Reply to post: This is bad but inevitable

Amazon: Put our ALWAYS ON MICROPHONE in your house, please. WHAT?

Vladimir Plouzhnikov

This is bad but inevitable

On the face of it it sounds like the staple of a lot of Sci-Fi novels - a house run by an AI which answers you questions, keeps your appointments, reminds you of things, orders pizza, books tickets and offers advice and encouragement when you feel a bit low.

This would appeal to a lot of people and that's why it will become popular (if not in this incarnation but the next or the one after that).

Unfortunately, the AIs in Sci-Fi novels are all run locally, they are loyal to you and they are under your control at all times. This Echo thing is anything but - it's an agent of a third party permanently present in your home. It is controlled by that third party, it works for that third party and it serves only that third party's interests - but it feels as if it works for you.

And because of how it feels a lot of people will be too ignorant to see the difference until it's too late!

This system is a trusted element in you home. "Trusted" means an element which, if compromised, compromises the whole system.

In Sci-Fi novels your AI is a trusted element which is secure unless compromised by the villain-du-jour, which may make for an interesting plot twist. With Echo it comes to you already pre-compromised.

I guess the correct classification for that gadget is "trojan horse"

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon