The Register Home Page

* Posts by Phil O'Sophical

7402 publicly visible posts • joined 28 Oct 2011

Thunderbird 142 lands with modest upgrades – plus talk of Pro service ahead

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Yes, IIRC it was Supernova that really screwed-over the UI. Like you I stayed on the old one on my main system, while I figured out how to workaround the new "features" on another system. It's probably time to try the latest one and see what they've broken now.

Don't cave to Euro censorship or backdoor demands, Uncle Sam warns US tech firms

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: Luckily for me...

several hundred years ago.

The "National Razor" was still in use in France until 1977.

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: However will we survive?

When did the internet do anything else?

Until about 1980?

BOFH: HR plays checkers, IT plays 5D chess

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

it came apart at an elbow joint.

Funny how often that seems to happen just when there's an upgraded version of the server available, and still some money in the budget.

End well, this won't: UK commissioner suggests govt stops kids from using VPNs

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

His entire political career has been one of half-truths, dog whistles, and rabble-rousing, peppered with dodgy money.

So, like every other UK politician since the 1990s.

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

The LDs have never stood much chance. They've typically collected the protest votes from Tory or Labour voters who couldn't bring themselves to go all the way to the other side, but now Tory and Labour are much the same, the LDs are to the left of Labour and Farage is collecting the populist protest vote because people really don't care anymore.

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Alas, Labour seem to be continuing where the Tories left off.

No surprise, considering that when Cameron brought the Tories to power he just continued where Blair & Brown left off. The only difference these days is the colour of the rosette.

KPMG wrote 100-page prompt to build agentic TaxBot

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: Only tax agents can use the tool, because its output is not suitable for people

Then each client can have an instance of their AI agent arguing with an instance of the tax office agent about what they have to pay, without any expensive tax lawyers being involved. There's bound to be a way to monetize that,

A Linux alternative? Debian/Hurd shows microkernel Unix dream is alive

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: Microkernels have a *much* smaller attack surface.

If by "sinks the ship" you mean "crashes the whole system" that's possibly true, but most security exploits aren't intended to do that. They are more directed towards data access and exfiltration, or subverting the system for other purposes. For that it really doesn't matter if your exploit is in kernel or user land, it just needs to affect the part of the overall system which manages the resources it is targeting. Indeed, it may be easier to exploit a bug in accessible userland code than in the kernel.

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: In the meantime . . .

Well, at least the copyright is up-to-date...

(probably automated)

That's risky. Copyright protection lasts for a certain time into the future, so claiming a 2025 copyright for something written in, say, 2020 means that you're claiming 5 years more protection than you're entitled to. When updating source code for products our corporate legal team had very tight rules about when the (C) notice at the start of the files had to be changed, and when it must not be. Automated updates didn't extend copyright.

In Otter news, transcription app accused of illegally recording users’ voices

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: "In Otter news ...."

Sounds like they're using weasel words in the T&Cs to badger otter customers.

Teen interns brute-forced a disk install, with predictable results

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

The supermarkets round here have arrangements with local charities to send nearly-out-of-date food to them for use in soup kitchens, etc.

Alexa hits snooze on basic functions as alarms and timers KO'd in UK outage

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: "even scheduled wake-ups they'd long since deleted"

What they think they're going to do with every alarm you've ever set is anyone's guess.

Marketeers never get rid of data, there's always someone they think they can sell it to.

The plan for Linux after Torvalds has a kernel of truth: There isn’t one

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge
Trollface

Almost sounds like a proprietary product...

Pay attention, class: Today you’ll learn the wrong way to turn things off

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: One of my regrets

The worst part about that particular silence is the way your footsteps echo as you walk back across the raised floor. Very disconcerting.

Marc Andreessen wades into the UK's Online Safety Act furor

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

until a secure and privacy-preserving proof of age system could be put in place

There's no such animal, and never will be. Generating proof of age requires surrendering some privacy, by definition.

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Using a VPN doesn't guarantee security end-to-end

Using a VPN for general connections (instead of bypassing geo restrictions) gives something of a false sense of security. If you connect to a remote site through "Fred's VPN service" you will have a secure connection between the client on your device, and the server hosting Fred's endpoint. From there the connection will be routed over the ordinary Internet to whatever bank/shop/mailserver you're using.

Just using a standard SSL connection, like HTTPS, gives you a secure connection from your device right through to the remote site you're accessing. A VPN adds little to that.

Obviously using a VPN like OpenVPN, Cisco AnyConnect, etc. for, say, remote work, where the VPN endpoint is on your employer's server and opens directly into their secure network is a different matter. There it is useful, because you have end-to-end security.

Mexit, not Brexit, is the new priority for the UK

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: Alternatives

absolutely nothing stopping the English Govt. establishing its own .Gov version of Debian and requiring all Govt. departments to use it

But I can absolutely guarantee that every government department will then spend more money on proving why they must be an exception, and keep MS, than they would ever spend actually making the transition. People don't like change, and civil servants really hate it.

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

most people are happy to learn a new OS & apps when they get a smartphone

Most ElReg commentards, maybe. Most ordinary people absolutely hate having to do it.

NASA won't name the Shuttle picked to move to Texas

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge
Coat

Re: Ease of transportation

Cut & Shut(tle)?

Prohibition never works, but that didn't stop the UK's Online Safety Act

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: Ignorant politicians

Anyway, don't UK ISP's have some sort of child filter already?

That would require parents to do some parenting.

KLM, Air France latest major organizations looted for customer data

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: Another 3rd party supplier

The responsibility lies entirely with the large companies that hired the supplier. It's their job to make sure that they choose, and pay for, appropriate service.

Meta used Flo menstruation app data to sell ads, jury finds

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: People, people

If the user does due diligence and the company says explicitly that they don't do something but then do, I'm not sure what else you expect a user to do

If the company is Meta or Alphabet you assume they're lying. That boat has sailed.

Real estate agents use the power of AI to command plumbing, layout to disappear

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

For sales involving such huge amounts of money it's amazing how little care the agents take.

Like anything else, they just reflect the [lack of] care of the buyers. If they'll take any old crap, then that's what the agents will sell. Caveat Emptor, as always.

Amnesty slams Elon Musk's X for 'central role' in fueling 2024 UK riots

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

The saying that "a lie is halfway round the world before the truth has got its boots on" applies now more than ever before.

That quote has its origins in a "post" (in a printed paper) by Jonathan Swift over 300 years ago, which really shows that there is nothing new in the world and this sort of manufactured outrage long predates the likes of Xitter. People will believe what they want to believe.

UK's Ministry of Defence pins hopes on AI to stop the next massive email blunder

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: Wages

How about just properly training the people you've already got?

Tech bro denied dev's hard-earned bonus for bug that overcharged a little old lady

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: Lawsuit culture

Would that be "normal" in the sense of perpendicular to the baseline?

Long live the nub: ThinkPad designer David Hill spills secrets, designs that never made it

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge
Thumb Up

Re: What's a "bento box"?

I always preferred his flea circus, I must have a look for that on YouTube.

Tested: Microsoft Recall can still capture credit cards and passwords, a treasure trove for crooks

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: Thankyou for the test!

It looks like typical US-centric crap that assumes all phone numbers are in "1 (xxx) mmm nnnn" format, all addresses have a "State" field, etc. Obviously won't properly filter fields from, say, a French site with an "identifiant fiscal" or "numéro de sécurité sociale" instead of an SS number, or a UK site with a "Unique Taxpayer Reference", etc.

You can never, ever, correctly filter all such fields through a blacklist-type mechanism, there are simply too many options.

Linux kernel 6.16 lands without any headline features but 38M lines of code

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge
Coat

Re: "world's most famous Finn"

As might Finn MacCool?

How to find forgotten Wi-Fi passwords and SSIDs in Windows and Android

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: last 10 passwords

Most systems I've used required you to enter the old password as well as the new, to prove that you had the authority to change it. That makes it easy to apply a "too similar" check, at least for password n-1.

For the "no reuse of last 10" case it just has to hold the last 10 hashes.

'It looks sexy but it's wrong' – the problem with AI in biology and medicine

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge
WTF?

Justified criticism

Satirical criticism by such public figures (that people may tend to trust more than ‘legitimate’ news sources) can throw into question the legitimacy of the scientific research community at large, and the public can come to distrust (even more) or not take seriously what they hear coming out of the scientific research community,"

That's not due to the entirely reasonable satirical criticism, it's down to the scientific research community publishing results without checking them, and it is perfectly understandable that such behaviour results in distrust. The community needs to fix itself, not shoot the messenger.

Copilot Vision on Windows 11 sends data to Microsoft servers

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: get off the internet

Can you bring a box of books and jigsaws?

The tiny tech tribe who could change the world tomorrow but won't

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: Ecumenism

So, nothing happens.

Either that, or you get a Holy War.

Sometimes "nothing happens" is the best outcome.

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: "There are ten people in the world who could decide tomorrow"

Ten people?

I've worked in companies where there are more than ten people responsible for UI standardization in each department and even they can't agree with each other.

As for cars, they may standardize on a wheel & a couple of pedals, but beyond that it's a free-for-all. It was bad enough when every manufacturer just put indicator and light switches in different places, but now that they're infested with touchscreen UIs designed by people who don't even drive they are even worse. Hire a car at an airport these days & you'll spend so long just to figure out how to start the engine, turn on the lights and adjust the seat that you'll end up trying to read the user manual on your phone (because they don't even print them nowadays).

This is a lost cause. Even voting with your wallet won't help.

UK government swoons over OpenAI in legally meaningless love-in

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: "build the UK into an artificial intelligence powerhouse"

So I bet they never use it to process tax refunds...

Japan discovers object out beyond Pluto that rewrites the Planet 9 theory

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: Why?

The original was the brilliant radio series. The books were the first adaptations. The TV series came a poor third.

Humongous parachute for European Mars landing mission tested successfully

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge
Coat

as it turned out, the parachutes didn't hold things up

Well, that's your problem right there...

Time for Britain's CMA to strike hard – or risk losing the cloud competition fight

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: A potential Brexit Benefit

For decades the UK has rolled out toothless regulators which only really exist to give an appearance of "doing something"

Unfortunately the current government's solution is to nationalise the industries which the inept regulators have so signally failed to regulate (Thames Water is an obvious example).

That just means that the same people who were so inept at supervising the businesses will now become responsible for running them completely.

What could possibly go wrong?

Coldplay kiss-cam flap proves we’re already our own surveillance state

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Exactly. If you're going to snog your mistress in public you have to accept the risk that someone will see you. For some people, that's the rush, until they get caught. It really doesn't matter if it's a papparazo, a private eye, or a roving camera at a concert, it has nothing to do with an imagined surveillance state.

Meta used AI to concoct low-carbon concrete it poured for a datacenter floor

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: greener concrete

Maybe they should use acre-feet?

Large Hadron Collider data hints at explanation for why everything exists

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: Might

Don't be so negative.

Junior developer's code worked in tests, destroyed data in production

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: Mine was far more primitive

I remember a sysadmin who ran a standalone backup (remember those?) and managed to copy the blank disk over the live one.

There was a reason those older systems had drive write-protect switches, and it's a shame that they are not common nowadays.

AI coding tools make developers slower but they think they're faster, study finds

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: Good for small stuff...

But I'm really a duffer at programming; I want to get things done, so I use AI

If you're that much of a duffer, how do you test that it has done the right thing?

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: Rolling the Dice

marketroid shoutings of how intelligent AI is. And then it turns out there's zero intelligence to it.

Nor from them, that's why they are so easily taken in.

You have a fake North Korean IT worker problem – here's how to stop it

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: Easier solution

Employment isn't a democracy. If you want to call the shots, either start your own business or develop a unique skill set, otherwise you're a commodity. You're an employee, not a partner, and easily replaced. That hasn't changed in millenia, nor will it ever.

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge
FAIL

Re: Easier solution

Why is it always the worker who must travel, beg, and prove? If in-person is so vital, send the manager.

In your haste to rant, did you even take the time to read the whole post you replied to? Specifically the bit which said "Who does what travel is irrelevant.". As the poster noted, what's important is the face-to-face meeting, not how it is achieved.

Slow down on building power plants for all those new AI datacenters, report warns

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: we need a two-tier power system

Yes, I'm saying businesses should have their power cut off before people.

And then the people who work for those businesses get sent home, so don't have money to pay for their electricity. That won't help.

French cops cuff Russian pro basketball player on ransomware charges

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge
Joke

Re: "He's useless with computers and can't even install an application"

But aren't the worst serial killers always the ones who look least like killers?

Firefox is fine. The people running it are not

Phil O'Sophical Silver badge

Re: Firefox is very slow

How many of those would you use in a typical day? I don't believe anyone can keep track of 400+tabs, nor need them all frequently enough to merit the waste of resources involved in keeping them all open all the time.