus years and have read the various bits of legislation including the ICO's legal status on a daily basis over that period so what do I know.
Yes the ICO isn't fit for purpose (or at least the current Commissioner isn't) but they fined BA the maximum they could under the law so I am not sure what else they could have done.
Last time I checked the ICO wasn't responsible for the pandemic and the financial crash of the aviation industry. Had there been no pandemic then the penalty would have been higher as it is based on the company profits st the time the MPN is issued
Actually it wouldn't require a warrant, it would however require a RIPA Authorisation to conduct covert surveillance.
Walking down the street and observing something in plain sight, like one roof free of snow in a whole street would require neither. You would however need a warrant to enter the premises.
Tell me you don't understand how ICO calculates fines without telling me...
The maximum MPN that can be imposed is based on company turnover and given the company was filing for bankruptcy by definition their turnover was low therefore the fine legally could not be high.
See also BA where a notice of intent for around £180m was issued but the MPN was actually far lower as due to the pandemic their profits cratered and so did the max MPN that could be imposed.
I am all for attacking the Chocolate Teapot that is John Edwards and his tendency towards inactivity, but you can't really criticise when he is constrained in what he can do by the law.
Newsflash...no schools or hospitals have been fined under GDPR in the UK and the only public sector bodies fined were the MoD and the Cabinet office for a combined total of about £1m.
Given the max fine for the public sector is £17m ish I would say neither fine is 'enormous', particularly when you look at the budgets of these departments
Perhaps if you knew the law you would realise they couldn't fine BA £190m in the end.
MPNs (they aren't fines and this is an important distinction to make) are based on turnover at the point the MPN is issued.
As the arse had fallen out of the Aviation industry due to the pandemic by the time the MPN was issued the fine was reduced as BA's turnover was significantly reduced.
By all means criticise the ICO as the current incumbent is a charlatan who is more interested in soundbites than actual meaningful action, but at least criticise them for something they have done wrong rather than doing what the law allows them to do.
I am struggling to see what the issue is in relation to Apple requiring employees use their tech when working... I would assume Dell Staff use Dell PCs/Laptops and HP Staff would use HP devices and it seems a fairly obvious thing to do/expect (with certain caveats i.e. iDevice cannot do a certain thing so another device is required to fulfil that task)
The access to personal devices is an overstretch mind unless they suspect said employee is doing something shonky using their own device
Au contraire. In the UK there may be the expectation that you will be caught on CCTV but the use of FRT without notification is a clear case of unauthorised processing, particularly by a private entity, and so whether it takes 0.004 of a second or 4000 seconds to process the image its still unlawful.
Also for the purposes of DP law the data is still 'collected' even if the whole lifecycle of the process from collection to disposal is a fraction of a second.
Of course the easiest solution is proper signage but why would a multi million/billion AUS$ business bother with that as it will cost them to put the signs up and eat into their profit.
Actually under GDPR as the 'home' authority for Ryanair the Irish DPA is the one responsible for all regulatory issues across the EU so the other national authorities will defer to them.
It would operate the same with an Irish customer of Air France making a DP complaint - any regulatory action would be dealt with by the CNIL, the French DPA.