Reply to post: Re: Passing of Random Data

Big Bang left us with a perfect random number generator

Michael Wojcik Silver badge

Re: Passing of Random Data

There are already multiple websites that claim to distribute true-random data, such as HotBits and EntropyPool. Of course, if you're not getting them over a secure channel, an attacker might substitute chosen data. And you have to trust the source in the first place.

(HotBits offers conventional TLS for a secure channel, so that's great, unless there are any problems with TLS or the X.509 PKI. Hmm. EntropyPool doesn't even use TLS.)

If such a scheme were popular, who's to say the NSA wouldn't set up a whole bunch of sock puppets sending data generated with DUAL_EC_DRBG? No one's shown how to distinguish its output from truly random data, but it's widely believed to be backdoored.

And if you already have a trustworthy channel, why do you need those "large blocks of random data"?

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon