YALD * 2
Here we go again. There's are good reasons why these distros wither away, the main one being not enough people use them. And why don't they use them? Cos there's not any compelling reason to do so. They are YALD.
-> When it was still part of the Ubuntu distro, there were three separate branches of the Unity desktop
Yes, take one think and immediately divert resources to maintaining three lots of it.
-> Saraswat has plans for the development of a new Unity-like desktop
Oh wow. That sound really good. But it gives me a sense of deja vu, like all the 500,000 other Linux distros.
-> Both Unity7 and the planned UnityX are entirely separate and independent from Unity8, Ubuntu's planned touch-driven mobile desktop. That isn't dead either: the UBports community is continuing work, and has renamed the desktop Lomiri.
Yes, because a rename is really essential to give a sense of continuity. What family of OS is Windows 11 from? Is it by chance from the same family as Windows 2000? Who would have thunk it? But in the Linux world we have Lomiri which used to be called Unity8. Go figure.
-> Canonical was also working on a new display server to replace the now elderly X.org – duplicating much of the Wayland project.
There you have it, ladies and gentlemen in black and white: DUPLICATION, AKA wasted resources and effort.
-> However, concealing functionality behind hotkeys and hamburger menus leads to more time wasted hunting for functionality that used to be in plain view.
Let me shorten that for you: it's unfriendly and hard to use.
-> These may seem like small things, but such small paper cuts add up. They are the reason that whole teams of people get together and fork abandoned projects to keep them alive.
That's half the story. The other half, the first half, is that these paper cuts are why the projects are abandoned in the first place.
-> Today, there are half a dozen teams all maintaining separate Linux desktops
Only half a dozen? I reckon that figure is under counted by at least 500 times.
-> it was mostly written in C++, while Unix traditionalists tend to favor plain old C
And now we have people demanding to rewrite things in Rust. Not to get ahead, just to get to where we are now.
-> That's a huge amount of duplicated effort.
Thank you again for mentioning the work DUPLICATED. It is also wasted effort.
-> Something about divide and conquer?
The Linux desktop groups have divided and conquered themselves. Instead of a couple of large settlements, there are now hundreds of villages. A quick history lesson: villages had to reach a size of about 500 people before they could begin to sustain themselves. The Linux world has hundreds of unsustainable villages.
I expect to receive down votes from people who don't like my ladle of truth. The Year of the Linux Desktop is nearly here.