The Register Home Page

* Posts by Doctor Syntax

42942 publicly visible posts • joined 16 Jun 2014

Page:

Europe gets serious about cutting digital umbilical cord with Uncle Sam's big tech

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Feel-good bull-sh

AFAICS what prompted the CLOUD Act was various US law enforcement net using the existing legal routes because their fishing expeditions couldn't meet* the standards needed for a warrant in Europe. Those scare quotes protections are real enough if law enforcement don't have a good enough case.

* For whatever reason not enough evidence for a warrant, not prepared to disclose the evidence they had or just plain couldn't be arsed.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Lovely

It requires things such as servers and operational skills. Companies used to provide those for themselves. Even quite small copanies would run a small tower server, sufficient for their needs and were able to engage someone to provide the skills as and when needed. There are also UK and EU businesses which will run NC as a service for those who don't want to run things internally. UK and EU users do not need to go to US companies for those.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"Europe will strongly favour legislation over innovation"

Useful innovation meets requirements. Legislation sets the requirements. They're complementary.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Shout It From The Rooftops

"Britain is too small on its own to create an independent hyperscale cloud service."

That word "hyperscale". What does it mean apart from "big"? Big enough for the likes of AWS, Azure and Google.

The issue here is that AWS, Azure & Google are the problem, not the solution. They're the problem because they're running shared infrastructure that sucks in nationally critical operations and exposes them to a foreign power.

What's needed, be it Britain or EU, is capacity to provide services at a sufficient scale for a given application. We used to do that. Then the snake oil grafters sold the beancounters on the economy of scale at - unspoken - the cost of security. Now security has raised its head again.

That word "hyperscale". It needs to be seen as a warning. That's what it means.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

The game has changed.* Now it's not just little people's data any more. It's governmental an supra-governmental systems at risk. It's economically critical local businesses at risk. It's infrastructure that's at risk.

* Not really, it's just that governments are finally realising what it always was.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: You can't have a sovereign digital cloud

Who runs Windows? Too many.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Nextcloud??

Citation needed but unfortunately A/C can't remember. How convincing.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Subeditor: don't lie

We've already had articles about others. Others including Denmark and if Denmark has had any inclination to slack off a bit (not suggesting they had) they've just had a further nudge and no doubt other countries will have taken note of that.

The nay-sayer A/Cs (how many are there in reality?) get so tiring.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: You can't have a sovereign digital cloud

"an open source solutions can be moved to any of the vast number of European bit barns, which will soon be available at knock down prices once the AI bubble bursts."

If they're optimised for LLM processing they're going to be sub-optimal for real work.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"Not because they're evil but because they need to write a 50-page privacy policy in every European language, following the individual rules of every European country, that nobody will ever read because of how big it is."

The advantage of EU setting rules is that you don't have rules for every EU country, you have one set. Of course it complicates things a bit if you have to consider countries outside the EU but even there it helps if the country decides to adopt the EU's rules, foregoing the right to participate in the rule making process because somehow doing that erodes sovereignty.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

The basic situation has been festering since the EU (including the UK at the time) started weakening GDPR with various privacy fig-leaves.

It's taken Trump 2.0 to concentrate minds on the dangers. It was OK with TPTB when it was seen as just little people's personal data. It took Trump to make companies and governments to realise that they were also at risk.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Lovely

There is NextCloud the company but there is also NextCloud the FOSS application which was forked from the earlier OwnCloud. Either can be installed by anyone wishing to run their own service - right down to anyone wishing to run their own server in their own home. Likewise the client S/W can also be installed by anyone who wishes to. Any of those could be forked if that became a necessity.

That's why the one guarantee of digital sovereignty is FOSS. It's not any sort of principled choice - FOSS vs evil corporation. It's a strictly practical choice as, of course, is digital sovereignty.

One real reason AI isn't delivering: Meatbags in manglement

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"They think they have a smart system, but what they really have is a stateless algorithm that never improves."

And what were they sold as by the sales-snakes? A smart system that could learn.

Microsoft wants to replace its entire C and C++ codebase, perhaps by 2030

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: "It's new and shiny - it must be better!"

".but I don't get the hate for Rust here."

I don't see any. What I see is extreme scepticism in Microsoft's belief in it as a magic bullet.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: this used to be my bag..

"Are you suggestion Microsoft code actually has core {cough} logic {cough}?"

Let alone planning and testing.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Why use AI to convert from c/c++ to rust?

"Given the maturity of much of Microsoft's code, the number of errors liable to cause significant problems will be relatively low (many of the more recent howlers are to do with code that has been gratuitously rewritten)."

If that were indeed the case the best approach would be to go back to an earlier version as the starting point, reimplement that in Rust and then roll forward adding the intended functionality of the later versions. Or just leave it there without all the slurping and user hostility.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Not the holy grail

"warts 'n all?"

Warts especially. That bit will be assured.

21K Nissan customers' data stolen in Red Hat raid

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: “[NAME] takes this incident very seriously“

"a third party server"

Statistically likely. The longer the supply chain the bigger the attack surface.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: “[NAME] takes this incident very seriously“

Lessons are best learned from other people's mistakes.

US punishes China’s ‘dominance’ of legacy chips with zero percent tariffs

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: The result of an investigation into China’s semiconductor industry

"if enough of us just laugh in the face of marketers and salesdroids when they try it, maybe we can get them to stop"

No chance. They wouldn't realise why you were laughing, let alone adjust their behaviour in response unless they thought it was a negotiating ploy in which case they'd just offer some non-concession.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"increasingly aggressive and sweeping non-market policies and practices in pursuing dominance of the sector.”

I think that translates "not abandoning them in pursuit of latests shiny".

SoftBank scrambling to come up with $22.5B in OpenAI funding before New Year

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

It's getting closer. Do I need to explain what "it" is? Probably not.

What the Linux desktop really needs to challenge Windows

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Yawn "Too many Linux DEs is bad"

"why Microsoft is predominantly chosen for these organizations"

Decisions are made by those who only know Microsoft (although they might use iStuff themselves because they're special).

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: What Linux needs to be pre-installed on PCs

You then create a Windows Mk II situation. You're in the hands of the vendors and their chosen distro. I appreciate what you say but you end up with the situation where the vendors say "Jump!" and you jump.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Devuan user here

"our if you include raspberry Pi - although that's a bit limited in performance."

It runs my home NextCloud just fine and will run either MythTv backend or TV HeadEnd when I get round to sorting that out.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Are you suggesting I should get pushed into your selection of Mate or Xfce for the desktop? That's not why I use Linux.

Having the choice is far, far more important that having Linux or some other Unix variant take over the world. Having Linux take over the world on those terms would be little better than having Windows everywhere. The whole point of having a modular, layered approach to system design is to enable the user to select their choice.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

KDE also isn't "better" than XFCE or Cinnamon. It's just what the user is comfortable with. Isn't it nice being able to make a choice like that?

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

A quick look at Waterfox suggests the Linux install is a tarball. Not ideal.

However I can't see LibreWolf drinking the AI KoolAid either and you can add it's repository and install it and get updates along with everything else in the apt world. It's a little more security conscious then FF and out of the box it has a few quirks to stop fingerprinting.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"Users should not have to be tech-literate to use a computer"

How did you learn to become expert at using Windows? My guess is that you just clicked around. Right click on this and that and see what the menus offer? Well, stand back and prepared to be flabbergasted.

That's the exact way we learned to use Linux desktops.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: The reason is Office

"To create a desktop shortcut, the process is you spend a while Googling"

That's your problem right there.

You have a GUI. Use it. How would you do something unfamiliar on Windows? My guess is that you'd experiment with clicking around. This is what you'd find on KDE desktop but I doubt others would differ in more than detail:

What did you want to create a desktop short cut for?

1. An application in the applications menu? Right click on the item in the menu. Select Add to Desktop. Done.

2. A file or directory in some directory that you have open? Select the item, drag it to the desktop and drop it. When the dialog opens to ask if you want to move, copy or create a link select create a link. Done.

3. Anything? Right click on the desktop. From the menu select link to file or directory or Link to application. Type in the name and, for the former, navigate to select the file or directory. For the latter, navigate to the executable, select that and then use the tabs to set the properties you want rather than typing them in as Google told you. You can also select an icon for it. It's a bit trickier than exporting it from the menu but you only do that if it's something that's not already installed on the menu.

But no doubt your post will be quoted by other A/Cs who'll repeat it without checking for themselves. But how come you didn't discover it for yourself? I can see why you posted A/C, after all it doesn't show up your desktop skills in a good light.

What you seem to be describing from Google is something you only need for something with very special requirements, not your average run-of-the-mill application. For instance I run an Informix server* which has a lot of environment settings etc. If I were to set up a shortcut for a terminal session to run Informix clients it I might go through that routine although, in fact, I just set it up in the system profile so that any terminal session has access. This, however, is real sysadmin stuff because it's what I used to do for a living on Unix servers. I repeat, it is not what you'd be doing to set up a typical productivity app.

* I have some genealogical data on it.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: I suspect a commercial entity may end up with "the win" for Linux on the Desktop...

"Microsoft’s real win was owning the enterprise.

...

Microsoft made its money from every PC sold"

You've got them the wrong way round. By all sorts of leverage they got OEM installs so that's what people knew and that's how they got into the enterprise. They managed to distract SCO by offering to hold their coat while they had a fight with Linux. By the time that settled they'd got an arguably inferior server OS into the enterprise.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Mint

"And that's my point: Joe and Josephine have no idea how to install anything - or configure anything for that matter."

I agree with you. It's just there on the PC they bought, they don't need to install it.

But what do they do when Patch Tuesday banjaxes their Windows? The recommendation for what to do when that happens aren't pretty and my experience was that the only way out was a reinstall.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"Unix died because of endless incompatibilities between versions."

Unix lived because of the different versions portability to different H/W. I wouldn't expect to be running Solaris on HP Prism or VAX. I wouldn't expect to be able to run HP-UX on Sequent, etc. but because it was all Unix it was easy to move from a gig on one platform to a gig on another. This adapability mattered less as Intel/AMD H/W trounced most of the other stuff. The feature of different versions became less of an advatage.

Unix's problem was that regulatory issues required that it be transferred away from AT&T and ended up in the hands of SCO. SCO in turn ended up in entirely the wrong hands and Microsoft egged them on to fight IBM in the courts over Linux, distracting them while Microsoft took over the server market with an arguably inferior product.

The Roomba failed because it just kind of sucked

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: I'm not lazy,

Your link doessn't want to be visited. Blocked by CloudFart.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

As Jack Dee might have said

"the cat hairs of reality meet the shiny hype of smart tech"...."it's the end of the programme."

Airbus to migrate critical apps to a sovereign Euro cloud

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Tesco

Remind me of what the "M" in "MBA" stands for.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: IMAGINE IF...

You have to wonder why the clue in "ICL/Fujshitsu" was missed.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Like Amazon focussing on running a shop?

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Yes Airbus is big enough

You mean it's safer to go with someone you know you can't trust rather than someone you can trust for now on the off-chance that they might become untrustworthy later.?

For avoidance of doubt, Microsoft's president has admitted that they can't be trusted, although wrapped up in slightly longer phrasing.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Alcachofas has the right of it. It was my error.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Yes, SHE. Sorry.

Ah, well, not the only one. The account written up in another place, citing el Reg, says they're moving from one of the US corps, not from on prem/.

User found two reasons – both of them wrong – to dispute tech support's diagnosis

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"the modem?"

Our internet connection failed a few weeks ago - weather related - which got fixed fairly quickly but the tech ran through a series of tests. everything was working but he announced we had a split pair. Plugged his tester into the master socket after unplugging the modem cable and found the master to be OK. Confidently announced "It's your modem". Never stopped to think that a modem, identical to thousands of other mass-produced modems is unlikely to have been manufactured with an internal fault but --- the cable he'd just unplugged?

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Not the intention. Just the outcome.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Back in the day

"It shouldn't have to fall to her to write it down, that's your job."

I'm not sure about that one. Sometimes it helps to learn. Perhaps produce an instruction list but also sit with the user who's having problems and walk it through with them suggesting it might help if they take notes.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Back in the day

"Why does Windows have a wind sock?"

Just part of the junk.

DOE recruits cloud, chip, and AI giants for Trump's Genesis Mission

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: TROUGH – Backronym required

Trump's Regneration Of US Greatness Hubris.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"the Trump administration's Genesis Mission, which aims to use AI to drive scientific discoveries"

I suppose it will be trained to tell him what he wants to hear. Scientists are unreliable - they say things he doesn't like.

Sydney Uni data goes walkabout after criminals raid code repo

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: “there is currently no sign that the data has been misused”

Corporate speak for "We're getting in theplausible denial before they've had chance to use it while it's true. It won't be much longer but we've said out piece."

pearOS is a Linux that falls rather close to the Apple tree

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Midwinter? (Checks calendar) .. happier days

They've also managed to prove Stuart Broad wrong. Now Alex Carey will be remembered for two things.

Infinite Machine e-scooter is like the offspring of a Vespa and a Cybertruck

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"anodized aluminum and steel"

Steel isn't exactly a new material in motor cycles. Not even in scooters. I suppose the reference to Cybertrucks and De Loreans means it's stainless steel and the difficulty of working with that explains the fuggliness.

Page: