
Death by Window
What a great way to bring back an old favourite - top work Simon.
7 publicly visible posts • joined 22 Sep 2023
"buying them in lots of hundreds" - that's a massive assumption but I would love to have that kind of budget. We only have around 500 laptops/chromebooks in school and apart from the occasional motherboard failure any parts requiring replacement are because of vandalism.
We very rarely buy parts for Chromebooks (because of the costs I already mentioned) and my team are very adept at transplanting parts from scrapped devices.
"Built down to a price, they're simple to open up and the components are cheap and widely available"
Parts are certainly not cheap and are often impossible to find e.g. £100 plus for a Lenovo keyboard or every parts supplier we talk to saying they can't get any parts for certain HP models. When you can get a new 14" Chromebook for around £250 repairing is often not a financially viable solution.
Chromebook start up times and battery life make them great for Education but because they're 'built down to a price' they don't withstand the abuse students give them as well as traditional laptops e.g. we've got over 100 Dell E5430 laptops still in service after nearly ten years (granted many have had SSD conversion, extra RAM, replacement batteries and new keyboards etc).
We're still trying to work out the best balance between Chromebooks and laptops. Realistically, even with 10 years Google support, the Chromebooks will end up on a faster replacement cycle.
"Why? Because Chromebooks already last forever." - that might be true for a home user but not when it comes to Education environments.
As much as I love the relatively low cost and easy setup of Chromebooks, the expense & low availability of parts or how the chromebook is constructed often means writing off a device for fairly trivial vandalism/damage.