The Register Home Page

* Posts by Liam Proven

4414 publicly visible posts • joined 7 Jan 2008

Orbit Global Menu: A working global menu addon for GNOME

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: A desktop environment is the Marmite of computing

> Love it or hate it. Anything beyond 'evilwm' and '9menu' is just bloat.

No thanks. It's 2026. I do not want a Unix environment from 30 years ago.

But frankly, take the Windows NT 4 Explorer, add multithreading (as Apple did with the Finder in MacOS 8), and I'd be happy. It did all I want and it did it with rich keyboard controls too.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: As a former RISC OS user...

> They ought to appear when needed, right where you clicked so no mouse gymnastics, and go away otherwise.

100% agreed.

Now, what we need is someone to go modernise the ROX Desktop so it uses Python 3 and Snap instead of 0install. ;-)

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

> Gnome, in its turn, is the Marmite of desktop environments.

Good point, well made.

And just as no sane restaurant would give all its customers Marmite, distro vendors shouldn't all give us GNOME.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: The top panel should go

> As long as the top panel was not designed to host a global menu, it should go. Go away! Shoo!

Agreed. There was a handy extension called "Tiny Floating Panel" for this. GNOME 51 broke it, of course. _But_ it didn't show status icons or app indicators, or whatever TF they are called now, and it didn't show the overview indicator, so it wasn't ideal.

If it's got to be there, then make it earn a living.

> GNOME never intended to have a panel that could host launchers and icons-with-freaking-text (the window title)

Agreed. Only...

> like GNOME2, MATE, XFCE, KDE, LXDE, LXQt, and Win95+ do.

Several of them don't. You need to be a _lot_ more careful with your generalisations.

> Once you rely on a stupid dock and the panel is mostly empty, it should go.

Agreed.

> OTOH, even Windows fakes a dock, and even when it didn’t (Win10)

Wrong again. It's been trying to fake a dock since Win7.

> it defaulted to icons-without-text on the taskbar (KDE, too, adopted this retarded thing, leaving most of the panel empty;

More to pick apart.

I don't mind icon-only buttons so long as they are big and clear and easily identifiable _and_ there is zero delay on a big readable tooltip on mouseover.

But again, pre-IE-ified Explorer had a better answer: show the text buttons until the bar is full, then and only then shrink them.

So, again, you need to dig more into the early days.

95 and NT4 had a direct-rendering Explorer.

98 brought in HTML rendering because MS was terrified the US DOJ would break it up and it wanted to demonstrate IE was integral.

If you know the history then the reasons are clear.

> and XFCE adds a dock by default,

Not exactly, no. Xubuntu started this. Xubuntu itself no longer does it. And it's not really a dock or docklike, as I criticised recently. And yes I've filed bugs with Xfce.

> despite also having a multifunctional panel!).

It could be better.

> So people really like what is wrong with macOS

It's not wrong. It works well on the native platform. You're free not to like it but "I do not like this" is not the same as "this is wrong" and it almost never equates.

> Good, we’re all Chinese now, and all mimicking whatever Apple decided is good for the world.

Been that way since the iMac. Arguably before.

> But the real ergonomics or human factors argument against a global menu is that many apps are used with non-maximized windows. We’re really no longer in the days of Classic Mac OS and 512 × 342, 640 × 480, or 832 × 624 pixels. When an app only takes up part of the screen, and the global menu is literally 3 inches away from the place where the app’s window ends, this forces the user to MOVE their eyes and mouse to an area of the screen they shouldn’t be interested in!

I don't think you know much about either how eyes work or about what top panels or for.

It's an info source, one I glance at regularly anyway. It's not just there for menus. It was in 1986 or something but we've moved on a bit in the last 40 years, you know.

> And no, Liam, this is not what Fitts’s law says! It DOES NOT say that a global menu is better! Especially not about moving one's EYES!

You badly misread me, and as in most of this comment, you don't understand what you are complaining about. If you spent as long learning as you do complaining then we'd all be better off.

Fitt said nothing about looking at things. This discussion isn't about looking at things. It's about your hands not your eyes. It's about _aiming_ at things with your pointing device.

Window edge: 2D aiming -- _both_ height and width.

Screen edge: 1d aiming -- only width. A small flick of the wrist, even with my crippled right arm with limited wrist flexibility and movement now, and the mouse is on the top edge WITHOUT AIMING and then I only have to do left/right aiming. Better still I can't miss too high as the mouse can't go off the top of the top screen.

This is fact, not opinions, and only fools try to argue against measurable facts -- and they always lose, inevitably.

> But, of course, vultures and other Apple users are so used to this crap that they want it everywhere.

Bullshit. We're just opinionated and we all differ.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: Reading with interest

> I could never get on with global menus.

Suggestions:

1. Get used to using menu _keystrokes_ more.

2. Turn on mouse acceleration and get used to using it.

Before you or anyone shouts at me:

If you care where they are, this suggests you're using the mouse for them. In-window menus are harder to hit; this is science -- it's called Fitt's Law.

General principles here: If you're using the mouse then learn to use it better. Also, for greater efficiency and speed, learn not to use it -- learn the shortcuts because you will get faster and more accurate. We all want that, don't we?

Pratchett's Patrician hung mimes upside down facing a sign that said LEARN THE WORDS.

My version: LEARN THE KEYSTROKES.

The latest FreeBSD report is here, and the AI debate is ongoing

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: Too Radical

> The article mentions that FreeBSD has projects to create something similar to Proxmox, Snap, Flatpak and AppImage,

Yes...

> then goes on to say "interesting and quite radical stuff is happening in the FreeBSD space."

Yes...

> I do find it interesting that the original Linux design was to copy BSD (and Unix) but now the radical design is for BSD to copy Linux.

And suddenly, screech of tyres, cloud of smoke, black rubber laid down across the road as we unexpectedly veer off into a whole new direction.

In the early 1990s, Linux copied the basic very-early-1970s Unix design, because the other FOSS projects and Unix-like projects out there back then were doing other things.

* Plan 9 was not FOSS yet.

* FreeBSD and NetBSD didn't exist yet and wouldn't for a couple of years. One can interpret them as _responses_ to Linux and the new style of community internet-distributed development. The bazaar not the cathedral.

* GNU HURD was trying to do 2 things at the same time: _both_ be a GPL Unix _and_ be a pioneering new microkernel Unix-like OS.

* Minix 1 & 2 weren't FOSS. Being able to see the source does _not_ mean something is FOSS.

* Minix 3 came later and did what the HURD was trying to do.

Linux succeeded for 2 or more reasons.

1. It's GPL. Blessing or curse, you are obliged to share your work.

2. KISS principle: there's a whole industry of proprietary monolithic Unixes. Let's do a GPL one.

The core point you don't even mention is that Linux copied late-1980s Unix, including BSD, and made something as good but GPL.

Then the BSDs are trying to do the same, but in a BSD license context, and that's much harder and results in lots of forks. That's bad.

Linux has spent ~30 years evolving into its own thing: a modern graphical Unix which scales higher up and further down than any other OS in history ever did.

Now this leaves FreeBSD with catching up to do.

Not in scaling, not in underlying capabilities, but in the user facing stuff, like containerised GUI apps, nice easy installers, nice easy management front ends.

It can do this stuff, but the bits are all spread around... rich containerisation, and a Linux runtime, and a GUI layer, but it needs works to bring 2 of them together for containerised GUI apps. Then if they do it right, the ability to run Linux GUI containerised apps will more or less pop out for free.

> How about more from Plan 9, Haiku or AmigaOS?

I don't think 9front has a statement, or not yet. There is one person in the Reddit 9front who keeps posting new stuff that is bot-extruded. The users in there are not keen.

Haiku & AROS both have strong anti-LLM statements and I approve.

> Or maybe something new?

Great. Love to see it. Let's have it.

LLMs can't program. They can emit reams of code-like text but writing the code is the easiest bit of programming.

A lot of programmers apparently can't tell and that scares the hell out of me. But I don't program and won't touch LLMs so maybe I am missing something.

LLMs don't help review code, and _that_ is the hard part of distributed collaborative development.

But they are pretty good at translating. The more closely the better.

LLM translations of existing OSes into new forms could be great.

MacOS 8.1 for old low-spec models of Raspberry Pi? Cool, let's have it. Ignore the PowerPC stuff.

Translate the MacOS 8.5/8.6 nanokernel and run MacOS 9.2.2 on top? Much harder. No clear separation.

If someone could say modernise Multiuser DOS and make it work on a 21st century machine, I would love that. Slap a DESQview style windowing system on top? Joy!

Better still, slap a reverse-engineered X/GEM on top.

Mac lookalikes multiply as Linux raids Apple's wardrobe

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: All I really want in Linux..

> Linux typically uses the Meta key for MS-DOS era window manager shortcuts. WHY??!

You don't have a Meta key.

WTF are you on about?

Meta means Alt. KDE gets this wrong. But then KDE gets most keyboard shortcuts _Wrong_.

Do you mean Super?

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: Excellent

> round up, thank you. Have you a favourite?

Thanks for that!

No, I do not. I only tried LordOS and it's not for me, for some reasons including some ones in the comments here.

I like the idea of a much-enhanced Xfce as the basis, and if someone did this on top of vanilla Alpine or Devuan or something, keeping it very minimal, then it could be great... but for now, the only one that even looks close to that is maybe Desert OS. I may try that and give it a proper review.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: mac wheezer

> Why no kudos for Elementary OS? It is very pretty in a Mac-like way.

I am torn on ElementaryOS.

When I first wrote about it, I said it was based on GNOME but prettier. I was wrong, and we ran a correction. It's its own indepenent desktop, called Pantheon and available on other OSes.

I had read it was Mac-like. It is not, if you know anything about Macs. It's *APPLE* like. This is not the same thing.

BMW, say, makes cars and also makes bikes. If you were to say that a new car was BMW-like and you meant BMW bikes not BMW cars then you ought to:

[a] know the bloody difference

[b] spell that difference out very clearly.

Elementary uses Apple terms, e.g. "Command" and the looped-cross symbol, but its UI is not like macOS at all.

* There is no menu bar

* There are no global menus (absolutely core part of the MacOS experience for 42 years and more if you count the Lisa)

* There are no status indicators in the menu bar aside from the very few bundled ones -- and you can't add any

It doesn't have a filesystem you can lay out yourself; it decides where apps go, not you.

It doesn't let you move the dock around easily, or pin it at one end as early Mac OS X did. I don't bloody want it at the bottom, ever, under any circumstances. It's a pretty dock and I think it is related to Plank, but there are _lots_ of Linux docks and most of the others are more customisable and more flexible than this one. I want it at the side, I want groups in it, I want submenus, I want indicators and monitors in it. I also want my own icons in the top panel and I want menus in there, or a tiny panel that doesn't waste a whole strip of my screen. I can't have any of these.

It doesn't let you download and install your own software easily. No Debian packages by default, only the App Store, and that is Flatpak only.

All these things are unlike Macs, but what they *are* like is iPadOS.

The top panel isn't a menu bar, it's a fixed almost functionless vestige of one and a very wasteful clock -- like the iPhone.

The looks are similar to Apple looks, but without most of the keyboard UI and the functionality -- like the iPhone.

Apps only come from the App Store and it decides where they go and it just gives you a launcher -- like the iPhone.

It's all an iPad-like experience and I don't like iPads.

It is maybe the single most beautiful Linux desktop there is, and it's clean and elegant and works and does the job. Its bundled apps are very simple and not rich in functionality. Jailbreaking it is as easy as opening a terminal. Then you can install your own apps the old-fashioned way, using `apt` or even `dpkg`.

I tried to daily-drive it for a while. I installed all my personal apps, as native Debian and Ubuntu packages. I tried to configure it for my dual screen use. I don't use any of the built in apps except the file manager and the terminal emulator. Then I started to realise I wanted to replace them, and the dock too, and I realised that really I wanted to change almost everything, and in that case, then why use Elementary at all?

I like ElementaryOS!

It is a great distro for the sort of user who can happily do almost all of their computing on an iPad. It's simple and clean and elegant, in a way EndlessOS used to be but isn't any more. It would be a good basis for a FOSS ChromeOS sort of distro.

Me, if I tried to do my job on an iPad, I'd scream and break the thing over my knee and throw it through the nearest window, even if still shut, before lunchtime.

It's great but it's not for me.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: As a Macbook user...

> If their machines weren't so locked down and I could run what I like on it, I'd probably buy one.

No, I don't accept this.

I like macOS. I am typing on an M1 MBA. I did put Asahi on it, fairly early on when they started doing regular releases alongside Fedora, and IMHO, KDE looks _so_ bad and _so_ amateurish compared to macOS that I laughed sadly, in a very pitying way, and after a couple of releases nuked it and reclaimed the disk space.

But the point is, *you can*.

You can currently run half a dozen other distros on the Asahi foundations: you don't need to have Fedora. You can have Debian or Ubuntu if you want. But it's optimised for Wayland so for now X.org is allegedly poor and flakey... and since there are no cross-distro desktops I really like on Wayland, I'm not tempted. The only 2 I find usable at all are COSMIC and the Raspberry Pi Desktop, and I don't think there are any ready-to-use COSMIC packages for Arm64.

Or, you can run OpenBSD on it.

You _do_ have choices.

Both this M1 Mac and my own personal x86 iMac only have my 1996 Apple account with no payment method on it. A few things throw errors but they are things I don't want, like Apple Music.

I don't have _any_ paid Apple apps, no paid digital content, no streaming accounts, nothing. It's all mine, and apart from Chrome, Slack, and some other freeware, and one decade-old version of MS Word, and only Word no other Office apps, it's all FOSS apps. You can install whatever you want, no blocks or hindrances.

Don't believe the haters. Macs are not iPads.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

> How long have you got?

Well it was to a large extent a rhetorical question. ;-)

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: if you’re doing macos looks

> is the 10.6.8 era look and feel but running on modern hardware

Ooh, good point, well made. Yes please!

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: 26 may not be the end for Intel

> So, it's been the general consensus that macOS 26 would be the end for Intel hardware with OCLP. And it probably is with the current OCLP devs.

They have finally cracked the T2 requirements and have it working now. I haven't tried but I prefer to wait for final release stuff.

> But I'm starting to hear noises that it may not really be the end. I've seen rumors that progress is being made on putting Intel code back in macOS 27, at least one report that it's at least partially booting on Intel now.

I haven't seen that.

I thought about mentioning this, but I was under a lot of time pressure yesterday and decided not to in favour of getting the story in: I _have_ seen signs of progress in cracking Arm64 binaries and prizing Apple Arm kit slightly more open: I've seen both demos of Android on iPhone kit, and iOS booting on 3rd party Arm64 kit. It is not totally beyond the bounds of possibility that someone will find a way to run Arm macOS on non-Apple Arm kit... but I reckon that's likelier than somehow crowbarring x86 support back into an OS that had it removed. I could well be wrong of course.

> Anyway, these look interesting. But I'd be pretty hesitant to trust an OS that has what look like jesus freak overtones, calling something "lord" OS with a triple point crown logo or that style fish logo are kinda red flags.

I strolled casually away from christianity in the late 1970s and I'm not familiar with the symbolism, so I don't know what you mean. Can you explain for the benefit of other such heathens, please?

Crowd fave Linux Mint update approaches, fresh from autumn release of Cinnamon desktop

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: Hit a bork within 5 minutes.

> Back to windows for me.

1. Don't use Brave.

2. Don't use Flatpak.

Problem solved, permanently.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: Mate!

> I hope there's a Mate release!

There will be, and Xfce as well.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

> That will further reduce the load of the team.

I am baffled by your comment.

Everything they change from upstream Ubuntu is something that they have to maintain themselves. So using a different kernel from upstream Ubuntu means more work, not less.

openSUSE Leap 16.1 gives Linux users the right to remain immutable

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

> I stuck with RH for a few years, but eventually jumped ship to Ubuntu

If you're right about 1997 then more than a few years: at least 7 years.

I don't remember the first RHL with a graphical installer but they were _extremely_ rare until the noughties. The first ever was Caldera OpenLinux.

The first version of Ubuntu was 4.10 in October 2004. As you say it had a text-mode installer.

I think the next version, 5.04, had a graphical live CD but you couldn't install it, plus an installer CD.

Then something like 5.10 had a graphical installer on the live CD so you could try the GNOME 2 desktop, use it to connect to networks or whatever, and then launch the installer from the same enviroment.

Then came 6.06, the first LTS and the only time it ever slipped so badly: it was originally intended to be 6.04 but wasn't release until June.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: >SUSE is better than Red Hat

> This isn't quite our experience, although it would be wrong to say that there is a world of difference between both.

Thanks for this. An insightful contribution. It is a shame you chose to be an AC because I'd like to discuss this further.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

> considering it a RedHat-based distribution

It is not. No version of SUSE has ever been based on any RH product.

Do not be misled by the use of RPM: that is a cross-distro packaging system, and although it uses the underlying raw RPM package files, SUSE does not use the higher-level management tools from RH (`yum` or `dnf`). SUSE has its own, called `zypper`. This recursively resolves and installs dependencies and it's an independent, separately-developed tool.

Zypper is to DNF as APT is to DEB. Apt does not directly handle DEBs -- it calls dpkg underneath. Zypper calls RPM. Zypper is completely independently built from DNF, the modern RH tool.

Mandrake *is* derived from RH: it started out as RHL+KDE. It evolved in its own way and at one point used its own recursive dependency-resolving packaging front-end URPMI but several of the surviving descendants of Mandriva use DNF now.

Sometimes you can install largely self-contained RPM packages from Fedora or RHEL on SUSE but it's not something to rely on. SUSE has its own config files in its own places, and is built with its own tools.

I've been using SUSE on and off since about 1998, coming to it a year or two _after_ Red Hat Linux, which I tried after failing to install Slackware in about 1996. (As it happens the first distro I got running was Lasermoon Linux/FT, a now mostly forgotten very early graphical live CD.)

After nearly 30 years of experience with both: SUSE is better than Red Hat, and it always has been. Its tools are more mature and more feature-rich, it's more reliable, and it has a better process for managing external 3rd party drivers.

I have been using Ubuntu on my own machines since 2004, but I moved to Ubuntu from SUSE, and for years I kept SUSE around just for configuring graphics cards -- I would then copy the X11 config files into Ubuntu. Its admin tools are second to none in the industry and they have been for as long as such tools have existed. Its documentation is also pretty much the best in the industry.

SUSE is *not* Red Hat derived. Its very earliest roots are in a fork of Slackware, but it's been its own thing for 30 years.

And frankly, it's better than RH.

Fedora 45 is finally finished and fit

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: ..... its new next-generation text console, which is a welcome change. .....

> You're confused. Linux is the kernel, what you're thinking of is X Windows, a program which runs on Linux. The console is the "standard Linux terminal", and this console certainly wasn't ported from X Windows.

It was not my comment but I think you are profoundly misreading nim@nim's comment to which you were replying here.

The meaning was plain to me:

[kmscons] is a port of [a standard Linux terminal] to the console.

All your stuff about kernels and Xterm is irrelevant guff.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: re: buggy or absent

Both agree and disagree.

> Fedora is not touted as being 'Production Ready'. AFAIK, it is a Beta level test bed of technology that may (or may not) get into future versions of RHEL.

Agreed.

> By the time that the next version is about to become available, many of the bugs that annoyed us at release, have been resolved.

An interesting take, but TBH I am not usually that patient.

> I had hoped that this release would have a working version of XFCE and/or Cinnamon that uses Wayland and not XOrg.

Hmm. Not something I care about but it's getting close.

Of course both are available and both have Spins. Both use X.org.

Cinnamon 6.8 just came out and it supports Wayland, finally in non-experimental form. So you'll get your wish in time and I would guess that will be released in Fedora 46.

openSUSE has Xfce on Wayland, and it works. Labwc looked indistinguishable -- the only difference was no keyboard shortcuts for window size manipulation. Everything else that I could see was identical.

Saying that, I'm getting quite fond of tiling interfaces now. COSMIC especially. I will be rather interested if someone can bolt a conservative flexible tiling Wayland compisitor onto Xfce...

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: ..... its new next-generation text console, which is a welcome change. .....

> There are over seventy options to be set in its configuration file. But basic functionality is buggy or absent.

Absolutely standard for RH-backed product development, then. Unix philosophy? We've heard of it and we make fun of the idea.

https://www.theregister.com/software/2024/06/13/version-256-of-systemd-boasts-42-less-unix-philosophy/313657

So, if we are lucky, and it does sometimes work, what happens is:

* status quo holds for years, every accepts problems because they're used to them

* disruptor comes along and fixes the problems, while of course introducing a tonne of new ones

* original gets fixed, eliminating use case for new fancy tool

> This contrasts markedly with the older kernel console, which just did the Right Thing without having (or needing) a config file.

The reason I linked to Laptop Ultravision is that in DOS in the 1980s I could switch screen modes, from the CLI, on the fly: MODE CO80 or CO40 or MONO

LTUV added graphics-based "fake" text modes to that and while they didn't work in DESQview or other fancy 386 tools, they worked for ordinary DOS apps.

I want that back, dammit. I used it a lot. Linux and BSD can't do it, while everyone venerates and worships the text UI.

Bring it back and you can freely burn kmscon in a fire and I will not grieve.

> and make sure the GPM mouse daemon was running.

I could count the number of distros that do that on the fingers of one hand. Possibly of one foot.

GhostBSD 26.2 takes the fright out of FreeBSD with a friendlier installer

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: Gershwin

> Main dev Eric Turgeon was quickly on to this and found the problem straight away - a new release should follow shortly

Oh, good work on both counts!

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: Gershwin

> A little disappointed to hear about the lack of Gershwin in this release.

Me too, but it was not a great "fit" with the GhostBSD distro IMHO.

That's why I focussed on it last time around.

> Even though my daily driver today is XFCE, and will most likely remain so, I was curious to see how Gershwin handles. I can say similar things about the forthcoming Mocka.

Same.

> How manageable is it to switch desktops in GhostBSD?

I have not tried. I would expect similar to in Linux but a bit more manual. E.g. BSD display managers tend not to ask which desktop to launch.

In other words: better off trying on Linux I suspect.

'Mother of all editors' Emacs is 50

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: Suggestion

> You can even write edlines with it.

Kindle leave the stage.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

> Somewhat outdated info.

Not really "info".

A joke. Yes an outdated one, but then again, see the earlier comments about how much 8MB of RAM cost for a VAX.

(A PDP-11 couldn't address that much RAM, I think...)

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: Gosling emacs?

> uEMACS was built for micro computers,

Linus still maintains his own personal fork.,

https://github.com/torvalds/uemacs

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: Gosling emacs?

> I thought it was pre-gnu???

No, it came later. That's why I didn't mention it: it doesn't push the timeline back.

AFAICT:

Gosmacs was a lightweight partial clone of Emacs after Emacs got established, but while it was still a bit big and heavy for many computers.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

> And you consider that an improvement?

You are missing the key point.

The car's *UI* is an improvement, yes.

I can't turn my right hand any more. I don't need to keep taking my left hand (my dominant hand) off the wheel to change gear. That's a big win. It is not a performance car. I am not doing racing changes. I don't want or need that.

My wife is Czech and right-handed. She is not used to taking _her_ dominant hand off the wheel to change gear. Driving on the wrong side of the road for her, she has enough to think about. This is an improvement for her, too.

Simpler controls that do all the essentials you need are better, yes.

I am not arguing with you here. Your points are valid.

My boss at Red Hat used JEdit on a Maltron keyboard. Phenominal editing power. He had a single keystroke for moving a line up or down. Very clever. I need that so seldom, I do not need a key for it, and I definitely do not need to learn a new editor just for that.

A new UI has to be remarkably good to replace the existing perfectly functional UI which I know.

For me, this is where Emacs fails, and Vim fails, and Hyprland, and Miracle-WM, and almost every other new WM I've seen in 15 years fails.

We have something that works. Start with that, and improve that.

My car starts with the 3-pedals, clutch-and-gear-lever model, and it improves it. It removes the clutch pedal, simplifies the gear lever beyond any ICE auto box because I don't have 1 or 2 settings, and yet, it does the same job... simpler.

When I use a little throttle, the petrol engine stays off, and it uses the electric motor, whose torque is largely independent of revs, so I don't need 1 and 2 "low gears" any more.

Hyprland et all remove all the pedals, all the levers, and give me a joystick and a yoke and 100 concealed buttons, and tell me to relearn. Get lost. I don't want to.

COSMIC gives me a panel, and a dock, or combined, and a file manager and a desktop... but press a button and it's tiling. No more window management. That is a good compromise.

Back to text editors...

I do not need Emacs for occasionally editing my config files or once in a blue moon writing a script.

I write Markdown and Panwriter does that and little else, and it can import and export from anything thanks to Pandoc. It's clean and it's simple and it shows me if I mess up my Markdown. That is all I need.

I could use Ghostwriter or Gram or a dozen others if I needed, or if I didn't have 32GB of RAM... but I do, and on this old iMac, Panwriter is fast, so I use it.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: Viper

> It had a plain text editing mode that was quite widely used for coding in pre-IDE days

Indeed it did. Most distros today offer `joe`, a very minimal editor that uses the keystrokes.

Unix folks knew Vi keystrokes, Lisp folks knew Emacs ones, and CP/M and DOS folks knew WordStar.

I knew WordStar.

https://www.theregister.com/software/2024/08/06/wordstar-7-the-last-ever-dos-version-re-released-for-free/464207

That does _not_ mean I _miss_ WordStar, because I really do not.

Aside and blatant plug: my little USB-DOS project includes it... and needs an update, but it works.

https://github.com/lproven/usb-dos

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

> Vi and Emacs are more like the early cars when compared to modern software.

Exactly!

Here are the 3 pedals of a Model T Ford:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ford_Model_T#/media/File:Model_T_pedals.jpg

The mean Clutch, Reverse, and Brake.

That reverse pedal is the equivalent of talking about a Meta key in the mid-2020s.

We have moved on. Time to join everyone else.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

> My car then had a gas pedal, brake pedal, a clutch pedal, and a gearshift then and it worked just fine.

Oh, cool, retro stuff. Nice. Does it have a choke as well? Can you advance or retard the ignition? Crank to start it when the battery's flat?

Mine just has "go" and "stop" pedals, and the stick pretty much says "go forwards", "go backwards", "park" and a fairly useless option that in theory puts it into neutral, but as I discovered when the little 12V battery died, is electronically operated so doesn't work at all.

Luckily it still has manual door handles.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: Viper

> So you're saying that Emacs *does* actually include a decent text editor?

Nah -- it's Vi.

Wake me up when it includes MS-DOS Edit emulation.

I traded in my muscle memory of Wordstar, Wordperfect, Locoscript, The Last Word, Tasword, Displaywrite, MultiMate, and even Edlin. I have no desire to learn another proprietary system now. I don't write code so all that functionality is of no interest to me.

Now, use its famed versatility to imitate the Canon Cat UI, and I will wake up and pay attention.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: An agnostic caught between Eastern and Western orthodoxies

You repeat yourself regarding Kedit, which I think is a sign of how important it is to you. :-)

What is "Gmacs"? Is this an abbreviation for GNU Emacs?

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: €2,998!!!!

> Gee, what are these keyboards made out of?

I spoke with the chap that runs it. His postal address was within walking distance of my place in Prague. (A long walk and actually I'd have cycled or taken the tram, but it was possible. It was about 20 min away.)

Sadly, as I was hoping to do an interview and Geek's Guide, it's a forwarding address and he's the other end of the country. Ah well.

It's mainly the hand-cast keycaps, apparently. He reckons on a cost-per-hour basis they'd be €75 each or something in that vicinity.

Getting the weight, feel, and etched legends is very tricky... and the key switches are almost unobtainium these days too.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

> one of thr few people who hates the old editors

Why do you think I wrote the article about _not_ making you work like it's 1976?

I mean the clue is right there in the title.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: Viper

> emacs even contains a vi emulation

You did read as far as the part about Spacemacs, right?

AlpineBSD announced – an AI-free FOSS OS

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: Meh, I say. Meh.

> whether you need KDE or GNOME

"Need" isn't questionable. This isn't a tool for corporate rollouts, and for lone ranger types, no, you don't _need_ either.

But FOSS people are full of very strong feelings and opinions. Need, no. _Want_, yes. They fight over text editors!

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: Thanks for the Article, But.....

Certainly!

https://www.theregister.com/security/2026/10/30/in-the-year-ai-re-wrote-the-infosec-rulebook-its-comforting-to-know-crypto-exchanges-still-have-bad-security/5306539

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: If you want NetBSD, use NetBSD

> NetBSD's userland is also small

That's one of the snags. Small, missing important tools, doesn't have current versions of things like KDE or GNOME. Alpine does.

> The FreeBSD kernel (as used in a Debian distro)

It was -- dev ended in 2023:

https://wiki.debian.org/Debian_GNU/kFreeBSD?pow_referer=

But you are missing the points about both the kernel and the userland here.

FreeBSD has failed to vote against LLM code, and with the work that JKH is doing in Daemonarchy:

https://www.theregister.com/os-platforms/2026/10/27/freebsd-founder-ports-omarchy-to-freebsd-in-ten-days-ten-releases/5305446

... It now looks very clear that it will _not_ block or bar LLM-generated code.

The whole reason for picking the NetBSD kernel is that it's slop-free. FreeBSD is not suitable because it is not.

The reason for picking the Alpine userland is that it's slop-free, it's small and already works with Busybox and Musl libc, so it's known not to depend on GNU stuff, so it should be adaptable.

We'll see if it works out.

I am slowly slightly moderating my anti-LLM stance. Things I use every day are using LLMs and I can't avoid them completely, although I do try.

I have now also seen the first LLM-emitted project that has genuinely impressed me:

https://www.theregister.com/os-platforms/2026/10/27/zacos-9-and-mavernix-two-classic-apple-desktops-find-their-wayland-to-linux/5305710

However, I like and approve of diversity, and freedom of choice, and freedom of expression.

I think it's great that some people are saying no to LLM use and forking projects to keep them handcrafted.

I am very happy for the botlickers to stride boldly off into the bright machine-assisted future that they envision.

Me, personally, I think that in a year or so, the entire LLM bubble will collapse and all the cloud LLM vendors will vanish like the morning dew on a hot day. There is, tragically, a significant chance the PROC will invade the ROC and even if big China fails to successfully annex little China, the chip makers will be disrupted.

But it's not just Taiwan. The AMOC is teetering on collapse. Much of the tropics is going to become uninhabitable well within a human generation (that's 25Y for reference). A lot of chips are made in the tropics, in Thailand and Malaysia.

That is going to get disrupted too.

Computers and their parts may never get cheap again.

They may never get faster again.

They may start getting slower. We will have to keep using older, slower ones for longer.

The sloppers are going to find that their costs go up by a factor of 10, then another one, and then another one.

Suddenly LLM-assisted dev will get much harder and slower and more expensive. The fancy GPUs and the CPUs with tensor accelerators will not come. Local LLMs will not get faster. Their training will become insupportably expensive.

This problem is self-limiting.

The people with the skills to do dev and debug the old way, by eye and by hand, with their carefully-cultivated slop-free codebases, will end up winning.

And if I am wrong? Great. Free software for everyone and the bots can ensmarten themselves, embiggen their artificial minds, and solve global warming and take us to Mars. Yay, hurrah, cheers, doubles all round!

LibreOffice's 'no AI' stance meets LLM-assisted code

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: Is that a bad thing?

> Office 2007 did have some noticeable improvements

Such as? Genuinely curious here.

In 2014-2015 I worked at an all-MS house. I used Office 365 and did a lot of work with a web interface to a customer database.

I found that selecting a block of cells but accidentally _not_ including the last would always, 100% of the time, crash Excel if I pasted in a non-rectangular range.

Luckily I had local admin rights, so I just installed LibreOffice and used that instead.

I had no real alternative but to use Outlook back then -- now, Thunderbird can do it, but not then -- but nobody noticed. I received Office docs, edited them, annotated or changed them, and sent them back. Not one person in a year could ever tell.

"Not compatible enough" my left kidney.

I am not totally ignorant of the wretched suite. Back in the 20th century I professionally trained people on how to use Word and Excel. I left them for good reasons, not ignorance.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: Practicalities?

> how would we expect the TDF to be able to "police" submissions

Why does it matter?

Do we ask if we can enforce speed limits, before setting them?

The rule, and the ethics, matter more than detection or enforcement.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: High-quality discussions

> I mean if you're under the impression that Mastodon, of all places, is where the low quality discussions are, you've definitely lost some cred right off the bat.

Exactly!

Masto has taken the place of Google+ as where the geek community hangs out. Sure there are trolls and ragebait but less than anywhere else.

A Reg commenter, Graham Perrin, recently said to me that he prefers Reddit as there's less trolling there. That is bizarre: this is the exact *opposite* of what I find.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: Is that a bad thing?

> basic quality-of-life features that were added to Microsoft Office 20 years ago

This one made me stop.

QOL stuff in Office in 20Y?

Well, I wouldn't have seen it. I ditched MS Office 19Y ago because of the Ribbon.

Office 2007 was the final straw, when the enshittification became too much.

But I only used it then for Word, and I only use Word for Outline Mode.

So I usually run Word from Office 97.

You can see a fresh copy in the screenshot here:

https://www.theregister.com/os-platforms/2026/10/24/raspberry-pi-desktop-proves-old-pcs-arent-past-it/5304676

So never mind 20Y, for me it is 30Y.

Rhetorical point here -- bear with me:

From 29Y ago to 19Y ago I can tell you *ALL* the new quality of life features that matter to me in the entirety of MS Office. (Because for me that means Word.)

* Nested tables: you can put a table inside 1 cell of a table.

* Highlighter: you can swipe over text to call it out with a virtual yellow marker pen.

The end. That's it.

I don't use either but Word 97 can't do either and crashes on nested tables. Highlights just vanish.

I keep Word 2003 around on some boxes because it can do 2 things 97 can't:

1. The Office 2007 File Convertor Pack works. It can open .DOCX files perfectly.

2. It supports high-DPI screens and portrait mode screens in WINE.

So, those are the improvements I know of from 1997 to 2007, covering Office 97, Office 2000, Office XP, Office 2003, and Office 2007.

It is not a long list and so it was easy to remember.

What are yours? What are you missing? Please, name some of these QOL features or improvements I have never seen since the Worsening Of Life features drove me away.

I am sincerely, honestly, _very_ curious.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: Seems some are getting confused…

> with nuts it is very clear... there is a real risk

Fair.

But this is a clear difference.

Nobody _chooses_ a food allergy.

Modern software is almost universally bloated crap, written in either unsuitable languages, or languages built in unsuitable languages.

C is crap. C was crap in 1969 and it is worse now. But I have been told to go and kill myself for saying that.

The people that invented C and Unix spent the next quarter of a century fixing their mistakes and making it better, and a big part of that was getting rid of C.

Early versions of Plan 9 were in C, then Ritchie and Thompson invented Aleph and moved to that. Even that niche experimental academic OS got pushback and they went back to C for later versions.

Then Inferno, UNIX 3, banished C forever, replacing it with Limbo.

How much Inferno do we see? None. It doesn't even have a continuation like 9front.

C is crap. Everything built on C is crap. If the new wave of LLM vuln finders burn the entire C industry to ashes, I will gleefully damp down those smoking cinders with my own body fluids. (Trying to be decorous.)

The thing here is that right now, bots can find bugs. Whether they can _fix_ them well is not yet clear but by Jove they can find them faster than ever. So objecting to bots on safety grounds -- the nut allergy comparison -- does not stand.

But the veg*n comparison is "I want my diet to be free of ingredients of this specific origin".

Not for survival, not for health... from choice and from ethics.

LLMs are unethical. They are built on theft, enrich oligarchs, destroy jobs and minds, and their use and their training are boiling the oceans at the worst time for that in the evolutionary history of _Homo sapiens_.

There is no ethical use of LLMs.

So wanting LLM-free code is an ethical choice, not a life-or-death allergy requirement.

Like being veg*n -- as opposed to being allergic to peanuts.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: Seems some are getting confused…

> I find it mind boggling that... your rebuttal... is getting downvotes.

Thank you for that.

I do, too. But there's a Pratchettian feeling of narrative inevitability to it. I like being a veggie. I am very slightly proud of being a veggie. It's not hard, but still, it impresses some people (notably my mum) that I chose it and stuck to it for 45 years.

But people hate veg*ns and we all live with constant background abuse from the hard-of-thinking.

Ubuntu 27.04 may bring a preview of the long-awaited Core Desktop

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: Linux, OpenZFS

> I remain mildly surprised that Oracle hasn't been more heavy-handed about lobbing lawsuits at Linuxes shipping ZFS.

Recommended watching:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-zRN7XLCRhc

And note, I hate videos as a format for info.

Cantrill eloquently spells out the case that you must not anthropomorphise Oracle _or Ellison_.

Neither is a rational actor.

Fortunately, soon, when the AI bubble pops, it won't be an actor at all, it'll be a historical footnote.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: Good luck with that...

> RAM and storage prices

LXC is good at hybrid contrainers that act like VMs. This is exactly what you want when storage is expensive: it's much more resource-frugal than full VMs.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

Re: Good luck with that...

> That's a very limited use case

I am honestly not so sure.

Transparent containers which transparently map to your home directory, R/W distro boxes, and so on... OS-integrated virtualisation, thanks to LXC... it really could work.

Liam Proven (Written by Reg staff) Silver badge

> That sounds like a soon to be vacant niche ready to be filled if they get their act together.

Agreed.

I was going to look into GooglebookOS and write about it, but virtually all the existing info is "AI! AI! AI! AI!"

I use Android daily and quite like it, but I don't want anything that is all AI all the time.

> Just don't tie it to some specific vendor for login.

Well, Ubuntu One is the obvious back-end, but with any luck -- they're not daft -- then any cloud drive that can store some files would do: Dropbox, Nextcloud, Owncloud, and gods help us, MS/FAANG. (I don't reckon Amazon fits, but the rest do.)