Re: Congratulations
Seriously, how does one manage to say for sure either way when it's only just been opened for beta?
It's just been opened to the public for beta. Beta testing has been going for about a year (I was invited in August) but the NDA has just been lifted.
Now I'm seeing in the press the exact same range of comments I saw from new beta testers, and they fall into basically 3 groups:
1. Elder Scrolls gamers complaining that the world isn't as open as they're used to. This is correct, but necessary -- you can't adjust the game world for a single player when you have thousands of players;
2. MMO fans complaining that the game was missing common UI elements of MMOs (e.g, combat log, minimap). This, while also technically true, ignored the facts that you can play the game quite effectively (and achieve better immersion) without them, and that there is an add-on API for which add-ons are already being developed to provide these features; and
3. Players who treated the game as a new experience and took the time to learn how it was designed to be played.
Group 3 was invariably the most pleased with the game, and in my experience provided some of the most constructive feedback (which, BTW, I can tell you has definitely been incorporated into the game.) However, even groups 1 and 2 usually ended up liking the game despite their initial complaints.
In short, don't expect "Skyrim Online" or "WoW in Tamriel".