Re: No Brainer, Really....
"It is much easier to SAY you're going to set up a lunar base than to actually do it."
That may be true, but is it more difficult to do that than to create a large scale space station? It would certainly be easier to scale once established.
The fact is, we need a staging point somewhere around this planet in order to do anything really effective beyond its orbit. The Moon may not be the perfect place, but it's a lot better than lifting everything out of the Earth's well. We may start with having to import everything from Earth anyway, but with time, we could probably figure out how to use the local resources for some purposes.
The plans for going to Mars as they stand at the moment are going to end up just like our little jaunt to the Moon. We go, we bring back some rocks, we say we went, then forget about it for 50 years because it was too expensive.