Reply to post: Yet another way for people to share (and steal) data.

Tim Berners-Lee asks everyone to do new biz a Solid and let him have another crack at fixing the Web's privacy

Peter Fairbrother 1

Yet another way for people to share (and steal) data.

Two problems as far as I can see: First, this isn't a way to protect data, it is a way to share data.

Second, the data is kept in a big database which Tim Berners-Lee can access (if he can't, how can anyone else?).

How come people promoting so-called privacy enhancing technologies always want a big database? In some cases it is because they want to charge for it, in others the reason is more nefarious - but a big database of secrets is never needed, it is just another copy of private or secret data, and it breaks the second law of security - "Stuff you don't have can't be taken from you".

Sharing secret or private data is almost never to the advantage of the user - sharing medical records between surgery and clinics, and some credit reference data, are about the only exceptions I can think of, and these are well serviced already

Shame on you, Berners-Lee.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon