Reply to post: Re: The dangers of prior assumptions

NASA blames the wrong kind of Martian rock for Perseverance sample failure

EvilDrSmith Silver badge

Re: The dangers of prior assumptions

The problem is that the boring tool you need for one soil or rock type is not the appropriate choice for another soil or rock type.

Plus the ground can just be a sod (no pun intended) sometimes.

Even in London, with a well known stratigraphy, site investigation boreholes sometimes come back with 'no recovery' at certain depths, and that happens with (as I just noted) a good idea of what we're boring, the right kit in good condition with good, skilled, drillers operating it.

I suspect that this thing has basically one type of coring bit, which has to handle any and all rock types its operators want to try and core. From the article, it seems they mistook a very weakly cemented silt (soil) for a more competent rock.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon