* Posts by C.Carr

35 publicly visible posts • joined 17 Nov 2016

Worry not. China's on the line saying AGI still a long way off

C.Carr

Re: Generative AI models have passed the Turing Test ...

Some models can pick the next appropriate image in a sequence, by figuring out the rule. Doing it close to human level requires a lot of very expensive inference compute.

People in these comments really have no idea what they're talking about.

Ex-Googler Schmidt warns US: Try an AI 'Manhattan Project' and get MAIM'd

C.Carr

Not to worry

Chill, America. It's not like the CCP would pursue some big centralized program.

Signal will withdraw from Sweden if encryption-busting laws take effect

C.Carr

Will the UK then ban the side loading of apps on Android devices? Will they ban VPNs? If they don't want anyone using user-friendly, E2EE messaging apps, that's what they'll have to do. ... but then I suppose they'll also have to ban flashing custom ROMs on Android devices ... and if you keep going they're going to have to ban GitHub ... and if you go even farther they'll have to ban semiconductors ... then the one-time-pad technique ... then writing implements ... ... and eventually math.

US senator wants to slap prison term, $1M fine on anyone aiding Chinese AI with ... downloads?

C.Carr

Re: Instead of improving the quality of American goods...

You do know the year isn't 1985, right? There is very high-end cheese and chocolate in the USA. Some of us live in cities and don't shop at Walmart.

Also, those Cadbury eggs are nasty.

C.Carr

Research

Do we know for certain that access to genAI CSAM doesn't in fact _reduce_ the acquisition and production of the real thing? Seems to me we might want to figure that out prior to potentially making things worse.

Mental toll: Scale AI, Outlier sued by humans paid to steer AI away from our darkest depths

C.Carr

Re: Mechanical Turk

Or, more accurately, there was likely a mechanical Turk involved at some point in the process. Your little aphorism could be read as a claim that inference is all human workers, all the time.

C.Carr

Hmm, ok.

Not to completely dismiss the possibility of genuine psychological harm, but I wonder what these people thought the job was. They seem ... fragile to me, and certainly not suited to such work.

Short of outright horrors like snuff films and child porn, I'm pretty certain I wouldn't be bothered -- and, honest, I'm not a socio/psychopath. I was, however, born in the 70s, and so perhaps psychological put together a little differently than the kiddos these days.

We can't make this stuff up: Palantir, Anduril form fellowship for AI adventures

C.Carr

"Sauron is the embodiment of evil on Earth ..."

Well, not really. Sauron is more the embodiment of fascism. Big on order. Morgoth was more the pure evil guy.

Imagine a land in which Big Tech can't send you down online rabbit holes or use algorithms to overcharge you

C.Carr

The CCP would prefer to be the only entity that can manipulate and control the populace in such ways. Or maybe they're just genuinely concerned about the wellbeing of Chinese citizens. Lol.

C.Carr

Re: Some good ideas but at what cost

Orwellian? The Chinese Communist Party? Who would have thought ...

Why Google's Chrome monopoly won't crack anytime soon

C.Carr

What would open-sourcing Chrome even mean? It's already based on Chromium, plus proprietary Google stuff.

Linus Torvalds affirms expulsion of Russian maintainers

C.Carr

If Putin were really that concerned about the expansion of NATO, he wouldn't have commenced an invasion that anyone with two neurons to run together could have foreseen leading to Sweden and Finland joining the organization.

Great job, Vlad, your border with NATO has increased by 1,340 km.

Putin knew Ukraine was never going to invade Russia. He knew Ukraine was never going to invade Russia.

Russia's top-secret military unit reportedly plots undersea cable 'sabotage'

C.Carr

Russian influence campaign bots and university sophomore post-Soviet-neo-tankies. What a lovely comment section.

C.Carr

Re: Russian activity damaging undersea critical infrastructure

They're called Russian trolls, with some Putin-lovin' MAGA folk and a few lefty tankies.

Before we put half a million broadband satellites in orbit, anyone want to consider environmental effects?

C.Carr

Starlink sats are in a low enough orbit that they passively deorbit in a fairly short period of time -- like 5 years, IIRC, without station keeping.

Satellites above 600km are a much larger concern

I guess you can review the environmental impact of all those launches, but there is no environmental impact to review in, you know, space.

Google begs court for relief from Epic Games' Play Store demands

C.Carr

If the Play Store is a monopoly, what the heck is is the Apple App Store? On Android, one can at least fairly easily side-load apps, by flipping a settings toggle. Last I heard, that's not possible on iOS at all without a jailbreak.

Disenchanted Windows user? Pop open a fresh can of Linux Lite

C.Carr

KDE would be better. Windows 10/11 user is going to think they were transported back to the early aughts with XFCE.

C.Carr

I think you've really got this backward. You're thinking people coming from Windows 10/11 are going to find XFCE appealing? People coming from Windows are generally going to want all the bells and whistles -- they aren't going to be satisfied with a bare-bones distro.

A tale of two missions: Starliner and Starship both achieve milestones

C.Carr

Re: "before toppling over into the ocean"

You're misunderstanding what this was. They set the booster down in the water at around 2 or 3 km/hr, in a vertical position -- which is exactly what they were trying to do.

It was a test flight. They intended to expend the booster. Eventually (apparently in the near term) they are going to attempt to set the booster down on arms extending from the launch tower. Whether that's attempted on the next test flight probably has a lot to do with just how much booster descent control they had, and how accurately they placed the water landing.

By the way, every single other US rocket manufacturer dumps their booster in the ocean -- IIRC, Rocket Lab may have recovered and refurbished one. Everyone else throws them away.

C.Carr

Re: Think that 33rd engine did light

I'm assuming much of the control is from thrust gimbaling, but I'm sure the flaps play some significant role coming out of the belly flop.

The software must have been compensating for the screwed up aerodynamic control surfaces.

C.Carr

Re: Think that 33rd engine did light

That hinge mechanism seems to be amazingly robust. I was sure that flap was going to tear off. I was very surprised to see it still actuating right before splash down.

Flight control software must be very good as well, to compensate for those missing chunks, being able to pull off the flip despite screwed up aerodynamics from the holes.

Glad to see that Starliner did manage to dock. I know a crew capsule isn't trivial, but Starship-level difficult it is not.

Endless OS 6: How desktop Linux may look, one day

C.Carr

Re: Gnome? Friendly?

No downvotes from me. It's _fine_ with a few extensions. Sort of spiffy, even.

Manjaro has some decent Gnome setups out of the box.

Gentoo and NetBSD ban 'AI' code, but Debian doesn't – yet

C.Carr

Re: Squawk!

Except that just isn't how it works.

DEF CON to set thousands of hackers loose on LLMs

C.Carr

Better than hackers for red teaming an LLM

If you're finding exploits in the ChatGPT web app, or whatnot, sure, hackers -- but if we're talking about probing for "bias, hallucinations, and jailbreaks," with a natural language interface, they should get a bunch of academic linguists, maybe particularly people with applied linguistics degrees.

Online Safety Bill age checks? We won't do 'em, says Wikipedia

C.Carr

Safest place in the world ... ?

Even safer than ... China? How about Iran? Saudi Arabia?

I don't know, fellas, that's a tall order. Maybe set your sights a little lower, like Russia.

US cyber spymaster calls TikTok China's 'Trojan horse'

C.Carr

Welcome, Wumao. Y'all are indeed getting better.

The issue isn't merely that kids spend a lot of time on it, it's that they spend a lot of time on it *and* the CCP can do whatever they want with that attention. Bytedance has zero ability to refuse Beijing. Chinese government control over Bytedance is unparalleled in Europe or the USA (although the CCP has banned US social media, search, online tools, etc, anyway).

If tomorrow an app out of Sweden took American youths by storm, and stole all the attention away from TikTok, no one in the US government would give two sharts.

Why ChatGPT should be considered a malevolent AI – and be destroyed

C.Carr

A toaster that is entirely incapable of harming a human is also incapable of making toast.

Spooky entanglement revealed between quantum AI and the BBC

C.Carr
Meh

Are they going to build fancy androids with sophisticated nervous systems?

Human language is the product of embodied things that walk around on the surface of a big spheroid, at the bottom of a gravity well. Words point to things in the world, as well as at each other in a network.

You can't fully comprehend language by only examining relationships between words. A system that understands human language must be able to hear and see and pick things up, and feel the inertial mass of objects smacking it upside the head.

Better CEO is 'taking time off' after firing 900 staff on Zoom

C.Carr

Hopefully his time off makes him feel better, poor fella. That must have been hard on him.

Turns out humans are leading AI systems astray because we can't agree on labeling

C.Carr

Re: AI in everything is the problem

To state the obvious, the labels need to consist in more than their complex relationships with other mere labels. The actual things need to be represented by sensory data, and the AI system needs to be located, discretely, in 3D space --- that is, if we want a system to actually *know* what things are.

The killing of CentOS Linux: 'The CentOS board doesn't get to decide what Red Hat engineering teams do'

C.Carr

Re: We are still in the "Decide where to go" process where I work.

For 97% of people who aren't sure if Ubuntu LTS is a suitable replacement for CentOS, it is. The less sure one is, the more likely Ubuntu LTS is a perfectly fine replacement.

CompSci student bitten by fox after feeding it McNuggets

C.Carr

Idiot college kids thinks: Well, I think this wild animal is really cute, so it necessarily follows then that the animal won't bite me if I move my hand towards its head.

Dumbarses.

Alphabet, Apple, Dell, Tesla, Microsoft exploit child labor to mine cobalt for batteries, human-rights warriors claim

C.Carr

Cobalt sources in the USA, Canada, and Australia need to be developed.

A bit tangential -- we going to need a heck of a lot more copper as well, if there is any hope of rapid decarbonization. Big Oil vs Big Mineral -- can't get rid of both.

After four years, Rust-based Redox OS is nearly self-hosting

C.Carr

That's really quite impressive, actually.

Security bods find Android phoning home. Home being China

C.Carr

"Security researchers have uncovered a secret backdoor in Android phones ..."

*Some* Android phones. A relatively small number.

The way it's phrased makes it sound like there's a backdoor *in Android*. Were you trying to be misleading in that paragraph, or are you dense?