Re: Big Fizzle
Until the hype bubble burst and all references to AI will be removed in a panic.
42273 publicly visible posts • joined 16 Jun 2014
kmorwath might be surprised to discover that I personally rate W2K as a very good desktop UI. Since then it's been downhill for Windows. KDE, OTOH has built on the W2K getting such things as multiple workspaces before Wondows. The divergence between the two has left us with the situation that the free UI is what the Windows UI could have been if, in kmorwath's own words "Microsoft had someome far more clever than Nadella at the helm" and W10/11 is what it is.
Similarly LibreOffice retains the UI that Office 97 had achieved before Mircorosft produced the brainfart that is the ribbon interface.
Between them KDE and LO have conserved the UI the Microsoft had achieved before they embarked on quarter of a century of enshittification.
"resource are needed to write truly good UIs"
But who judges what's a truly good UI? Is it going to be ISO Good UI standard? And what then happens to users who don't like the standard? Who find it unuseable?
Who's the best judge of the UI I, personally, find most useable? Have a go at working out the answer to that one. I'll give you a hint: it's not you.
"You don't think that it's a brilliant piece of 'nudge' thinking by the government to get people to think seriously about online security?"
No. It's a piece of unuerpassed government stupidity of people who think they think about online security the children. When the whole thing blows up in their face it will be the political class as a whole that gets a much needed nudge.
Not sure about your "older generation" remark as I'm sure the "digital natives" will be quite blase about the whole thing. I suppose the inevitable porn to pwn hitting the headlines in a few months' time will finally make governments start tinking a bit more about the consequences in dabbling in this sort of legislation.
"WHY does anything have any reason, means or motivation to even be able to break `sudo` in the first place"
That's an easy one: because it breaks Salzer and Shroeder's Separation of privilege principle: "Where feasible, a protection mechanism that requires two keys to unlock it is more robust and flexible than one that allows access to the presenter of only a single key." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Protection_of_Information_in_Computer_Systems
I doubt they made such an improvement deliberately and in any case the whole thing breaks the Economy of mechanism principle: Keep the design as simple and small as possible.
"Devuan a bit on its way out (as per this discussion)?"
No. As ususal its tracking Debian so whenever Trixie becomes the current Debian Excalibur will follow it as Devuan current a few weeks later as usual and it's OK to use now, in fact. The usual bits of enshittification in UI due to devs everywhere not being able to leave well alone - one of them seems to be KDE playing games with default window opening behaviour. I suppose they thought it was time the swindow system menu has some more work to do. Still, it could be a lot, lot worse. It could be Windows.
"f all of the people who object to systemd were to get together and design an init system they liked, they might come up with something good"
That's not necessary. It already exists. It's Syvinit. Systemd is exactly the sort of thing you get when you lose sight of "good enough".
"had more adverse impact on the atmosphere than any other single organism in Earth's history"
There's an interesting point here. The biggest impact any organism had was the first photosynthetic one. It and its decendents released an extremly reactive molecule into the environment that totally changed the environment of the planet. Whether this was adverse or not could be debated as an abstract point: we have a vested interest in it but all the obligate anaerobes descended from pre-photosynthetic life have been driven into restricted niches.
Not really a problem. Your storage is really a patchwork of blocks of data. The file system is an abstraction layer to present that as a coherent structure of directories and files (with links added to give a bit of fleximility. A GUI interface is another layer of abastraction layer on top of that and folders are part of that. You think "abstraction layers" are just fancy talk? If so, ask yourself if you really want to deal with your computer as the mass of ones and noughts it really is because everyithing that makes it easier and less confusing than that is an apstraction layer and they're piled one on top of another from ragiststers counters and ISAs upwards.
"it's a lot of little commands that have well defined purposes that you are not required to use if your use case does not require you to run them"
There's one small difference between that at Unix. With Unix they were separate commands, not bits sticking out of a hairball.
"What then should the penalties be?"
What should the penalties be eventually? I could imagine that running through the courts to decide who had jurisdiction. In fact MS's declared approach would be to challenge it so they'd probably have the legal situation sorted out by the time they did or didn't hand it over.
The only way to be anywhere convincing is to have made the investment in establishing a presence well before you start posting the propaganda. Creating a new account for the job just stands out. And we'll probably spot the propaganda anyway but we won't be able to call you out so easily.
Your post downvoted for not reading carefully. The complaint was about the ambulance chasing variety. Earlier in my career I spent a lot of time in the courts. As with any other profession there were good and, shall we say, not so good. I found the episodes where they shunted the jury (if there was one) out of earshot fascinating while they debated points of law. Particular respect for Dessie Boal for, amongst other things, getting FIB 1 as his number plate although it sounds like you'd disapprove of his doing that.
But you know what that's about, don't you? Money.
If they hadn't let recent purchasors upgrade they'd have had the ambulance chasing lawyers gearing up for action. Nothing to do with limited generousity.
If they let everybody upgrade they wouldn't get the licence sales from new hardware.
"having to make"
Already a done deal as far as I can see,. Trixie is Debian Next and also the basis for Devuan Excalibur which I've been running as test for several weeks and is currently my daily driver because the no 1 laptop has suffered a bit of a knock & is in for repair.
Not sure about LMDE.
Just thinking about the timing. If they suspect a leak two weeks before public release on the 8th why did the attacks only start on the 7th? Did it take that long for the leak to work through?
I'm not familiar with the way these things are due but are the PT releases simultaneous world-wide ot locally timed because there a places in the world where it's July 8th while at other places it's still july 7th?
"I can only imagine that the vast majority of humans would not be fooled into giving away their Windows product keys just because someone asked them to play a guessing game."
True but only because the vast majority of humans wouldn't be able to find their Windows product keys. Something easier - no problem.