The Fundamental Problem
The “test” of whether your work role is a supervisor or not is if you are able to impose any kind of discipline or punishment upon a subordinate.
So the Americans voters are proud that they are the “boss” of the government, but of course that’s not true: there is absolutely zero recourse against any politician, except to vote support for some alternative.
And the nature of democracy is to divide into two main opposing groups, left vs right, which increasingly become dominated by extremist fringe elements pushing radical agendas.
Meanwhile, almost all of the voting public are merely consumers just trying to make the best choice out of a radicalized extremist selection.
Hey, did you know there’s another form of democracy? One that forms the backbone of Robert’s rules of order?
Yes it’s known as “plebiscite” in which voters are provided fully symmetric voting options: support, opposition, or abstain from the vote. The full numeric range: +1, -1, or 0.
Hey did you ever realize that, when you go to cast a vote in general election, there’s one of those options missing? Like, you can vote support or you can abstain, so you get the +1 and 0 options. What happened to the -1 option?
I wonder what would become of rich and famous candidates if all of a sudden voters were equally capable of voting -1 as they are of voting +1, I wonder if being rich and famous might become equally a political liability as it is a political advantage.
Maybe unqualified and discredited candidates might face a bit more headwind in that circumstance. You know, if “no such thing as bad publicity” becomes less of a truism, somehow.
Hey, what if voters were able to reject ALL the unqualified fringe extremist candidates, and force a new election, and allow some better-qualified candidates to run in place of the rejected ones?
What if voters were provided the power to discipline or to punish political candidates, for once? You know, as if voters were “actually” in charge of the government, as like a supervisory arrangement, in which government acts for the benefit of the voters for once in history.
I call this radical fringe extremist idea “r/PlebisciteBallot” it’s on Reddit, I even described it one time on YouTube, but I can’t seem to get any traction.
Hey, do you have an issue with arrogant unqualified discredited politicians, and can’t think of anything to do to solve it?
I have the humble suggestion that maybe one time we might trying this fully-symmetric version of democracy that they enjoy in parliament and other places of power.
Who knows, maybe something worthwhile?!