The Register Home Page

* Posts by Doctor Syntax

43025 publicly visible posts • joined 16 Jun 2014

Page:

Google's TPUs could end up costing it a billion-plus, thanks to this patent challenge

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

I can't help wonder whether a jury of randomly selected citizens is the best tribunal of fact in such cases.

Former Post Office boss returns CBE to sender over computer system scandal

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: How many fraud and theft cases in the 80s?

It's called "arm's length".

With OpenAI GPT Store imminent, apps are already being ripped off by copycats

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: My word.

"I shall try to find my violin."

I have a microscope you can borrow.

Cutting-edge microscopy reveals bottled water has 'up to 100 times' more bits of plastic than previously feared

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Mount Inaccessible

What comes out of the tap is supposed to be drinkable anyway.

But until I was nearly 14 we lived in a house with lead pipes and unfiltered spring water as the source of drinking water. At some point a municipal piped supply was provided but the 3rd tap, the spring water tap was preferred as drinking water. Like you, last time I checked I'm still alive very many decades later.

According to the directer of the Traad Point water research lab on Lough Neagh lead in potable water only became a problem with central heating and working wives, the combination resulting in water sitting stationary in warmish surroundings for many hours during the day so that the concentration built up. In a multi-generational household with seldom less than two adults in the house and where there would be ice on the inside of the windows on a cold morning that was not a problem.

'Only 700 new IT jobs' were created in US last year

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"the firm didn't immediately respond to our questions. "

That's what happens when the call handlers are replaced with AI.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Only 700? Perhaps the 'software crisis' is due to not enough bad programmers?

I'm not sure who all these "data scientists" are (Are they what we used to call statisticians? There seem to be an awful lot of them.) or how they think but I'd hope they'd ask questions such as:

"How many significant figures does this represent in the overall US IT job market?"

"How does it compare with the annual number of people leaving and entering the market?"

"How does it compare with the daily turnover in IT jobs?"

"Should I call these people out to More or less?"

Private lunar lander Peregrine mission's now measured in hours, not days

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"From: Department for Science, Innovation and Technology, UK Space Agency, and The Rt Hon Michelle Donelan MP"

You'd think even a history and politics graduate would know to check on progress before bragging.

Need to plug in an EV? BT Group kicks off cabinet update pilot

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: "this hack is an EV driver..."

HMG;s target was for every motorway service station to have at least six rapid or ultra-rapid chargers by the end of 2023 with a "rapid" charger adding 100 miles range in 35 minutes. If I were to buy an EV I wouldn't be happy having to spend 35 minutes for every 100 miles of a long journey. That's if I could find a vacant charger and, were EVs to be universal as HMG wants, this target certainly comes under the definition of pisspoor because the chance of finding one would rank with being hit by a low-flying porcine. As it happens the RAC, apparently based on the Zapmap app you mentioned in another post, is only met by 40% of service stations.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: More Magical Thinking

Whatever the battery technology the overall infrastructure need is to be able to replace the energy provision currently supplied by liquid hydrocarbon fuels. What's being done to achieve that?

Doctor Syntax Silver badge
Happy

That's going to puzzle the younglings.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: 7kW

Very likely your "if not" applies.

And the ICE cut-off is 2035 for purchase of new cars. That means that is 30 years time any surviving ICE vehicles will be 20is years old.

COVID-19 infection surge detected in wastewater, signals potential new wave

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Why did everyone get vaccinated?

For some people thinking of evolution is hard if not proscribed.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: "the only figure that really matters is hospitalisations"

Complacency is also counterproductive.

Virus in sewage is taken as an early warnings of possible hospitalisations to come.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"the UK no longer collects the data"

Not is Palantir's skill set, I suppose.

Another airline finds loose bolts in Boeing 737-9 during post-blowout fleet inspections

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: BOEING... or Boding?

Just as well that it was in the garden, not on the house.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"fly the flag"

Did he also risk flying the company's product?

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Shameful

It's shameful how Boeing's management is flying the passengers into the ground.

FYFTFY

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: A gross understatement?

Maybe it suggests that "the area in question" should be the entire aircraft when conducting these inspections.

UK PM promises faster justice for Post Office Horizon victims

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

I see that Vennells has now given way to public pressure and handed back her CBE but intends to make no further comment until her evidence to the enquiry*. I'm not sure that this is enough to be described as doing the decent thing.

* If the PO's foot-dragging keeps going it might never get to this point.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Balls of steel - 'IT System assumed to be correct'

"That presumption can, however, be rebutted if evidence to the contrary is adduced. In that event it will be for the party seeking to produce the computer record in evidence to satisfy the court that the computer was working properly at the material time.."

Superficially, where the evidence is being provided by the prosecution in a criminal case it makes it look as if the burden of proof is on the prosecution - which is part of the long tradition of Common Law. In practice, of course, it places the real burden on the defence in providing rebuttal. It's that repeal that opened the door to this whole mess. I wonder how many less notorious cases have been brought to court by the same means.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: How is Fujitsu not in the dock?

"doesn't have the option of buggering off to Israel to escape justice."

I'm sure other places are available.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: How is Fujitsu not in the dock?

PE will have been ignored on the basis that "They're always saying things like that. Just ignore them." Meanwhile the technical press is too difficult to understand for chaps with PPE, classics or English litt and history.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: How is Fujitsu not in the dock?

"And despite this being public knowledge and in the press for years, it takes a TV drama to actually get something done?"

Knowledge of a very limited public, I'm afraid, and for that part of the public that might have done something about it, it probably looked too much like hard work.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: No Justice

"When did the post office first become aware that perhaps the software was the problem?"

That's an easy one. Earlier than they'll admit.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: No Justice

"The petitions have a role of sort of safety valve"

This particular site seems to be one for gathering email addresses to "keep you informed".

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Project management by those ignorant of IT systems?

"Anything you try to make Fujitsu pay would have to have been in a contract with them or they'll just wriggle out of it "

If their staff were giving evidence that they knew was wrong then they might find such wriggling harder than you might think and they might wish.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Remote Access

"Appalling ignorance by the judges"

The judges can only go by what evidence was presented to them. If they're presented with biased expert witness on one side and none on the other that's what they have to go on. To an extent if they think something needs clarification they might question a witness but they don't have previous careers as Sysadmins to know that that would need clarification. They may well, along the way, have picked up knowledge of police procedures, criminal MOs, even (regrettably rarely IME) forensic science and have a typical users knowledge of PCs but not ystem administration

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

I'm labouring under the experience of having spent about a third of my working life in the 70s & 80s as a forensic scientist. I am probably even more appalled than you at that case and struggle to understand how it could have even got to court. I can only report my own experience but I think everyone I knew - colleagues, police and medical examiners - as well as myself were well aware of the difficulties involved in allegations of sexual assaults, the possibilities of miscarriages of justice in one direction or the other and anxious to avoid them. Personally I think the stress of that job affects me to this day.

Possibly the DPP/CPS are less aware and are sometimes under political (and even less aware) pressure to increase conviction rates as measured against complaints. I can only think of one case in my career where the local DPP's office seemed to have had a rush of blood to the head despite the police having located an eye-witness who demolished the complainant's story; the case was dealt with by the Crown counsel calling the witness but then handing proceedings straight over to the defence to take her evidence.

However whataboutery gets us nowhere.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

This wasn't just one scandal, it was a whole stack:

1. The initial PO/RM prosecutions. I don't know if the problems were known from the start but it's clear that prosecutions continued when it was known.

2. That PO/RM didn't. of their own initiative, promptly seek to get the early convictions quashed as unsafe, once they became aware of Horizon's errors, including those where there were guilty pleas and drop all pending cases.

3. That when Fujitsu realised that there were problems and that PO/RM were conducting cases on faulty evidence they didn't alert defendants and make defence witnesses available.

4. That PO/RM didn't, on their own initiative, promptly seek to compensate those convicted, awaiting trial and who had paid to settle without prosecution.

5. That, when it became publicly known that Horizon was in error and that PO/RM had been carrying out prosecutions knowing that, the Ministry of Justice or any other official body didn't step in to get the convictions quahed as unsafe.

6, That, when it became publicly known that Horizon was in error and that PO/RM had been carrying out prosecutions knowing that, no official body stepped in to insist that PO/RM compensate those convicted, awaiting trial and who had paid to settle without prosecution.

7. That, when it became clear that PO/RM had been prosecuting cases knowing that their evidence was faulty, that prima facie cases of false prosecution and/or perjury were not investigated with dispatch and, where appropriate, prosecuted, possibly related to ...

8. That in place of 7 the government's attitude seems to have been that it preferred a public enquiry with not powers to prosecute

9. That, as those who have followed the saga of the public enquiry elsewhere will be aware, the enquiry has been appallingly dragged out by delays in making evidence available.

Justice delayed is justice denied.

It's not all watching transparent TV from a voice-commanded bidet. CES has work stuff too

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

a voice-controlled luxury toilet seat

"Flush it properly this time."

America's first private lunar lander suffers 'critical' fuel leak en route to Moon

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Corporations

I wonder how much they are being paid or are they just "rockstar" youngsters being promised the world if they just "give all they have"?

Whether they are or not, they'll be working at much less than maximum capacity on a job that needs just that.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Cryptocurrency????

Maybe. Is that on the cryptocurrency buyer's list of smart things to do?

HP customers claim firmware update rendered third-party ink verboten

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: "If a printer is connected to the internet, the update downloads automatically"

The average punter isn't going to be able to do that and these days you've got to be a very average punter to but this kit.

And that's a wrap for Babuk Tortilla ransomware as free decryptor released

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"the Amsterdam police force arrested the individual behind Babuk Tortilla, and the Dutch Public Prosecution Office prosecuted them, although neither institution has published information about the case"

If they successfully prosecuted them they should be publicising the fact as a deterrent. Is it possible the sentence was a wrist-slap?

OpenAI: 'Impossible to train today’s leading AI models without using copyrighted materials'

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

OpenAI has said it would be "impossible" to build top-tier neural networks that meet today's needs without using people's copyrighted work.

So that makes it OK then?

Fine. Let's try another argument along the same lines. Sauce for gander, etc.

It would be impossible to operate a personal computer without using Microsoft's copyrighted work*

so it should be OK to just use that freely in the same way. How does that sit with OpenAI's backers?

* Admittedly I know this premise to be false but Microsoft are unlikely to agree and we're looking at it from their PoV.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Sounds like...

"Can it be argued that training is similar to a child reading a copyrighted book - learning what the book teaches but simply not allowed to duplicate it, which is plagiarism?"

No it can't. Pick up any book published in the last few decades and open it at the page with the copyright, Library of Congress data ets. It will be somewhere near the title page, the dedication, if any, and before the table of contents. You will see something along the lines of "No part of this book may reproduced, stored in an electronic retrieval system" etc. etc.

The terms on which the book was sold to you explicitly forbid various stuff that isn't like a child reading a copyrighted book.

CEO of chat tech plumber Twilio is leaving the building

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"Twilio has already undertaken several reorganizations. In February 2023 it announced plans to cut 17 percent of its staffers. It also formed two business units: Twilio Data & Applications and Twilio Communications.

...

Twilio's revenue growth slowed markedly in 2023, "

Cause and effect?

New year, new bug – rivalry between devs led to a deep-code disaster

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: To Require Alignment Or Not To Require Alignment?

You reminded me, for the second time recently in these pages, of a FOSS project that wasn't an emulator. Worked fine until it didn't and it didn't because it crashed on the splash screen of a product I ran under it. A lot of other users reported issues with other products.

A bit of git-slicing took me to the responsible commit. It added a case option that said if the driver reports it needs 24 bits per pixel use 32 instead. The devs argument seems to be that using 24 is slower for gaming - hint, guys, if it crashes you'll never know whether it's slower or not.

Obviously, knowing where to look I just edited the function on every release, rebuilt and continued using it. I used to run their test suite on every release and it failed multiple tests on the unedited version and ran more or less perfectly with that one edit but eventually they started refusing to accept results from the fixed version. I suppose that was easier than having the results of their obduracy staring them in the face every month or so. Eventually there was a big rewrite and I couldn't be arsed to go looking for where they'd moved that erroneous assumption so I started using a VM instead.

Eventually I moved to different H/W and the problem went away but it's one project I've never really been able to take seriously ever since.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: About box Easter Eggs

I was, I think, one of the guinea pigs to get a system reviewed for security under the BT project (the name escapes me) following on from Prince Phillip's Prestel mailbox getting hacked. I was asked to confirm our system had no undocumented features. I suggested he go to BT procurement and get them to get Microsoft to sign such a declaration. I think he did - the question was dropped from the checklist. I later found out his background wasn't IT at all, it was perimeter security.

Welcome to 2024: Volkswagen really is putting ChatGPT into cars as a gabby copilot

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

The most chilling phrase in that report was "as standard". If they were to take a leaf out of the BMW script and make it pay to unlock it wouldn't be a problem. The same applies to all the rest of this S/W junk in cars.

I wonder if any of them will grok that there's real money to be made by a subscription to lock it instead.

Open source's new mission: To boldly go where no software has gone before

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Only for a specific type of open source, and only from a certain viewpoint

"I think trying to weasel out of responsibilities with 'well, it's a project, not a product' is terribly convenient"

My classification into products and projects is simply an observation of what's out there. If you want an every-day workable FOSS system for web browsing, writing books or whatever it exists with S/W with the polish that entitles it to be regarded as much a product as an equivalent that's not free in either sense of the word.

If you want something that provides the Windows platform that might be regarded as a product (and I know there'll be substantial disagreement that it can be so regarded) then you have to go with what Microsoft provides under their terms. Nobody said FOSS has to provide you with that.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Only for a specific type of open source, and only from a certain viewpoint

I think the GPL vs BSD argument is a distraction. In practice a Linux distro will include stuff with a wide variety of licences including GPLs 2 & 3 as well as BSD and others. From the point of the typical end user this makes no difference at all. The restrictions of GPL only apply to those distributing modified versions and they are not typical end users.

I do agree to quite an extent with the polish aspect. My thinking about this goes back the Chapter 1 of TMMM and Brooks' discussion of what is and isn't a product explained in this diagram this diagram Some development teams are content to stay in the top left corner but others do indeed produce a product. Those would include LibreOffice and various browsers and email clients. Add to that short list the tools you'd find in, say KDE - Dolphin (file management), Okular (PDF viewer), Kate/KWrite (simple text editor), Gwenview (image viewer), digiKam (image collection management) etc. - and you'll satisfy a lot of users and I'd rate all those as products. I don't think their developers can have considered raising them to that level as a thankless task, nor as one that doesn't involve solving interesting problems.

You also have to remember that there is not a single user audience to be pleased. Kate and vi, for example, are aimed at very different user demands for text editors (and even nvi and vim set out to meet somewhat different sets of expectations). The Kate user will undoubtedly find the vi experience stark and the vi user will find Kate bloated but both are nevertheless right for their respective users.

AFAICS your real gripes were with Wine and that is one I'd marked off as a project rather a product long ago; your comments suggest it still is although I think it has to be conceded that trying to recreate Microsoft's tar pit without getting caught in it will never be easy.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

"but that the flow of data must be discoverable to the originator of that data. Where's it coming from? Where's it going?"

Increasingly FOSS software's USP should be that the answer to the latter question can be "Nowhere, you can keep it local".

Gaia-X project doesn't have a future, claims Nextcloud boss

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Tine to fork the project and get rid of what you don't want. Karlitschek and Nextcloud know about that from their own experience.

Nearly 200 Boeing 737 MAX 9 airplanes grounded after door plug flies off mid-flight

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

A little before this incident I came across this: https://www.seattletimes.com/business/boeing-aerospace/boeing-wants-faa-to-exempt-max-7-from-safety-rules-to-get-it-in-the-air/

Ransomware payment ban: Wrong idea at the wrong time

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

That requires serious money upfront to make the bet with a possible risk of a loss if it doesn't work out.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Attack the toolchain

Then some local prosecutor shoots his mouth off to the press for a bit of self-publicity pulling the rug out from under the whole scheme. Or somebody who was appointed to a job that should have had better vetting tips off her boy-friends criminal mates.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: "Such a ban would need to be universal"

No suspended sentences for the CEO. Actual jail time. And why should the CEO be doing it on behalf of the directors. The directors can share the cell. As to shareholders - just whose money do you think is being used to pay ransoms? It's the shareholders. And as far too many seem to forget the shareholders are ultimately the holders of pensions, private and corporate, and of life insurance policies etc. They're you and me. We are the victims in these crimes.

And don't lose track of the fact that the object isn't really to strengthen the corporate defences although that would be a useful side effect, nor to punish CEOs or boards for being hit. It's to cut off ransomware by stopping it being worthwhile for the perpetrators.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Wrong

At the moment we have a feedback loop.

1. Ransomware generates profits because businesses pay.

2.. Businesses pay because they get hit with ransomware and there's nothing stopping them.

3. That makes ransomware profitable so go to 1.

That feedback loop needs to be broken. From my past career I'd love to see that done by going after the criminals but in practice the most accessible place to stop it by removing that second term in the 'because' clause in 2. And without ransomware the shareholders get a better deal. You're forgetting that the ransom doesn't get conjured up out of thin air. It's the shareholders' money that gets paid.

Doctor Syntax Silver badge

Re: Wrong

It's not a question of punishing the CEO for letting ransomware in. It's punishing the CEO for paying a ransom. If the ransoms aren't going to get paid where's the motive for demanding them? A CEO who wants to protect their back and the company can ensure he or she is doing their best to run a tight ship although once the message gets through that ransomware's day has gone because there's no benefit to be gained from it then both back and company are better protected anyway.

"Nothing would please me more than investors/shareholders/stakeholders getting a kick in the bollocks"

You do realise, don't you, that this might include you via your pension fund?

Page: