Re: Re:Atheism is no more rational and theism.
Trevor_Pott:
>Atheism is about a desperate need to believe there is no god. They have no evidence.
Evidence to prove a negative? I trust you see the fallacy of that position.
I have a hard time accepting fantastically large claims without a shred of evidence. And further, where a large number of these fantastic claims are now provably false with scientific advancement. Want to bet that more religious claims of divine truth will not be debunked in due time?
I presume a minority of people have a pathological need to disbelieve, basically as contrarians. But the test for that is easy: these people would still not believe if shown scientifically rigorous evidence. This does not seem to be the majority position of Atheists, as you seem to think.
When you examine believers, there is commonly an emotional hook that compels them to believe. This is why they are impervious to rational discourse. Their decision to believe is not a rational one, but emotional.
Note that the reverse cannot be said (without ridicule). It is completely rational not to believe something that has no evidence.
Finally, my fraud detector goes off when people are selling an invisible product. No one is going to come back from the dead and say what it's really like. But, if you can remember what it was like before you were born, it'll probably be a lot like that.
Hey, do you remember how things changed in the middle ages? Neither do I.