ShortLegs: You have clearly never spent a day in anyone's Forces. And if you have, I'll apologise: I didnt know the muppets had an army.
cow: Being a random soldier in an army does not make you an expert in anything except the limited role you performed.
Serving in any army does not make you an expert in all the equipment in that army. I hope i dont have to explain this.
After 40+ years I have a hell of a lot more experience and knowlege than you. You have no idea of what *roles* i performed in, nor the experience I have. You plainly have zero experience of any role, or capabillity, of any weapon system, force application, arm, or service.
~
ShortLegs: There is no single weapon system that is all conquering and can be deployed on its own in every single tactical environment. Drones and tanks cannot hold land.
cow: I never claimed any of these statements.
No, you are quotoing out of context:
"Short: If the mission purpose is to take and hold land, those two elements are support roles to take land, but neither can hold land (for any value of $land, ie a hill, a building, a village, a river bank. etc).
cow: America had a lot of tanks in AF, they never held the land there. Close to 90% of AF was always held by the taliban. The Taliban never had any tanks and they held all of AF and continue to hold it today."
And now you are totally ignoring the comment. that those two elements (tanks and air) are support roles in the taking of land, but neither can hold land in isolation. You need infantry for that.
America did not have a lot of tanks in AF. None coalition forces deployed tanks in appreciable numbers, primarily because Afghanistan is not suited to manouever warfare. Its a tad difficult to deploy a 60ton tank in the mountains.
"Holding land is a cmplicated topic, its not about parking a tank anywhere. You are making v large sweeping statements."
I never made any such statement. I stated that tanks and drones cannot hold land.
~
Short:
Every single "tactical" advancement - from snipers, through mortars, through tanks, to drones, has seen a counter.
cow:
Of course it has.
My original statement was that tanks have been shown to be on the way out... just like horses were on the way out and it took a long time for them to stop being used in the military. For Fucks sake Hitler was still moving crazy amounts of supplies in WW2 with horses. Today its tanks.