The problem here I think is that the rules weren't being applied and then all of a suddenly these three guys were singled out for the most severe punishment possible. To me this looks an awful lot like the company wanted to get rid of them for some other reason. Over all I think this is a good ruling, it will help to stop companies from making up all manner of crazy rules and regulations that are there purely for getting rid of awkward people.
Biting the hand that feeds IT
