* Posts by Alan Brown

15085 publicly visible posts • joined 8 Feb 2008

UK.gov loses crucial battle in home-taping war with musicians

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: How music got free

"it then goes on to explain cutting of artist rosters etc., as if the downloaders were causing this rather than it being an ongoing trend in the industry that dated back to the early 1990's (at least) anyway."

Nor does it even go close to the fact that as sharing increased, so did CD sales (which as you mentioned had been in terminal decline for 7-8 years).

The inconvenient thing for the media companies was that demand wasn't for the stable of 20-30 moneyearning artists they keep promoting relentlessly, but lesser-known material, often from the back catalogues.

They don't want people buying a wide range of music. It's much cheaper to forcefeed a narrow range of stuff into the market and rely on volume to increase profits by decreasing per-unit costs.

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: Hang on a mo

> That we even have a situation where some outfit thinks they're entitled to sell the same product in different forms to the same person - that is what is aberrant.

Up until the days of digital media, record companies would release multiple variants of popular artists albums in order to extract money from "completists" - I first read about this tactic in a book detailing Talking Heads history that was published about 1984.

The thing is, they've been getting away with it for so long that they assume that it's their right to do so. Either the media is free and the material has a price or the material is free and the media has a price. The current situation is nothing short of double-dipping.

EU copyright law: Is the Pirate Party's MEP in FAVOUR of it?

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: Double edged sword

"It's not a free market where the state grants legal monopolies"

The original intent of modern copyright and patent law was to allow inventors and authors to make enough money from their work that they'd keep on working.

The copyright and Intellectual property cartels are trying to move back to the days where copyright and patents were granted forever. This model was dumped in the 16th/17th centuries in most countries.

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: Double edged sword

"You are free to buy my books in one market ... and then cross a border and sell them in another in the hope of making a profit ... that's what they call, "business." - whether it is legal or not depends on your paying the appropriate duties. "

Even _you_ (the author) are not free to do that.

Copyright is assigned to an exclusive distributor in the other country. As soon as you sell those parallel-import books in the other country you're infringing the distributors copyright (perhaps criminally in some countries) even if you're the author of the works in question.

Yes, copyright law really is that perverse and yes people have ended up in jail for selling legally purchased material which didn't go via "the right channels"

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: Double edged sword

"material sold outside the home market will require more work, dubbing, etc."

Those who want to pay for (generally vastly inferior) dubbed versions will still do so.

Those who can speak/read the languages in question can and should be able to buy them wherever they want.

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: No surprise - Pirates want free stuff.

"Piracy can be dramatically reduced by getting rid of artificial scarcity and by charging sane amounts"

As far back as the early days of personal computer software one of the larger suppliers made a decision to price their products so they'd sell for about the same price as a retail blank tape (about $3) instead of $20

Where retailers didn't pad the price out, sales went up 100-fold. Where retailers did keep prices high, sales levels fell slightly, even if the retail figure was now $10

I ran into the same thing selling books. Local shops would charge a 1500% markup over USA prices for ordering in "specialist" titles from "Overseas" and take 3-4 months to get them, when it turned out they were coming from a warehouse 40 miles away (next day delivery) and could be sold at double the US price whilst still taking a comfortable profit margin.

The same shops took legal action against a student collective from the local university who noticed that they were selling academic titles at 20-40 times the US cover price (often in collusion with lecturers from the same university) when they could be imported for about 3 times USA cover price - the collective made arrangements for students to bulk order the things so the bookshops managed to secure local copyrights in order to secure their profiteering, then got injunctions preventing the parallel imports.

The NHS pays up to NINE TIMES over trade price for commodity kit

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: Old news

"And one inspector when investigating that GP for fraud during an audit got back from the GP to find his senior manager asking him not to dare to ask a GP questions like that. (the question being if 3 are here, why are 3 now at your house?)"

Ah, so the fraud activity is organised?

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: Not just NHS

> I questioned this with one of the IT Contracts/Procurement team. He went red in the face and I was told to "Shut up and don't mention it again!"

Again, once you put in a FOI request the results can be....... interesting.

Alternatively you can just pay a visit to your local constabulary and mention that you believe that systematic fraud in excess of £threshold is happening at $ORG and you'd like to stay anonymous.

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: Bureaucratic procurement

"they have nice, secure jobs and (at least on one place I worked) featherign their nests with bungs"

Proof of that would be rather interesting in this day and age when the Internet means that it can't be hushed up.

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: Bureaucratic procurement

> NHS Procurement: "Yeah, we know, but we will only buy it through one of our pre-approved suppliers"

A couple of FOI requests can make for very interesting responses.

Vodafone hikes prices to 37.5p/min – and lets angry customers flee

Alan Brown Silver badge

"I swear it's a revenue raising service."

Which is why the practice is banned by the NHS.

http://www.pulsetoday.co.uk/your-practice/practice-topics/access/hundreds-of-gps-to-be-threatened-with-breach-of-contract-over-use-of-084-numbers/20004947.article

Alan Brown Silver badge

"Notably, 084 numbers, used by some doctors' surgeries, rise from 19.17p a minute to 37.5p."

Doctors' surgeries are forbidden to use 08[45] numbers and a complaint to your local health provider is in order if they are.

Why is that idiot Osbo continuing with austerity when we know it doesn't work?

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: all you lefties and champagne socialists should...

"Labour is, sadly, doing this all wrong. First they need to understand why the country rejected them so strongly"

They didn't. The swing was tiny. It's just the gearing effect of FPP which makes it seem huge.

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: Spending money

"What difference does it make if money is spent by private contractors or multi-cultural lesbian single mother awareness campaigners? "

In the one case you should get some hard infrastructure (and therefore long-term public benefit) for your money. In the other it's ephemeral.

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: Spending money

> creating more students doesn't create more jobs requiring graduate qualifications

"I don't often talk to arts graduates, but when I do, I ask for mine with extra fries"

Students in the current environment take "soft" and "cheap" degrees. Those are the ones which have no real job market, but you get a "degree" attached to your name.

Hard sciences and vocationally-related jobs are still in demand. The problem is that graduates incur such high levels of debt that they may never be able to pay it off.

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: What spare capacity?!

" I'm not really seeing anything new coming onto the market now that would improve our productivity any further."

The British Civil Service are by-and-large still using antiquated, outdated pre-computer methods and employing too many layers of management to be able to effectively run the organisation.

That makes it inefficient and ripe for cost savings, unless you're using it as a way of hiding real unemployment figures (arguably the case in many post-industrial areas where the govt has taken the place of t'mill or t'mine as the employer which brings money into the area from outside and everything else is support industry that takes money from civil servants and spreads it around.)

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: It helps to actually read the article before commenting...

QE: printing extra money

QE by giving iot to banks or QE by paying people/companies to do things _should_ both achieve the same result from the financial point of view (more money in circulation with a lower overall intrinsic value per instrument)

However the fact that the banks have largely hoarded what was given to them has thoroughly blunted the intent of printing more money - which was to stimulate growth by encouraging economic activity and getting more money circulating. Someone forgot to give the banks the memo that if money's not actually circulating then the plan doesn't work and the govt might just as well have printed the money and stashed it at the royal mint.

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: What austerity?

"They could cut the benefits paid to those working (£30 billion/yr+)"

If those are cut _and_ taxable income points are simultaneously raised you can have a paradoxical effect of not reducing what's in the pockets of those working whilst also saving a fair amount of money. This is achieved by laying off those in inland revenue who only exist to take in, handle and disburse those credits and is an ongoing year-upon-year savings.

There are two sides to taxation:

1: Gross amount taken

2: Net money available

The more complicated the tax structure is, the less ends up in #2 and conversely if the structures are simplified with loopholes eliminated, you can reduce #1 whilst simultaneously increasing #2.

This was done in New Zealand. 30% of the inland revenue department was made redundant over the following 5 years and staffing levels are now 1/3 what they were in 1984.

Some of this is down to increasing computerisation, but NZ had already been reducing its staffing levels under this model - unlike the UK which has been hiring more and more people to work for the inland revenue since computerising, whilst providing worse and worse service (Hint: the more people a manager has under them, the higher their position, which means more pay and higher retirement benefits. There's no real auditing of the usefulness of departments and their staff which in turn results in rampant "Featherbedding" across the civil services - other EU countries do it more blatently but the UK is still bad in terms of public sector inefficiency.)

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: @BB- What the...?

> "At the insistence of the LibDems the electorate were offered an alternative to FPTP just a few years ago."

The "alternative" was "meet the new boss, just like the old boss" - seriously, the _least_ proportionally representative (on a national basis) and most prone to confusion of all the PR alternatives.

> "They roundly booted it into touch, much to the consternation of our North London 'opinion formers'."

The electorate didn't even bother showing up for the most part (abysmally low turnouts do not a 'round booting into touch' make). I voted no because it's arguably worse (and far more suceptable to abuse in real world implementations) than the FPP system in place at the moment.

It wasn't FPP vs Proportional Representation. It was FPP vs 1 variant of PR.

The question needs to be "FPP or PR?", then "Which type of PR?"

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: What the...?

"England voted and chose"

England chose nothing. Britain did - and the results were close enough to be in the noise. Noone has a clear mandate, nor have they had for a long time, not with only about 1/3 of the votes cast.

Sun's out, guns out: Plucky Philae probot WAKES UP ... hits 'snooze'

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: Cost of launch

"Short answer: yes"

Longer answer: We don't have the tech (yet) and even if we do, we don't have big enough launchers(*) yet to get the initial ball of string into orbit.

(*) Chemical launchers are unlikely to ever be large enough. An Orion nuclear launcher would work and a single successful launch could put all the necessary material in place to build the first one.

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: Excellent work!

"The biggest cost in these missions is not the hardware. It's in the launch "

Not even remotely close. Launch costs are a small percentage of mission costs.

As are the _actual_ hardware costs (ie: the marginal cost of making the final production item which flies, plus its spare, which is normally used as a ground-based simulation rig once the launch goes off ok)

Most of the money goes in labour costs for designing and prototyping dozens-to-hundreds of test models which will never be flown and in most cases never even exposed to a vacuum chamber or vibration test rig.

These are necessary to make sure that the item which goes up, stays working, and doesn't fail in unexpected ways (but of course they still do for one-off missions as they're necessarily going to encounter unexpected conditions, such as ice so hard it broke the drill and it's hard to simulate what 3 years of power-off, deep-space cold-soak temperatures do to a thruster without investing billions into enough vaccuum chambers and chilling kit to keep the test items that cold for that long.)

Making a dozen flight articles would add a few percent onto the mission cost as the R&D cost is already sunk. Making and flying a dozen Beagles would have cost roughly double what 1 did. (The percentage hit on other missions is less, because Beagle was done extremely cheaply - so cheaply that it reused test components and that was probably what killed it (the most likely scenario is iced up airbags which didn't inflate properly or which split. They were watersoaked, patched and overweight when packed for flight)

The problem is that space missions are seriously strapped for cash. Space isn't sexy except for Geeks. At its peak spending, expenditure on NASA was less than the US public spent on outboard motors in any given year or pizza delivery charges. These days NASA's entire budget is less than Google spends lobbying the US congress (and Google is one of the smaller lobbyists) or what the US military spends operating airconditioned tents in the Middle East.

If there was more money available, organisations could afford to be less cautious. Getting things wrong in spaceflight results in budgets being cut, not boosted to make up the difference as funding is fixed and mostly based on "national prestige" or PR value.

As it is, 80-90% of proposed space missions deemed scientifically worthwhile never get past the funding proposal stage (which in turn leads to a lot of people scatter-gunning badly thought-out proposals in the blind hope of catching a crumb or two). Those that do get funded tend to pick up lots of "hitchhikers" en-route between mission core and launchpad as it's easier to propose add-ons than separate flights and some lose funding before launch for myriad reasons. There are plenty of completed spacecraft sitting around NASA/ESA/Russian warehouses which have been waiting 20+ years for a ride which will never come.

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: Excellent work!

It did work properly from the start.

The solar panels were a "It'll be nice if it works" afterthought.

'Right to be forgotten' applies WORLDWIDE, thunders Parisian court

Alan Brown Silver badge

"And lose a 60million+ population advert target potential? "

Google walked out of China - and you can guarantee that french consumers _AND_ businesses would be screaming blue murder in less than a week.

LastPass got hacked: Change your master password NOW

Alan Brown Silver badge

"If someone wants your passwords bad enough, they will get them"

ObXKCD: https://xkcd.com/538/

Future Range Rovers will report pot-holes directly to councils

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: I live in a nation with better solutions..

Councils _GOT_ extra budget for bad roads.

And generally pissed it away doing consultations on how to fix the bad roads, rather than actually getting on with the job.

The one who actually patch potholes often farm it out to the cheapest bidder, resulting in the same hole needing to be filled 3-4 times in as many months. I've seen patches disintegrating in less than 24 hours, reported it and then observed it not be repaired for months.

Alan Brown Silver badge

"damage to your car caused by driving into a pothole which has not been reported to the the council is your problem,"

Not at all, they still have a duty of care. The problem is that it's much harder to get done and usually involves multiple rounds of FOI requests.

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: Potholes - theres tool for that.

They don't need to run right across the road, merely across the part that you're able to drive on.

There are lots of places around here where the choice is "hedge, pothole, oncoming cyclist" never mind any larger mobile obstacle.

Toothless Ofcom: C'mon consumers, show your teeth on broadband speeds

Alan Brown Silver badge

"Plusnet has apparently been chasing down issues in the BTw network since January"

You mean 'One part of BT has been chasing down issues in another part of BT since January'

And it's a good reason to jump ship, not put up with it - losing customers en-mass has a galvanising effect on management, vs persuading them to put up with poor service and keep handing over the dosh.

WRT the games Telcos and ISPs play on billing: A small claims filing is usually more than enough to sort that stuff instantly. They're taking the piss because they can and because most consumers will pay up rather than keep on fighting.

Alan Brown Silver badge

"Are ISPs going to be required to provide an official tester hosted on their servers? "

It would be good if they did, but smokeping is a useful tool if you want to see where congestion is happening.

Alan Brown Silver badge

phone lines

"This is more than likely due to the phone line and not any particular ISP issue."

I pay the ISP, the ISP pays Openreach.

My contract is with the ISP, not with Openreach. If Openreach causes my ISP to breach their contractual obligations to me, that's entirely between them and Openreach. I have no legal power to force Openreach to do anything.

If the ISP cannot sort the line problems because their processes suck (BT/Plus, Talktalk/AOL and Sky are particular culprits here) then I'm perfectly within my rights to jump ship and go to an ISP who won't let Openreach take the piss.

Thankfully such ISPs exist. As a big hint, none of them are operated by Telcos or Content Providers.

Condoleezza to China: 'The rules' mean cyber-spying isn't allowed

Alan Brown Silver badge

Rolling out the Pacific Fleet

America says it can subdue China by rolling out the Pacific Fleet and thereby keep China out of international waters.

All China has to do to subdue America is block exports for 3-6 months. What are the americans going to do? Invade and _force_ them to be in international waters?

Of course Condee and the neocons all know this, but they're trying frantically to keep the illusion that "Amerika Rules the Waves" etc, in order to keep the great unwashed ignorant pliable and shouting "U-S-A!" instead of actually thinking for themselves.

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: Pot, kettle called..

"The problem is, nobody really trusts American tech because of cyber-security issues.”

This is one reason we spent $150k on Huawei kit instead of Cisco.

GCHQ has already vetted the Huawei stuff.

Using leather in 'leccy cars is 'unTesla', rages vegan shareholder

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: Unless your grid is entirely coal based

Nuclear is the only one with long-term viability.

That's because the next-generation MSR designs are highly throttleable, so they can be used to provide backing capacity to the other three OR provide baseload and throttle up to handle peaks.

As they'll only make money when run in the latter mode, expect enercos to start refusing to allow uncontrolled installations to interconnect.

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: Vegans

can I get my car seats made out of leather made from the skins of vegans?

Israeli firm gets legal on Indian techie over ISP ad injection spat

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: I wonder..

' That all turnsvon "Fair Use" and that is very country specific '

No, it doesn't, and the country specifically is the USA, not bumfuckistan.

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: Bharti Airtel and Flash Networks

"Yes, and GitHub followed the law as Flash's IP had been stolen."

Incorrect and false DMCA claims are a criminal matter (perjury).

If the guy chooses to dispute it, github will reinstate the pages on the spot.

Voyager 2 'stopped' last week, and not just for maintenance

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: Typical short-sighted approach

"The rocket equation is a pain in the bum."

What's needed is for Elon to get a bee in his bonnet about Loftrom Loops.

Chips can kill: Official

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: What about that 'High Fructose Corn Syrup' then?

It's got about the same proportion of fructose in it as table sugar.

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: Acrylamide toxicity is nothing new

"Analogous to toxicity in general."

And this includes radiation exposure.

Empirical proof: Aircrew aren't dropping like flies and they're the population routinely exposed to the highest levels outside of laboratory/specialist environments.

You have to be spectacularly unlucky to develop cancers in the long-term from exposure to radioactive materials or direct exposure to ionising radiation. ex-smokers being a case in point - all that polonium fizzing away in their lungs and it they're still far more likely to develop cancer from the chemical effects of breakdowns than the alpha particles (lead, bismuth and mercury - whilst the alpha particles usually just kill cells)

(Disclosure: My employer ran a multi-year study on ionising/particle radiation exposure levels in aircraft. It turned out to be much higher than anyone had estimated)

Anecdote: The old laboratories used by Rutherford at Oxford had a cluster of cancers which caused panic about residual radioactives. After years of trying to find what had been missed it was finally determined that the culprit was mercury compounds coming out of the woodwork - sourced by broken thermometers in the days predating the lab's used in radioactive research.

A pause in global warming? What pause?There was no pause

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: What we really need

"we lack comparable datasets over the range of more than a couple of decades or so."

We also lack consistent ways of gathering those datasets.

As the paper points out:

1: Originally ocean temperatures were observed by hauling a bucket of water and dropping a thermometer in it.

2: This changed to measuring the intake water temperature of shipping engines (distorting the readings slightly upwards)

3: In the last 20 years it's been more common to use buoys to measure temperature. These also get distorted depending on local currents - in some parts of the world the ocean temperature can change 10C in 20km depending on upwellings, etc.

4: Land based measurements get distorted depending on surroundings - grassy fields run cooler than paves area, and many sampling sites have ended up urbanised or paved in the case of airfields. They're also affected if they're downwind of population areas.

The problem is that the overall changes in the last 100 years have only been a few degrees, so we're arguing about 0.1-0.2 differences in short term which are hard to measure and subject to calibration error, plus there are climate cycles of 40 years or more to contend with. It's _hard_ to average this out over short periods, but we don't have the luxury of being able to wait 100 years and say "there's a clear trend there"

Cause for more immediate concern is what's happening in the Laptev Sea (methane outgassing) and if it's spreading. If it does spread then switching off CO2 emissions tomorrow won't have any effect on what happens next.

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: ohboy

"Personally, I suspect/feel/have a reasonable suspicion that tossing millions of tons of CO2 out there is not a good thing for the planet overall"

The only times in geological history when the CO2 levels have changed in a short period have been associated with Great Dyings.

This may be the first time that a large CO2 shift hasn't been associated with a flood basalt event burning through fossil fuel layers on the way up.

Past oxygen levels have been much higher (and lower) than they are now. Past CO2 levels have been higher (and much lower) than they are now. The issue isn't the levels, it's the _rate of change_ falling outside that which ecosystems are able to adapt. In many ways ocean levels and warming are amongst the least worrisome things on the agenda.

Those who point out that CO2 levels were this high 500 million years ago should also take into account that the sun is pumping out 10-15% more energy than it was then. This planet is only going to habitable for 500 million more years at the outside. Past that the oceans will be above 50C even if there was no CO2 in the atmosphere. I'm more worried about what my grandchildren will inherit.

Vodafone: So what exactly is 'ludicrous' about the Frontier report?

Alan Brown Silver badge

"Its entirely separate if I can buy shares in it separately to the bt shares I can buy.

Can I ?"

No.

You could if the New Zealand model was followed - and remember the NZ model was picked specifically because the BTOR model being proposed by the incumbent telco there was studied here and discovered to be massively abused by BT to maintain its monopoly.

Alan Brown Silver badge

"all the different BT business units are run entirely separately."

With the dead hands of BT HQ seeing across all companies and pulling the strings as it sees fit to maximise its profit.

Oh, shoppin’ HELL: I’m in the supermarket of the DAMNED

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: Waitrose

"Brilliant. Used it dozens of times and never had a problem."

6 of the last 8 times I've used it, I've had "you have been selected for a random audit" - queue waiting 5 minutes for a meatbag to show up and rescan at least half of your shop to ensure it was done accurately.

Why fucking bother?

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: I just go to the tills

lick your fingers. You'll get enough traction to open the bags.

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: I just go to the tills

"I just go to the tills where people get paid to scan the stuff."

You clearly haven't been in UK supermarkets.

In most of them there are _no_ tills with meatbags on them after 10-11pm.

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: Some Dutch shops..

"Also, why is it that only people in the UK seem to have a problem with automated check-outs?"

They're fine for a half dozen items (ie, as a replacement for express lanes)

When you're forced to run the entire week's shopping through them they're an infernal bloody nuisance.

The only thing worse than having to do such a thing at 11pm is being behind someone who is doing that when you only have 3-4 items and all-bar 1 or 2 self checkouts are actually working.

Alan Brown Silver badge

Easy solution

Dump everything on the bagging area and walk out.

If enough customers do it the twats in headquarters will get the idea.

China's hackers stole files on 4 MEELLION US govt staff? Bu shi, says China

Alan Brown Silver badge

Re: Of course they didn't!

If China really wanted to screw over the USA all they need to do is prevent exports going there for six months.

The rest is simply noise.