Reply to post: Re: information conservation

Stephen Hawking reckons he's cracked the black hole paradox

E2

Re: information conservation

If we don't know the quantum physics behind this well-known thermodynamic process

We do. Quantum statistical thermodynamics is a very well established field. It's what gives you Boe-Einstein condensation, the Chandrasakar limit etc. It doesn't violate determinism.

Heisenberg's uncertainty principle should have led us to question the general validity of determinism in any case.

No. HUP doesn't violate determinism. A least not per-se. Maybe worth pointing out that detirminism in the quantum sense is the uniqueness of the time evolution of the state vector (which is what completely describes the system), not of classical variables.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon