* Posts by veti

3939 posts • joined 25 Mar 2010

Russian invasion has dangerously destabilized cyber security norms

veti Silver badge

Re: Distinction

Are you saying non-Windows platforms are inherently more secure, or that the early Internet was less vulnerable to DOSsing?

Either way, I don't think that's a defensible position.

veti Silver badge

Re: Disingenuous!! Misdirection!!

Did you, like, read the story or its links at all, before jumping to whatabouts?

All the work to agree "norms" happened precisely *because* everyone knew shit like that was going on. And everyone thought it would be a good idea to establish some kind of limits. Like, e.g., no attacking a country's emergency services.

Doesn't mean everything is meant to be nice and safe. Just that there are supposed to be *some* rules. They still leave plenty of scope for nastiness.

veti Silver badge

When there's an actual shooting war on, the participants should not be expected to hold back. Moderation in war is imbecility.

I assume that the "volunteers" taking their own action to "support" Ukraine in cyberspace - probably, mostly, haven't thought too hard about what they're doing. And governments like Estonia's are too sympathetic to take a strong line with them, but prefer to turn a blind eye.

Yes, I also assume the Russians won't hesitate to cite this as precedent whenever it suits them. But will it make them do anything they wouldn't have done anyway? - that I doubt.

Norms are only norms if they're enforced. Enforcement relies on a network of shared values and mutual goodwill. That doesn't exist in this case.

US car industry leads the world in production cuts over chip shortages

veti Silver badge

Re: to have electric windows and electrically moving seats without needing any chips.

Electric windows have been a feature of cars for more than 50 years. And while there have been a handful of tragic child accidents in that time, there are simple design fixes that can pretty much eliminate the danger.

Most obvious, limit the force applied to the window. Make sure the windows only have power when the ignition is on. And make the control either recessed, or take the form of a switch that has to be pushed up to close the window, down to open it.

None of these things requires a control chip.

Tesla Full Self-Driving fails to notice child-sized objects in testing

veti Silver badge

Re: assumption

Except it wasn't a child. Possibly the car was smart enough to know that.

Short of live testing, ideally using Elon's own kids, I don't know how to resolve that.

Chinese scammers target kids with promise of extra gaming hours

veti Silver badge

China should be an instructive test case for the rest of the world, a demonstration of what can happen if you push Internet regulation to their limit. It would be worth knowing, for reference.

Unfortunately, for it to fulfil that role, we would need to have reports we can trust from inside the system. I don't see any plausible way of getting those.

GitLab versus The Zombie Repos: An old plot needs a new twist

veti Silver badge

I think they'd be fine with that, at least at this point. If you care enough about your repos to do that, then fine, keep them.

But GitLab suspects, and I suspect, that there are a non-trivial number of users who no longer care about their repos at all. Maybe they've got bored and moved on with their lives. Maybe they're dead. Who could tell?

Microsoft tightens Edge security for less visited websites

veti Silver badge

Re: Good for Microsoft

If anything becomes "much harder to use", people will simply switch browsers. It's not 2005 any more, people are aware of the existence of other browsers now.

veti Silver badge

Re: That's a nice little website you have there,

You need a dominant market position to swing that kind of thing. 15 years ago, maybe Microsoft could have pulled off something like that. But now? - the big hit would be on the popularity of their browser, not the website.

veti Silver badge

Re: Please stop saying

According to StatCounter, it's the third most popular browser behind Chrome and Safari - ahead of Firefox, Samsung and Opera.

And please nobody say "people need to use it once to download a proper browser", because that's obvious, hackneyed, silly and untrue. I repeat, Edge gets more day-to-day usage than Firefox. It deserves some respect.

UK wants criminal migrants to scan their faces up to five times a day using a watch

veti Silver badge

Re: Collapse

All I'm saying is, if you can't be bothered to make yourself heard, you shouldn't be too surprised - or indignant - when those who can, get to set the agenda.

But it's your choice. Don't try to tell yourself you're powerless, because there is something you could do. You're choosing not to do it.

veti Silver badge

Re: That word "Justice" ...

You misspelled "victimisation".

Sometimes all that's needed is some group it's OK to be evil to. Being evil to migrants or criminals is controversial. By intersecting the two sets, it doesn't actually become much less so, but it does double the conviction of your own supporters, and that makes it much easier.

veti Silver badge

Re: Coming soon...

Yep. You'd think, for such an application, it would be easier to scan a fingerprint than a face. (Hey, fingerprint scanning is mature technology with way fewer issues than facial recognition.) But that would be to miss an opportunity to develop new tech, doubtless handing contracts to some useful supporters in the process.

veti Silver badge

Re: Collapse

Already done.

veti Silver badge

Re: Collapse

The groups that de facto have power and influence will destroy any movement that works against their interest.

That's clearly not true, or Brexit would never have been contentious. Either it would have died stillborn, or it would have passed overwhelmingly.

Electorally, I recommend picking a party and getting involved in it. For all the talk about "power and influence", "big money", "dark money" etc., there is still real political power to be had by committing actual time. Every party needs people who will do that, and it will generally bend (at least somewhat) to accommodate them.

Nomad to crypto thieves: Please give us back 90%, keep 10% as a reward. Deal?

veti Silver badge

Re: Tax...

The people who get it, obviously. That's their responsibility anyway, nothing changes except that it's 90% less.

Enough with the notifications! Focus Assist will shut them u… 'But I'm too important!'

veti Silver badge

Re: Another great victory for Tim Cook and Jonathan Ive

That's something that can be deliberately configured, but it's not compulsory. Your gripe is with the machine's owner or user, not its maker.

One way Bitcoin miners can make money: Selling electricity back to Texas

veti Silver badge

Re: Nice power grid you got 'ere, Guv

Most bulk buyers of electricity use contracts that specify how much they are going to pay for, each half hour (or whatever period their market uses) of each day. Most electricity generated and sold on the wholesale market is priced this way.

But there's also a spot market, to account for things like weather that can't be predicted with confidence several weeks in advance. The spot market is where the exciting price fluctuations happen. This is the marginal price, and only a small amount of power is actually traded at that price.

When the spot price rises, someone with a contract has the option to cut back their consumption and sell part of their capacity to another buyer (such as ERCOT). That's a private arrangement between the two buyers. It's also not that unusual, and my guess is it's only making news because of the crypto angle.

Pull jet fuel from thin air? We can do that, say scientists

veti Silver badge

Re: At scale??? Yes, easily

I'd like to see how the author came up with that cost estimate. Specifically, how he costed the >200 TWh of storage and the TW-capacity global (i.e. trans-oceanic) transmission grid, and what he has allowed for losses during storage and transmission. And what assumptions he made about the cost of land to put all this infrastructure on. Also the maintenance and depreciation of the solar panels themselves...

Once we've thrashed all that out, we can begin to think about the politics. Which specific Saharan country should be entrusted with producing all the world's energy? How would we ensure that countries couldn't hold a "downstream" country to ransom by threatening to cut its supply?

Once we've answered those, then we can begin thinking about little details like who, specifically, is going to build and run this thing. I can't offhand think of any engineering company that has ever delivered a project of 0.1% of this scale for less than 400% of its original budget.

veti Silver badge

Re: you focus on EVs were you can

How many people drive a car that's more than 25 years old? And how many of those do it because they can't afford anything else? (My experience is that cars get kinda expensive to maintain sometime before that age.)

The plan for the combustion fleet isn't to ban them from the roads, but simply to let them wear out.. What's important is that we stop making new ones.

The US grid is ready for 100% renewables, says DoE

veti Silver badge

I think that is the answer. The idea seems to be for every wind or solar installation above a certain size to have its own dedicated battery (or other storage) backup.

Which sounds expensive to me, but what do I know.

What I'm looking forward to is how the US military is going to zero its carbon emissions by 2050. If they can do it, truly we all can.

Anti-piracy messaging may just encourage more piracy

veti Silver badge

Re: Thanking users who choose legal means to get the desired products for their support

And you are guilty of equally gross exaggeration in the opposite direction.

Typically, something like 15% of the retail price goes to the performers. Then there's the writers, who will also be on a percentage. The shop that sells the CD, if there's physical media, will pocket maybe 40-50% - hey, they have costs y'know. (This is why online distribution is just as popular with the industry as it is with consumers.)

Then the various uncredited session musicians, engineers etc. involved in the production need to be paid. To say nothing of publicity, video production and the other expected expenses of modern music.

Then, if there's anything left over - and by this time there very often isn't - the publisher starts to make a profit. For maybe one song in a thousand, that profit is very handsome - enough to pay for the other 999 songs they need to produce to get lucky.

veti Silver badge

Re: The "poor" victims of piracy

Well, they could show the session musician who played sax on said artist's first hit, who is struggling to pay for his kid's dental care. There are lots of people involved in the music industry, and the great majority of them are far from rich.

China's 7nm chip surprise reveals more than Beijing might like

veti Silver badge

Re: Ours

If greed had not been a factor we'd still be hand painting the walls of our caves. Greed has driven civilisation from the beginning.

Granted, that would be quite environmentally sustainable.

Feds put $10m bounty on Putin pal accused of bankrolling US election troll farm

veti Silver badge

Re: So Donald was right?

No more than usual. And it certainly wasn't "pro-Clinton", otherwise she'd have a way better reputation than she does.

It was certainly "anti-Trump", but Trump himself went to a deal of trouble to make sure of that. The sheer novelty of this approach took most of his opponents by surprise, and enabled him to swing the election. In this he was certainly supported by the Russians, and I'm quite sure they made a difference, but how much is unquantifiable.

veti Silver badge

Hillary was an awful candidate, but I don't think you can claim you weren't warned what Trump would be like.

And, quick reminder - *more* Americans voted for him the second time around. What was their excuse?

veti Silver badge

It's worse than that...

Who informs the public and influences opinions about potential reforms to the law? The media, of course.

Now, who benefits from candidates spending fortunes on ads?

veti Silver badge

Re: Transporting

Unfortunately, current banking sanctions on Russia make it impossible to pay the bounty to anyone in that country.

I wonder if anyone thought this through...?

Tim Hortons offers free coffee and donut to settle data privacy invasion claims

veti Silver badge

Why. RAR, particularly?

Why not .zip or .7z or .gz? Is there something about RAR that makes it particularly suitable?

BOFH: Selling the boss on a crypto startup

veti Silver badge

If someone like Derek was acting like an ally, I for one would be looking very carefully under my car before starting it for the next several weeks.

I paid for it, that makes it mine. Doesn’t it? No – and it never did

veti Silver badge

Since BMWs are only ever bought (new) by fleet buyers, they don't give a toss. The subscription will be budgeted for the three years of the vehicle's life, and after that who gives a shit anyway?

(Secondhand market? Not my department, mate.)

Businesses confess: We pass cyberattack costs onto customers

veti Silver badge

Re: Where else would the money come from?

Because every company operates in a perfectly competitive market with identical products, perfect information for all participants, and zero costs of switching suppliers?

Look, Econ 101 is a decent start, but it's only a start. There's a lot more to be learned after that.

veti Silver badge

Re: A report full of obvious points

The trouble is, that assumes there *is* a better secured competitor.

My experience is that there are lots of small companies all taking a fairly relaxed attitude to security, whose market niches are sufficiently narrow that they only have a handful of competitors - who are similarly relaxed.

And the cost to the customer of switching providers is often quite significant, too. Think data migration. It's not the sort of thing you want to do every year.

So yeah, in theory the company that invested in more security up front has a potential advantage - but then, so does the company that doesn't (because it saves the cost of that investment). And advantage against whom, anyway?

Meta proposes doing away with leap seconds

veti Silver badge

Re: why should our year coincide with the Earth’s orbit around the Sun.

Approximately half the world uses various kinds of lunar calendars, and they manage somehow.

Infosec not your job but your responsibility? How to be smarter than the average bear

veti Silver badge

Re: Be careful with that bold statement

OK, I went to the trouble of reading that whole slab of debate. It clearly shows that all parties are well aware that the snooping powers will be available to a wide range of people for a wide range of purposes. That much is not even questioned. So I'm not sure what specific lying assurances you're trying to draw my attention to.

veti Silver badge

Re: Be careful with that bold statement

RIPA stands for "Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act". It does what it says on the tin - it sets out a framework of rules that public agencies are expected to conform to, and mechanisms for ensuring that they do it.

It was only ever about "terrorism" in so far as that was the current buzzword when the act was being passed. The Home Office and other usual suspects lobbied aggressively that these snooping powers would help deal with terrorism - and as far as it goes, this was true. But no-one ever claimed that this was the only possible or permissible application.

My smartphone has wiped my microSD card again: Is it a conspiracy?

veti Silver badge

How many home owners have their own cameras?

The oft-quoted figure for the UK included cameras set up, owned and monitored solely by property owners and shopkeepers. An equivalent figure in the US would have to include all of those, plus police bodycams, car dashcams, every visual sensor set up anywhere by anyone to monitor anything. Are you *sure* there aren't that many?

veti Silver badge

1999 called, it wants its statistics back...

Britain was a pioneer in widespread CCTV, but it hasn't held its position. The Chinese have more cameras, and no one even knows how many the Americans have.

Russian ChessBot breaks child opponent's finger

veti Silver badge

Re: Questionable Explanation

I can think of no good reason why a chessbot needs to be able to grab anything at all.

If I were designing it, it would work by moving magnets around beneath the board.

China seems to have figured out how to make 7nm chips despite US sanctions

veti Silver badge

Re: Chess.

Biden didn't "reverse" anything. He just dithered, which in practice turned out to be not very different from Trump's vacillating.

Decent summary here.

Biden is decent, but not smart. Trump is smart, but also the biggest crook in America. Of the two I would still take Biden, but I'd want a better choice.

British intelligence recycles old argument for thwarting strong encryption: Think of the children!

veti Silver badge

I always have the same response when this nonsense comes up. "If you think I've been trafficking in this material, send a goon squad to sieze my hardware. Once you've got it, you should be able to decipher anything on it. That's fair enough, it's no different from what governments have been doing for centuries.

"If, on the other hand, you don't have any evidence to back up a warrant for that, then GTFO. Your suggestion is to drastically reduce the barriers and costs of snooping on me, and I see absolutely no reason why any person of goodwill should support it."

veti Silver badge

Re: Quite apart from online...

"The best argument against democracy is a five minute conversation with the average voter." - Winston Churchill.

If you think politicians are bad, I can only assume you never talk about politics to strangers. You would not believe what some people believe.

Microsoft to blockheads: NFTs and blockchains aren't welcome in Minecraft

veti Silver badge

I am not nearly as pleased as some commentards about this story. The reason being, Mojang has conspicuously left the door open to change its policy later, which I interpret as "when they've figured out how to make money from it."

I enjoy playing Minecraft with my kids. Would hate to see it being monetised.

Intel, other chipmakers boost lobbying spend to get CHIPS Act passed

veti Silver badge

Re: How Much ?

The subsidy isn't all for Intel, it'll be shared several ways. And remember it has to be spent. And it has to be spent in an economically suboptimal way. And this is only one quarter's spending.

Security flaws in GPS trackers can be abused to cut off fuel to vehicles, CISA warns

veti Silver badge

Re: How GPS works - but not GPS DEvices

all cars now have ecall trackers and mobile connection builtin

Citation needed. My car doesn't.

Now what is that they say about no cars allowed at weekends

I have no idea, what do "they" say about it? Nobody - literally not one person - has said it to me, whatever it is.

Funny that no-one was allowed any say in this

Any say in what, exactly? Please be more specific and include citations in your paranoid ranting, then at least we'll know what you're talking about.

India's central bank calls for cryptocurrency ban

veti Silver badge

Look up "legal tender".

If I owe you $1000, and I give you 10 (genuine, central bank issue) $100 notes, my debt to you is paid. You can't demand some other form of payment and get a court to enforce it. If you can't handle the cash, that's entirely your problem.

(There is a grey area around contracts that stipulate a specific method of payment, but that's contract law, which is always stupid.)

The bank takes cash. Your utility providers take it. The tax office takes it. You want to clear a debt, cash works. Always.

Crypto - doesn't.

Crypto miners aren't honest about power use – time for a crackdown

veti Silver badge

Re: Google

If you can think of a fair way to make that comparison without accurate figures for either side of the calculation, then go right ahead.

Or are you just whatabouting?

If Google stopped serving ads, can you suggest how else you would like to pay for its services?

Being declared dead is automated, so why is resurrection such a nightmare?

veti Silver badge


Before attempting to answer that, could you please clarify what you mean by "fair"?

Get over it: Microsoft is a Linux and open source company these days

veti Silver badge

Re: Mostly agree

Well yes, of course you can, in the same way as you can warm your home with a burning oil drum in the living room.

Bloody stupid thing to do, though.

veti Silver badge

If you had hundreds of millions of users worldwide, and developed a new platform that makes it far easier (from your point of view) to maintain and secure your applications and your customers' data - wouldn't you be doing everything you can think of to persuade them to move over?

No matter what MS does, there will be some people saying it hasn't changed. It's easy to interpret someone's actions in the worst possible way, if that's what you've been training yourself to do for 30 years.


Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2022