The Register Home Page

back to article UK.gov lacks understanding of climate impact, says watchdog

Public bodies in the UK expect higher operating costs and energy charges as a result of climate changes and the transition to lower carbon energy, but few have a good picture of the risks, according to government auditors. A new report from the National Audit Office (NAO) says some public bodies expect financial impact from the …

  1. Aladdin Sane Silver badge

    UK.gov lacks understanding of climate impact

    FTFY

    1. DJV Silver badge

      Damn. You beat me to it!

  2. Pete 2 Silver badge

    Unrealistic expectations?

    > although bodies were often not able to cost these – even approximately.

    I doubt there is anybody on the planet (or ISS) who could put an accurate figure on that. Even for the UK I suspect that the overall cost would be scary enough (personal guess: £50+ trillion, or 50 HS2's up to 2050) to discourage anyone in government from putting their name to a number.

    From a political point of view, the transition would have to take place over several parliaments. Possibly dozens given the average government lifetime of the past decade. So the pain would be shared across parties, with each new incumbent being able to pin the blame on the previous lot - no matter that they would have had to do the same, if they were in power.

    1. Pete 2 Silver badge

      Re: Unrealistic expectations?

      *500 HS2's - though at the rate the price increases, it could well be £1Tn in the end

  3. steelpillow Silver badge
    Holmes

    There are no votes in understanding climate change, plenty in downplaying it.

    1. BebopWeBop Silver badge

      And lots of cash for politicians who can ignore it (along with the primary offenders)

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Like who? Which politicians will get lots of cash if they ignore climate change?

        1. Jedit Silver badge
          FAIL

          "Which politicians will get lots of cash if they ignore climate change?"

          All of them. Corporations profit greatly from governments not doing troublesome things like telling them we'd quite like to have a habitable planet, so are ready to buy as many politicians as they need.

        2. rg287 Silver badge

          Like who? Which politicians will get lots of cash if they ignore climate change?

          At least 24 of the new MPs in 2024 had previously worked for fossil fuel firms or lobbying/think-tank outfits that counted the likes of Shell; Exxon; BP; InterGen; Phillips 66 and International Airlines Group as clients.

          They're hardly likely to burn their bridges because there's nothing quite so "former" and a former-MP.

          Meanwhile Heathrow Airport counts on their Board the Rt Hon Ruth Kelly - former Secretary of State for Transport. I'm sure no one ever discussed the possibility of a lucrative board seat whilst she was in politics. Nudge nudge wink wink.

        3. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          "Which politicians will get lots of cash if they ignore climate change?"

          Just check out where the fossil-fuel money machine is putting its political donations. >Cough!< Reform >Cough!"

  4. alain williams Silver badge

    There are none so blind ...

    as those who do not want to see.

  5. Tron Silver badge

    How many droughts do we need...

    ...before the corrupt morons in government and the utilities decide to build enough reservoirs - big ones, small ones and micro ones for farms etc.

    We get heavier rain in winter and heatwaves in summer. You would have thought that even politicians could work out what to do there.

    We are a tardocracy.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: How many droughts do we need...

      They have to deal with the NIMBYs who block them. Thames Water have been trying to build a new reservoir in Oxfordshire for 30 years. It's constantly blocked by locals, despite the fact that we still have a hosepipe ban that was introduced 6 months ago.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: How many droughts do we need...

        Be fair. The blocker are not corrupt morons. They are social-bureaucracy morons.

  6. Art Slartibartfast

    Confusing the topics

    What makes the discussion really difficult is that there are two different things being mixed up here: the impact of climate change and the energy transition as proposed mitigation effort.

    To begin with the latter, indeed, no one has a good idea of the cost. For one thing because energy from wind and solar are highly variable in cost. Over the course of four days, electricity price recently went from € 13 per MWh to over € 300 per MWh in Germany. Even if you have sufficient name plate capacity in solar and wind, you still need the same capacity in thermal power generation as a backup. This means investment in two power generation systems instead of one. Not the most efficient use of money.

    For any modern industrial society renewables will not be able to deliver what is needed. Case in point is the El Hierro project where circumstances seem optimal. Even with pumped storage and wind, this island of 11,000 people generated only 44% - 65% of their electricity needs with renewables in the years 2018 - 2023. The rest had to be covered by diesel generators.

    As for the predictions on climate change, over the past decades, so many wrong predictions were made. And then there was the recently abandoned RCP 8.5 scenario that was consistently presented as a business-as-usual scenario, even though it was highly improbable from the get go. Climate science is rife with alarmism and unfit for policy making.

    1. LBJsPNS Silver badge

      Re: Confusing the topics

      What drivel.

    2. Goodwin Sands Bronze badge

      Re: Confusing the topics

      >there are two different things being mixed up here

      Absolutely this. It is the elephant in the report and it likely is deliberately so with the govt endlessly wishing to conflate the two issues.

      Climate change is happening and we're along for the ride whether we like it or not. But Net Zero policies and the energy supply & price issues they create will be ditched if/when Lab are out of office. The report should have acknowledged that.

      1. Missing Semicolon Silver badge

        Re: Confusing the topics

        I'd agree, but Labour will never be out of office.

      2. rg287 Silver badge

        Re: Confusing the topics

        Climate change is happening and we're along for the ride whether we like it or not. But Net Zero policies and the energy supply & price issues they create will be ditched if/when Lab are out of office. The report should have acknowledged that.

        Any party that ditches net zero is clearly in the pocket of foreign actors. Climate Change and Net Zero are two different things, but Net Zero is both a Climate Change and National Security policy, and the latter in particular should be accelerating investment in it.

        As you correctly state, climate change is happening. This is - empirically - due to anthropogenic emissions, at least in part. The world should be going net zero. But there is the nihilistic Republican/Tory view which says that if the USA and China aren't bothering, then what's the point.

        The reality of Net Zero policies is that aside from leading by example, net zero is a key and profound element of national security policy. Even if climate change is not due to anthropogenic emissions:

        • Climate Change will see increased political and social unrest around the world, along with mass migration from areas that become uninhabitable.

        • This unrest will add risk to choke-points for global shipping (such as Panama, Suez and Hormuz). This on top of the climate change risks to those choke points - the Panama Canal for instance is currently running limited transit because there isn't enough water to operate the locks without draining the canal and lakes themselves to the point of being un-navigable.

        • 50% of the world's shipping is carrying hydrocarbons around

        It follows that is a deeply stupid and insecure policy to pin our economic prosperity on fossil fuel prices, which realistically means foreign (Arab/American) fuels.1

        Any government content to sit back and say "Yeah, continuing to be critically dependent on foreign hydrocarbons is fine by us" is either extremely stupid, or else in the pocket of a foreign actor. They're certainly not interested in supporting British business, nor in long term national security. The empty unit down the road where my local chippy used to be didn't go bump because of woke. They went bump in 2022 because Putin invaded Ukraine and their energy bills were unaffordable.

        As we know, energy prices are sky high due to external geopolitical events, not "net zero nonsense". Heavy industry currently has higher energy bills than France or Germany, despite the fact that UK "green" levies are lower than either of those countries - because energy pricing in the UK is dominated by the global gas price, whereas France is dominated by nuclear, and Germany has a mix of renewables and lignite (shudders).

        Renewables and net-zero levies are not the reason for high UK energy prices. The underlying causes include:

        • A failure to invest in resilience (e.g. Tories closing the Rough Gas Storage Facility, which would let us smooth some of the spikes)

        • A failure to invest in grid capacity (Eastern Green Links) in a timely fashion, resulting in NG paying turndown fees to Scottish wind producers. As Greg Jackson has repeatedly stated, Scotland should basically be getting free electric, instead of paying through the nose because National Grid plc has been too busy paying out shareholder dividends instead of investing in infrastructure.

        These of course are underpinned by global external price pressures which no UK party has any meaningful control over (Russia-Ukraine and USA-Iran).

        1. Even if you open the remaining North Sea fields, they can't supply a baseline UK demand - much less peak demand. Moreover, what's left is left there because it is difficult (i.e. expensive) to extract, meaning it is only viable if gas prices remain high. North Sea gas is not a route to cheap UK gas prices. It fails on both energy security and pricing.

        1. Jellied Eel Silver badge

          Re: Confusing the topics

          Any party that ditches net zero is clearly in the pocket of foreign actors. Climate Change and Net Zero are two different things, but Net Zero is both a Climate Change and National Security policy, and the latter in particular should be accelerating investment in it.

          Nope. Any party that continues pushing Net Zero is clearly in the pocket of foreign actors engaged in economic warfare against the UK. But Net Zero is directly connected to Global Warming. We must ban ICEs, gas central heating and cooking to 'save the planet'. Achieving Net Zero will cost a few trillion, but will make no measurable difference to Global Warming, especially when the Met Office weather stations are badly sited and unreliable.

          And then as the OP said, the 'science' has been revised due to the abandonment of the dodgy RCP8.5 emission scenarios, where Thermageddon only existed due flawed & unrealistic assumptions plugged into climate models.

          As you correctly state, climate change is happening. This is - empirically - due to anthropogenic emissions, at least in part

          But how much has CO2 contributed? Climate change has always happened with naturally occurring events like the MWP and LIA. CO2 can't explain those documented events, so climate pseudo-science ignores them, or pretends they never happened. Usual excuse is they were somehow regional, yet there's no plausible explanation as to weather patterns that could explain these. But CO2 is very lucrative, so Burnham's stealth re-joining of the EU announced we'd be plugged back into the EU's emission trading scam that makes billions trading credits for thin air.

          All of which creates a colossal drain on UK/EU economies and has no measurable benefit outside of spread sheets and balance sheets.

          ..because energy pricing in the UK is dominated by the global gas price, whereas France is dominated by nuclear, and Germany has a mix of renewables and lignite (shudders).

          It's only dominated by gas pricing because 'renewables' has meant we need gas for when the sun doesn't shine and the wind blows too strong, or not at all. Thus energy pricing is dominated by 'renewables' costs. See-

          https://notalotofpeopleknowthat.wordpress.com/2026/10/31/nesos-wind-power-plans-blown-away-already/

          A day after I reported on how NESO’s Winter Outlook had assumed we could rely on a minimum of 5.4 GW from wind power, we find that currently it is just sending 2.67 GW to the grid.

          For more info. So we're increasingly reliant on gas and interconnectors, and then pay through the nose because when wind speeds are low in the UK, they're also usually low across the rest of Europe. There's also no real 'global gas price', only the cost of production and availability of supply.

          These of course are underpinned by global external price pressures which no UK party has any meaningful control over (Russia-Ukraine and USA-Iran).

          We have control over a couple of those. So Russia-Ukraine was a decision by the UK & EU not to buy from Russia, so self-sanctioning that's helping deindustrialise Europe due to high energy costs. We could end the conflict in Ukraine, but instead choose to extend it and escalate it. Burnham bunged another £10bn into Zelensky's golden toilet fund. Keeping the money spigot flowing means there's no incentive for Zelensky to seek any realistic peace deal, so he'll keep fighting to the last Ukrainian. And possibly torturing a few along the way, and you won't know what I mean by that because it's a bit of a scandal that our media is currently ignoring.

          And then we could improve energy security and reduce costs by simply exploiting on and offshore gas deposits in and around the UK. Burnham made one small step to improving energy security by permitting production at one of the smaller gas fields, but because he's a f'ng idiot, announced that proceeds would go towards the pockets of the 'renewables' lobby instead of building more nuclear generation.. Thus in typical politician style, making the problem worse.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon