Reply to post: Re: Pilots were no longer in charge

After deadly 737 Max crashes, damning whistleblower report reveals sidelined engineers, scarcity of expertise, more

heyrick Silver badge

Re: Pilots were no longer in charge

Reading this, something occurs to me...

So this system was freaking out because the single sensor had malfunctioned.

Why the heck wasn't it also noticing readings from the altimeter? Because pitching the plane nose down to level out the flight doesn't correspond with nine hundred metres, seven hundred, five hundred, oh shit.

Additionally, if the system is going to be controlling the ailerons, it must have some way of sensing the actual current position of the ailerons to know how to move them. You can't be flying in a straight line if the flaps are in the "descend" position. It just isn't logical.

So it seems that there should have been sufficient telemetry from elsewhere to inform the system that things were going really seriously wrong. Why was none of this information considered in tandem with the sensor readings?

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon