Re: The top panel should go
> As long as the top panel was not designed to host a global menu, it should go. Go away! Shoo!
Agreed. There was a handy extension called "Tiny Floating Panel" for this. GNOME 51 broke it, of course. _But_ it didn't show status icons or app indicators, or whatever TF they are called now, and it didn't show the overview indicator, so it wasn't ideal.
If it's got to be there, then make it earn a living.
> GNOME never intended to have a panel that could host launchers and icons-with-freaking-text (the window title)
Agreed. Only...
> like GNOME2, MATE, XFCE, KDE, LXDE, LXQt, and Win95+ do.
Several of them don't. You need to be a _lot_ more careful with your generalisations.
> Once you rely on a stupid dock and the panel is mostly empty, it should go.
Agreed.
> OTOH, even Windows fakes a dock, and even when it didn’t (Win10)
Wrong again. It's been trying to fake a dock since Win7.
> it defaulted to icons-without-text on the taskbar (KDE, too, adopted this retarded thing, leaving most of the panel empty;
More to pick apart.
I don't mind icon-only buttons so long as they are big and clear and easily identifiable _and_ there is zero delay on a big readable tooltip on mouseover.
But again, pre-IE-ified Explorer had a better answer: show the text buttons until the bar is full, then and only then shrink them.
So, again, you need to dig more into the early days.
95 and NT4 had a direct-rendering Explorer.
98 brought in HTML rendering because MS was terrified the US DOJ would break it up and it wanted to demonstrate IE was integral.
If you know the history then the reasons are clear.
> and XFCE adds a dock by default,
Not exactly, no. Xubuntu started this. Xubuntu itself no longer does it. And it's not really a dock or docklike, as I criticised recently. And yes I've filed bugs with Xfce.
> despite also having a multifunctional panel!).
It could be better.
> So people really like what is wrong with macOS
It's not wrong. It works well on the native platform. You're free not to like it but "I do not like this" is not the same as "this is wrong" and it almost never equates.
> Good, we’re all Chinese now, and all mimicking whatever Apple decided is good for the world.
Been that way since the iMac. Arguably before.
> But the real ergonomics or human factors argument against a global menu is that many apps are used with non-maximized windows. We’re really no longer in the days of Classic Mac OS and 512 × 342, 640 × 480, or 832 × 624 pixels. When an app only takes up part of the screen, and the global menu is literally 3 inches away from the place where the app’s window ends, this forces the user to MOVE their eyes and mouse to an area of the screen they shouldn’t be interested in!
I don't think you know much about either how eyes work or about what top panels or for.
It's an info source, one I glance at regularly anyway. It's not just there for menus. It was in 1986 or something but we've moved on a bit in the last 40 years, you know.
> And no, Liam, this is not what Fitts’s law says! It DOES NOT say that a global menu is better! Especially not about moving one's EYES!
You badly misread me, and as in most of this comment, you don't understand what you are complaining about. If you spent as long learning as you do complaining then we'd all be better off.
Fitt said nothing about looking at things. This discussion isn't about looking at things. It's about your hands not your eyes. It's about _aiming_ at things with your pointing device.
Window edge: 2D aiming -- _both_ height and width.
Screen edge: 1d aiming -- only width. A small flick of the wrist, even with my crippled right arm with limited wrist flexibility and movement now, and the mouse is on the top edge WITHOUT AIMING and then I only have to do left/right aiming. Better still I can't miss too high as the mouse can't go off the top of the top screen.
This is fact, not opinions, and only fools try to argue against measurable facts -- and they always lose, inevitably.
> But, of course, vultures and other Apple users are so used to this crap that they want it everywhere.
Bullshit. We're just opinionated and we all differ.