@Nic
As usual, there are exaggerations on both sides. You seem to think that anyone using an ad blocker systematically steals other people's lunch. Not so. And I will pass on your lightning-quick association with pirating music which has nothing to do in this debate and is much too troll-like to my taste.
Ads used to be simple still images. I had no problem with those, they didn't keep me from reading what I had actually come to read. Then they became animated images. At that point came the difference between usefully-animated-but-still-could-be-ignored and horribly-flashing-annoying-piece-of-crap-begging-to-be-shot. Not to mention Flash-based ads that are heavier than the page I actually want to see.
And don't get me started on popup ads that cannot be closed or other such malware-enhanced nuisances.
As a result, and because the ad industry has not been able to keep itself in check, I use AdBlock since I cannot stand having things shoved in my face, and ad makers do not seem to know anything else these days (I know, I know, that's an exaggeration as well).
What I would like to see is a mod of AdBlock that allows simple, still image ads and blocks all the other crap. After all, an ad in a magazine cannot be animated either, yet there are plenty so it must be useful enough.
What I would also like to see the next time you go in a store is a pair of ugly fat ladies in garishly pink tutus following you around and constantly yelling to your face to buy Mountain Dew. I'm sure you wouldn't mind shopping like that, since otherwise you're just a freetard music pirate, right ?