The Register Home Page

* Posts by Roland6

14636 publicly visible posts • joined 23 Apr 2010

Smart meters to cost the UK billions: 2G switch-off means replacing 12-13 million

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Did these smart meters collectively save more than £4m to consumers?

I would hope they did save consumers more than £4m, (million) given the forecast was for £5.6B (billion) of savings to consumers and £6B (billion) of network savings “over the course of the rollout”

What is perhaps noteworthy is the seeming lack of research into whether these savings have materialised.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Did these smart meters collectively save more than £4m to consumers?

>” They should have been mandatory from the start and as for the stupidity of rolling out single provider meters to a market that had already adopted supplier switching words fail me.”

Not only single supplier, but installed by individual suppliers, resulting in patchwork deployment.

Under the old municipal utility system rollout and replacement of meters was done systematically. I doubt a modern “privatised” UK could organise anything like the 1960s switchover from town gas to natural gas.

Microsoft teaches schools that free email was just a phase

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Good

Most now share IT services, so whilst they don’t have an exclusive on-site IT guy they will have access to a shared person and to the LEA. So not too difficult to get access to an LEA area wide initative to move away from MS 365…

Anthropic's super bug-finding Mythos model is going into Cisco and IBM products

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: IBM and Cisco hit by antropic hack

Given we understand that any use of Mythos involves the upload of information to Mythos, this most certainly seems to be a contributor to making Mythos the “one ring to rule them all”.

Previously, Cisco and IBM could offer a fig leaf of security due to their code being proprietary and the source only being readable by them, with Mythos it would seem all of their source will become accessible to all who can cast an appropriate spell (ie. An AI prompt with appropriate guardrail circumvention ‘incantations’…)

Landline phones will switch off across Britland in 100 days, no extensions – Openreach

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Contingency

It is essential the “wires” used for telecoms have a metal core because then it is a simple task of detecting both breakage and then using TDR to remotely locate within a few metres the point of breakage.

Whilst OTDR is supposed to do the same (as TDR) for fibre, detecting breakage requires a second circuit, the laugh was the line (with service guarantee) Openreach installed a couple of years back (post COVID) used a fully copper circuit (routed differently to the fibre) for this service management circuit.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Contingency

>” I recall there being rules for that. Every exchange had a sizeable contingent of batteries for that exact purpose.”

Expect much of the battery capacity was removed in the 1970s - back then many friends had glazed plant pots etc. that were previously exchange battery jars. I remember for several years an exchange in north Wales had a stack of such jars which people were free to take.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Contingency

>” Anything from BT/EE a minimum box ticking fucking PITA, and why Plusnet are trying to stop any landline provision at all..”

EE, prior to BT deciding to make it their new consumer brand only supported landlines on FTTC, their FTTP service didn’t include any phone provision - customer had to source digital phone service and equipment from elsewhere and had to do it (and port the number) before they cancelled their landline service if they wished to retain their existing geo-based landline number.

In general UPS’s for low power DC applications (*) are both scarce and rubbish. I wonder if Practical Electronics has a suitable project or if there is a “kit” of the sort that was once upon a time available from Maplin, Radio Shack et al. Obviously, it would take a (currently) widely available 12V lead acid battery as its power source.

(*) I’m referring to the type of UPS many have specified here, smelt one that can support 4~6 devices each having a different VA requirement in the 3~12V range and obviously a selection of plugs and/or adaptor tips (remember the bag of adaptor tips that often came with third-party laptop adaptors).

Roland6 Silver badge

Residual on premise equipment…

Whilst the POTS network will get turned off, currently there is no change in the status of BT/Openreach on-premise equipment. So to clear out old BT cabling and distribution boxes dating back to the “GPO”, I still need an Openreach engineer to visit and fully disconnect it from the (decommissioned) street cabinet, before I can start the task of removing the many layers and generations of phone wiring and distribution boxes from several clients premises.

Perhaps, I should ensure the Openreach engineer leaves one line intact, to which I can attach a tone dial phone to, just in case TPTB decide to maintain the POTS network as an emergency fall back…

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Separate Power Supplies

From my experience with solar panels and battery, a “15-minute” online UPS on the desktop and associate equipment is very handy. Whilst my house batteries can maintain me off grid for a “normal” weekend the switchover between mains failing and battery (line interactive UPS) isn’t always quite as clean and fast as the PC needs to prevent reboot…

Roland6 Silver badge

Also the decision to do away with the wholly separate emergency services Airway Network based on TETRA technology…

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Contingency

>” You do realise that IP telephony doesn't need external support.”

If there is any use of DNS or DHCP by any device necessary to establish and maintain a call, and in the management and billing of that call, then it does need external support…

Britain on notice: AI-powered ransomware attacks to arrive by 2028

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: It's spelled "defence"

BTW If we are being pedantic and grammatically correct: it’s spelt “defence”

But given how Blackwood (sic) some left pondians are, they might actually believe IT security and AI prompting is witchcraft - defence against the dark arts.

(*) who would of thought JK Rowling was a futurologist and hence could see school children would need classes in the defensive arts…

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: The next train will be along shortly

It is:

” ARTEX, an open source, Chinese-made AI red-teaming platform, in attacks on UK registrar 123 Reg, Microsoft 365, and others since its launch in July.”

It amused me the contents of the article dispels the comfort blanket offered by the title: it’s today’s problem, not tomorrows - so needs to be in the “To Do/Action Now” tray, not “Pending”.

Open models can do 90% of agentic work at a twentieth of the cost of a frontier LLM: Gartner

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Software is aspirational

>” most of them seem to want "only the best" while buying software.”

Where “the best” is actually what everyone else is using and requires the least effort ie. Other people and businesses tend to follow the herd, which get drawn to market leaders or those who have had the best advertising. It takes an exceptional set of circumstances for people to diverge.

If we look at CoVID lockdown, we should note the speed at which people and businesses converged on Zoom - as it solved an immediate problem, subsequently people have largely gone back to the fold and replaced it with Teams (conveniently bundled with MS 365) rather than continue with third-party or “outsider” products.

I suggest the year of the Linux desktop will occur a year or so after governments adopt it and stop using MS 365…

Roland6 Silver badge

Even the BBC...

However, I note the BBC have strayed into questionable clickbait with their headline...

"These firms you've never heard of are feeding fears the AI bubble could burst"

Reading their article, and others, its not that we should "fear" the AI bubble might burst, but should expect and plan on it bursting.

Britain's tech ambitions depend on minerals made in China, MPs warn

Roland6 Silver badge

So MPs discover the blindingly obvious: the UK depends on imports and the goodwill of others...

As has been previously covered on ElReg, China dominates certain mineral supply chains because of US policy which decided to offshore the mining and refining of certain minerals to China.

With the US deciding to resume mining and refining of relevant minerals, the UK should be able to reduce its dependency on China but still it's ability to obtain them will be wholy dependent upon the Whitehouse-Downing St relationship.

Even with relevant minerals being available within Europe, the UKs access will almost certainly be influenced by its relationship with the EU...

So unless the UK suddenly discovers significant mineral reserves here in the UK and doesn't decide to sell them on the world market (to fund government deficit/tax cuts etc. ie. it doesn't really matter whether Conservatives/Reform/Labour are in government, the reserves will be worked and sold to customers outside of the UK...

US air traffic control enters the 21st century, starts to abandon floppy disks

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Silly Questions

>systems should be recertified at least every decade to force the issue when ossification occurs. Hardly moving fast and breaking things.

Going back to the 1980's we were building IT systems to support safety critical mass transit systems, the IT systems had an contracted initial operational life of 20 years. Given the lead time on procurement, build and deployment, this effectively meant the system would be in for 10~15 years before getting reviewed for replacement. Although given the IT system was often replacing (fully manual) Victorian block signally...

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Silly Questions

>"Sure, the obvious bugs have been beaten out of old systems"

Could look at it differently: The old systems, by not having Internet capability don't suffer from the obvious bugs...

RIP to the world’s ugliest car

Roland6 Silver badge

>

"Real Muricans drive large gas-powered cars, ideally with noisy exhaust systems. "

That trope gets trotted out so much that I blame marketing and adverts for it rather than it being reality.

You missed the law makers from your list - remember many states have banned the Kei car…

Uber says it alone can make robotaxis pay, hours after Waymo quit its app

Roland6 Silver badge

The problem we have is not so much the getting to places, but getting back, particularly if the destinaion doesn't have a taxi rank..

Microsoft improves Windows 11 performance on 8 GB PCs as RAM prices keep climbing

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: It's like someone at MS discovered ReviOS/AtlasOS/debloat script of choice...

I wonder when someone at Microsoft discovers Rufus et al and changes the supported CPU’s, enabling many home users to upgrade to a supported version of Windows rather than either take out a mortgage for a new PC or switch to Linux…

'Mother of all editors' Emacs is 50

Roland6 Silver badge

The other bit of fun from wayback was seeing those who didn't know vi had a file size limit and discover if they wanted to edit particularly large files you had to use ed...

Oracle wants to bill you for every AI task, not just every seat

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Where is the money coming from?

The 2-part film “De Gaulle” is worth viewing, part 2 we found particularly riveting and showed both the American and English political class in a poor light.

What is particularly noteworthy is how the vitally important role the Free French played in the North Africa campaign has been massively down played by both the America and British accounts of events.

Also what is interesting, the US, without consulting the French had drawn up a post war partitioning of France - effectively removing France as a country… what the US is doing with respect to Ukraine has many parallels…

Google struggling to make AI Mode searches pay

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: AI - money down the drain

>” I remember the sheer amount of very expensive Sun hardware being purchased”

That’s reminded me of Worldport datacentre in Dublin, fully fitted out with Sun kit in anticipation of the dotcom boom, only for it to be shuttered etc.

I suspect those behind the many applications still in the planning queue when the dotcom bubble burst were glad they hadn’t incurred the expense of build and kit out.

The bursting of the AI bubble is going to have a similar effect, a side benefit will be the clearing of planning queues and so reducing delays…

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Another One

Which has effectively been the business plan of the majority of web startups: build a huge user-base, do a ra-ra funding round to build a huge war chest, use said war chest to workout how to turn huge user base into a revenue stream, before the money runs out…

Roland6 Silver badge

Just remember the “consensus opinion” is the AI’s take on all those ad-laden sites - frequently I’ve encountered the AI consensus method has been derived from methods appropriate to a number of versions of Windows and hence doesn’t work on any particular real-world version…

Shortlist of age checks for the UK's under-16 social media ban is out, 'some' adults will need verifying

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: And

You are missing the part played by Chrome/Edge and their unique machine/user ids.

I’ve had instances where I have browsed stuff in “private” whatever mode closed and restarted the browser and received adverts in a normal session that relate to what was viewed in the “private” session…

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: It's supposed to be proof of age, not proof of identity

>” But don't leave out malice as an element of the original requirement.”

That’s the security angle; expect the spooks and law enforcement to propose options which would make their lives easier.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Fleabay anybody?

…Apple stop allocating @me.com email addresses in September 2012, so not long before they could be used as evidence of being 18+

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Face age checks

It amuses me when the assistant is required to verify I’m over 18 at the self checkouts with face camera, turns out to be someone who is barely 20. Would not be surprised if their accuracy rate and (wages) cost out performs a high tech AI recognition system.

British intelligence agency misplaced 'thousands' of storage devices, years later still can't say how many

Roland6 Silver badge

But not into the hands of a journalist…

Farm PC 'maintained' by a 14-year-old dumped support chap in a steaming pile of tech mess

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: what

Autonomous Sensory Meridian Response

‘People watch or listen to ASMR content (widely available on platforms like YouTube) to induce relaxation, reduce stress, lower their heart rate, or help with sleep and anxiety.“

Roland6 Silver badge

But back then floppies were the way to go.

We implemented InPharm - a pharmacy management and dispensing system for the Apple II & III, it ran off floppies.

ICL, after a failed approach to buy us out, to all intents and purposes copied it to run on their more expensive DRS workstation (which also used floppies) and called it OnPharm…

LibreOffice's 'no AI' stance meets LLM-assisted code

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Is that a bad thing?

The main difference I remember is a significant raising of limits on the size of worksheets, something I found useful as circa 2006~2012, I was doing a lot of systems and network modelling using Excel and so wanted to create large 3D workbooks with ‘interesting’ formula.

My irritation with Office 2007 was that none of my stylesheets (dating back to 1986 and Word 3) worked and both the creation of replacement and getting Word to use them was a right pain, plus a suite of charting tools I accumulated no longer worked and would have to be reimplemented…

However, in saying that, I did continue to use it until my email provider updated their security to use settings Outlook 2007 didn’t support, at which point I jumped to 2019 and have studiously avoided the MS web versions of Office for any thing other than accidental preview of stuff sent to me via 365.

Not made the move to alternatives because some of the packages I use only support Excel; but like many, I know it is only a matter of time before there will be no real choice… However, when I move, I will be taking my key SME/third-sector clients with me.

As you say Thunderbird can now do much of what Outlook did (and does today, given it seems MS seem to have depreciated the forms flow ‘Notes’ killing functionality) the other office suite tools have similarly improved. Fingers crossed the UK government realises the vast majority of its desktops and dependent upon a single US supplier and if government has seen fit to maintain at least two suppliers of: buses, trains, planes etc., throwing some money (From the IT monies spent circa £1bn Pa is a good starting point) at an open source second supplier is simply good practice.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Is that a bad thing?

I would hope Chris was (favourably) handwaving at Office 2003. Although putting the Ribbon to one side Office 2007 did have some noticeable improvements particularly to Excel. Which seems to be the trick MS have repeated, for example W10 where the underlying OS.seems to be much improved, just that it was coupled with questionable UI refresh…

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Seems some are getting confused…

Liam your “explosion” is actually very informative and aligns more with my overnight thinking about BSE and the discovery of the extent to which beef products had permeated the vegetarian food chain and that strict vegans need to check E numbers…

> “C is crap. C was crap in 1969 and it is worse now.”

Coming to C from a background in the “classics” (ie. Algol-68, Pascal, COBOL, Fortran, ADA), Prolog and various Assembler languages, I was surprised just how much people raved about C. However, as that is what the world seemed to want, developing a C workbench (think forerunner to VisualStudio) for the MSDOS PC seemed reasonable…

A concern has been whether replacements eg. Rust - influenced by C, are going to be significantly better.

A second concern has to be the amount of C source being used for LLM training, which can surely only perpetuate the use of C.

>” The thing here is that right now, bots can find bugs. Whether they can _fix_ them well is not yet clear but by Jove they can find them faster than ever. So objecting to bots on safety grounds -- the nut allergy comparison -- does not stand.”

There is a lot in here. Firstly totally agree using the best tools available to find bugs is a good thing and if the best tools are AI then let’s use them. Your second point, the “fixing”, is the real issue, like you I have doubts and it is here we need to be most cautious about the uninformed use of LLM based AI code tools. It is this context, where LLM AI can introduce unexpected code/side-effects, I think the parallels with nuts and BSE are relevant. However, these side effects still don’t necessarily mean the resulting code contains “AI features” which users would recognise as AI augmentation.

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Seems some are getting confused…

The article, covers two issues, the first is as you note about the “cleanliness” of the code from the input of AI and the other is the marketing of the resulting product as being “AI free”.

I get TDF have made a statement that covers both areas, however, it the purpose of the article is to draw attention to the double standards in development, namely - development is not AI free as TDF want to promote it as being. I suggest statements such as: ”TDF … has made the absence of built-in AI a selling point” aren’t really relevant to that argument.

>” Comparison: I'm not vegan, but I've been vegetarian for 45 years. I am very annoyed when restaurants tell me something is vegetarian and then serve me food with bits of animal cadaver floating in it. ”

I drew the comparison because, with nuts it is very clear, if a factory handles nuts, there is a real risk of cross contamination. However, it is not so clear how the use of AI in development by an expert could “contaminate” the resulting product with “AI”. Although I do get there is a risk an AI code generator could include calls to AI, which could survive a code inspection; which would suggest code submissions will need to be scanned for such constructs.

[BTW I’ve not down voted your clarification, and like your would be interested to know reasons for the number of down votes your comment has attracted.

Roland6 Silver badge

Seems some are getting confused…

Using AI or other tools in the production of code doesn’t mean that the resulting code actually contains runtime calls/hooks for AI augmentation.

or are people suggesting AI is like nuts and thus the resulting code needs to carry a health warning such as: “ "Made in a factory that handles nuts AI” and/or “may contain nuts AI” ?

Amazon tells tokenmaxxing devs to slow their AI roll

Roland6 Silver badge

But in Amazon’s case, it does lead to less resources being used internally and more left for paying customers to use…

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Measuring productivity by consumption . . .

Just like measuring productivity by number of lines of code produced… - probably explains some of the bloat we see…

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Nothing new

More recent that the mainframe days.

I started my career when the options for code input were:

1. Fill out coding sheets and wait for them to be converted to paper tape or punched cards.

2. Book an hour’s slot on a shared terminal (circa 1 terminal per 30 students - so getting more than one slot a week could be challenging)

I remember the first employer (1985) where I had an Altos 386 (System V) all to myself; luxury…

Tape is so not dead that Fujifilm will increase production capacity 5x

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Back in the day

I think you are alluding to the subtle but important difference between having a backup strategy and having an archival and recovery strategy.

Yes you can have backups in the cloud, but whilst this may satisfy the needs of most day-to-day operational data recovery needs, it will be of limited use if you need to do a more extensive business and IT systems recovery.

Eg. Try and recover backups from “your” compromised or disabled (at the whim of the Whitehouse or Microsoft) 365 account

A whopping 3% of boardroom execs spy productivity and costs savings from AI

Roland6 Silver badge

“ A whopping 3% of boardroom execs spy productivity and costs savings from AI ”

spy? Blind faith, more likely - based on overhyped promotional pitches.

I’ve yet to meet any executive from a large company who has any in-depth understanding of IT issues and specifically AI to be able to identify any savings not brought to their attention by an expensive management consultant…

PubKeep picks up where Microsoft Publisher signs off

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Wrong audience possibly

>” The parents not registering they're on benefits is a serious matter in its own right”

Agree, it was problem we encountered 20 years back. People didn’t like drawing attention to themselves and their financial circumstances.As a PTA we discretely circulated grow out of school kit and blanket funded a breakfast club on the basis it only needed one kid to be disruptive for an entire class to suffer.

>” But volunteers can't do all that money shifting stuff.”

I get where you are coming from.

My partner (works full time in the third-sector), whilst encouraging people to become trustees is also hard on them and doesn’t allow them to simply be “names”, they are expected to do something, like help with funding and glad handing…

At my children’s school, we brought the (stay at home/role reversal) dads and grand parents together (selected from those regularly seen at the school gate dropping off or picking up children), These having business knowledge and time to devote.

So yes I don’t expect general volunteers to do all the money stuff, but ask around and you might find some who are more than happy to contribute in this way rather than in-person service delivery volunteering.

Not saying it’s easy, just don’t accept No as the first and final answer to a request…

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Wrong audience possibly

Agree Canva isn’t a “drop in” replacement, but it does a decent job for the sorts of promotional material many v.small organisations need.

>” or are too busy bidding for funding for the core activity.”

I come across this a lot - people forget - IT is a key enabler for delivering the core activity, and so don’t properly factor in on costs. For one bid we increased the hours needed to cover “record keeping”, naturally we spent the money on IT … Basically, to run an association/charity you have to get creative and not necessarily tell the funders the full truth…

I mentioned local councillors as they each have a £500+ pa budget they can spend on projects in their community. They can be quite generous in Feb/Mar when they realise they haven’t spent their allowance and the cut off is the end of March…

For a PTA, lean on the school, they will have IT and an additional laptop can often be made available. Obviously, with PTA’s you need to encourage parents with children who qualify for free school meals and classroom support to register with the school so that the school can draw down additional funding…

However if you really need Publisher, Groupon currently have Office 2021 (the last version to include Publisher) on offer: Office Pro Plus 2021 - £6.75 with code HALLOWEEN

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Just Claude it

https://getartcraft.com/apps …

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Wrong audience possibly

The audiences you talk of are the ones Canva has been marketing its free plans to…

As for £100 being a significant matter, if you can write a funding bid or talk to your local councillor, it’s not.

Alternatively, there is DesignCraft…

> A(nother) curse on Microsoft for killing a tool that ordinary users needed

Yes, Microsoft has form here, remember Works, once bundled for free with Windows. Basically, MS have been moving away from the Joe Public market for some years now, and could even be said to have been moving away from the SME market with its move away from on-prem to cloud…

Raspberry Pi Desktop proves old PCs aren't past it

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: I always thought "Why buying a Pi"

>” Avoid stuff without enough USB ports an without bultin LAN”

Also avoid laptops,with half-height ports - the sprung flap will almost certainty came off and then there is nothing to hold the cable in place…

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: I might try this.

The problem with older laptops is finding replacement batteries that aren’t of a similar vintage to ones you are wishing to remove. Better sellers will provide date of manufacture information, but don’t expect bargain basement prices….

Roland6 Silver badge

Re: Relationship

Apart from choosing the right USB port, the main reason I’ve encountered for poor performance is the use of “cheap” USB sticks only really intended for documents or music files.

USB sticks suitable for running VM’s and OS’s from (ie. Performant and capable of staying cool under sustained load), aren’t cheap. Also USB powered drives tend to be less performant than independently powered USB drives.

I have been running a WS2019 VM resident on a 256GB Samsung FIT Plus USB 3.1 flash drive plugged into a HP Probook 450 G4 (2016) i5-7200U CPU 8GB RAM natively running W10 since circa 2021 (aside my biggest problems have been the laptop doesn’t like being permanently adaptor powered, also it periodically looses the USB drivers and so has to be rebooted). Okay the laptop has a USB 3 port so has the capability to support performant USB, but together they out perform the in-built SSD.