The Register Home Page

* Posts by Doctor Syntax

43025 publicly visible posts • joined 16 Jun 2014

Page:

If you're cautious about using ML and bots at work, that's not a bad idea

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: tendency to generate false information – a phenomenon known as "hallucination."

Right now AI is the term being used to push these things onto the world in general. Yes' it's an oxymoron but that's the way marketing works.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: tendency to generate false information – a phenomenon known as "hallucination."

A statement based on reports that somebody reported a crime or was a witness at a trial and mangles them to say that that person was convicted of the crime is simply not true. Which epithet you choose to apply to the untruth is your personal choice and frankly doesn't matter very much. What matters is that people are trusting the system that creates such a statement.

"How much of a world model or theory of the world does a newly conceived human have?"

The newly conceived born human acquires a world model by being a physical entity and encountering the other physical entities around it. It starts to do so before starting to acquire language. Our non-human relatives do the same without ever acquiring language. Language - words - is/are the means by which we apply symbolic labels to the real world in order to build and manipulate ideas about them. They are not intrinsic to an internal model of the external world. But words are al LLMs have. They do not have the physicality to react with the physical world.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: "Who's responsible for the hallucinations?"

Hence Pascal's point. If you use AI to generate a file and use it in some way which causes problems it's your fault and those problems are down to you.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: tendency to generate false information – a phenomenon known as "hallucination."

They also know which is which. The AI knows nothing.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: "Who's responsible for the hallucinations?"

"Go get a lawyer to do the job."

We've already had the case of a lwyer using an AI to write his documents. It didn't go well because of hallucinations.

Apple squashes security bugs after iPhone flaws exploited by Predator spyware

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: These clowns

“take full control of our device” sounds more like Microsoft's approach. I think Apple is more along the lines of "it's your device but you're not going anywhere outside our walled garden". I suppose vulnerabilities like these could have also opened up the possibility of 3rd party stores such as F-Droid run for Android phones.

Europe wants easy default browser selection screens. Mozilla is already sounding the alarm on dirty tricks

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Yes, it's the frameworks that are the problem. All they give to the developer is apparent plausible deniability. Given that they chose to adopt the framework it's not even that plausible.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Choice screens are the least of the problems. Much worse is the growing habit of web sites checking the browser and refusing to play if it isn't one of their favoured ones - which is increasingly likely to be Chromium based.

Colleges snub Turnitin's AI-writing detector over fears it'll wrongly accuse students

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

People have been using textual analysis for years to (try to) identify writers. Computers have been used in the Who Really Wrote Shakespeare game since they became available. But I don't see it working well by trying to score individual sentences. I'd have thought it would work better picking on a whole lot of factors, consistency of choice of grammatical constructions, consistency of shortening (e.g can't vs cannot vs can not) & so forth that would require gathering statistics from the entire text or at least substantial portions of it. It might be quite reasonable for all replies form any particular LLM to occupy quite a small portion of a multidimensional space defined in that way.

How is this problem mine, techie asked, while cleaning underground computer

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"Installing Code Red / NIMDA patches on windows 2000 machines"

Not Code Tangerine?

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: A cave, rather than a mine, and a laboratory, rather than a computer

They may well have their own source of radon without the radium. https://www.ukradon.org/information/ukmaps

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"Experience is a dear teacher but some will learn by no other."

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Dickensian

And probably causes byssinosis as well.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Dirt

But what about the rest of the desk?

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Dirt

Or they hated it so much they didn't want another. In fact i have a cheap keyboard like that which is years old - I got it to set up stuff which would mostly run headless so it's had hardly any use.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Ah, the 80's...

An over-seas allowance? I'd have appreciated that. Instead I was up against the Civil Service/HMG mentality which says "We rate people who are qualified for their jobs by their education well below those who aren't, promotion comes with responsibility measured by direct reports, not by what the actual job is, and if we want a national pay policy the easiest place to start is with the public sector."

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Ah, the 80's...

Jake may well have been free-lance.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Ah, the 80's...

There were a few occasions where I had to go to places where i needed an armed escort, either RUC or Army. At at least one later employer I looked back and wondered what my current HR would have thought of doing that without a team-building exercise first.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: "......the mine had closed."

It'll be intersting to see how it affects the fibre.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Dirt

You really should have rised it as an H&S issue.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Dirt

"I'll chuck it in the bin without a second thought"

And replace it with the cheapest you can find because it's not going to last long anyway.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: A 1980s minicomputer at the bottom of a mine ?

If they didn't budgie fast enough the response times would be something dreadful.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Nasty IT places

Scene of crime visits could be nasty and some of the nasty bits got brought into the lab. A colleague had a sofa brought in; it stood around for weeks for some reason and had to be given a wide berth - the little buggers can jump. In fact fleas were a (fortunately infrequent) occupational hazard. But the nastiest job was removing bits of a bomber who'd scored an own goal from bits of his clothing so the latter could be shown to his family for identification.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Dickensian

Reprographics offices have their own black dust. I learned to take a replacement floppy drive if I thought I might have to reinstall anything. The days when you could install things from floppies...

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: A 1980s minicomputer at the bottom of a mine ?

At a guess - the maximum cable length for the terminal wasn't enough to reach from the surface and nobody thought to look into something carrier based and install modems.

Amazon 'protects' against junk AI e-books by limiting author-bots to three a day

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: I'm happy

It would take a controlled experiment to find out but it may well be hurting their profits already. They may be making money now but it's quite possible they could make more by letting customers find wht they're looking for.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: "that limit protects its customers"

One book every three days would be too much.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: in order to help protect against abuse, we are lowering the volume limits

Amazon is going to show you what *they* want you to see and buy,

They may succeed with the first but fail with the second. Perhaps they could try an A/B test with an alternative search engine that does as it's asked to find out how much trade they're turning away.

Airport chaos as eGates down for the count across UK

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Current problems

Far from it. They're a perfect fit. even better than Rudderless.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Current problems

It was a Labour Home Sec who declared it unfit for purpose. I don't know why. It's been super-efficient at house-training its ministers and that seems to be its prime purpose.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Nowadays they'd be on a subscription so they'd be Billed Gates.

UK-US data deal could hinge on fate of legal challenges to EU arrangement

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: "permit the flow of personal data [..] without the need for further safeguards"

"Could someone please remind me why personal information needs to change continent ?"

Monetisation

Menacing marketeers fined by ICO for 1.9M cold calls

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"it's probably best just not to answer the call"

No, siita has the right idea. Get them to hang on. While they're doing that they're not bothering anyone else so you can put it down as a public service on your part, and it's wasting their time. Given how few such calls we get my belief is that there are lists circulating of numbers it's best not to ring.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Spam calls

I keep saying this but:

The telco has records of at least who it took the call from. What's needed is a number, say 1476, to ring immediately after hanging up to report the spam. The telco records the number and with a bit of statistical checking to see if the source is being reported enough times it credits the reporters' accounts with a fee for their troubles (at least double for numbers on TPS), adds a fee for its own troubles and bills whoever sent it the call. If it's another telco then they can add their own fee and pass the bill back to the source until it either reaches the caller's account or a telco which has not yet learned to keep records. This will make it unduly expensive either for callers or for telcos who are prepared to handle the calls carelessly. One way or another it would kill the whole business stone dead.

In practice it probably wouldn't need to be implemented. It would put telcos to considerable upfront costs to set up the system. Once legislators or regulators started talking seriously about implementing it I think the industry would quickly discover other, effective ways of stopping such calls, ways which up to now haven't been practical.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Spam calls

"although I never answer calls from numbers I don't recognise"

What you should do is answer ask them to hold on - you need to look something up to answer their question, have to go to answer the door, whatever - and then put the phone aside for 10 minutes. AFAICS that gets your number on an even more valuable list, the list of numbers it's best not to call. It certainly works for me as we get very few.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Sweet FA for those of us harassed

Citation needed

Mastodon makes a major move amid Musk's multiple messes

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

The word you're looking for might be "monetised".

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"One way to understand Mastodon is to consider each instance as an email server that can talk to other email servers!

Like Usenet?

Nothing new under the sun.

BOFH: A security issue, you say? Activate code tangerine

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Wonderful episode once again!

What? You're saying BOFH isn't real life?

Now IBM sued for age discrim by its own HR veterans

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"Fines aren't enough. Actual jail time for these liars might actually change things."

An award of substantial damages against the actual executive from an individual who's been laid off might be even better. At least for the first claimant and the next few until the exec's been bankrupted.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: HR...

"Of course she has the box."

Even better might be the written instruction to destroy it.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: HR...

"One just can't help feel some Schadenfreude."

Yes, but whose discomfort are we celebrating here? HR know where the bodies are buried. They're the ones who really need to be kept onside.

Data breach reveals distressing info: People who order pineapple on pizza

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: I don't understand...

Remember, functional requirements are always important. I usually buy pizzas with pineapple as that's the best way to ensure there's no garlic which SWMBO doesn't like.

Neuralink's looking for participants willing to be part of human trials

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

If self-experimentation was good enough for Neil Noakes it should be good enough for Elon Musk.

Robocall scammers sentenced in US after netting $1.2M via India-based call centers

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"managed to convince her to give them her O2 account details"

Always ask them to prove who they are by telling you prt of the account details.

UK Online Safety Bill to become law – and encryption busting clause is still there

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Coming next: a law to make pi equal to 3.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Don't Understand......

And it's the recipient's key that's needed to decrypt PGP. That assumes the recipient has a key. Perhaps I'll create a key pair, thow away the private key and use the public one to encrypt a message for my MP.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: The biggest surprise...

But they didn't hide it.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"But the penny is still falling it seems."

Not isn't. It's been snapped up by an airborne pig.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Blighty seems determined to cut itself off from the rest of the world

Given that MPs and ministers are quite apt to blab about Whatsapp or whatever messages they probably think that security is just a myth.

Page: