The Register Home Page

* Posts by ChrisC

1643 publicly visible posts • joined 2 Jul 2009

Memory makers mint megabucks while buyers beg for mercy

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: not just RAM

They're not all the same type of memory though - flash memory (and the SSDs, memory cards etc. which use it) is more akin to spinny rust, in providing a means to store data for extended periods of time. Which is what AI bitbarns also need to do - no good them just having gobs of DRAM available to run their models if they don't have anywhere to store all of the data the models need - hence why storage is also seeing price increases and reduced supply.

And that's a key, yet frustratingly largely overlooked by the general media, problem being caused by the AI hype machine - whilst pretty much all the headlines are focussed on how detrimental it is for DRAM pricing/availability, the true impact spreads much further across the wider electronics industry, and the corresponding impact on manufacturers is similarly much broader than might be imagined if all you're doing is thinking along the lines that "AI is pushing up the price of high spec DRAM". The increased cost of adding an extra stick of DDR5 to your PC is merely the most obvious effect to the general public, it's absolutely not the only such effect.

Landline phones will switch off across Britland in 100 days, no extensions – Openreach

ChrisC Silver badge

If you're worried about someone flipping the wrong switch (or flipping the right one, just without the necessary authority to be doing so), then maintaining the copper lines *in their current state* would be almost pointless, because once you get beyond your local old-school analogue loop (i.e. the bit of copper between your premises and the exchange), the entire network is digital anyway, and has been to some extent for decades.

So removing these last mile remnants of copper is the final step in modernising the phone network, it's not the initial step which could therefore be easily abandoned leaving the networks behaving just like they did back in the days of the GPO.

'Let's just shove a bigger fan in there and see what happens'

ChrisC Silver badge

Back in the days when my Amiga was still my primary workhorse for both serious and entertainment tasks, I ended up cramming my desktop A4000 with so many expansion cards and drives, that the already limited amount of airflow through the case generated by the single fan within the PSU was proving insufficient.

Solution - a trip to Maplins to pick up a few PC fans and an adapter cable so they could all be powered from the one spare molex power connector in the system. As the A4000 wasn't designed with additional fans in mind, all of these additions were then simply held in place by whatever means worked - e.g. gaffa taping one of them to the sidewall of the case to generate airflow across one area of the innards, and discovering that blu-tack maintains its tackiness and vibration absorbing capabilities for quite some time within the warm and dusty confines of a hard-working Amiga, holding another fan nicely in place closer to one particularly warm IC, whilst still allowing it to be easily moved out of the way whenever performing system maintenance (such as cramming in yet another card, just to make sure there literally was no wasted expansion capability, or airflow capacity, by the time I'd finished throwing money at the beast)...

iFixit dismantles Apple's Duo: 'You'd better baby that screen'

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: I want to like folding phones...

i wrote swathes of HTML and javascript on my HTC Universal back in the day - absolutely loved the form factor that offered, with its ability to switch between PDA and laptop modes of operation, and it's one of the few phones I've owned that I was genuinely upset to have to replace after it finally succumbed to wear and tear and old age.

Windows said modem worked fine. That unmistakable scorched electronics smell suggested otherwise

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: Ahh, nothing like the smell of blown electronics in the morning..

So by the sounds of your opening comments, you were opposed to the idea of running the course because it was a waste of time, superfluous to needs or some similar reason. And yet, as you then go onto note, every time you ran the course, at least one of the participants proved beyond any doubt that it was anything but a waste of time...

Because regardless of *why* the mains voltage switch had been incorrectly set, making sure it was correctly set before *you* apply power for the first time was an utterly essential lesson to have learned back in those days before auto-ranging PSUs became the norm.

So better for these students to have learned that lesson, either first hand through having been the ones caught out, or second hand thanks to simply being in the same room as someone else who had learned it first hand, in the controlled confines of a lab session, rather than the hard way when building their first real system... And for those who already knew, or at least thought they knew, it, having a reminder as to why it's a lesson they don't want to be forgetting would also have been beneficial.

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: Has Windows failed to find an obvious fault?

Generally speaking, equipment that has sacrificial parts like this would also be designed to detect, in *some* way, that the sacrifice had been made.

It might not be able to differentiate between the different reasons as to why it's now seeing these fault symptoms, but in this sort of example the "hmm, modem is saying there's no phone line connection" feedback from the device would complement the human troubleshooting steps - "well, the cable is definitely plugged in at both ends", "swapping the cable doesn't clear the fault", "a phone plugged into the same socket gives me a dial tone" etc - to allow you to come to the inevitable conclusion that the fault lies somewhere within the modem itself, without the need to crack open the case and be able to identify that something inside has indeed paid the price of protecting the PC it was connected to.

Whilst it would be nice to be able to narrow down faults more precisely to help accelerate the troubleshooting process, if it's outside the scope of the design requirements[1] or is something that's difficult/costly to achieve because of where said fault occurs within the system[2], then you're probably relying on the more generic "there's a fault *somewhere* in this general part of the system" type of feedback that's easier to provide.

1: likely not the case for high reliability/safety-critical systems, or anything else for which the related certification standards say you damn well have to do it, but for a consumer-grade, designed down to a cost target, device, likely yes.

2: e.g. in this example, the sacrificial component was likely on the line side of the modem electronics, so any ability to sense its state would need to cross the isolation barrier between line side and host side electronics, making it less easy than simply wiring in a spare I/O line between the sensing element and the modem controller.

Tiny11 puts Windows 11 on a diet without the PowerShell workout

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: Tiny 11 very much like what Microsoft claims to be building

Not sure hiring them would be the answer MS are looking for, because MS's goal here is simply to allow 11 to run sufficiently well on 8GB systems, whereas Tiny 11 and similar tools achieve that as a side effect of their *actual* goals - namely stripping out all the shit that MS very much DO still want to be retained on every installation, and leaving just the core functionality required to deliver a functioning OS environment within which WE, the system owners, can run the stuff WE need to run on our systems, without all of that MS-mandated crap clogging things up in the background...

I mean, I'm entirely willing to be proven wrong here by MS, and it'd be a pleasant surprise if their in-house efforts to debloat 11 actually do result in something that genuinely is debloated as opposed to something that simply uses less RAM, but I'm not holding my breath here. IMO, the only reason MS are putting any effort into this is because people genuinely can't afford to spec systems with enough RAM these days to run 11 comfortably, and MS don't want to take the risk of them being lured over the fence into the Linux world by all the promises of "we're leaner and meaner and can run all the stuff you actually need to run these days without you having to spend any more money on hardware, give us a try, pleeeeeeeeeeeeeeease", discovering that, actually, life is pretty good over there, and never coming back.

Trump Mobile customers' data dumped - and some never even received their gold device

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: That's a new low...

Oh for a return to those halcyon days of Presidents actually being Presidential and, occasional gaffes, fluffs and other blunders aside, could reasonably be considered to be acting in the best interests of the USA.

Spies, prime ministers, and balls: The BBC Domesday project @ 40

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: Why do they need to preserve it?

Dismissing the original physical medium used to deliver that data, with all of its unique tactile sensations as you interact with the data in ways that can't be fully appreciated when said data is delivered to you in other ways, is missing the point of what's valuable here. Because sure, the data is valuable, but so is the way in which we interact with it. Either because it's such an inherent part of the process that, to do so in any other way just feels meh (e.g. reading an actual book vs reading the exact same information on a screen), or because of whatever significance it has historically, technically etc.

So in this case, given how bespoke the Domesday Project hardware and software was, and how big a deal it was in the context of the UK's computing heritage, I'd say we damn well do need to preserve not only the data but also examples of the actual systems themselves.

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: What did they 'get wrong' with using a trackball?

The worst mouse I've ever had the misfortune of using was the one HP shipped with their unix workstations in the early 90s - a low profile rectangular body housing the buttons and cable entry, with a big semicircular blob slapped on top housing the ball mechanism, onto which you had to then perch your hand whilst arching your fingers down, unsupported, towards the buttons... I can feel my right hand cramping up in pain just at the merest thought of that ergonomic disaster.

In contrast, those earlier efforts from AMX (both the BBC one shown in that YT link, and the slightly later version I had for my Spectrum) were pretty decent, especially given the limitations of the systems they were connected to, and did a good job of giving their users a leg up on preparing for the decades of mouse-dominated UIs that were to follow. Plus, for the Spectrum version at least, the software that came with it was also rather good fun to mess around with - AMX Art got me nicely warmed up to the idea of bitmap art before I got my first Amiga and access to all the art tools it had to offer, and the BASIC extension they supplied to enable us to write our own mouse-driven programs helped get me even more interested in coding than I'd already become.

Coming back to the overall subject of this article though, I'm having some mixed feelings about all of these 40th anniversary reports for things I still remember as clear as day from my childhood, because on the one hand it's nice to be able to sit back and reminisce a little with like minded folks, but on the other hand it really starts to hammer home just how much time has passed since those childhood years...

Starship finally makes orbit but engine trouble cuts the victory lap short

ChrisC Silver badge

"When one of the Raptors shut down early, the remaining five burned longer to compensate. That wasn't to ensure Starship would return to Earth. It was to get it to the velocity and trajectory they had originally intended at engine cutoff. If anything, failing to make up the lost velocity would have caused it to come down sooner, not remain in space."

Reading that part of the launch coverage reporting at the time immediately brought to mind Apollo 13 and its similar extended ascent burn times to compensate for a lost engine, and is a good reminder that at least some of the issues SpaceX are having with Starship are the sort of things that have happened before and will happen again (at least for any design using multiple engines), so they're less of a "hah, SpaceX don't know what they're doing" gotcha as some will be only too quick to pounce on, and more of a "this isn't easy, because this really IS rocket science..."

Astronomer watches Starlink satellites sinking to build a ‘planetary barometer’

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: AI Paper Writing

Having seen AI "detectors" confidently disagree by quite significant amounts as to the provenance of the exact same document, my opinion of such tools is almost on a par with my opinion of AI itself...

Boss bought cheap 'printer' from a catalog and was left without a leg to stand on

ChrisC Silver badge
Coat

Re: Shocking…

"Delegation, delegation, delegation, that's what you need

If you wanna lead the team

If management's your dream

Oh oh delegations what you need..."

With heartfelt apologies to the late great Roy Castle, and all those who have happy childhood memories of hearing the original at the end of Record Breakers

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: Don't even mention RS

At least once you've ascertained that RS do have it in stock at a local site, you're still pretty much guaranteed to then get it next day.

Farnell always *used* to be similarly predictable, and their generally better pricing and wider range meant for years they were our preferred supplier for development parts/tools/etc. with RS only being used if absolutely necessary. Over the past year or so however, their "next day" service seems to have quietly transmogrified into "next day after we can be bothered to move it from our warehouse into the dispatch bay and book a collection", which means now typically waiting 3-4 working days before stuff arrives, resulting in RS now picking up the bulk of our business...

Microsoft configuration change leaves SharePoint pages drawing a blank

ChrisC Silver badge

IME, Sharepoint feels like an attempt to implement security through obscurity, by making it so difficult to find anything once it's been committed to the great melting pot of files that we know were moved *somewhere*, so having it then refuse to serve up a file if you actually manage to find its location would then merely be a further layer of security to ensure no-one can ever access your precious data, no matter whether or not they're actually supposed to be able to do so...

I mean, at a theoretical level, I understand why it's so useful to have a single point of reference that the entire team can use when working on anything which reasonably does need to be treated as a shared resource, but at the practical implementation level, as with pretty much everything MS has touched since Gates/Ballmer passed on the leadership batons, what we've actually been given to provide this desirable functionality leaves a LOT to be desired.

For all the faults of MS of old had at a corporate level, we could at least rely on them to deliver products which generally worked well enough. These days we don't even get that out of them, so their continued stranglehold over the corporate desktop environment gets ever more baffling as time passes without any indication they have any sort of a plan to stop releasing utter shit which makes the lives of end users an absolute misery.

Part didn't fit so techie got out his screwdriver. Then something flew off the motherboard

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: How on earth does a HEATSINK have an active compent…

"Only takes a slight slip of a screwdriver to chisel bits off the motherboard..."

Or, for CPUs without heat spreader plates, bits of the CPU itself... Fitting a heatsink to a CPU with such a naked die was always a fraught process, especially given that some of the creaking and cracking noises coming from the mechanical parts of the process sounded *very* much like the noises you might expect to hear coming from a piece of silicon that was in the process of, or already succumbed to, being snapped in half by the stresses being applied to it.

Always disliked having to fit heatsinks where the design of the clamping/retention mechanism made it difficult to avoid applying, even briefly, any sort of asymmetric force to the CPU. Bad enough that it could mess up your neatly applied thermal compound, but when there was also the risk of trashing several hundred quids-worth of shiny new CPU in the process... One of the things I most appreciated about the i7 system I built a few years ago was the way the heatsink was attached via individual spring-loaded push pins on each corner - that thing was *so* easy to fit, it was one of those genuine "why didn't someone come up with this design yonks ago?" moments when I first experienced it.

Trump sends the US Navy back to the steam age

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: Very wierd design choice

The QE class was designed to meet the requirements of the RN. The same RN who'd spent the past 40-odd years gaining first hand experience of both peace and wartime VSTOL operations from flat tops, and who therefore might be reasonably expected to have at least some level of clue as to what works and what doesn't work...

So if they felt that larger decks would make for a better operating experience, who are we to argue? There may well be a bit of willy-waving at play here in wanting to have some big capital ships again to impress their counterparts around the world, but there's enough evidence publically available to suggest that the larger deck area and other aspects of their generously proportioned design genuinely DOES make a positive difference to operations, such that criticising them as being even just way, let alone way, way, oversized, is almost certainly well wide of the mark.

ChrisC Silver badge

I'd accept the B being classed as having lower capability (if VSTOL capability itself isn't deemed important in its own right) than the A or C variants, perhaps, but to dismiss it as merely being of low capability in general reeks of a negatively biased assessment. Is it perfect? No. Is it exactly what we need and ought therefore to have invested such significant sums of money in buying and supporting? Debateable. Is it low in capability? Absolutely not.

Similarly, useless? No.

Airbus keeps an A350 flying for 24 hours

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: Noise cancelling headphones

Or a set of earbuds that do a good enough job of muting the outside world, combined with a suitably soothing set of podcasts or other audio sources, AND making use of the provided blanket to cocoon oneself away from the small but annoying changes in localised air temperatures within your part of the cabin, which (for me at least) make it bloody difficult to properly relax/fall asleep.

Or, if you actually want to remain awake without being bored senseless, then a tablet loaded with stuff you'd happily watch/read/play, to keep your brain engaged and blissfully ignorant of the passage of time, without the need to find anything of interest on the IFE system.

But above all, pay whatever you have to pay in order to secure yourself a seat you know you'll be comfortable in, because if you can't get properly comfortable, then even the shortest of flights will very, VERY, quickly become an unpleasant experience.

Cassette simulator rewinds digital audio to a more analog time in hiss-tory

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: Why?

Same reason some people pour inordinate amounts of time and effort into doing stuff like designing video filters to make your pristine LCD, with its perfect geometry, solid expanses of colour etc, look like a cheap 14" portable TV - sometimes perfection *isn't* what you want, sometimes what you really want is to replicate all of the flaws of the original medium as closely as possible, in order to give a more authentic experience of using it.

Whether this is being done for educational purposes, to give a more accurate representation as part of a media production, or just out of a desire to relive the good old days, it doesn't really matter - what matters is that there *are* good reasons for wanting to do so.

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: Up next: A text editor spell check that can make you sound functionally illiterate

it's called nostalgia. Progress is good, but sometimes it's nice to take a step back along your personal timeline and remind yourself of how things used to be. Whether it's the taste of a childhood food favourite, the sound of a tape slotting into place or a floppy drive head moving from track to track, the smell of a warm CRT, anything that can, even momentarily, give your subconscious enough of a kick to unlock a flood of memories, is something to be cherished, not dismissed so glibly as crap.

Tech support chap told angry customer to think inside the box – and solved the problem

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: "when many phones still had removable batteries"

Ah yes, the "form over function" problem that plagues so many aspects of modern life, and where those in the position of authority to make the decision are, far too often, biased in favour of the "form" answer because they don't get to then suffer from the resultant lack of "function" their decisions have created, unlike all of the poor minions under their control who just have to deal with it as best they can...

Software bloat? This elevator needs an 8 GB Core i5

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: I would be taking the stairs

Given that displays like this will play at best a minimal role in providing core functionality of the lift (i.e. at most, they might be used to provide the audible and visible indication of which floor the lift is on/heading to), with all of the serious stuff required to ensure the lift actually does function correctly and safely being handled by devices with far more attention paid to their design re reliability/stability/etc, then my only reaction to seeing this might be a raised eyebrow or a wry smile, as I happily used said lift to convey me to my chosen destination. It's no more of a safety issue than, say, having the in flight entertainment system reboot mid-flight. or having your car stereo lock up during a drive. Inconvenient, perhaps, unsafe, no.

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: Principles (again)

"This is a screen in a lift. It will be showing only a select number of images that the owner/operator of the screen wants it to show"

Not always - one of the reasons we're seeing larger/higher quality displays appearing in lifts is precisely because the building owners want to push multimedia to lift passengers, so the idea that a screen (and the backend system driving it) like the one in this article would be ticking over on idle power just cycling through a handful of carefully curated still images is somewhat outdated.

e.g. https://www.dewhurst-global.com/emea/product-category/displays-directional-indicators/multimedia/

AI slop writing has taken over the internet, particularly LinkedIn and X

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: AI detection seller detects AI everywhere?

This isn't caring, it's rejoicing with style...

OK, so I guess I *would* care about it in *that* sense, just not in the "oh no, poor AI, sorrows sorrows prayers" sense ;-)

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: AI detection seller detects AI everywhere?

Yup. Almost cost our son his chance to complete this years college course, because every time he submitted his final written report it kept being flagged as AI. Although they didn't actually tell him this at the time, they simply kept rejecting each version and asking for a rewrite.

Fortunately, after the 3rd or 4th (we lost count) such attempt to submit as normal, they then asked him to come into the college in person and verbally create another report, answering questions on the fly in the process to determine his true knowledge of the subject, by dictating it into a college PC to be transcribed into text for analysis. Even THIS version of the report still tripped their AI detector, however as they now had cast iron proof that it HAD been written by him with no outside assistance, they finally had to admit that his work was simply at a level far enough above what they were expecting from students at his stage of the course, and therefore above whatever trigger threshold they'd set for the AI detector, and that this was also the reason why all of the previously submitted versions of the report had also been rejected...

My opinion of the mindless dive into adopting AI everywhere it possibly can be adopted, some places you wouldn't expect it to be, and some where it absolutely should never EVER be used, was pretty low even before this, so this personal example of how AI itself can not only get things badly wrong, but also how the blind acceptance of AI answers by people who ought to know better then makes it harder for the genuinely aggrieved to get the correct result at the end of the day, was just the very sour tasting cherry atop the rancid cream cake of AI sloppery.

Like any tool, AI *can* be useful, but only when wielded with care and thought, and only as part of a wider array of tools and techniques. Blind acceptance of it is a mugs game, and anyone who chooses to embrace AI so wholeheartedly is someone to treat with the utmost of caution. Especially if they hold any sort of power over your personal or professional life.

If I woke up tomorrow and learned that AI had ceased to exist overnight, never to return in any way, shape or form, I genuinely wouldn't care, and I'm struggling to think of any other technology where I'd be able to say the same thing.

Ex-NASA boss points out small flaw in Moon landing plan: No lander

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: unclear deterrent

"These nukes can't be launched unless the USA gives its permission to use them."

https://www.chathamhouse.org/2025/03/uks-nuclear-deterrent-relies-us-support-there-are-no-other-easy-alternatives

"In day-to-day operations, the UK’s Trident programme is completely independent from the US. The British Prime Minister can launch the missiles without any external input."

Other credible reference sources are available which will say the same thing, so I suspect your assertion that we can't launch unless the US gives us the nod is based on ignoring these sources and relying on those which are rather less credible...

"An adversary carried out attacks with chemical weapons on UK soil - clear violations of international law. The allegedly independent nuclear deterrent deterred nobody."

That's really not the purpose of a nuclear deterrent though, is it...

"BTW Ukraine's capability to destroy Russian oil refineries and pipeline infrastructure wasn't much of a deterrent when Putin decided to invade."

What capability do you think Ukraine possessed at the start of the 3 day SMO which might have acted as a deterrent? Their ability to NOW wreak havoc almost unchecked on targets increasingly deep into Russia is something that's been developed as a result of the war, it wasn't something they already possessed beforehand.

GitHub cuts short offer to burn repos on CD after mockery ensues

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: Physical media has benefits.

"I have software on floppies, CDs and DVDs that I can load and run from decades ago."

All well and good right up to the point where completing the installation of said software requires it to phone home to a server to authorise the install in some way, or to enable use of the software (e.g. games which in theory could be played entirely offline, but which still need to check in with an active server for updates etc, and which are therefore rendered useless the second said server is EOLd)... The key point here isn't so much the method by which the necessary data reaches your system, it's whether you can then make use of it without the need for any further assistance from the original provider.

So physical originals or backups are a good idea, sure, but ensuring access to the files is increasingly only part of the problem we've been starting to face for some time now, and which will only get worse as more companies rely in some way on server-side tie-ins.

NASA unsure Boeing Starliner will ever be certified for human flight

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: Vostok 1

"The US has successfully flown four different crew capsules"

Orion makes it five...

DRAM it! Cheap PCs being priced out of existence as memory cost bites

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: My suggestion being implemented?

"My ISP is rolling out 2.3Gbps internet for £25/month. 2Gbps! Faster than a HDD! Who besides a server host could possibly need that eh? 20 years ago 2Gbps was the backbone for my entire university, and that was considered fast."

20 years ago we still bought games, music, video etc on physical media. 20 years ago our digital cameras weren't routinely generating GB's of image/video data during a single shooting session. 20 years ago we weren't having to download GB's of patch data for stuff we already had installed on our systems (and 20 years ago, the definition of "systems" in this context was rather less expansive). 20 years ago, the average user didn't need that sort of bandwidth, because the average user didn't have a use for it.

It was 26 years ago when I got my first home broadband connection, a 512Kbps ADSL link, which was genuinely more than fast enough for my needs at the time. These days I wouldn't even bother trying to get online if I knew my connection was that severely constrained, because it'd be an exercise in extreme patience and ultimately futility in trying to achieve anything of use.

Times have changed...

Sysadmin broke hardware worth more than he made in a month – and lied his way out of the mess

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: fix was to turn them upside down and drop them

Thanks for the first hand experience clarification - I couldn't quickly find any references to it online, and it's been so long since I last heard the story, I honestly wasn't even sure if my memory was just playing tricks on me and it was nothing more than something I'd imagined...

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: Sticky Bits

"I had to reluctantly retire the Amiga as they went out of fashion"

They may have gone into hibernation for a bit, but they've never really gone out of fashion, at least not with those of us who were either big Amiga users back in the day, or who now want to experience what a well designed retro system is like...

Whilst this now sounds more like an urban legend rather than a true story, back in those days I recall talk that some Amigas would be DOA because their socketed custom chips had been shaken slightly loose due to speed bumps on the road leading away from the Westchester loading dock, and the fix was to turn them upside down and drop them, to encourage the chips back into place.

Former Microsoft engineer shrinks Notepad down to size

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: PFE

An elegant weapon for a more civilised age...

Boffins build a better pixel capable of emitting and receiving light

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: HP-35?

Yeah, having used the same technique some years ago (though not *quite* as far back as HP were doing it) to use a LCD backlight as an ambient light sensor in the "off" periods within the PWM switching cycle that controlled its brightness, in order to adjust said brightness, I was struck by the opening "Traditional pixels generally do one or the other – illuminating a display screen or capturing light in a camera sensor" comment as sounding like a massive oversimplification...

...though admittedly, as this then made me all the more curious to read on and see what the researchers actually HAD come up with, I guess it served its purpose to lure me in, like every good tabloid headline/intro paragraph these days.

O2 joins UK 2G switch-off with summer 2029 start date

ChrisC Silver badge

"in a couple of years we'll start to see the consequence of battery powered smart gas meters stopping the supply of gas (when the battery fails they disconnect supply: far better that consumers should freeze than the industry lose a few quid of revenue)."

Citation please - various searches have failed to elicit any results indicating this being one of the effects of a gas smart meter battery failing, and instead elicited several results indicating gas supply would be maintained...

Microsoft Access finally breaks free of its 22-inch form limit

ChrisC Silver badge

"The 640 x 480 pixels of the Video Graphics Array (VGA) standard might be scoffed at by modern engineers"

And yet, fire up an emulation/virtualisation environment running an older system with that sort of resolution, and more often than not it *won't* feel anything like as cramped as the numbers suggest - yes, we have larger screens running at higher resolutions, but as with memory, drive space and CPU cycles, the software of today has simply bloated out to fill the available capacity whilst offering little in return.

When you *had* to squeeze your UI into 640x480 (or even lower if we're going a bit further back in time), you made damn sure that every last pixel was put to good use. Blank space was wasted space, so there was little or no thought given to making the UI look like a graphic designers dream - function over form every single time.

I think back to how much work I was able to get done on a single 14" screen running Workbench at 640x256, and I think about how much time these days I spend juggling windows across dual 24" 1920x1200 displays, and I realise just how much I miss those good old days of personal computing...

Transport for London keeps Capita behind wheel of road charging ops in £912M extension

ChrisC Silver badge

That might justify the continued existence of the CCZ and, to a lesser extent, the newly introduced tunnel charges, though even then the question is still entirely relevant - just how keen are TfL to *actually* reduce congestion, vs making use of its ongoing existence as a revenue stream.

It's however not an argument for maintaining *all* of the road user charging schemes currently in operation, because they're not all aimed at reducing congestion in those parts of Greater London where congestion actually is a problem, nor is it an argument as to why such charging schemes are treated as the *only* means to address the problem.

ChrisC Silver badge

In order for TfL to merely break even here, these road user charging schemes have to bring in an average of £182 million every year for the next 5 years.

So either they expect to still be raking in a *lot* of standard daily charges, or not quite as many but still what ought to be considered an unacceptably high number of penalty charges, across all of these schemes, which begs the question as to just how interested they actually are in encouraging drivers to change their behaviours in order to avoid having to pay these charges/penalties in the first place...

Windows devs rerolled old code to save precious bytes

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: Compact code

"The days when literally every byte counted"

Those days have never gone away for people still working in the embedded systems area - a decade after your anecdote took place, I was tasked with completing a design based around a controller with 1KB of program memory, and even just a few months ago I was working on a design with a relatively paltry 16KB.

Feds freaked over Fable 5 after simple 'fix this code' prompt, not jailbreak, says researcher

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: "I gave Fable a very well written and working function and asked it to improve it."

"well written" != "perfect"

Also, even if it genuinely was perfect, with no possible means by which it could be improved by so much as the slenderest of margins, then merely asking for an intelligence (whether real or artificial) to improve it SHOULD have resulted in an answer along the lines of "I'm sorry Dave, I'm afraid I can't do that", though preferably without the murderous undertones...

What it absolutely SHOULD NOT have resulted in was said intelligence adopting an illogical interpretation of "improve" which led to the modified version performing, even by so much as the slenderest of margins, any less effectively than the original. Because that really isn't an improvement, no matter which way you try and sell it.

Chinese e-tailer claimed 14-inch box stretched the size of a 9-inch tablet

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: Whoops wrong size

Indeed, and the marketing division of Dolman Saxlil thanks you for your efforts in promoting the company ethos in this sector of the galaxy, your reward voucher is winging its way to you now via the sub-ether net...

Trump phone has HTC guts. Tremendous guts. The best guts

ChrisC Silver badge

Less the name per se, more the fact that the name is being used in this way whilst he's still el Presidente.

If he'd still just been a reality TV show host and occasionally successful businessman, choosing to slap his name across everything like this in order to extract more cash from the gullible, then so be it. But to be doing so, knowing full well that his name currently has even more sway/power/whatever you choose to call it because of his privileged position at the top seat of US government, THAT'S the real problem IMO. He's cashing in whilst *still* in office, rather than having the decency to at least wait until his term ends before raking it in based on the still lucrative position of being a former President.

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: Be seen in public with it

As is your take on the previous comment, because it doesn't make any reference to men *wearing* gold, so could just as easily be interpreted as referring to men *using* gold things, such as the tacky phone under discussion here...

That an app 'Fits on a Floppy' is still a useful measure in 2026

ChrisC Silver badge

"if you impose an artificial limit on project size"

For those of us working in sectors where these limits are entirely real, and where failing to adhere to them means your code literally cannot run at all, so much of the sentiment here isn't just wistful longing for the good old days, it remains an utterly integral and essential part of our everyday lives.

Right now I have the relative luxury of developing code to run on an ARM core microcontroller with a positively expansive 512KB of non-volatile storage, and an equally impressive 128KB of SRAM. By the standards even of an old school PC, such figures would sound laughably small, yet this is a far from atypical level of memory/storage resource limits that modern embedded systems developers work with. And note how I've described this particular device as being quite spacious, because compared with many of the other devices also currently available, it genuinely is. Another project I'm currently involved with uses a device with 16KB storage/2KB SRAM, and even that is an order of magnitude bigger than the most constrained of devices I've worked with so far.

So yes, as someone who not only remembers how efficient old school desktop code used to be across the myriad of systems I had experience with back then, but who is constantly reminded how much can *still* be done with some efficiently written code, I'm absolutely onboard with any and all criticism of how little effort is now paid to writing stuff that takes full advantage of the hardware capabilities for the good of the end user, as opposed to taking full advantage of it for the benefit of the coder - i.e. allowing them to write underoptimised crap that only runs as adequately as it does because of how much raw power the host system is able to throw at it.

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: Obviously too old

Also an early example of a fidget toy - held between thumb and middle finger, leaving the side of the shutter nicely within reach of my index finger, allowing it to be slid open and then let it go with a satisfying click, to be repeated as often as required during a late night coding session in front of my Amiga...

I'm convinced all the various sensory feedback (the sounds, the tactile sensations, even occasionally the smells) provided by these earlier systems is one of the reasons why we now look back on them so fondly in comparison to the rather more sterile and anonymous systems we have these days. I mean, sure, I love the performance improvements things like SSDs have brought to the table, but I also find myself sometimes missing the way my older HDD based systems would sound and feel depending on what level of drive activity was taking place, and as for the very satisfying sensation of pushing a floppy or Zip disc into the drive slot, or a cassette into a tape deck, nothing about a modern system comes even remotely close.

UK Typhoon jets fitted with bargain-bin drone busters for Middle East sorties

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: I have a better idea

The problem for the Ukranians is that the present incumbent of the Kremlin (or wherever it is he currently chooses to hide out) seems entirely disinterested in allowing Ukraine to remain an independent nation no matter how neutral it might be, and has made it pretty damned clear he wants to bring it back into the welcoming arms of the motherland as part of Russia itself, because he's never regarded it as ever being a truly independent nation in the first place.

So if you think for a nanosecond that, were Ukraine to sign a cast iron agreement to never ever join NATO, the EU, or any other organisation that so much as gives off the merest whiff of being anti-Russia, and promises to remain entirely neutral until the end of all eternity, that this would suffice Putrid and he'd withdraw his forces leaving Ukraine well alone for a similarly lengthy period of time, then I'd urge you to think again, and keep on doing so until you realise just how utterly unlikely such an uneventful outcome would actually be.

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: I have a better idea

2018 is in with a good shout here, when your bestie in the Kremlin decided to deploy nerve agents in public areas... It might have been a quite targeted attack intended only to target one specific individual, but between the fact that using chemical weapons is abhorrent in its own right, and the fact that the haphazard way in which they were used meant an entirely innocent person lost their life, it very much WAS considered a hostile act against the UK generally, and one which likely played a part in how willing we were to support Ukraine in the early days when so many other nations were dithering around.

But on the other hand, the lack of any larger scale attacks against us isn't necessarily the smoking gun you're making it out to be - is that lack of attacks because no-one really wants to attack us, and therefore our defensive expenditure has been a complete waste of money, or is it because we HAVE spent so much on making ourselves a less desirable target...

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: I have a better idea

The threat to the land based nuclear deterrent was the driving factor in the development of ballistic missile submarines, which Russia has several of in active service - it's *those* which are now responsible for maintaining the MAD concept, because unless you do something remarkably stupid whilst operating them, or unless your enemies have managed to come up with a way to reliably track them at all times such that, in the event of said enemies wanting to initiate a first strike against you, they'd also be able to guarantee the destruction of every one of your missile boats, then no matter what happens to the motherland, you'll always be able to deliver a retaliatory strike, i.e. MAD...

And if Ukraine joining NATO is genuinely a cause for concern due to how close NATO could then position missiles to Moscow, then why weren't the Baltic states of similar concern when they joined? Right now, the closest part of NATO to Moscow is around 580km, whereas if Ukraine joined this would come down to around 450km - i.e. Ukraine being part of NATO makes the square root of diddly squat difference to NATOs ability to initiate a surprise strike against Moscow, and if we're considering other targets such as St Petersburg, Murmansk, Vladivostok etc, then adding Ukraine to NATO would provide no benefit at all.

And all of THAT presumes you're willing to accept that NATO actually would want to initiate a surprise strike, in complete contradiction to the reason it exists - i.e. as a defensive organisation aimed at deterring against attacks on member nations via the "an attack on one of us will be treated as an attack on all of us, so think VERY carefully about your next move..." doctrine.

So nope, the whole "ooh, we can't allow Ukraine to join NATO because of how much danger that would put Russia in" argument is a load of hooey. It's a convenient excuse Putrid can trot out to deflect criticism of his unwarranted invasion of Ukraine, but that's all it is. We managed to get through decades of the cold war without NATO making any efforts to attack Russia, so why would we want to upset the apple cart now? Russian paranoia is no justification for attacking a country in order to prevent it joining a military alliance that has shown throughout its entire existence a noted lack of desire to poke the bear.

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: I have a better idea

So basically, your argument seems to be that, because all wars are pointless and could be brought to an end quickly if only people would bother to talk to one another, there's no need to spend any resources on providing an effective means of defending yourself against whatever crap is thrown your way in that brief period between someone deciding to attack you, and your figuring out what you need to say to them (and just how much you'll have to then give over to them as a result...) in order to stop them doing that?

Nope, no thanks. Negotiations are one thing, but until they bear fruit I damn well want the people entrusted with running a country for the good of its citizens, to have the ability to at least *defend* the country and said citizens against attack.

ChrisC Silver badge

Re: Laser Guided?

B Ark, no, that's far too pleasant a fate. An eternity listening to Vogon poetry is the very least they deserve.