The Register Home Page

back to article North Korean fake job interview led to $6.3B Binance heist

North Korean cryptocurrency thieves tricked a Binance software engineer into downloading malware onto their work-issued computer during a fake job interview process before last week's record-breaking $6.3 billion heist. In an incident report published on Tuesday, the cryptocurrency exchange said several techniques - including …

  1. elsergiovolador Silver badge

    Alternative

    > North Korean fake job interview led to $6.3B Binance heist

    > another software engineer was contacted via a “legitimate job-hunting platform” by someone purporting to be a project director who arranged a series of job interviews for the Binance engineer with the fake company.

    I think what led to this were poor employment conditions if (my guess) developer couldn't afford a personal computer to look for another job and was desperate enough to download something from a stranger.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Alternative

      So you think it was the employer's fault, not the gullible engineer's! Blimey.

      1. Sorry that handle is already taken. Silver badge

        Re: Alternative

        The employer in this case being a bunch of cryptobro conmen. The tears shed were tears of laughter.

      2. Blazde Silver badge

        Re: Alternative

        It's not the engineer's money(*), and he's got a cracking pub story out of it. Ergo, employer's fault. Or whoever's money it is. You can apply this logic all the way up the chain to whoever you want to shift the blame to.

        (*) To be fair I don't know that for sure.

        1. hoofie2002

          Re: Alternative

          If the Engineer was based in Asia with their more "relaxed" judicial systems he is more likely to be getting the 3rd degree via a piece of rubber house in a basement somewhere from the forces of law and order.

          1. Anonymous Coward
            Anonymous Coward

            Re: Alternative

            A rubber house? Is that some kind of kinky S&M establishment?

            1. Casca Silver badge

              Re: Alternative

              Bouncy castle?

              1. Excused Boots Silver badge

                Re: Alternative

                oooooh Matron!

      3. I could be a dog really Silver badge

        Re: Alternative

        I didn't read it as shifting blame, merely as an observation that normally if you are having job interviews, you'd use your own computer.

        So either the engineer was really clueless, or they were being paid so little that they couldn't afford their own.

      4. doublelayer Silver badge

        Re: Alternative

        Check the poster. They think everything is the employer's fault, every time. If it turned out this person was paid at the 95th percentile, it would still be too little in the argument, and if they were even higher, there would be some other argument for why this was still some kind of mistreatment.

    2. NoneSuch Silver badge
      Trollface

      Re: Alternative

      Repeat post - deleted.

    3. NoneSuch Silver badge

      Re: Alternative

      I see a lot of downvotes OP. I have a short PDF file that shows just how right you are. Give me your email and I'll send it to you.

      Best give me your date of birth and mothers maiden name and I'll encrypt the PDF with that as the password.

      1. Excused Boots Silver badge

        Re: Alternative

        Shirley you will need his bank details as well to make it biggly secure?

  2. Paul Crawford Silver badge

    What a Dick (III)

    A VM, a VM, my kingdom for a VM!

    1. John_Ericsson

      Re: What a Dick (III)

      I would not have a dirty area on a privileged device. Exploits have occurred that allows the VM to access the host.

      It gives users (and IT) a false sense of security.

      1. Paul Crawford Silver badge

        Re: What a Dick (III)

        Security is like an onion.

        You mean it makes you cry?

        No Donkey, I mean it has layers!

        1. fedoraman
          Happy

          Re: What a Dick (III)

          OK, Onion boy!

  3. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Perhaps

    Perhaps the engineer was so pissed at Binance he wanted to not only leave but screw them over? This way he has plausible deniability.

    1. Homo.Sapien.Floridanus

      Re: Perhaps

      Never attribute to malice what can be explained by stupidity

  4. steviebuk Silver badge

    Although

    its annoying and a pain in the arse, this is why you need to just block all apps then only allow the ones needed to do work. So then when an engineer like this attempts to install something, it gets flagged.

    1. K555

      Re: Although

      Most of the pain is the wailing from a few users that 'we're not allowed to do anything in our computers!'.

      You are, you can do some work.

      And, my favourite, the petulant 'because I'm not an admin' phone call. Those ones are even better if it's something a non administrative user can do, they just don't know how.

    2. cookiecutter Silver badge

      Re: Although

      oh no you might slow die developers who have to work at speed! you can't have security or common sense or even basic rules that may slow them down! because their mummies call them "rock stars" - fucking ridiculous state of affairs!

      1. FIA Silver badge

        Re: Although

        oh no, IT might have to come up with sensible policies that understand that different people use computers in different ways... but that would mean they'd have to do work rather than just blanket apply the most restrictive policies to everything.

        (See... works both ways... ;) )

        1. cookiecutter Silver badge

          Re: Although

          what things like "why can't i stick kubernetes into an environment without first going through a TDA? or " why can we just copy the production database across into development?" or "why can't we put APIs on the internet for testing with no passwords or security" or my favourite "why can't we make changes in production?"

          Rules are there for a reason .. THIS is what happens when you let devs have admin access. or "we want to be able to use any library that we've found in github"

          I've had to explain to Devs why I insisted that they used DNS names on their scripts instead of hardwired IP addresses as they couldn't understand why "you can't have 2 machines with the same ip address"

          1. I could be a dog really Silver badge
            Facepalm

            Re: Although

            I've had to explain to Devs why ...

            Me too, only in that case it was "here are the credentials to allow that specific website to send emails via our server, DO NOT use them for any other site". Fast forward a few months, there's a problem and I change the password on that account, only to have devs wailing that "many" sites now can't send mail. So I explain again, why it's a set of credentials per site: so a) I can block one site if it "goes wrong", and b) I can see from the stats how much each site is sending.

            PS, this forum needs a "Banging head against the wall" icon

            1. Gavsky

              Re: Although

              "Look, if you bang your head on a wall - that's where your headaches come from. Ergo, STOP doing it"

              "Oh, can't you just prescribe me something?"...

      2. Doctor Syntax Silver badge

        Re: Although

        They have to work at speed if they're to fit everything into a mere 90 hour week.

  5. sindrelspec

    And that's why banking institutions are regulated, so it ensures that no one person has the ability to move billions of dollars all by themselves.

    1. simonlb Silver badge

      Ahem. A certain Mr. Leeson and a few of his former colleagues from Barings Bank would like a word.

      1. FrogsAndChips Silver badge

        Different use cases. Leeson was a rogue trader who knew exactly what he was doing, unlike this idiot developer. And he operated in a context where traders had god-like powers and almost zero scrutiny. After several high-profile incidents, banks have highly strengthened their processes, monitoring and controls, and rebalanced the powers between front, middle and back offices, so what Leeson, Kerviel and Iksil managed to pull off is much less likely to happen again in a serious investment bank. The crypto industry has a lot of catchup to do.

      2. I ain't Spartacus Gold badge

        Ahem. A certain Mr. Leeson and a few of his former colleagues from Barings Bank would like a word.

        Barings were a merchant bank. A completely different thing, and much less regulated. We regulate the high street banks, because runs on them can destroy the economy. And we used to force a split between the high street and the traders - then we didn't, then 2007 happened and now we do again.

        Also he was both trading, and his own manager - which is an absolutely terrible idea! Apparently he started off by covering-up other traders' losses from his team - and then getting the money back before it had to be reported - and then started doing it for himself. They don't seem to have had much in the way of security - but also the traders weren't making payments - but market trades. So they're unlikely to be able to directly steal from the company - they could maliciously (or more likely accidentally) lose it money - but weren't in a position to actually steal anything. So require a different level and kind of oversight.

        When I worked for a US multi-national twenty years ago - we had a specific computer/terminal for bank transactions. I think it took a single director / finance manager to authorise under £10k - 2 up to £100k and 3 for more than that. And all had to be physically present at the machine. It was also in the finance main office (the desk opposite mine) - so you couldn't get at it sneakily (at least in office/banking hours). I didn't ever use it, so have no idea how well it was secured or how easy to compromise - but if I were creating a major trading system - I'd not allow big transactions from any computer not on a fixed network and physically located in the office.

        Just looked it up, and I was surprised at how small the amounts were Leeson was dealing with. Because of his final doubling bets, the losses ended up in the hundreds of millions - but it was mostly small beer at a small office, until the end.

        1. munnoch Silver badge

          "Just looked it up, and I was surprised at how small the amounts were Leeson was dealing with"

          It seemed enormous at the time, but soon eclipsed by even bigger failures. That's progress I suppose...

          Leeson just made duff trades and parked them in an account that for some reason wasn't monitored, or the people who should have been monitoring didn't feel able to challenge him. The Kobe earthquake moved the market sufficiently that they had no prospect of making the margin calls. If it hadn't been for that he might have gotten lucky and got out without anyone knowing. He earned the jail time for his attempts to cover it up not for any personal gain.

          The "Securities" part of the bank had been acquired some years previously and was filled with larger than life characters. Leeson took his place amongst them. They seemed to be making inordinate profits and the Brothers were happy for that to continue so presumably didn't feel compelled to look very hard at it. I think the famous quote from one of them was something like "Its not very hard to make money in Asia". I'm not going to say they deserved it, but...

          Nevertheless I have fond memories of that place. My first proper job, learned a huge amount, made lifelong friends.

          1. I ain't Spartacus Gold badge

            munnoch,

            The account was supposed to be monitored by the back office manager of the Singapore office of Barings Bank. One... Nick Leeson.

            Basically they made him head of trading and head of back office at the same time. And thus responsible for auditing his own (and his team's) trades. This didn't end well.

    2. FIA Silver badge

      This is one of the main issues with first generation blockchains.

      More modern ones have smart contracts and multi sig wallets that would help with stuff like this.

  6. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    In a professional UK Banking Environment

    Downloading software onto a Bank's computers from an untrusted external source would be a sackable offence.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: In a professional UK Banking Environment

      Quote: "Downloading software onto a Bank's computers from an untrusted external source would be a sackable offence."

      ....and downloading PETABYTES of other people's copyright material should be a reason for JAIL TIME!!

      But no......two teenagers download a few gigabytes from TFL and get five years jail time................

      ........on the other hand Sam Altman downloads a million PETABYTES and everyone cheers!!!!!

      Sigh!!!!!

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: In a professional UK Banking Environment

      Hahahaha, not in the banks I worked at. The HR manual might say that, but detection and enforcement were woeful. Security was just seen as a compliance checkbox, where a lot of time the box could be ticked by an internal interview audit without spending profits unnecessarily on actual security.

      1. FrogsAndChips Silver badge

        Re: In a professional UK Banking Environment

        What was the name of that bank, so I can make sure I close my accounts if I have any and never deal with them in the future?

      2. Steve Graham

        Re: In a professional UK Banking Environment

        I did one project for a bank (RBoS) and the security was nailed down very tight. There was no possibility of a developer getting access to a live, running system.

        If the Binance hackers could operate live transactions by using the engineers' compromised devices, surely that means that the engineers themselves could have done it if they were a bit smarter (or more dishonest).

    3. John_Ericsson

      Re: In a professional UK Banking Environment

      "Downloading software onto a Bank's computers from an untrusted external source would be a sackable offence."

      I would say ...

      Allowing software to be installed on a Bank's computers from an untrusted external source would be a sackable offence.

      When lockdown began and users began using laptops and I locked them down so all they could do is connect to required servers withing the org.

      My argument was I did not want users accessing personal data on laptops that had Minecraft on them.

      When I left the first thing "IT" did was remove that rule because endpoint protection is a security control that covered the risk.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: In a professional UK Banking Environment

        "Welcome to the PowerShell Gallery

        The central repository for sharing and acquiring PowerShell code including PowerShell modules, scripts, and DSC resources.

        The packages on this repository are community content and should be regarded as inherently untrusted."

        right in the middle of our build chain....

  7. lglethal Silver badge
    Facepalm

    Why in the world...

    Why in the world would you do a job interview over your work laptop???

    1) It is highly likely that it could be flagged by IT, so now HR knows you're looking for a new job.

    2) In a lot of places, such an act could be classed as a sackable offence, not the looking for another job, but using work equipment for non-work purposes.

    3) So great you've now been sacked before the other job has come through, and being sacked from your current job, is probably a reason for the new firm to pass you over. Because clearly your not very bright, if you let your previous firm know you were job hunting before you had things sown up.

    If you cant afford your own PC, then there are Internet cafes around or use your bloody phone. If those Engineers havent been sacked, for the sheet stupidity of job hunting on a work computer, then frankly they should be. Not for the failures that led to the breach, but for being more then a few sandwiches short of a picnic in the first place!

    1. Excused Boots Silver badge

      Re: Why in the world...

      People, even quite clever people, can be really, really stupid.

  8. cookiecutter Silver badge

    bloody developers! genuinely how dumb do you have to be to use s work laptop for interviewing?!

    just had to get off a webinar where they said "developers will just work around security controls that slow them down" - like it's OK!!

    No wonder more beaches are happening with more cves & less secure software and shittier products!!

  9. Locomotion69

    I guess this reflect the current approach for hacks.

    As it becomes harder to get in from the outside, you need an asset inside to open up the door for you.

    May be a human, but I fear soon we find out that AI did just that...

    /putting my crystal ball aside

    1. ShadowDragon8685

      I can't WAIT to read the AI's apology for the steps it took to let a foreign operative in. Bonus if it just says outright "yes, the rules say I should not have done this but I did it anyway."

  10. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    And still

    Nothing of value was lost.

  11. TeeCee Gold badge
    Meh

    "$6.3 billion heist"

    Oh, wow, that's serious!

    "cryptocurrency exchange"

    Ah, right, as you were then.

  12. big_D

    What idiot?

    Uses a company laptop to take a job interview? Surely, if you are planning to defect to another company, you don't want to provide your current employer with a heads-up that you are looking, you do it on your own device and over your own network or mobile network. I certainly wouldn't use a company device to contact a prospective employer.

  13. Wempy

    There is someone missing

    I wonder what befell Engineer B

    1. lglethal Silver badge
      Trollface

      Re: There is someone missing

      "oh that poor basta... ahh nevermind, nothing bad happened.... We just dont talk about Engineer B anymore, it tends to upset the secretaries after all..."

  14. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    "..deploy a container, and triggered a script to launch the cryptocurrency-stealing attack"

    So a single engineer actually had the power to do this and the entire business was relying on good chap theory to stop them running away with billions.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      In my day banks kept dev and ops apart for exactly this reason. This hack reveals the true power of devops. For the Norks at least.

    2. Sok Puppette

      ... and they "fixed" it by changing the keys.

  15. trevorde Silver badge

    Guess he didn't get the job ...

  16. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    I guess if they wanted to, the criminals could really screw over the dumb dev by ... waiting a while, then making a big payment into his bank account. The delay needs to be long enough that it looks like it was intended to be missed by those who'd probably stopped investigating, but short enough to ensure it doesn't get missed. That would really rub salt into the wounds they must be feeling now.

    1. doublelayer Silver badge

      I suppose they could, but do they have any reason to? They want the money for themselves, they don't get any benefit by giving more clues where they have the money now, and they have no reason to hate the dev and want to cause harm to them.

  17. RM Myers Silver badge
    FAIL

    Web3 still going great!

    See the title.

  18. Gavsky

    Security is complicated because: humans. Don't use obvious passwords/never open unsolicited attachments/don't download something because they tell you to etc, but...well - humans.

    We can be lazy/manipulated - even otherwise intelligent & aware individuals. So, systems need to be designed so they protect us: from ourselves. I salute the effort & artifice of the scumbags responsible. At least Crypto currency is infallible...er..

  19. midnitet0ker

    Deregulated Finance Means Fine Tobacco!

    I have zero empathy for anyone whose crypto got swiped. When you put your money into shady financial institutions that have lax security like this with n00b engineers interviewing for a new job *from work*, ya pays yer money and ya takes yer chances.

    I worked for a regulated finance company before and no way in hell would anyone have been able to interview from their workstation because our internet access was locked down to prevent something like this happening. Even the USB ports on our work computers were sealed off to prevent thumb drive use and malware insertion/data extraction.

  20. W.S.Gosset

    Cold War

    >Norks

    Gawd, haven't seen that outside the old Cold War era documents.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon