Netheads v Bellheads
The link to the '96 Wired article was incredibly interesting.
The statement by Steve Deering
"How about we come up with something *completely *brain-damaged. Then maybe the computer guys will notice.'"
could be profitably applied to many recent "innovations."
In the late '90s there were two University Campuses in AU that ran IP over ATM which was so successful that, after the lot was replaced in the noughties, one of the remaining complicit networking chaps denied its ever being deployed but forgot that he had documented the campus deployment on personal Uni web pages.
Back then DEC OSF/1 had a kernel module that implemented classical IP over ATM which I had the misfortune to have to deal with. Its ability to cause random or acausal kernel panics would have been envied by Microsoft's Windows engineers.
I don't think IP broadcasts played nicely with IP over ATM networks which could have been a problem for some legacy networking a protocols.
In any case I think the netheads won. I believe most telephony, or at least LTE, is now carried over IP.
Given that it was as much a packet v. circuit argument I suspect the last page hasn't been written.