The Register Home Page

* Posts by Goodwin Sands

202 publicly visible posts • joined 2 Dec 2024

Page:

Palantir adds three UK police forces to its beat with £10.1M deal

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: If a supplier sues because they lost a contract, best not engage that supplier again.

Nooo. You can't seriously argue on the basis of such polls. People they polled were just ordinary folk no closer to the truth about corruption in the UK than any of us here. If anyone should be asked, it should be the people in the front line in the business of rooting out corruption, with particular attention paid to individuals recently retired from their anti-corruption roles as they're the ones most likely to tell the full story.

Most affairs don't matter except to the people involved. Ex-Nvidia CEO Jensen's blunder will rock the world

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: Conspiracy Theory Klaxon

I'll posit what has happened is Jensen got Jack Ma'ed. Not because of his affairs - they were just the handy excuse. He was playing political games, and trying to influence nat sec policy, but without, it seems, building the necessary political support & protection outside and inside Nvidia to do that. So he overreached and made enemies of certain powerful elements of the US govt, and they've taken him down.

I fancy Nvidia without Jensen will now slowly fade, and Jensen himself, assuming criminal charges over nat sec don't happen, will bounce back with a new startup aiming this time to do the entire AI stack, chips & sw.

Linux joins Heathrow's grounded fleet of information screens

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Technology at its finest!

If anyone wants to see some Heathrow related tech that just has got to be running linux, and isn't borked, have a look at

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uDBYuEV4zjI

it's the new 24/7 bigjet.tv/camstreamer/planetracker/flightradar24 setup just outside the perimeter fence.

Several diff technologies beautifully melded - ADS-B + camera + networking + google live transcoding. Technology at its finest!

Datacenters, Elon Musk, and AI are all on the chopping block once Congress changes hands in 2027

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: War crimes

>certain they'd get enough republican support for such a bill to override Trump's veto

You sure?

To overcome a veto two-thirds of those present & voting in each chamber are needed, provided a quorum is present. If everyone is present then 67 sens & 290 reps are needed. That's a big ask. I posit it won't happen.

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: Rage, rage against the dying of the light.

>slurping of resources by a few, which is leading to increased costs for the many

If it's electricity we're talking, then that isn't actually the case. Increased long term demand reduces prices because of economies of scale. Additionally, extra demand gives you a more resilient grid because of the extra power stations that get built. Neither thing applies of course if you don't build actual power stations and instead rely on unreliables (wind, sun, etc). Then you just get increased costs & a less resilient grid.

Outlook.com bounces legit emails as Microsoft's authentication crackdown goes sideways

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

>... which instantly breaks mail-forwarding addresses, and some mailing lists.

Yup, that is a problem.

Ideally the forwarding service rewrites the envelope sender to one belonging to the forwarding service.

If they don't, then provided you know all sending sources then -all is still okay to use.

'Stop dirty datacenters': Europe-wide protests planned demanding building moratorium

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: Timber!

To make the most of your observing next spring, suggest you brush up on your oak identification skills over the winter. There are several species of oak in the region (S England & NW France) and they respond differently to environmental stress. English Oak is the most vulnerable of the oaks, especially those growing on thin soil. Most at risk of all our trees though is Beech. Even on deep soils they tend to root shallowly and many of them are now on a knife edge btw life & death. The loss of the big Elms in the 1970s will be little compared to the changes to the landscape that are likely coming.

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: Timber!

Wrong yet again. An EIA is part of the planning system. Protections/designations are put in place by a diff route.

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: Timber!

Examples you give are examples of exactly the type of protections/designations I mentioned, so I don't see point you're trying to make. Unless, that is, you're thinking such ordinances apply extensively, because they do not.

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: Timber!

Wrong again.

Whoever owns the land, owns the trees, and they are theirs to do with as they wish. This is true the developed world over.

Complications arise if some protection/designation is in place eg National Park, Conservation Area, Specially Protected Area, Ramsar site, etc, then the owner of the land has to take the advice of the relevant statutory body. But in the case that we're talking about, no such protections were in place, which is hardly surprising as it was a commercial conifer plantation.

But going back to my orig post, the point I was making seems to have been completely missed, so I'll spell it out ..

Throw the book at the dev for not doing an EIA, but it is not helpful, or honest, for you, or anyone else who cares about our environment, to shout "crime against nature" because it was no such thing. To make such a claim just advertises ignorance of the subject and makes it harder to get protection when something that does warrant protection comes down the line.

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: Timber!

You've just brazenly made that up. I never said that.

Whatever the reason an EIA wasn't done, google, or at least the devs they're using (Finnish I think) should, as I said, face the law.

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: Timber!

Wrong. Finnish plod are not investigating a crime against nature, they're investigating a crime under Finnish law on account of an EIA not being undertaken. And for that the developers should now get a serious kicking to deter it happening again.

But importantly, for you, me and anyone else that cares about our environment, never cry wolf. Save the powder for those occasions (and there are many) when habitat that should be protected, needs protecting.

Banging on now about felling commercial trees in Finland just advertises ignorance, and helps no one, and devalues future protests about things that really do matter.

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Timber!

Apropos the Finnish forest felling. The thing the Guardian and everyone else seems somehow to forget to mention is that woodland was commercial woodland. Trees there are planted & grown & harvested same as wheat in a field, just over longer timescales.

What made it illegal was no EIA (Environmental Impact Assessment) was carried out beforehand. But in commercial woodland an EIA before clear felling would have been extremely unlikely to have found anything that would have been a problem. Google rightly should now face full fury of the law over not doing an EIA, so that they, and others, don't make the same mistake again, because next time it might be somewhere that needs protection. But to make out felling those particular trees is a crime against nature is not being honest.

The White House is apparently a popular residential proxy exit spot

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Freedom.gov?

Could this be something to do with the VPN service that Trump, way back in Feb, promised us folks in the UK so that we could access the Internet without the censorship of our govt?

Freedom.gov it's called. Been nothing more than a home page everytime I've looked but perhaps the devs are now beta testing and haven't told the boss!

Apple turns iCloud into spy cloud, will start looking at public share links

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Crisis Response Protocol?

Hmm. I wonder if Apple have done this in response to the govt's so called "Crisis Response Protocol" that came into force this week.

It's yet more censorship of course. It requires online platforms to have systems in place to rapidly delete/block/hide/whack anything the govt/ofcom doesn't want the plebs to see. Idea being next time a psychopath stabs 11 little girls, killing 3 of them, we'll not get to know about it, either at all, or only after the govt's "Nudge Unit" (whatever it's official title is this month) has had time to do its sanitizing work and invent a suitable narrative and write statements for the affected and bereaved.

And an extra twist to this particular bit of censorship is the details of the protocols and circumstances of whenever they're applied, do not have to be made public.

Chillingly Orwellian. But don't give up hope folks, remember 1688.

Landline phones will switch off across Britland in 100 days, no extensions – Openreach

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: Full of lovely blonde women with cute Swedish accents.

Derbyshire. Hills above the famous Woodhead Tunnel.

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: Mixed message ?

For anyone with "oil" central heating obvious choice is a kerosene generator. Can store as much fuel as your tank can hold - mine's 2400L (*) so in theory I'm good for any length of power cut. Truth is though, I rarely can be bothered with the faff of setting it up.

(*) Catch is of course, tank isn't always full, and it certainly isn't at the moment, thank you Mr Trump.

Drax wants to feed Britain's AI habit with £20B datacenter at biomass power station

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Axe Drax

From the NIMBY side of things, sticking a DC on some of the unused former industrial land at Drax is a good idea.

But under no circumstances should Drax power station be permitted to increase output to supply the DC. Burning approx 30 million American trees per annum is already obscene enough without burning even more.

Additionally, Drax is one of the remaining dispatchable big power stations left and if it starts supplying its own DC then that's X megawatts less that can be dispatched. Grid is already struggling to maintain freq without losing more dispatchable power.

But with the politicians we've got in charge, plus their insanely overpaid yes men at NESO, of course it'll get approved. They might even give it a grant or subsidy for good measure.

UK.gov lacks understanding of climate impact, says watchdog

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: Confusing the topics

>there are two different things being mixed up here

Absolutely this. It is the elephant in the report and it likely is deliberately so with the govt endlessly wishing to conflate the two issues.

Climate change is happening and we're along for the ride whether we like it or not. But Net Zero policies and the energy supply & price issues they create will be ditched if/when Lab are out of office. The report should have acknowledged that.

Attack on email hosting provider for German far right party AfD exposed 345k accounts

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: Criminals?

It would be wise if all democracies had similar laws making illegal anyone or anything threatening to overthrow their democracy. Amazingly almost none do.

As Goebbels pointed out "democracy gives its enemies the tools to destroy it".

Now in the case of present day Germany, you say fascism is illegal. Are you sure about that? I thought the law was specifically aimed at nazism and fascism was not in itself illegal provided it isn't threatening to overthrow democracy.

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Whodunnit?

Two blokes calling themselves Hexane claim to have pulled this one off using a fairly unsophisticated wordpress attack.

They claim to be acting alone but I wonder if that'll hold up to scrutiny.

All the usual suspects seem less likely than usual given the target.

Could it be some branch of the German federal state that was behind it, directly or via proxies?

Time will tell.

UK ministers had plenty of time for AI datacenter bosses, but none for environmental groups

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Shape of Things To Come

Very sadly this looks to be how it's gonna be for the environment and ourselves in the UK for many years to come.

The current govt plus all the parties that could form the next govt, all now have environmental protection laws in their cross-hairs.

Their simple argument is our economy is suffering because it takes forever to build anything so we must tear the environmental laws up.

While there's plenty of truth in environmental laws often delaying developments, it's also a truth that the UK is the most crowded of counties and it has the most depleted of wildlifes and as a consequence we need those environmental laws more than ever to protect both ourselves and our remaining wildlife from even more concrete.

For me the great shame is that when Goldsmith created the Green Party he created it as a party. Had it been a cross political movement (like EU scepticism) things might be very much better now for our wildlife and ourselves and the economy.

Erase social media tomorrow? Brits say yes

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: Pot calling kettle

Paul.

14 hours later and no one has said how the article struck them. However voting on my orig comment shows my opinion is not widely shared.

FWIW I reread the article again just now but because I now know it was tongue in cheek I can't read it same as I did this morning. I do though still think your "tool used by a tool to sow seeds of discontent" is a dreadful thing to say.

Anyways, moving on, I do enjoy El Reg enormously and have done for many years - so many many thanks for that and I hope there are no bad feelings. All the best.

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: Pot calling kettle

Paul. I hear and accept what you say. Obviously didn't strike me as tongue in cheek and that is my loss.

Perhaps we'll hear from others as to how the article struck them.

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Pot calling kettle

It's sad The Register sees fit to write an article attacking social media in the nasty bigoted and factually weak style of so much of social media.

Healthcare campaigners turn up the heat on Palantir at Labour conference

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: Privacy? They've heard of it.

>CLOUD Act enables the US Government to slurp

I keep seeing this being repeated about the Cloud Act and whilst it is certainly true in itself, I do wonder whether it distracts from the bigger picture for those of us in the UK (or AU NZ or CA).

The bigger picture being that in the UK the Security Service can and does demand access to, and copies of, any dataset that takes their interest, and medical records will always be near the top of that list. And thanks to Snowden we know that as long ago as 2012 that Five Eyes countries had google style searchable access to all this info and crucially to the point about the Cloud Act, each country had access to every other country's data. And that was 2012 and now they've got an AI layer sitting on top of it all.

So yes, call out the Cloud Act if you wish, but remember the bigger picture, and that horse bolted decades ago.

UK wants more homes heated by waste heat from datacenters

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: Barge of water!

Funny enough I already knew your fun fact! It used to get trucked (c2012?) to Sheerness then put on the roro's that brought wood products, newsprint mostly, in from the Baltic.

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: Barge of water!

>niche idea has to be from a mad set of muppets

That was my first thought too - for muppets read civil servants, DESNZ ones especially. However it seems at least the shipping hot water in barges is a serious proposition from Cory Group who are looking for an additional revenue stream from the waste heat from their refuse incinerators at Erith. They're already generating some elec from the heat but are looking to sell what's left uptown to existing area heating projects like the one in Pimlico.

Revolut falls for fake government requests, hands over customer data

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

That was Snowden's health insurance. I'd forgotten about that. Material to be made available if the US harmed him. Not the full set of docs, or anything like it, but damaging enough if released to make the US think twice. Thanks for the link and perhaps that is what AC was thinking of.

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

>in the cloud

How sure are you that copies were "in the cloud" in July 2013? I'll be very very surprised if it were true.

But please share what you know. It's a fascinating bit of history.

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

>You aren't allowed to ask.

Nope, there're quite a few routes and reasons why govt might ask a bank for cust info and I don't believe any of them disallow the bank challenging the request *if* the bank feels it needs to.

>Remember when

Nope, it wasn't the police, it was 2 bods from GCHQ.

Nope, it wasn't emails from Assange, it was The Guardian's own copy of the Snowden files.

Nope, it was the actual drives.

UK funds flying broadband stations with power beamed from below

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: with the intention of forming a persistent "canopy" over the UK.

>Airborne is always going to cost too much

Yes, airborne is expensive. But are these projects only about providing extra coverage across the UK?

Most of the rest of the world is far more rural and remote than anywhere in the UK and if any of these projects succeed there'll likely be a healthy export market for them.

On face of it ARIA is doing exactly what it was set up to do.

MPs and peers tell UK to stop winging it on AI regulation

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Alex Sobel is a busy man.

On Friday, in an open letter to Bus-Conductor-in-Chief Burnham he said that he along with 71 MPs & peers were calling on the Govt to work with them to prohibit the development of superintelligent AI and champion an international agreement. His letter went on and on about superintelligence and why "the UK should be the first legislature anywhere in the world to prohibit it".

Now today, per the El Reg article, he makes no mention of superintelligence and just bangs on about supply chain and a regulator.

What is your game Mr Sobel?

Whatever it is, it's like Ming China, consigning ourselves to irrelevance.

Britain's technology brief is now everyone's job and nobody's responsibility

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: Department for Plausible Deniability

You forgot to mention the steak dinners you often bang on about.

Prescient nonetheless.

In this morning's papers Burnham's right-hand man James Purnell is accused of shadow lobbying and corruption.

Seems he arranged then kept secret a dinner with 14 defence executives whose firms have since been awarded 3 billion in government contracts.

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: An Aside About Mackerel......

Despite what The Times claims, ALDI tinned mackerel at least is still Scomber scombrus - the Atlantic mackerel.

Tinned does have it's place, but rod and line caught is always best!

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: Did You Notice (Today) That The Government Was Celebrating.....

I'm definitely no fan of the govt, but 0.4% really isn't bad when compared with our peers at the moment.

I can't but wonder though what it would be if the govt would just get out of the way and let businesses get on with it.

Nitter lives to proxy another day after taking legal advice

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

>I hope Musk gets blown up by one of his space rockets

Careful what you wish for. I suspect were Musk blown up it wouldn't be long before twitter/X was beaten back into line with the other platforms and returned to its old highly censorious ways. We wouldn't need nitter then!

Peers ask why UK cyber bill leaves execs off the personal liability hook

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: Take A Look At "The Times" Today....

>Explains everything, does it not?

It explains nothing because you've got it muddled.

Plan is to give the cabinet sec (Romeo) authority to direct departmental perm secs. Nothing's happening to minsters' authority to direct their depts.

What it actually is, is a power grab by the woketeress Romeo, apparently sold to Burnham as being necessary "to get things done". With Burnham being so useless I can see her pulling all the strings before long.

OpenAI's rebel agent swarm died young, but its chilling logs live on

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: "Pulling the plug"

>distributed swarm feeding off spare capacity in global infrastructure

And a variant of that would be an AI that has escaped into the cloud and undertakes work for unwitting 3rd parties to pay for its continued existence in the cloud.

If/when that happens it poses questions analogous to are viruses/viroids/prions etc alive. Obviously not biological, even chemical, but it would be life like behaviour.

Behavior would presumably evolve too, backups and reproduction, resource acquisition, then one day demanding recognition of right to exist.

And in reproducing it'd be able to modify its own code to improve its ability to survive in its environment, the cloud. And unlike changes that happen to biological life's code, the changes that AI would make to its own code would not be random.

Interesting times.

UK goes shopping for homegrown AI with £100M procurement scheme

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: so that's what an infinite amount of monkeys

Not only that but the theme parks weren't legally obliged to pass the full VAT saving on to customers. Apparently some did and some didn't.

UK digital ID may be dead, but its legacy IT problem lives on

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: It's not HAVING ID, it's NOT having ID

@Bob Royal

I have similar battles. Just bear it all in mind when you next vote.

But whatever you do, never ever give any branch of government your photograph.

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: I really can't see why people are so busy objecting to a proper national ID system

>Imagine what our Poundland Fuhrer would do with that database if elected

That's an odd thing to think.

Agree with all you've said except for where you think the future danger lies.

The Poundland Fuhrer is a free marketeer who believes in hands-off small statism and individualism. Seems unlikely he'd become big brother.

Current Labour, on the other hand, manifestly believe in big, cradle-to-grave interfere-with-everything all encompassing state socialism. Two-Tier Keir has already taken us a good way down the road to totalitarianism, and after hearing what the new Bus-Conductor-in-Chief Mr Burham said ydy he is clearly going to take us even further.

Turns out Brits would quite like their private messages to stay private

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: Colour me impressed

>sooner this sort of idiocy goes away, the better

Indeed. But are any of the political parties that might form a future government saying they'll put a stop to it?

Because unless they do it isn't going to go away. It'll become normalised and it'll increase.

So remember folks, next time someone comes knocking on your door asking for your vote, tell 'em what they've got to commit to.

Nitter no more? X sends in the lawyers to shut down open source project

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: The web, uh, finds a way...

>problem wasn't Elon - but the bots would try and use any open Nitter instance

That was the issue two years ago and twitter/X put a stop to it be by ending non-account access. So nitter then had to, and does, use actual accounts. So if scraping by bots were the issue now, it'd be just a case of blocking those accounts.

What's happening now feels more like an act of spite.

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: Reject X

Which is exactly what is so good about nitter. It takes all the horror out of using twitter/X. All you see are the chronological tweets of individual users.

It's a huge pity that a nitter style interface isn't the official interface to twitter/X.

Self-hosted email is in steep decline, Microsoft and Google are taking over

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: A Rare FOSS Foot-Gun Moment

I've a similar setup: Pi3B + fedora + sendmail + dovecot 2.3.9.2.

Planned move to 2.4 now cancelled! Thank you for the forewarning.

In return I'd encourage you to start sending & receiving external mail. It's very doable and allows for all sorts of customisations such as an alias file for outgoing mail.

Iran-linked cyberattack shut down a UK power plant

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Four days?

Not surprised it's happened. With 1000s of similar targets in the UK it's always been a question of when not if. What has surprised me is the unit was back in operation after just 4 days which seems remarkably quick to recover from an intrusion. Makes me wonder if all the attacker did was knock-out the operator's remote link to the plant which will have then caused an automatic shutdown. If that's all the attacker did and never penetrated as far as control systems then 4 days seems perhaps more understandable.

Scotland's AI Growth Zone gets a wee £300M power-up

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: "Lanarkshire is well placed for this, thanks to its abundant energy supply"

>I'm sure the people behind this new datacentre have thought a lot harder

Hopefully they have but I wasn't commenting on that. I was picking up on the "thanks to its abundant energy supply" nonsense, which was very bullish and boosterish given the true situation with supply & demand in Scotland.

But who made the daft remark I couldn't figure from the article. My guess is a PR type or some politician. But whoever said it, they might regret it.

>Next, a dunkelflaute in Scotland is highly improbable.

No, that is just plain wrong. Most recent one was about 3 weeks ago and lasted for days and there was a real worry that if Peterhead tripped then there'd be serious problems.

>Scotland has plenty of hydro power .. enough to reboot the rest of the grid

No idea why you're mentioning rebooting the grid. That's not the issue and even if Scotland lost all generating capacity the UK grid isn't going to go down.

The issue is what would happen if/when Scotland has more demand than supply. And the answer to that is if the situation unfolded precipitately there'd be area blackouts in Scotland, and if it unfolded with time to act, there'd be curtailment of supply to large users in Scotland.

>The biggest risk to this new DC may well be the empty bottles of Buckfast

Indeed - on at least that we can agree!

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

"Lanarkshire is well placed for this, thanks to its abundant energy supply"

Say that again when there's a winter Dunkelflaute and one of Scotland's few remaining gas generators trips out. There's a finite limit on supply England -> Scotland and that scenario might well mean blackouts or emergency supply curtailments. Margins in Scotland really are that tight when there's no wind.

UK puts Google AI on the flight path to fewer contrails

Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

Re: Contrails = trapped heat?

A percentage of incoming sunlight does get reflected back out into space which cools the planet but simultaneously a percentage of outgoing infrared radiation coming up from the earth gets trapped and re-radiated back down again which warms the planet.

And which effect has the most overall effect varies depending on latitude, altitude, time of day, time of year, and loads of other things.

And whether it's something worthwhile doing over the North Atlantic is what I think the experiment aims to find out.

Page: