Re: Sure, Linux could make a truly usable desktop system....
Question: Who's the best judge of the UI I, personally, find most useable?
Answer: Users.
Maybe a lack of reading skills. Look at the question again:
Note thetwo words "I, personally".
Why should a mass of undefined people "users" be able to make a judgement on my preferences. Why? How? It's an answer beyond reason.
The only person who can judge that is me. Not you. Not "users". Sure, some users might come to the same conclusion. Some might come to different conclusions.
You find Gnome ittitating. So do I. So I don;t use it. I have choices and, FWIW, my choice would also exclude Apple's UI which I think weird
W8 which is exactly the opposite of what I want from a UI. I think a lot of people agreed about that and yet I assume it wasn't coded by amateurs.
I'm not sure you intended your last paragraph to say what it di but as far as KDE is concerned you are correct.