* Posts by steelpillow

2583 publicly visible posts • joined 16 Jun 2016

Google imagines out of this world AI - running on orbital datacenters

steelpillow Silver badge

Surely so.

Also looking forward to the formation-swarms sweeping up some of the growing piles of space junk in low Earth orbits.

UK judge delivers a 'damp squib' in Getty AI training case, no clear precedent set

steelpillow Silver badge

In the news: Dog bites Man! UK Judge makes sense! (Only kidding, m'Lud)

> by the end of that process the Model itself does not store any of those Copyright Works.

Right. It just reproduces their subject matter and/or style, which is perfectly legal. Like, when I was at college I drew cartoons in the style of the Peanuts characters we all knew well. Had I traced them off a published strip, I could have been sued; were an AI to copy pixel for pixel, it too would be in trouble.

And don't reproduce the feckin' trademark! So I took care to sign myself Schplatz.

Some sense at last emerging from the AI shitfest.

Now, how the hell do you get an AI to understand what a trademark is and recognise one when it sees it? IMHO this problem might just focus minds rather usefully.

Google Cloud suspended customer's account three times, for three different reasons

steelpillow Silver badge
Mushroom

Enshittification

A perfect example of the way Web2 is going.

As my grandparents used to say, if you want something doing, you have to do it yourself.

ISPs more likely to throttle netizens who connect through carrier-grade NAT: Cloudflare

steelpillow Silver badge
Holmes

Re: NAT Advisory Protocol

Automated, mate. I mean, who has to manually update DHCP tables, FFS.

steelpillow Silver badge
Coat

NAT Advisory Protocol

A modest proposal:

Maintain a NAT Gateway Register.

Check the IP of the bot against it. If it is on the register, then alert the gateway using NAP.

Gateway then sniffs its own armpit and blocks source IP.

Debian demands Rust or rust in peace for legacy ports

steelpillow Silver badge
Holmes

Kernel capers

So, with all that C code and arbitrary driver blobs in Linux, Debian no doubt have a rusty new kernel up their sleeves....

Will this be the day that Devuan loses its Debian dependencies? I kinda hope so.

International Criminal Court kicks Microsoft Office to the curb

steelpillow Silver badge
Holmes

Re: Look at the Germans trying to take credit for UK tech

Collabora is mainly the document editing component of openDesk, with many others such as NextCloud and XWiki providing other components. Both outfits acknowledge Collabora's active support for openDesk. Collabora in turn is built on top of LibreOffice, to which they also contribute substantially, along with German outfit allotropia.

None of this changes the fact that it is ZenDiS, the German Government-owned Center for Digital Sovereignty, that pulls openDesk together as a coherent deal and makes it available.

A splendid example of Anglo-German cooperation, IMHO. Long may it continue.

Elon Musk's Grokipedia launches, filled to the brim with plagiarism and AI slop

steelpillow Silver badge
Pint

Re: Already more accurate

I am impressed by the number of commentards above whose heads your neatly ironic lampoon flies.*

* For their benefit, I should explain that I use the word "impressed" ironically.

steelpillow Silver badge

Re: ROTFL

@AC

>And Larry Sangar's criticisms. What say you of them?

Never heard of him. If you want me to care, you'll have to post his criticisms here in a nice Steelpillow-friendly format, I do have a life.

steelpillow Silver badge

Re: Muckipedia

Grotipedia

steelpillow Silver badge
Devil

ROTFL

Not the first to get the hump over Wikipedia's editorial practices and fire up an aspirational "better than" to show how it should be done, won't be the last. The few that don't soon fade away just barely sputter on in the background.

It's all down to the open and democratic consensus-building which lies at the heart of the Wikipedia ethos - and hence the way the MediaWiki software works.

It's surprising how many people cannot bear the idea of losing editorial control, passionately believe that Wikipedia "ought" to say what they want it to say, and regard us Wikipedians as the attached icon. I tell them to go away and build their own, which makes them hate me even more.

The Chinese Box and Turing Test: AI has no intelligence at all

steelpillow Silver badge

Re: no reason that AGI cannot eventually evolve

You are playing with words. We all talk of how technology is constantly evolving - "evolution not revolution" - and we all know we don't mean self-replication. It should be obvious even to you that I don't either. Yet you assume the contrary. Not impressed.

steelpillow Silver badge

Re: Someday AGI?

No shit, Sherlock. We all agree that AGI needs a cognitive step or twenty beyond today's crud. But remember, if we can evolve from flatworms, there is no reason that AGI cannot eventually evolve from GenAI. The basic flatworm biochemistry is still the lowest-level substrate in you and me. So too will GenAI form a low-level function for the AGI on top of it.

steelpillow Silver badge
Facepalm

Re: Someday AGI?

FFS! Do you not understand the difference between a substrate and an architecture?

steelpillow Silver badge
Holmes

Re: Someday AGI?

General Intelligence has evolved several times, following independent lines. Those which survive today include cephalopods, cartilaginous fish, birds and mammals. The neural physiology of these brains can vary enormously, converging back on some primeval flatworm with nothing but bilateral symmetry and a spinal nerve to its name. They all obey exactly the same law of physics as the silicon chip - heck, we can even implant chips in the human brain to offer basic vision for the blind and sound for the deaf. It is groundless metaphysical dogma to suggest that these chips cannot be developed to follow the carbon wetware to true AGI.

Sure today's AIs still lack the basic requirement of semantic extraction and modelling which underpins cognition, but for how long?

steelpillow Silver badge

Re: Isn't the Turing test considered "invalid" ?

It's not fair to say that some people "fail" the Turing test, they are just not very bright - and it shows.

But, as you say, that does not mean the Turing test can be debased to embrace mimicry without understanding.

We have learned a lot about how the brain, and hence the human mind, work since Turing's day. The Turing test is more a test of cognitive understanding and semantic reasoning than a test of simple mimicry via statistical filtering, no matter how high the intelligence being imitated.

steelpillow Silver badge

AMI - Artificial Muppet Intelligence?

steelpillow Silver badge
Boffin

The Muppet Test

> if a judge can't tell whether they're conversing with a human or machine, the machine passes.

As I have said before, only if a judge of Turing's calibre cannot tell will the machine pass the Turing test.

If it fools only Muppet judges, then it has only passed the Muppet test.

You have one week to opt out or become fodder for LinkedIn AI training

steelpillow Silver badge
Holmes

I'm cool

You imagine I ever put anything on LinkedIn that I did not want the world to see, scrape and trumpet from the rooftops? FFS! We are not all dumb as shit, you know.

Digital ID is now less about illegal working, more about rummaging through drawers

steelpillow Silver badge

Re: Gaslighting

> Are they that maliciously stupid?

More likely they are just thoughtlessly stupid, having never heard of the Law of Unintended Consequences.

The only people to benefit from this will be those rich and powerful enough to do the employing - or not, as they feel inclined. Now what's what I call core Labour Socialism!

steelpillow Silver badge
Devil

Persecution Day

So, if you don't qualify or you refuse on principle, your existing employer has you over a barrel. You have to take every scumbag abuse and exploitation they throw at you, or face being thrown onto the muckpile of the unemployed and unemployable. Enjoy the choice!

A single DNS race condition brought Amazon's cloud empire to its knees

steelpillow Silver badge

Re: bed is stuck

Schadenfreude

steelpillow Silver badge
Facepalm

Re: Looks like they still didn't catch the cause

A cascade of FFS! causes:

1. The enactor should not have been running slow.

2. Nothing to monitor its status.

3. The various boxen had no idea what to do about it before jumping in feet-first, cuz nobody had thought through Murphy's Law.

4. Someone who knows what they are doing should have been retained with sweeteners, not driven out by bullying manglement.

I expect there are several more.

Microsoft finance slang defines the eternal optimist: The 'hockey stick on wheels'

steelpillow Silver badge
Joke

Why don't you go take a running puck at a rolling hockey stick?

Amazon brain drain finally sent AWS down the spout

steelpillow Silver badge

> they need to refocus on quality

As in re F.O.C.U.S.

A simple AI prompt saved a developer from this job interview scam

steelpillow Silver badge

Re: "the faker posed as the chief blockchain officer"

Me want T-Shirt! Wear to work. :D

steelpillow Silver badge
Coffee/keyboard

Re: Who on earth wants to put blockchain work on their CV in 2025?

> LinkedIn Users.

You wouldn't mind making my new keyboard a Dvorak, would you?

AI boffins teach office supplies to predict your next move

steelpillow Silver badge
Facepalm

"Hi!"

"It looks like you are trying to stab your hand with a paperclip. Can I help?"

Schleswig-Holstein waves auf Wiedersehen to Microsoft stack

steelpillow Silver badge
Pint

A journey of a thousand steps

And the nice thing is, because of all the heavy lifting done by Schleswig-Holstein, it will be less daunting for others to follow suit. And harder for the naysayers to justify themselves.

Das Jahr von Linux auf dem Desktop kommt ein Wenig näher.

Framework flame war erupts over support of politically polarizing Linux projects

steelpillow Silver badge

The Wikipedia Take

Wikipedia hit this "are we allowed to hate our fellow contributors?" issue a good many years ago. After much heated exchange along the lines seen here, we formed a consensus that who you are is axiomatically irrelevant to "the encyclopedia that anyone can edit." All you need to do is stick to our community rules and not bring your personal bias with you. Founder Jimmy Wales reserves the right of personal diktat, and stepped in to ban paedos. So, as long as nobody knows you are a paedo, and you obey house rules, you can contribute to Wikipedia still.

We all know and love Linus Torvald's personal diktats, but I never heard of one that was not community/content based.

We also all know and have mixed feelings over the Debian overlords' community diktats. From now on, I am tempted to refer to them all as Jimmy.

Vodafone keels over, cutting off millions of mobile and broadband customers

steelpillow Silver badge
Trollface

Re: Every cloud has a silver lining

Boo! Hiss! Give that man an exploding cigar!

steelpillow Silver badge
Happy

Every cloud has a silver lining

WFH via a Vodafone WiFi router on the window sill. VPN to Steelpillow's Paymasters went down. Yay! Afternoon off!

Researchers intercept unencrypted satellite traffic from space blabbermouths

steelpillow Silver badge

Re: "unencrypted login credentials"

It's all that stuff written in COBOL and Pascal, that they refused to pay the last maintainer to update before he died fifteen years ago.

OpenAI GPT-5: great taste, less filling, now with 30% less bias

steelpillow Silver badge
Headmaster

Re: What is Ideologically neutral ?

I think you are describing a null ideology rather than a neutral one. Bit like the difference between an open circuit vs a mains Neutral connection.

steelpillow Silver badge

Re: What is Ideologically neutral ?

My ideology is self-evidently neutral, it's all the others that are biased.

More seriously, ideologies are made up in order to try and guide society away from primitive savagery. A "neutral" ideology would fail to give any direction, and be as aimless as its starting point. It's a contradiction in terms.

Microsoft lets bosses spot teams that are dodging Copilot

steelpillow Silver badge
Meh

Well, yeah, if it's around 25% trash it's almost certainly AI slop. 49% plus is a three-sigma chance it's the droid in person. Assessing it as below 15% means you just failed the Muppet test.

steelpillow Silver badge
Joke

"Oi you, stop that!"

"You are in the doghouse for AI avoidance."

Next week: "Oi you, stop that! You are in the doghouse for churning out AI slop all day long!"

"What's that, you want a meeting to agree an official AI usage window? Oh, dear, that's above my level of responsibility, I'll have to escalate that to my Demi-God."

Three years later: "Oi you, stop that! You are doing useful work and scuppering my attempts to tilt the AI Policy my way! Make sure you are at the 100th meeting next month."

Humans flunk the Turing test for voices as bots get chattier

steelpillow Silver badge

Re: If they want to disguise AI voices

The problem is, smart processing of human voices gets ever more aggressive: breathing sounds filtered out along with the office hubub and vacuum cleaner, comfort noise re-inserted in the resulting deathly quiet pauses, frequency spectrum massaged to a standard formula, and/or high frequencies "restored" and phasing "optimised". Goes without saying the AI rendition suffers a similar fate. Can YOU tell what source an "enhanced" processed audio track comes from? Not if the enhancement developers can help it! Who is this feckin' Tureen anyway? Did he invent mock turtle soup or somethin'?

steelpillow Silver badge
Facepalm

Re: Turing test this is not

If I set up a task to correct the spelling of "hipopottamus", is is ludicrous to suggest that, because MS Word can do that, it is indistinguishable from an educated person. So it is with voice impersonations. Sorry mate, but whatever you are on, you need to come down off it.

steelpillow Silver badge
Flame

Turing test this is not

Ever since moving pictures and recorded sound were introduced, people have been fooled by crafty playback scenarios.

This was, um, errr, not quite what Alan Turing had in mind when he sought to test if there was a human level of cognition in the delivery.

Meanwhile, it is hardly remarkable that AIs can write intelligible English in the style of some given author. That is mere prettying-up of a prerequisite - the word sequence - for a Turing test for cognitive understanding behind the written words. So it is with these little speeches.

What we see here is a Muppet test for Muppets who imagine they have been fooled by an actual Turing test.

Google goes straight to shell with AI command line coding tool

steelpillow Silver badge

Re: Dev lives in terminals?

CLI - Man pages tell you how to do everything except what you actually want to do.

WIMP GUI - Menus and icons offer you everything you don't want to do.

Touch GUI - Sod Pokémon, this game is about discovering all the gestures that pop up what you don't want to do.

AI assistant - Responds with answers to everything you didn't ask about.

steelpillow Silver badge
Windows

Re: Dev lives in terminals?

Counjures up images (icon) of the guy with his sleeping bag on the floor of my local bus terminal. Never realised he was a developer.

BT promises 5G Standalone for 99% of the UK by 2030

steelpillow Silver badge
Unhappy

Re: Grumpy old git

My Mobile provider refuses to enable my brand of vanilla-Android phone's built-in WiFi calling. It's phone calls home to check the larder I need, not Google Maps to navigate the aisles.

steelpillow Silver badge
Pint

Re: Grumpy old git

Nice one. Have a beer.

Just added the tokens to my Minecraft CraftGPT excuse generator.

steelpillow Silver badge
Windows

Grumpy old git

I don't want 5G. I want 4G/LTE, or even 2.5G, /inside/ the bloody supermarkets.

steelpillow Silver badge
Boffin

Depends whether the bottleneck is in the 5G air interface or the 4G back end.

No suds for you! Asahi brewery attack leaves Japanese drinkers dry

steelpillow Silver badge
Facepalm

Re: There is a pattern here

UK Gov has bottomed it out. According to the BBC, they have just diagnosed the root problem: The true extent of cyber attacks on UK business - and the weak spots that allow them to happen. Not enough spent on cybersecurity perhaps? Aww, c'm on, no, the real problem is that it's too easy these days to get hold of ransomware.

India's tech talent pipeline is sputtering

steelpillow Silver badge
Trollface

Re: Whose side are they on ?

Don't be such a troll - look at all those unhappy downvotes! In eighteen months the table-top nuclear reactor will arrive and save the West. I just need another $10bn starter fund...

Mad man builds chatbot in Minecraft with redstone, Python, and patience

steelpillow Silver badge
Joke

Solid, Bro'

> "The model is very prone to going off topic, producing responses that are not grammatically correct, or simply outputting garbage"

So, a pretty solid rendering of your state-of-the-art chatbot then, if perhaps a little slow.

Maybe he should build a GPU card in Minecraft, to go with it?

... Hey, what, Mozilla have started a project for a desktop GUI coded in Minecraft? Are you sure you didn't just read that on the Internet?

UK splurges £4.4M on drones, e-planes, and other flights of fancy

steelpillow Silver badge

Re: OXCAM

But both towns have top-flight (sic) hospitals. Why should they need to ferry emergency patents to and fro?