Love the ACCC
Love the ACCC. It's the only arm of government that whenever I read about them I think, hey they're actually doing something, and they're doing something good.
59 publicly visible posts • joined 12 Dec 2012
I think the writer of this article is promoting a utopia, a reality that is in defiance of reality. Copying of information is free by natural law. It is utopians who hope to defy natural law by putting a price on something which by nature is free.
Would our world come crashing down in this scenario? Well despite the internet and rampant copying, the world seems to be continuing just fine. Even the commodity which was copied most rampantly: music, seems to be continuing to be made. I didn't hear any news that the music died. And despite there being more free, out of copyright and brilliant books, not to mentioned pirated ones, I don't see anyone lamenting not enough new books being written. You can argue some masterpiece would have been writtten, but I doubt it. Creativity exists even without incentive. Even the Soviet union, lacking any meaningful incentive for anything, didn't do too badly in the area of artistic endeavor.
I don't know the justification for the purchase, but it may well be as simple as costing paper printed textbooks versus costing ipad, and ipad wins. Just because some crap Android tablet might be cheaper, and may have other features, doesn't mean its actually a viable solution. This hacker is just a fanboi who doesn't understand, probably.
It doesn't have to be plainsailing for everyone, only for mega that counts.
While nobody can know what the law ends up saying, your argument is just as strong against something like Google, who must be aware that a lot of the stuff they link to or even host must be copyright. Sure they take the stuff down when they find out about it, but so will mega.
You can still do that, you just post the key on the end of the URL, probably. mega.com/foobar?mykey=baz
The point is, mega now have plausible deniability. They don't know the URL that can access the data, only you do and whoever you give the URL to. If you post it publicly, sure the feds can chase it, but they can't blame mega, because they never knew anything.