Re: Energy generation mix
@rg287
"We'll just carry on burning coal and Russian gas then. Sure. Fine. No problem."
I dont have a problem with that. Instead we shut down the coal plants that we relied upon each winter. We keep using gas anyway because of wind and solar generators.
"Gas and oil are famously cheap and Russia/OPEC have never cut production to cause major oil-shocks that have shattered the world economy."
Very cheap. Thanks to fracking it is even cheaper and not under the thumb of OPEC.
"This idea of moving to domestically generated renewable energy with no paid inputs and predictable maintenance costs is totally unnecessary!"
You are paying for the inputs? Wind and solar is free as oil is also free. It the using it as energy that costs (and in unreliables case a lot!) and oil/gas/coal/nuclear are a store of energy that can be deployed as needed. Wind and solar have no storage, you need to add that separately AND have a reliable backup such as gas to fill the gaps up to 100%.
"The reason energy prices are high are down to a combination of Herr Putin"
Putin didnt stop selling. In fact Russian gas was selling cheaper as the Chinese and India found (and sold on to the west after marking it up).
"failure by NG to build interconnects concurent with highland windfarm construction so that we have the capacity to ship power down to England - with the result we're now paying windfarms to shut down when the Scottish grid is saturated. That's not the fault of the windfarms - it's the fault of government for dragging their heels on infrastructure (of all sorts)."
Since there is an interconnector problem why did so many wind turbines get built up there? After spaffing billions we need to spaff billions to keep spaffing billions on the next problem of trying to make the unreliables work. At the same time build actual generation (gas btw) to back these things up. The costs add up. And of course paying for the turbines to stop generating. We know how to produce power so we shouldnt have such a shortage of capacity nor such high prices.
"That's not the fault of the windfarms - it's the fault of government for dragging their heels on infrastructure (of all sorts)."
I place plenty blame on the gov for our situation.
"Nobody saw that, and neither did you. HP-C's total budget for protecting marine life is ~£700m. Of which the acoustic deterrent/"fish disco" bit is £50m. You can argue about the necessity of that, but it's not costing £700m. It's <10% of the total environmental protection budget."
The disco is £50m but the total cost of the measures is £700m to save very little-
https://www.irishtimes.com/world/uk/2025/12/03/fish-disco-freakout-starmer-looks-to-change-tune-on-obstacles-to-industrial-investment/