Re: Better concept follows...
You've read Pirate Cinema then ?
1473 publicly visible posts • joined 12 Jun 2009
"If CSPs refuse to provide those authorities with access to such data, a black box would be placed on a network where such information could be hoovered up."
CSP was defined as Facebook/Google rather than ISPs earlier.
So if Facebook/Google wont give in to a UK court order, and we know Google does refuse them, then every one in the country has to be wire tapped ? What 'logic' ...
So, the black boxes are required, and a key plank, unless you are using Talk Talk who already do DPI for something different ?
Or black boxes are only required if you wont give the spooks direct SSH access to the ISP mail cluster ?
Sadly no one of the committee new enough to ask him what will happen when the CA for the spoofed SSL certificates is removed from every ones browser...
It's worse.
With Twitter, for instance, the 'who' is embeded in a packet of JSON you send to the server. So the black box needs to parse that. And Twitter can change their format any time, never mind when a new service comes along...
But it's not about the technical details of why it wont work; it's about it being wrong to intercept everyones comms.
Innocent people have a right to privacy.