Not a useful comparison
You need to look deeper into customer preferences in order to have a useful comparison. Firstly, the comparison is way to biased against the E61i and second it does not highlight features that people actually use the most.
Example 1. Mac support, the Nokia should be 9/10 and Q9 should be 0/10. It is simple, Microsoft does not support the Mac for a good reason.
Example 2. Email/Calendar/Tasks. The right comparison is E61i with Blackberry Connect 4 vs. a real Blackberry vs. Q9. Here the Nokia offers the closest experience to a real blackberry including meetings, address lookup, etc. Alternatively, compare the Exchange clients. All other comparisons, IMAP, checking multiple accounts, etc. addresses such a small portion of the prospective buyers (may be 3% max) that it is not worth talking about.
Example 3. To do lists. The reason why to do lists on the devices are not full-featured is that the general customer does not use them. Look at some research before writing about a need that few care about.
Example 4. VoIP on Nokia. This is really the future especially for business executives that travel extensively and incur high roaming fees. Full integration, low power, etc. It is worth 50 points not 10. Basically, there are a few functions of the phone that people care about cellular calls, VoIP calls, email/meetings, browsing and multimedia. Everything else is not used by the majority.
Example 5. SMS sending. This is typically done by putting an SMS shortcut (one of seven possible) which results in sub 1 second sms send time on the E61i. Plus, you do have loose address string search within the sms application, just need to know how use it. It is OK to blame Nokia for not implementing the Blackberry functionality fully (sad) or that is has crippled the multimedia interface (sad) but to say that the Nokia sms application is flawed is just nuts since Nokia is widely acknowledged to have the best sms interface.
OK, and since now I got going, to some of the other posters: the P1i has not useable keyboard. Stop pitching this phone as an email solution. Same with the iPhone.
Gushter