* Posts by Pablo

348 publicly visible posts • joined 17 Apr 2009

Page:

Parents back legal ban of violent vidgames sales to kids

Pablo
Megaphone

What has freedom of speech got to do with it?

Video games, just like movies, are "speech" (expression), that's what. Were you perhaps under the impression that only adults had rights? Or that there was any evidence that violent video games were actually dangerous, like drinking, driving, and sex are? (Voting, unlike speech, is only guaranteed to adults in the constitution.)

Pablo
Boffin

Nuances? Not so much.

Actually, there's a pretty big difference between a voluntary rating system and a mandatory one. For on thing, if it was a law, it would most likely apply to every stupid little iPhone game, and maybe even free games on the internet. Getting these rated would be prohibitively expensive. Most likely the law would end up being ignored in those cases anyway, but any law that's unenforceable shouldn't be made in the first place.

Currently, nobody is obliged to get their game rated if they don't want to. Of course most retail stores won't sell it if they don't. (Which is kind of ironic given the popularity of unrated cuts of movies around here.) But there is likewise no law that retail stores have to obey the ratings either, most of them do anyway for the sake of their family-friendly image.

Another difference is that when a system is voluntary they can't do like Australia and "refuse classification" to certain media, thereby banning it without actually having to use the B word.

Finally, this law in particular had some even more problematic aspects. For one thing it piggy-backed legal power onto the ratings from the existing private rating organization. It shouldn't be to hard to figure out why that's not a great idea. Also, it required a giant "18+" warning on games considered "patently offensive to children" without even attempting to explain what that means. This would almost certainly have a severe chilling effect.

Is US prudishness ruining the internet?

Pablo

Craigslist

It's irritating that Craigslist never really explained their decision to pull the adult section and whether or not it was permanent. BUT in their defense, they clearly made a deliberate effort not to "ruin the internet" by confining the change to US-based listings only. Of course it would have been even better if they had limited it to the states whose attorney-generals were giving them grief, but whatever.

Brits unleash world's hottest chilli pepper

Pablo

They probably didn't actually do it that way

More often nowadays they use chromatography and convert it to an approximate Scoville heat unit value.

Jailbreak hole in iOS 4.1 will be hard to close

Pablo
Boffin

RE: Legal yes, and also required

Jailbreaking and unlocking are not the same thing. Unlocking refers to allowing use with any carrier, whereas jailbreaking means allowing the use of any software. Though at least at one time, jailbreaking was the only means of unlocking an iPhone, so in practice you may be correct.

Two-lane BRIDGE FOUND ON FAR SIDE OF THE MOON!

Pablo
Alien

Dholes

No, not the cute dog-like animals, the other ones.

Google pulls trigger on 'Instant' search engine

Pablo

Could be kind of awkward

I can think of any number of search term that would likely yield disturbing results if submitted incomplete. Shitaki mushrooms... rape hotlines... lolita fashion. But I suppose I'm safe from this as long as I've got scripts turned off.

New 'iPhoD' can 'adjust the speed of light by turning a knob'

Pablo

Radio in this case

But also microwaves, IR, UV, x-rays, and gamma rays.

'Copyright troll' seeks $150,000 from republican candidate

Pablo
Pint

Good

The more politicians and would-be politicians learn first hand how screwed up or intellectual property laws are the better.

Children's rights group threatens ICO with judicial review

Pablo
Go

Pleasant surprise

Nine times out of ten when someone starts talking about "children's rights" it turns out they're either on some kick that actually has nothing to do with children (like censoring Craigslist) or their definition of "rights" includes only the Jobsian "freedom (from porn)" kind of rights.

So it's a bit of a shock to see that label used for a group actually genuinely advocating protecting the rights of children. Amazing.

Hardware hackers defeat quantum crypto

Pablo
Pint

Is the future already?

"Quantum key distribution systems became commercially available around five or six years ago and are used for the secure exchange of highly sensitive material by banks and governments..."

I have to admit this came as a bit of a surprise to me. I see at least one other commenter was unaware as well.

I that just goes too show you... something or other. I don't really have a point I guess. Now where's my flying car.

Google butterfingers slip jazz hands bug into Gmail

Pablo
Thumb Down

*Groan*

You know your webmail system is too complicated when it has even the possibility of accidentally blasting users with jazz.

Flyover states up attacks on Craigslist

Pablo
Stop

It IS illegal

In case you missed it, this happened the US where prostitution is only legal in one state (and only in license brothels). Of course that just means the adverts have to be disguised as something else. Escort services and massage parlors seem to be the most popular covers.

How extreme is your pr0n? Depends on your lawyer

Pablo

BME Pain Olympics: Final Round

Wikipedia claims that video is a known fake: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pain_Olympics#BME_Pain_Olympics:_Final_Round

(Of course that doesn't make it legal, as long as it's realistic enough to fool people.)

Royal Society opens inquiry into why kids hate tech

Pablo

Indeed

I don't agree with the view that one person can no longer make an interesting/useful program in a reasonable amount of time. Mobile apps are just one example that disproves that. Even on a standard PC platform, it's still possible to write a genuinely helpful utility of your own. Because of course, you know exactly what YOU need. And with luck, someone else might need it too.

Being American, I obviously have no experience with introductory programing classes in British schools, but I have a sneaking suspicion they're still using Quick Basic, Pascal or something equally inappropriate for creating modern software. If true, that's the exact opposite of what they should be doing. Students should be introduced to something easy and rewarding first and learn the nitty-gritty details later on.

Skeletal scanner would ID terrorists from 50 meters

Pablo

Think again

The article linked to specifically says it could use x-rays or gamma(!) rays, though it does leave the door open to "other forms of body scanning". I guess some type of ultrasound might work, but that normally has a range of zero (bodily contact) not 50 meters.

Pablo
Alert

Oh good.

A few gamma rays never hurt anyone, right?

Firefox, uTorrent, and PowerPoint hit by Windows DLL bug

Pablo
Thumb Up

It's kind of a bug

It's logical, relatively safe, and potentially useful for an application to use DLLs placed its own folder preferentially. It's not logical, safe, or very useful (except maliciously) for an application to use DLLs from the folder of the data file you're trying to open. If I understand correctly, the latter is what's happening.

I can imagine how it worked out that way, but there's really no good reason for it to do that.

Aus gov, ISPs book seats for firewall demolition

Pablo
Thumb Down

Not such a good thing

So this is going to be an IWF style arrangement then? That's better than putting the government directly in control, but assuming this is still something end users get no choice in, serious issues remain.

First of all, who makes the list, and who will be allowed to audit it?

Second, how do they define child abuse? Do they mean child porn, or are they using the Aussie definition that includes drawings of Bart Simpson, videos of acrobatic Russian circus babies and women with small breasts?

Finally, wasn't one of the big criticisms of the filter that it would slow down the internet? Does that change just because they're blocking less content? I don't know if the UK's internet is slow or not, but I do recall IWF screwed up Wikipedia and the Internet Archive on separate occasions.

Shopping mall mulls Supreme Court bid to back no-speaking ban

Pablo
FAIL

State != Federal

This case deals with California law, not federal. The CA constitution has a stronger freedom of speech protection, making it a "positive right", not just forbidding the government from restricting speech. For this reason people soliciting donations or signatures for some cause or another are a common sight in front of stores around here, even though businesses would prefer not to have them there.

I don't know what the situation is in other states, but in California at least, private property doesn't automatically trump freedom of speech, not once you invite the public onto your property in the first place.

Google's Inventor gets short shrift

Pablo
Thumb Up

pretty colours

I think really the main point of these kinds of graphical programing environments is to make it look easy and inviting for a novice, not actually to make it easier. And that has some value, there are many people who wouldn't even consider trying something that required writing *gasp* code. But once they're eased into it they might find it's not as hard as they thought.

In a similar way I was impressed by a free utility called AutoHotkey, which at first appears to be a simple macro system, but when I was on their forums I regularly saw newbies discovering that it wasn't hard to start adding logic and before they knew it they'd have a nice little script to help with some task or other.

Nothing succeeds like XSS

Pablo
Heart

What I wish we had

Is something like NoScript, but with a built in (if you pardon the term) crowdsourced domain review feature. So when I see that "suihhx.net" is trying to run a script I can submit a request and see reviews for a clue about what they heck it is. Even if they were fairly terse like "Apparently just serves ads.", "OMG it ate my computer ^_^;;" or "Necessary to read comments on Washington Post." it would be better than just guessing.

Note that I specifically didn't suggest it should base the default policy on these reviews or even automatically display them, which would require summiting a list of every domain I visit to their server.

Facebook bug spills name and pic for all 500 million users

Pablo
FAIL

Wow, that's dumb

Security conscious login systems won't even reveal whether an account exists if you don't provide the correct password, the standard response is something like "User name or password is invalid." Admittedly that is a little bit annoying, so they might be excused to doing away with that security measure. But to actually reveal information about that account is idiotic, and when they combine it with a system where something widely known like an email address functions as the user name, that pushes this into Epic Fail territory.

Is it a phone? Is it a Taser? No, it's a cattle prod!

Pablo
Terminator

Nasty Things

I suppose they are, but that doesn't mean there's no reason for a civilian to have one. Nasty things are very handy when nasty people try to hurt you.

In the US, at least in most states, even famously pro-gun control California, you can easily buy a (non-projectile) stungun. Recently I've seen (projectile) Tasers in stores to, but these are fairly tightly controlled. Arguably even more than guns, not only do you have to register it and pass a background check, it fires serial number confetti when used.

In my opinion they have a bad reputation just because police are trigger happy with them. If anything they're probably safer in the hands of a civilian who knows they can't get away with that kind of behavior.

Admittedly, I'm not sure there's a really good reason for them to be disguised as phones.

Indonesian parliament gets smut eyeful

Pablo
Big Brother

Wouldn't you know it

"The filter would begin with pornography and would later be expanded to other undesirable sites."

(from the linked-to article)

Stealth fighter in Canadian Wikipedia brouhaha

Pablo
FAIL

That's not the issue

The problem is that he posted it from work, thus making the Department of National Defence look bad. I think just about any employer would object to that.

Polaroid 300 instant print camera

Pablo
Pint

Ditto

That's exactly what I was expecting this to be when I first saw it. I was prepared to be impressed. There doesn't seem to be such a thing but something similar exists (from the same company even). I didn't know about it until just now, but it sounds interesting. It's the "PoGo Instant Digital Camera" and it prints thermally on some kind of special paper. The camera is more expensive, but the price per shot works out to a much more reasonable 17 cents.

May I suggest it for a future Reg hardware review.

Turkish pranksters load Facebook Translate with swears

Pablo

Pablo and 4 others fuck this.

Ace indeed.

Apple sued over hot iPad shutdowns

Pablo

Maybe

But in this case that could be a legitimate answer, if it's incorrectly shutting down long before it's at risk of suffering damage that would be a rare case where a firmware patch could actually fix it.

Australian Senate censors print link to cartoon

Pablo

I'm not so sure

Arguably, apathetic voters who are forced to vote do more harm than apathetic voters who don't vote at all. When voting is voluntary, voters are self selected for being at least mildly interested in politics, which one might hope correlates at least to some small degree with being better informed politically.

3D films fall flat

Pablo
FAIL

Okay but don't do it again

The image is 3D, not the screen. The (apparent) position of the image does indeed require three coordinates. X relative to left eye, X relative to right eye, and Y. From this your brain can easily extrapolate the more traditional X, Y and Z. Just like it does with actual 3D objects.

Mozilla tames Firefox tab monster with Candy

Pablo
Thumb Down

Looks overcomplicated

I guess it's for people who never close their browser, or have it configured it to reopen with all their old tabs, but I never do that so... it's just more bloat. Yuck.

I would like some kind of tree or tier based system, but switching to a whole separate window looks like a waste of time. For now, using a separate browser window like bhotaling said seems to be the most practical solution.

Perv scanner code of practice still a balls-up

Pablo

RE: There's a bit more to gender

And what about the transgender people who were recently shown special concern with regard to ID cards. I imagine how awkward it must be fore them if they're currently at an "in between" stage? And just who the heck are *they* supposed to request view the scan?

'Howling lesbian gangs' greet jailed Lindsay Lohan

Pablo

Actually there are

They are sometimes referred to as "Son of Sam" laws, (after a particular serial killer). However, according to Wikipedia anyway, California's version of that law was ruled unconstitutional in 2002.

Adobe to fortify widely exploited Reader with security sandbox

Pablo

http://xkcd.com/463/

That is all.

Windows Shortcut Flaw underpins power plant Trojan

Pablo

@ Bod Re: NTFS links

NTFS does support soft links, though Windows XP didn't come with any utility to make them, the mklink command in Vista (and I assume Seven) can do both kinds.

Intel boffins usher era of 'I know who you are' TV

Pablo
Thumb Down

Wow, that's totally useless

The only potentially desirable use I could imagine for a remote that knows who you are is parental controls, but 70% accuracy isn't nearly good enough for that.

Australia unbans the internet

Pablo

Odd, isn't it?

Although presumably you know you're on the list once you suddenly cease getting any traffic from Australia.

Pixel Qi releases sunlight-readable netbook screen

Pablo

Color e-paper with video?

(That doesn't suck?) I'm sure it's coming, but I'll believe it when I see it.

Animated CAPTCHA tech aims to fox spambots

Pablo

Interesting idea, horrible implementation

Even if it's only another way to stay one step ahead of the bots, I think it's worth exploring. But even as a proof of concept, that implementation was sorely lacking.

I'm imagining something more like Google's CAPTCHAs, only instead of fixed a distortion, it would use a changing distortion, basically the "underwater" effect you've not doubt seen before (but randomized, obviously). And in this case the individual letters (and optionally a background) would move independently. Done well I think it could very likely be easier for a human while still posing some new challenges to a bot.

Of course I'm not crazy about adding more flash and just to sites, but this would probably still work okay as an animated gif.

Pablo

reCAPTCHA

That was reCAPTCHA. It's still around, except it was bought out by Google, so any warm fuzzy feeling I may have once had about it has evaporated.

Two infosec blunders that betrayed the Russian spy ring

Pablo

RE: They were going to run

I suppose that make sense, but they must have realized this would happen. The fake handler scheme couldn't last long against any but the dimmest adversary. As soon as she got back in touch with her real handlers the jig would be up.

So the question then becomes why did they escalate the investigation to the point where they blew their own cover now (or rather a little while ago)? Given that we're supposedly trying to patch up relations with Russia it still seems like very strange timing.

Nipper's naked arse provokes Street View outrage

Pablo

Not that crazy

I don't think that's so crazy actually, compared to similar demands about YouTube and the like. Google records to pictures in the first place, so it would only maybe double the labor to check them too.

Regular domains beat smut sites at hosting malware

Pablo
Headmaster

Not according to this

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2010/06/03/the_internet_is_for_pron/

It says here that 12% of the web is porn.

HK 'Dog Man' cuffed for voodoo ritual sex

Pablo

The difference

If a random guy says "Hey baby, I'm a doctor, wanna screw?", that's sleazy, but not illegal. But if he says "I'm a doctor and ohmygosh you've got phantasmaembryois. Come back to my place and I'll reach up there and fix it for free.", that crosses the line. The difference is he's lying about the purpose of the act itself, and that's what this guy did too. The fact that you'd have to be an idiot to believe it in this case is irrelevant. In California that would actually be considered rape, which IMHO may be extreme, but it's certainly not a "little white lie".

Russian spy ring bust uncovers tech toolkit

Pablo
IT Angle

Entertaining but...

It's entertaining to speculate about what kind of software you would use to outsmart the FBI but as far as I've seen, none of the information released so far explains what tipped the feds off to the existence of these spies in the first place. It could just as easily have been some unrelated leak, or even info from a US spy in Russia. To me it sounds like they were actually doing a pretty good job of keeping a low profile.

Pablo

She really used that

But it's not so strange. It was only for buying a phone, I put down stuff like that all the time. Still it's probably not a great idea if you're trying to keep a low profile.

Though it also occurs to me that the clerk could have put that in after she declined to provide an address.

Pablo
Paris Hilton

What do you mean "not very covert"?

Are you saying she's readily identifiable as a spy from that picture?

Secret ancient code, basis of all modern civilisation, cracked

Pablo
IT Angle

Yeah, that...

I think the problem must have something to do with the fact that it's not actually a link, but a very strangely styled button. I'm rather confused by that choice of design. It's kind of irritating because it also means I can't easily start a reply in a new tab.

Google can kill or install apps on citizen Androids

Pablo
Thumb Down

Fine

But that's no excuse for putting a back door on every phone. They could easily provide a separate remove-admin app for organizations who need it. It's not even clear that the current feature can be used they way you describe.

Page: