back to article Survey shows XP lingers on while Windows 11 makes a 0.21% ripple in the enterprise

Microsoft's Windows 11 adventure is going swimmingly. IT asset management outfit Lansweeper has published the results of a 10 million PC survey that gives the new operating system a 0.21 per cent market share. That is a good deal less than the 3.62 per cent of Windows XP and a nose ahead of the reviled Windows Vista. It is …

  1. Dave Pickles

    I wonder how many of those 0.21 percent are folks like me running a user-agent randomiser on their browser?

    1. Pascal Monett Silver badge

      .00001% IMO.

      Not many people know about the user agent.

    2. Dave K

      Some may also be from people like myself who spun up a VM of Windows 11 just to try it out. It's a decidedly mixed bag, but then again I'm still not a fan of Windows 10 either.

      1. andy gibson

        I find it ironic that they've try to kill the traditional start menu, but if you right-click the windows logo on 11 its even longer than before!

  2. Pascal Monett Silver badge
    Thumb Down

    "could be totally reasonable if it's just from the managed company PCs"

    Company PCs are the last ones, at this point in time, that are going to dally about with a new Windows release.

    It took about 10 years for companies to get away from Vista, and that transition still isn't entirely finished.

    Don't look to companies to bolster Borkzilla's new pet project numbers.

    1. Chris G

      Re: "could be totally reasonable if it's just from the managed company PCs"

      Also, while PHBs may not be IT wise they can often see the signs that may cost the company more and reduce their bonuses.

      If that is the case, they are likely to hold off as long as they can.

    2. Dave K

      Re: "could be totally reasonable if it's just from the managed company PCs"

      I don't know a single company that adopted Vista if I'm honest. All the ones I worked for stuck to XP and then migrated to Windows 7 once XP approached EOL.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: "could be totally reasonable if it's just from the managed company PCs"

        I remember a couple companies moving their deisgn/engineering departments to Vista just to run 64-bit versions of CATIA, MasterCam and other similar memory-heavy software.

      2. Anonymous South African Coward Bronze badge

        Re: "could be totally reasonable if it's just from the managed company PCs"

        We had Vista once, preinstalled on a couple of laptops.

        Surprisingly it was rock solid, never gave any blue screens or issues.

        Sadly the laptops themselves have dieded and gone to where dead laptops go, and Vista is no longer with us.

  3. Nameless Dread

    ... from beyond the gravy ...

    Count another XP user here.

    It's in a VM on Mint so I can use Lotus 1-2-3, just like the good old days.

    1. adam 40 Silver badge

      Re: ... from beyond the gravy ...

      XP? Windows 2000 and NT on some test equipment here.

  4. Lon24

    Adieu but not goodbye XP

    Microsoft said the 11 year old netbook I'm typing this on could not be upgraded to Vista. So it was forced to upgrade to Kubuntu. Now it's Kubuntu 21.04 - their latest and brightest on kernel 5.13. Great marketing MS!

    XP lingers on in a partition. Still doing good stuff. Though the fact that Linux can just read/write the NTFS partition while XP still denies the existence of ext4 makes communication a little one-sided. Especially as XP isn't allowed to go out and play on the interwebs anymore. Methinks many more XPs are lurking beyond the reach of these surveyors,

    1. karlkarl Silver badge

      Re: Adieu but not goodbye XP

      Its very true. Between myself and my colleagues, we have many XP installs. We just go through a Linux/BSD VM to access the web. I personally wouldn't recommend putting *any* Windows directly on the internet.

    2. Al fazed
      Happy

      Re: Adieu but not goodbye XP

      Indeed, my audio engineering is still done on XP 'cos it has been that way since I got into sound engineering. It requires no internet so isn't at any great risk of anything other than the hardware failing. It still scans and prints documents on the Canon PSC, which is more than I can say for my Windose 10 machine....

      I am ever warey of Microsoft upgrading this Windose 10 box to Windose 11 during an update - without my agrreement. They cannot do that to my XP box. NA!

      ALF

    3. Citizen99

      Re: Adieu but not goodbye XP

      I sometimes fire up an XP VM, on Devuan, to run the user-friendly proprietary s/w for my scanner. Also have W7 in a VM and on a partition, very rarely need to use it.

      1. andy gibson

        Re: Adieu but not goodbye XP

        Still using Windows XP here for car diagnostics.

    4. Nate Amsden

      Re: Adieu but not goodbye XP

      Curious which Netbook? I have a ASUS Eee PC 1000HE 10.2" Netbook that I just dug up the purchase receipt on and I bought it in May 2009 so 12 years ago. It has been running Windows 7 home for several years, originally came with XP.

      I didn't upgrade(windows) it, but installed clean from a Win7 home CD I bought through a friend who worked at MS at the time. I don't use the netbook often(few hours/year), but it is super handy in some situations with it's small form factor. Memory maxed out at 2GB I think and has a Samsung SSD in it now. Battery still seems ok too. My only real complaint about this eee pc I suppose is the weak CPU, being able to get more than 2GB of ram would be nice too but the cpu holds it back more than anything. I have a bunch of old games on it too from GOG that work fine(games that were built for 486s originally)

      I also had the original Asus eee PC with linux and a 4GB flash storage or something? That thing was terrible by contrast. Whether it was the screen, or slow storage, or lack of storage, lower memory(I think it was less than 1GB). I gave my original eee pc to someone else 10 years ago.

    5. Shalghar

      Re: Adieu but not goodbye XP

      Personally i have one WinXP, one Win2k and even a murky old Win98 computer sitting around...

      Along with all that hardware that cannot cooperate with later windows versions because the proprietary and never updated drivers just cannot be installed there and the likewise proprietary software also wont run.

      We also have some off the net WinXP computers at work, exactly for the same reason. While the price for a new computer with a newer windows is not much of a concern, the price to replace the specialised hardware the WinXP machines are attached to is quite exorbitant and in one case would mean we had to construct that kind of specialised plasma cutter from scratch as that model is no longer manufactured and the manufacturer also does not exist anymore.

      Take a look at other software collectors. Gamers for instance will still have XP around as none of the more invasive "copy protections" will accept or be accepted by a newer system. If the games run at all on newer hard/software.

    6. TCook1943

      Re: Adieu but not goodbye XP

      I use ext 3 for just that reason.

  5. a_yank_lurker

    Not Unexpected

    The Rejects of Redmond are not making any points with the hardware specifications for Bloatware 11. I have a Bloatware 7 partition around that get used a couple of times a year for the odd Bloatware program that needs to be run very occasionally (it is not allowed to connect to the Internet). The only reason for me to upgrade my hardware is for photo and video processing of large files, 4x and 8x files are not small. But here I might only upgrade on box as dedicated photo/video processing box (not using Bloatware for this). Otherwise, like most home users, I do not normally need that much hp to do my daily computer activities.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Not Unexpected

      My 6 household PCs/Laptops are still Windows 7. I've not had any issues with using them on the 'net. I have a very good enterprise class firewall and locked down browsers, however.

      All of these PCs will get converted to Mint very soon (with maybe the occasional Win 7 VM). Windows 7 will be the last version of Windows for our household.

      I work from home, and my work PC is Windows 10. I truly hate Windows 10, but with OpenShell it's sort of tolerable. I dread the thought of being forced to use Win 11!!

      Unfortunately retirement is too far off to be able to get completely away from f***ing Windows.

      1. eldel

        The coming of the Borg

        Took delivery of a new laptop yesterday. Booted it up and the Win10 install promptly upgraded itself to Win11. OK - let's try that.

        Start with - create admin user that isn't a microsoft account. Hmm - nope. Lots of web searches and trials. Still nope - all the helpful suggestions are no longer valid. OK - create a fake new account, complete the login process. Create local user, reboot and log in with that.

        Install Brave browser, set DDG as search engine, set Brave as default browser (which, in itself, took 20 minutes and a lot of reading). Click on a link - get Edge. Reboot. Try again. Same thing.

        Check pi-hole and see a *huge* amount of traffic going to microsoft sub domains that I've not seen before. Blacklist domains. Random stuff stops working - e.g. volume control. WTF?? And I thought Android was bad.

        Put Mint 20.2 on flash drive, boot from that, install with complete wipe of disk. Fully working laptop with no stupidity 20 minutes later.

        1. fidodogbreath

          Re: The coming of the Borg

          Mint FTW!

          Machines within my purview that are artificially obsoleted by Windows or MacOS quickly acquire a Minty-fresh aroma -- and several more years of useful life.

        2. JimboSmith Silver badge

          Re: The coming of the Borg

          Put Mint 20.2 on flash drive, boot from that, install with complete wipe of disk. Fully working laptop with no stupidity 20 minutes later.

          Exactly the same with me although in my case it was Windows 10 (as 11 wasn't out then). I was just trying to install Thunderbird without an MS account. Tried to do so but was beaten back at every point until I gave up rather early on. I put Mint on it as fast as i could and haven't looked back since.

          1. Anonymous Coward
            Anonymous Coward

            Re: Windows 11: Install 10, configure, lock it down (privacy), perform in-place upgrade?

            The key to Windows 11, seems to be setup Windows 10 with a local account, install the browsers you need, set the default browser. Lock down all the privacy settings (opt out of all the opt ins), turning off every single option. Then do an in-place upgrade to Windows 11.

            I've only done this with Windows 10 Pro -> Windows 11 Pro though so far, but the results are a fairly locked down Windows 11 Pro with a local account, and both Firefox and Google Chrome working as I expect. I'm not seeing Edge very often, but then I'm not using anything that requires a Microsoft account on this test machine. Search on the taskbar doesn't automatically give web results only local (locked down), but if you specifically search for microsoft.com etc, it's annoying in that it will open that address insecurely as http rather than securely, https in Edge. (more snooping?)

            But overall, it's mostly like a locked down version of Window 10, with a centralized menu that is all but useless/pretty much a blank space.

            Windows 11 certainly fights back in forcing product placement advertisements for Apps that are made to look like full version installs in the start menu, but are just adverts for trial installs.

            If Windows 11 was a person/colleague at work doing similar, you'd be reporting them for harassment, that's for sure. You have to wonder, do Microsoft employees take this type of control/abusive behaviour they program into their code, home with them?

            Or do you just accept defeat, walk away - install Linux? (rhetorical)

          2. Anonymous Coward
            Anonymous Coward

            Re: The coming of the Borg

            I see the Windows (Microsoft) fanboy is out and about today hapily down voting posts about converting from Windows to Linux.

        3. yetanotheraoc Silver badge

          Re: The coming of the Borg

          "Blacklist domains. Random stuff stops working - e.g. volume control."

          The new Teams mute button wants to phone home.

      2. Anonymous South African Coward Bronze badge

        Re: Not Unexpected

        User from another company was using Orifice365 (Word, Excel, Visio, Projects etc) for his stuff.

        Got whacked by an Orifice365 upgrade which hosed his entire Office.

        His IT team had to take in his laptop and fix the Orifice365 issue.

        I'm hating this newfangled installers which'll sh*t themselves if the smallest amount of Office is still left behind on the target PC, and you'll need to jump through big flaming hoops to get Orifice to install.

        Back in the days WP5.1 and SuperCalc you can get a speed advantage with muscle memory, especially with often-used commands. <clickety><click> and you're done... but not so with this newfangled Orifice and its horrendous ribbon...

        I'm thinking of getting a cheap Celeron-based craptop just for myself, just to do the odd web browsing and wordprocessing/spreadsheeting at home, but I shall most definitely install Linux Mint on it, and Ickdoze be damned.

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: Not Unexpected

          "Orifice 365". Ho ho. Bet you also use the terms Micro$oft and Micro$haft

          1. TCook1943

            Re: Not Unexpected

            Personally for me it's Microshit [- just saying.

  6. Mike Lewis

    Which OS

    When my Windows drive died four days ago, I had to decide which operating system to install out of Windows 7, Windows 10 and Linux. Windows 10 has a bad reputation with Microsoft's "Ready or not, here I come" installation of buggy updates, changing user preferences and hiding settings, all of which make Windows 7 appear more reliable to me. Linux was not a practical option as I have so much Windows software so I reinstalled Windows 7.

    1. Al fazed
      Happy

      Re: Which OS

      Since I went over to Windose 10 boxen for the daily grind, office admin has become a nightmare. Open Office and Libre Office both do the same unexpected crashes every half hour or so and have to re-cover the docuemt I was working on, had saved but the saved work is not evident and has to be re created !!!!!

      Is this an issue with both Open Office and Libre Office ?

      I do not think so. They work fine under Linux, XP, Win 7.........

      So I would expect that neither open office software will work properly under Windose 11 and so my next OS change will take me back to using Debian for my daily administrative grunt work.

      Happy to know that it'll take only twenty minutes to install and configure Debian, as opposed to - as many days for the Microshite OSes I've dallied with over the years.

      ALF

      1. Yet Another Hierachial Anonynmous Coward

        Re: Which OS

        Have been using Libre office (6.2.2.2) on Windoze 10 for a couple of years with no unruly behaviour whatsoever. Other than the usual 10 crap. Machine is MS Orifice free.

        But windows 10 will be my last windows as it is just so unproductive and unituitive. Once the move to 11 is forced, there will be a minty flavour of penguin everywhere around me, rather than just on some pi's and nuc's and the like.

  7. rcxb1

    Security

    <blockquote>there could still be millions of people using devices that are insecure and open to attack.</blockquote>

    As opposed to shiny new, fully updated Windows systems, which are highly secure and invulnerable to attack?

    1. Al fazed
      Facepalm

      Re: Security

      Running XP is probably more secure than Windose 11 ?

      I'm assuming what I read is plausible, that cracking a Windose 11 box is more attractive proposition than Windows XP, as there are more Windose 11 Users, er .......... but that isn't the case.

      Will it ever be the case ?

      ALF

  8. PC Paul

    Too soon

    At our somewhat large company the Windows 11 announcement happened just as we gave the first user a production Win10 laptop. These things take time!

  9. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Computer says NO

    Since my PC won’t run W11, and it’s perfectly serviceable, I’m happy to stay well away.

    1. andy gibson

      Re: Computer says NO

      Easy to bypass with RUFUS to remove the TPM 2.0, Secure Boot, 8GB+ RAM restrictions:

      https://pureinfotech.com/rufus-create-bootable-windows-11-usb/

      1. Roland6 Silver badge

        Re: Computer says NO

        Alternatively, disable TFM 2.0 and not be bothered by the system auto-updating to W11...

        Perhaps this is what GWXI Control Panel needs to do...

    2. Down not across

      Re: Computer says NO

      if only Win 10 had had same thing instead of sneaking in.

  10. Grunchy Silver badge

    But I just got Windows XP yesterday!

    I got me my new Toshiba Satellite 2400 and is she ever a beaut: Pentium 4 1.6GHz (180 nm!), 512 Meg DDR, 140 GB hard drive, DVD-rom / CD-RW, 3.5” floppy, wi-fi, 16MB S3 super-savage, V90 56K fax modem, ECP printer port, 3x Universal Serial Bus, infrared port, SD card slot, 2x PC Card slots, 85 key keyboard + 12 function keys, Alps touchpad, RGB monitor port, RCA video port, 1024x768 14.1” TFT LCD.

    HANDILY runs Lubuntu 16.04 straight off the live DVD, but why would I toss out Windows XP? How else do you propose I run my Purble Place?

    1. Al fazed

      Re: But I just got Windows XP yesterday!

      Or play proper Solitaire !

      ALF

  11. Anonymous South African Coward Bronze badge

    XP and 2003

    I have purged the network of all things XP and 2003.

    Don't need any Service Packs and ISO's to take up storage space.

    It is only Windows 7 and 8.1 remaining (4x Win7 and 3x Win8.1) here, but they'll get their marching orders. Soon. Muhuhaha.

    Server2008 is still hanging on, but we are busy looking at alternatives to that, and it'll go into the dark night sooner or later.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: XP and 2003

      Most of the machines in the office are still running Win8.1

      Can't get anyone to upgrade them (to Win10) 'because of Covid'

  12. Hogbert

    I was feeling reckless (and have a separate Linux PC anyway) so I went ahead with the upgrade. First action was installing the Start11 menu replacement, which has made it look quite pleasant.

    It's not too awful to use, except there is a bit of weirdness going on with the sound, not sure if that is realtek drivers or win11 that keeps losing the plot tho.

    Have to admit I have spent very little time on it, as after it was loaded I moved on to rebuilding my Linux PC and installed Pop!_OS, just for a change. Much nicer experience than Windows.

  13. Zippy´s Sausage Factory

    My wife has been on Ubuntu for years now, she loves it. (Why she was on Ubuntu in the first place is a long story)

    These days she's a Linux evangelist. While I'm still running a Win 10 box so I can finally finish Unreal Tournament 2004...

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Other stories you might like