The Register Home Page

* Posts by Doctor Syntax

43063 publicly visible posts • joined 16 Jun 2014

Page:

Vint Cerf: Everything we do will be ERASED! You can't even find last 2 times I said this

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Long term survival

Historically the survival of any particular document has been a matter of chance. Some Anglo Saxon charters survive as originals. Some older documents have survived in particularly favourable environments. For the most part, however, texts from antiquity have survived as copies several generations removed from the original and the more copies were made the greater the chance that one or more has survived.

I don't see that changing in terms of digital texts. Anything posted to Geocities, for example, is long gone unless someone copied it - archive.org doesn't seem to have got it all. If Google decided that Groups should go the same way as Wave how much of Usenet would survive?

If we are to have digital records available far into the future we need to do three things:

Have multiple archives of what is to be preserved*

Each archive needs to copy its material onto new media as old ones become obsolete

In addition to copying material archives need to translate obsolete file formats into current ones**

* What is chosen for preservation is a thorny problem. Every time an archivist decides to weed the archive their decisions will be incomprehensible to someone. I remember some years ago wandering into a 2nd-hand bookshop in Cromer and bound volumes of Nature that the county library had disposed of crammed into all sorts of corners.

** Ideally one format that can be kept current for a long time - long in an archival sense. PDF/A?

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Not really much of a problem

'In the main, the "plebs'" lives aren't very interesting - not even of today's "plebs."...Certainly there are things that need to be preserved - the back ground of historical events and agreements'

Maybe not from your point of view. However as you're not the only person in this planet that's a fairly limited one. Social historians find these lives much more interesting than the doings of the political classes.

To take one tiny area - how did the domestic textile industry of the West Riding evolve? Just how did the clothiers operate? How did this differ from the domestic industries of other areas such as the Cotswolds? How did it differ from the development of the metal-working industry of the Sheffield area? Manorial and parish records are remarkably unforthcoming about this aspect of their inhabitants. These are not trivial historical concerns; these trades launched parts of the industrial revolution and yet our understanding of them is quite limited.

Proposed US law could deal knockout blow to FBI in overseas cloud privacy ding-dongs

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: For the clueless...

Or maybe a business doing business with a US company? Or competing with one? Or...?

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: RE NY judge getting EU data

MyKolab claims to hold all data in Switzerland.

Gullible Apple users targeted by bogus order cancellation scam

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: The Oracle of technology

"we just all need to start replying to all Nigerian/Ivory Coast/Congo/etc 'princes' and they'll eventually get overwhelmed"

I'd like the mail services to add an option to forward each mail in the junk folder to the Reply to addresses of all the other mail. That would overwhelm them PDQ.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Thin line

"often its grammar as"

Oh, the irony!

UN negotiations menaced by topless women. Or not

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: He's just shy

"I do think that his hypothetical scenario reflects more his fantasies than reality, though."

Are you sure? I thought this was an interesting insight into Belarus and its politics.

Free WiFi coming to UK trains ... in two years

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Chiltern experience

From my experience of Chiltern back in the day just having trains would have been an improvement. Many hours were spent on Marylebone station waiting for them to find enough working DMUs to cobble together a train. At least that was my guess as to what was happening.

Skin colour's irrelevant. Just hire competent folk on their merits, FFS

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: marketing bacon at the synagogue ??

Jewish senior manager at a former client decided to regard bacon butties as kosher.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Three considerations

1. Why should MS (or Google, F/B, Twits or any other business) know what the composition of their workforce is in terms of race, sexuality or anything else? It shouldn't be an attribute on their staff database. Male/female might reasonably be if it's affected by different legislated retirement ages but that's that the only good reason to gather that information.

2. Age still seems to be a PC-allowable basis for discrimination.

3. What proportion of African ancestry is required to be classed as $terminology-of-choice as opposed to white? I ask partly because there are occasional findings of African Y-chromosome haplotypes in English families with no clear explanation.

'Giving geo-engineering to this US govt is like giving a child a loaded gun'

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Never mind that...

For some value of Swedish blonde that is non-volcanic?

BBC bins pricey Windows Media, Audio Factory goes live

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

From the blog

"These are still very early days for Audio Factory and we have been very focussed on getting the service live. There are still some local stations in mono, and our full range of bit rates and delivery methods have yet to be rolled out. "

And did it not occur to anyone that the time to close down what was already working was after the new version was fully rolled out?

Car? Check. Driver? Nope. OK, let's go, says British govt

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

I'd be quite happy to provide them with a local test route.

It would consist of roads which according to the local council are part of the road network and shown as such on the OS 1:25000 map. Several would be roads which have an unsealed but reasonable surface and are closed off with locked gates. Another would be a road which is occupied by a stream and supports dense rushes about 2 feet high. A final one would be a road bypassed by a turnpike in the late C18th and by the mid C19th had been subsumed into the field system following enclosures a few decades earlier.

Samsung: Our TVs? Spying on you? Ha Ha! Just a joke of course

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Is this at all surprising?

"Turned off the voice recognition first thing"

At least you thought you did.....

About that UK digital biz renaissance? Not so fast

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Another source of misleading registrations

Off the shelf companies. When I went freelance my accountant had a stock of pre-registered companies to hand out to new clients - and maybe old clients who needed an extra company.

Back off – it is ILLEGAL to make us accountable, claim ICANN lawyers

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Who appoints the board?

Presumably the members. So they can be given the choice of doing what the members want or leaving the gravy train.

World's mega-rich tax dodge exposed: Meet the HSBC IT bloke at the heart of damning leak

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Many legitimate reasons to hold a Swiss bank account?

3. You do business in Switzerland.

Boy, 16, cuffed after posting selfie with body of kid he allegedly killed

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Inadmissable...

Irrelevant whether the photo was saved or not. The recipient saw it and can testify to that.

Why 1.6 million people will miss Microsoft's Windows Server 2003 date with fate

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: 'Server systems are generally thought isolated from external attackers'

If you read the article it then goes on to call this an illusion and by implication an illusion held by those who also hold the purse strings.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Rockin' hard place.

"they didn't want to do it"

And do they also not want to make sales of their other products or services in the future?

$10,000 Ethernet cable promises BONKERS MP3 audio experience

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: I would buy them only for "tabs that are virtually unbreakable"

No, surely you want tabs that are really unbreakable.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: One born every minute

" the 1s would be backed up"

You have to unplug the cable from time to time to empty them out.

Calling a friend? Listen to an advert. You lucky, lucky thing

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Stop scraping...

...you've reached the bottom of the barrel.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Marketing types....

I think the prime requirement to be in advertising is to be so self obsessed as to actually believe that the world is anxiously waiting for your next fart - brain or otherwise.

Smartphones don’t dumb you down, they DUMB you UP

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: GPS and SatNav

"an HGV (usually from foreign parts) gets stuck half way down"

We have a local lane which is steep, had two right angle bends and a few lesser bends and gets narrower as you go down. I think the local farmer could do quite well out of a sign with the number of the local recovery firm.

One of the oddities of this is that the victims are obviously being SATNAVed to a particularly congested main road (which the Highways Agency would really like them to avoid) but have either crossed or turned off another main road which is less problematic. All the route planning sites have this strange preference. Do the routing algorithms prefer a road with a slightly lower number?

As a side issue, being near to a national park we often see parties of walkers all togged out with their waterproofs, sticks in each hand and, despite the maps in plastic envelopes round their necks, wearing distinctly lost-looking expressions on their faces. I've seen one group turn back just before they got to the footpath they were probably aiming at and turn up what was clearly marked as a private road leading to a row of cottages. It's not just drivers and SATNAVs who can't navigate.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: where I art be ?

Sheep are not kine.

'If someone in Australia says lick my toad, it's not a euphemism'

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Marmite?

"the EU Salt Reduction Framework"

I hoped you'd made this up. But no, there's no beating the EU at that game.

Ubuntu smartphone to go on sale: It'll be harder to get than a new iPhone

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Excellent news.

"Will users have root access?"

If it's anything like desktop Ubuntu you'll have to use sudo & given your own password.

Legalese and coding? Yup, it's the open-source FOSDEM shindig

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Here's a question for your lawyers

One further question to Radbruch's list. Did publishing them enhance your professional reputation and result in a better salary which supported your wife?

But like everyone else has said, talk to your lawyer.

GRUNTY CHIMPS 'blend in among locals' after moving to Scotland

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Cell?

Cell's a cytology journal. However the cell.com domain also hosts Current Biology which is where this paper is published.

Snowden leaks LEGALISED GCHQ's 'illegal' dragnet spying, rules British tribunal

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: soo.. illegal things are ok as long s they were done in the past?

"No, no, no....not that either - it is because a third party told on you and thus it became known what you had done, that things went from illegal to legal (and henceforth for ever more)."

That's the way elReg wrote it up. But as far as I can follow from a quick look at the judgement the disclosure to which the judges refer was one made by the Foreign Office, not Ed Snowden's.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Unlike Scribd this link doesn't require a login: http://www.judiciary.gov.uk/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/liberty-v-fco.pdf

Ofcom can prise my telly spectrum from my COLD, DEAD... er, aerial

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: "Broadcast is efficient" @dajames

I completely agree except for the x3 bit. Faster speeds are available, at least they are on Mythtv.

Anthem, America's second biggest health insurer, HACKED: Millions hit by breach

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: I love El Reg!

"Bloomberg is already stating that China's government is being fingered in this attack."

And, of course, you believe it unquestioningly. So what would a foreign govt. want with this? As opposed to a bunch of thieves who'd be aiming to make money out of it.

'How many years of "Linux is secure because we have all those eye looking at code!" did we just put with with from the El Reg commentards'

Do you have some inside knowledge of just what OS the systems that were hacked or are you just firing off random comments?

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Remediation

On a breach such as this each affected data subject should be entitled to changes of all feasible attributes: phone numbers, social security numbers or the like*, email addresses all funded - including out of pocket costs such as sending out "here's my new contact details" letters (letters because undoubtedly some companies will insist on written confirmation) all paid for by the breached company.

The costs of that should get shareholders' attention. More likely, of course, it would be covered by insurance but insurers would set premiums based on demonstrable protection of data - or lack thereof.

*Yes, I know this would require action by the appropriate authority.

'Tech' City hasn't got proper broadband and it's like BT doesn't CARE

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

'a note attached to say "remove from list or face prosecution under Data Protection legislation"'

I returned several mailings to a previous tenant. Eventually I rung up the offenders & said in future I'd bill them £10 for each mailing I returned. That stopped them.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"connect up my constituent to the green cabinet outside his premises.... BT should accept responsibly for installing superfast broadband to all existing cabinets in Tech City. "

Maybe she hasn't noticed that the cabinets for FTTC are different from ordinary cabinets. Maybe the one outside the premises isn't FTTC.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: We cannot spare the money to hook you up...

"although we sold the one we had"

Not even that. It was demerged as a separate company, AFAIK because BT didn't like the amount of money paid in the spectrum auction.

In fact, I wonder what it actually cost BT to do that. Staff TUPEed into O2 at the time would have been in the BT pension scheme. Presumably there would have been a pension scheme with equivalent benefits set up for O2. If the BT scheme hadn't been in deficit it would have been a straight transfer of the appropriate proportion of funds from the BT scheme to the O2 scheme. But as the BT scheme has been in deficit for years did BT have to add in extra to make up for the shortfall?

Swap your keyless key for keyless key-less key. You'll need: a Tesla S and Apple Watch

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Whose Tesla does it open?

First look: Ordnance Survey lifts kimono on next-gen map app

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: One of my favourite sites ,,,

Thanks for that. A quick check shows the local henge and buildings I never knew were listed. I'm a bit puzzled over a couple of listed building markers in the middle of roads, however.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Meanwhile, there's www.streetmap.co.uk

Why Windows 10 on Raspberry Pi 2? Upton: 'I drank the Kool-Aid'

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: @Salts - Hmmm...

And what boots the SD card? It's got a stage 1 boot in ROM on the SoC.

O2 notifies data cops 'for courtesy' ... AFTER El Reg intervenes in email phish dustup

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"A very clear and simple rebuttal of the O2 response"

True. An even clearer one is "how would the customer's computer have the PUK on it?".

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Who says it's a breach

"Maybe O2 just sold the data?"

PUKs included?

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: @TheTick and AC

"My opinion is that some spammers are wise to this trick, and might now spew email out to (for example) williamhill@ every domain on their lists"

If that were the case everyone who runs their own domain would see this sort of thing happening. More likely is that spammers would only do that for domains where they find that sort of address. If they buy a list that has williamhill@somedomain on it then they'll also try, say, tesco@somedomain too.

Personally I simply use a free mail address for anyone who I suspect might become a spammer. That way if NSA or GCHQ take a look at that inbox they'll get a load of Nigerian princes, urgent messages from the Outlook team and the occasional offer from Ticketmaster, all in the junk folder. Well, maybe not the urgent messages from the Outlook team as MS seem particularly adept at failing to recognise attempts to impersonate them; ISTM that it could be parleyed into evidence that they've abandoned some of their trademarks.

Who's come to fix your broadband? It may be a Fed in disguise. Without a search warrant

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: his raised suspicion among the staff

They were setting up an operation to relieve punters of money. Something to which casino operators would have deep moral objections.

Dixons Carphone clings to EE, Three in Phones 4U bullet dodge

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Did Goliath need a capital G?

Yes, it's a proper noun.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: You may laugh for all you want

"An enormous cluebat"

The cluebat will arrive when everyone with any sense says to the salesman "It wants what!!!?" and walks out. Sadly there are probably enough customers without sense to make the cluebat somewhat less than enormous.

Zimmermann slams Cameron’s ‘absurd’ plans for crypto ban

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: The Point

OK A/C. Pony up. No secrets.

Post here your bank account details, password, security answers etc. And your eBay, Amazon etc logins & passwords.

What's that?

You've just discovered that not only do you have something to hide, you're contractually obliged to hide it?

Target carders turn their attention to parking lots

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: "We already took action on this, and we are totally on it,"

For some value of "already".

Page: