* Posts by The General

2 publicly visible posts • joined 12 May 2008

NXP sues to silence Oyster researchers

The General

Forget the egos

...just forget the egos (of those that found the flaw and those that made it) - just fix the problem. Give Oyster a preview of the flaw and some time to fix it - then publish the report for the glory. Although flawed Oyster does work (most of the time?) - or should we just go back to loose change?

Just because houses catch fire and burn down - should we all be fire starters to prove a point?

Set-top box modders sent to prison

The General

Who is responsible anyway...

The interesting issue here is - if someone provides you with the information to assist you to do something "illegally" (view or steal content that should be paid for) who is responsbile (or guilty)? The one who provides the information or the one who uses it (or both?) Is it that the information (instructions in this case) is private and has been used without permission - meaning in this case both published/posted and used...

But if the information is mostly public domain (algorithms and technology) and it is just how they are used together that is private... hmm..