The Register Home Page

* Posts by Doctor Syntax

42942 publicly visible posts • joined 16 Jun 2014

Page:

That's no moon... er, that's an asteroid. And it'll be your next and final home, spacefarer

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"algae capable of producing enough oxygen to keep gangs of rats alive for months at a time and in return the rats produce carbon dioxide for the plants ."

And the rats will eat their own dead.

"Where's Grandad"

"Shut up and eat your burger."

Windrush immigration papers scandal is a big fat GDPR fail for UK.gov

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"Regardless of how, or what, you think of the Home Secretary at that time in 2010 (the British prime minister Theresa May herself), a minister or high-ranking civil servant overseeing the Windrush files should never have had to sign off on any data disposal. Good data administration policy should have been in place and meant it was part of a run-of-the-mill activity done once a month, or maybe once a quarter, without the need for upward reference."

And who signs off on the policy in the first place?

Each class of material needs its own policy. A sensible policy for these records would have been to treat them as being in the same class as BMD material and GRO are still storing everything in that category right back to the start of civil registration on the first of June 1837.

ISO blocks NSA's latest IoT encryption systems amid murky tales of backdoors and bullying

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"that places the IoT at a dilemma"

OTOH I don't think it places most of us in a dilemma in respect of IoT. We wouldn't trust it with or without encryption. In fact, without makes it easier for the users products to see that it's up to. It's the vendors who need to be trusted and anything that makes it easier for them to hide what they're up to is a good thing. For instance, would anyone have discovered that a smart TV was analysing the user's LAN and reporting back what files it found if the communication had been encrypted.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: "the NSA started attacking the reputations of those experts"

"Don't forget : it takes time to build trust, but only an instant to lose it."

And even longer to rebuild it.

ICANN takes Whois begging bowl to Europe, comes back empty

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"Unless they decide to just cut things off and spare the hassle."

No problem. They'll none of them be missed. (Can you provide a little list?)

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"But what about foreign businesses with no physical presence in the EU?"

If they want my custom they have to compete with businesses in the EU who are playing by the rules. So either they play too or else they lose out. What GDPR provides is a set of rules respecting the rights of the European customer. Within Europe that provides a level playing field. I can choose vendor A, B or C and be sure I have the same protection for my rights and, depending on their competence, must have more or less similar costs to achieve it. So why on Earth, if I value those rights, would I choose sleazy vendor D who provides an inferior, cheap and nasty product?

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Did ICANN really think WP29 were daft enough to allow a precedent? If they had done they'd be besieged by everyone else with FB's lawyers fighting to the front and shouting loudest.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"Still waiting for the balkanization of the Internet, where businesses who refuse to play ball and can't be fined by the EU (due to lack of presence) are simply blocked wholesale."

You've overlooked market forces. If as a European resident I want the protection of GDPR and I'm currently registered with such a business I simply move my registration to where my privacy is protected*. The rogue US registrars can either play ball or lose customers.

*I did this a long time ago anyway.

The Agile and the Continuous: Database Drift ... Neat film title but something to avoid

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: risk adverse

The DBA said something along the lines of "I'm not truncating shit until you get the CEO of the company on the phone to approve that change"

On the phone? A real DBA would want it in writing.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Fixing up the problems with Continuous Delivery and DevOps

"As either one of these functions is quite complex and requires specialization, it is a very rare person who can reliably pretend to be both"

Pascal, I rarely disagree with you. But in this instance I have to. I found it easier to to mix the two roles. Where I've been DBA for a system with an external vendor and a developer where the roles were split. I found each role more challenging than combining the two. Being DBA for what you develop feeds back into ensuring that what you develop is right and as a developer you understand what the database is doing. As DBA for someone else's code I've had to spend time going through the code to find out what they were doing to crash the engine (why did it become by job to teach someone else's devs what they should know?).

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Crossing the Fence 2

Like Bill and David I've been on both sides including having a job that covered development and production. My one question of those who need to make frequent changes to the database is "Why?".

Once a database, or at least a line of business database, in in production it's holding data that's practically and legally significant to the business; the work the database does is paying your wages. Making changes has costs both in terms of risks and performance, the latter possibly involving downtime. In code your can patch and re-release. If you damage the database you may not be able to recover lost data and may not have the information to reconstruct what's missing if you have to revert to a backup.

As a developer you really should have a good understanding of the data so that by the time the system goes into production the schema should provide a good representation of the real world. If you are making frequent schema changes you need to stop, review and put the database into the shape it should have been in the first place. If there are frequent changes of requirement of kinds you really can't anticipate (experience comes in useful here) then maybe you need to review your strategy.

Blighty stuffs itself in Galileo airlock and dares Europe to pull the lever

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: EU friends apparantly

"But ok brexiters wanted it now you have to deal with it."

Sadly, we all have to deal with it.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: EU friends apparantly @ ArrZarr

"I don't believe 10 is enough."

These will be Brexit satellites. They'll go round in small circles over the UK. If they were to stray off course the big nasty EU might be able to use them as well. 10 should be plenty.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: If this was....

"the remainers rejoice"

No, we don't. We're saying "we told you so" because - well, we did tell you so. That's not the same thing at all.

We didn't rejoice about the result because we could see what would happen. We're not rejoicing now that what we said is starting to become obvious because, frankly. it's nothing to rejoice about: it never was, it isn't now and it isn't going to be.

A bit of mea culpa from the leavers would be appropriate but I don't think it'll happen. At some point it'll transpire that nobody actually voted leave because nobody can be found who'll claim to have done so and the result of the referendum will appear to have been some odd fluke of mathematics so we'll end up going back in. Giving up the pound in favour of the euro will, of course be the price, referendum day anniversary will be celebrated by burning effigies of Farage and the anniversary of leaving day by burning effigies of Gove. Something will have to be thought of the BoJo and the rest of them.

TSB boss: We know everything's working, you just can't see that

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"TSB are required to provide all your details to allow this."

Being required to do something and being able to achieve it are two different things.

TSB outage, day 5: What do you mean you can't log in? Our systems are up and running. Up and running, we say!

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Fungible software engineers...

Visited Leeds today. Getting off the train there was a poster: "Write code/solve problems/save lives No experience needed". My emphasis. What really worries me - this is the firm that does my doctors' practice S/W.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Just emptied my account.

"What if I empty someone else's account?"

You'll need more in yours to pay for your defence.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Pester said in September last year that "over 2,500 man years of effort by TSB, Sabadell and our technology partners" had gone into TSB's "new banking platform for the digital age".

What counts is what comes out, not what goes in. He's emphasising the wrong thing.

Critical infrastructure needs more 21qs6Q#S$, less P@ssw0rd, UK.gov security committee told

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

One thing about large banks and building societies is that instead of educating customers to recognise and delete phishing emails they're training them to respond by sending out emails, or having 3rd parties send out emails which is even worse, with lots of links to click.

It's bad enough that this trains customers to be phished but even worse one must assume that whoever send out such emails sees nothing wrong in them, would see nothing wrong in receiving one and would happily click on a link to expose their employer's system to whatever nasty was lurking there. It doesn't matter how good their passwords are if they've just installed a key-logger.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Plus: No one will say whether Huawei, ZTE are the baddies

"But don't take the governments word or my word on this, educate yourself with the tools available to examine them for yourself."

But I don't own either so unless I buy them I wouldn't be able to examine them for myself. Have you done so?

Yahoo! fined! $35m! for! covering! up! massive! IT! security! screwup!

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: How about fining BT for also failing to disclose the breach.

"As always, BT's cosy 'Fcuk buddy' Ofcom should investigate, but don't hold your breath."

Wrong regulator. If it was a breach of personal data then it's ICO business.

'Your computer has a virus' cold call con artists on the rise – Microsoft

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Is you fridge running, Are there any walls in the house at all

"My bank rang me the other day, using what appeared to be an internet phone number, they wanted me to identify myself."

They get very confused when you point out that they rung you and it's up to them to prove who they are and no, telling you half of your post code isn't good enough.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Automated calls

"I get those from UB/RBS. They may be real as it happens the same evening when we have visited the branch. "

I used to get those ostensibly from HSBC when I had a business account with them. I always insisted that as I'd told my bank that I wouldn't take such calls they couldn't be who they said they were and in fact I wasn't either confirming or denying that HSBC was my bank. Always followed up by a letter from HSBC saying they'd really like to sell me some unwanted services discuss things with me.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"The option to spoof the calling number is a feature, not a bug."

It may have started out that way. We should now treat it as a bug.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"I once had a call from 1234567890"

Was the ANI 1234567890? No? Then it was spoofed. Not necessarily intentionally but spoofed none the less.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Some people recommend getting pervy

That could go sooooo wrong.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Need to stop worrying about fake calling number

Note to tin-foilers, I do say "opportunity" not "requirement".

I think we could safely assume it's an opportunity scammers won't take up. An opportunity for the callee to require it would be a different matter.

Medic! Orangeworm malware targets hospitals worldwide

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Orangeworm malware ?

"The President's got worms?"

Or the other way around?

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"Upgrading it might even require a recertification of the MID under US Food and Drug Administration rules."

It's amazing how often this has to be pointed out.

UK 'meltdown' bank TSB's owner: Our IT migration was a 'success'

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: "what comes out of a cow's arse"

"You really can't.... nothing good comes out of a cow's arse."

The grass on my neighbour's fields says otherwise.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Egg meet face.

UK.gov demands urgent answers as TSB IT meltdown continues

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Use of Live Test Data

"You should have tested the systems properly"

I suppose it could be tested by moving accounts over in tranches. Whose accounts should go in the first tranche? How about senior managements'? Second tranche? Senior management of any big consultants and audit firms involved? What - none of them bank with TSB?

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Do the TSB not have anywhere left where you can just go and draw your money out?

"Clearly there is little point complaining as they are not listening so just move to another bank that does listen, where is the problem?"

Finding that other bank that does listen. Most of us are running out of choices.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"How is it quantified?"

By being big enough for politicians to notice something's wrong.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"We are currently experiencing large volumes of customers accessing our mobile app and internet banking which is leading to some intermittent issues with people accessing our services."

But isn't that what your mobile app and internet banking is for? Or are you still expecting customers to call into the branches that you've shut?

Translating Facebook's latest 'Hard Questions' PR spin – The Reg edit

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Anyone asking "How did they get all my personal data and profile me like this"

"Should look in a mirror."

That assumes the "anyone" has an account. What about those who don't but still have had a profile built by their family and friends' contacts etc being slurped?

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Targeted ads

"Presumably it costs so little for them to keep hounding you, on the off-chance that if you haven't bought it"

That doesn't explain car dealers from whom you've just bought a car keeping spamming texts etc. The people who place these adverts don't seem to be thinking at all, they're just addicted to advertising.

IETF: GDPR compliance means caring about what's in your logfiles

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

It's going to be a hard journey

A few days ago I placed a query with quasi-public sector body. They answered. Today I get a feedback request from a plc to whom they passed my email address. Are they really going to turn the tap off in a few weeks time?

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: GDPR is MADNESS

"GDPR means MADNESS."

Not really. It's just another set of rules as to how you do business. You have to comply with accounting rules for instance. If you sell food you have to make sure you're not poisoning people. If you sell electrical equipment you have to make sure you're not electrocuting people.

Basically all GDPR says is that you don't abuse the trust people place in you when they provide data for some purpose. If you were planning to do that then the madness lies with you. If you weren't it's stuff you should really have been doing already.

"I really whish I was not living and working as an IT consultant in Europe."

In that lots of businesses weren't treating personal data properly already you should be pleased to be working as an IT consultant in Europe. It should mean more clients.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: How long are you required to keep financial records?

"How does a European keep their personal or corporate financials on the right side of the law now?"

You've half answered your own question. There are statutory reasons to keep this data. You are permitted to hold data for statutory reasons.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"So in the State of Nevada where the government wrote PCI into law, meaning you are obligated to comply with all provisions of the PCI DSS, it's OK to keep all of that data. Presuming you are subject to GDPR, of course."

Yes, but if the data subject is in the EU then GDPR restricts what you can do with them. You can use them for compliance. You can't sell them on. You can't use them for marketing pestering.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Why are people finding this difficult?

"If you need to promulgate IP addresses beyond this point, for marketing, SEO, CMS campaign management, etc, then the redacted form is more than sufficient."

It isn't sufficient. You will need the data subject's explicit consent.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"Do I have a requirement to demand that any access.log records pertaining to my site are restricted?"

Yes, you are the data controller..

"Who is responsible for ensuring that the web server logs are maintained in accordance with GDPR?"

The client in the first place, they will be the data controller..

Your hosting company is processing the data so they have responsibilities but the data controller determines the manner in which data is processed.

In both cases the data controller needs to ensure that this is in the contract.

Yay, you've won your Fitbit lawsuit, folks. But, lawyers, about those filet mignon expenses...

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"I've always wanted to know the shysters took their cut out of the plaintiffs' hide instead of making the defendants pay the fees and costs."

As this and similar cases involve shareholders suing the company they own it really doesn't matter. They can pay as plaintiffs, they can pay as defendants, it's still their money.

Brexit has shafted the UK's space sector, lord warns science minister

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Hmmm..

"a few opportunities"

Even insuperable opportunities.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Cue Boris Johnson....

"parallel universes"

I think you've just explained BoJo.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"If you don't they'll start to charge your UK bank account."

Can anyone spot the built-in assumption?

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Don't Panic!

More likely to be per aspera ad ardua

Bungling cops try to use dead chap's fingers to unlock his smartmobe

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"the two officers didn't think a warrant was required because there is no expectation of privacy after death"

It may or may not be required but it was up to them to know, not to think.

Capita reports pre-tax LOSS of £515m for 2017

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"The Public sector partnerships business unit recorded a 4 per cent sales dip"

Is this a sign that the public sector is finally getting a clue?

Page: