The Register Home Page

back to article FBI pins $6.3B Binance crypto heist on North Korean hackers

The FBI has blamed North Korean hackers for the record-breaking $6.3 billion theft from cryptocurrency exchange Binance, pointing the finger at the notorious Lazarus Group as the exchange scrambles to replace stolen funds and reassure customers. In an alert published Saturday, the agency attributed the October 29 attack to …

  1. lglethal Silver badge
    Go

    No comment from China - hmmm....

    I find it interesting that there has been no comment from China about the Binance Hack.

    Binance is nominally Chinese, run by two Chinese entrepreneurs. However, Crypto is also nominally banned in China, or at least it is officially banned to trade Crypto for Yuan currency, even if its not illegal to mine it or hold it. Even with this "ban", the Chinese people are still one of the biggest holders of Crypto, and a lot of the users of Binance are in China. So this does hurt Chinese people, more so then Americans and "the West", as Binance America has claimed to be unaffected.

    North Korea are completely propped up by China, although they are currently playing China off against the Russians, and so it seems like a case of biting the hand that feeds them. That China hasnt given them a smack on the nose, for targeting a Chinese firm, is very much a surprise. Unless, NK was given the go-ahead, as a way to try to reduce confidence in Crypto, and get those Chinese citizens back to using good old trackable Yuans...

    It will be interesting to see what China does and says in the coming days... If it says anything at all...

    1. Paul Herber Silver badge

      Re: No comment from China - hmmm....

      It won't be the ordinary folk of China who are using Binance. It'll be the entrepreneurs, the political classes, those with power, money and influence, just like most other countries. Plus there must be a goodly amount of dirty money around in China.

      1. lglethal Silver badge
        Go

        Re: No comment from China - hmmm....

        Which if true, doubly raises the question why Kim hasnt been given a good spanking and sent to the naughty step...

        1. LucreLout Silver badge

          Re: No comment from China - hmmm....

          Maybe he offered to make Chinese citizens whole? Maybe the hackers avoided Chinese accounts. It does seem odd though.

    2. Blazde Silver badge

      Re: No comment from China - hmmm....

      They're "propped up by China" for the same reason Turkiye's huge refugee operation is propped up by the EU. They're nowhere close to being a vassal China can order around. More like a slum corner of the continent to carefully tolerate.

      If N.Korea managed to acquire nukes in defiance of China, I doubt a cryptocurrency exchange heist here and there is going to register. Except in so far as the two things are linked! It would be interesting to know what Xi thinks of Putin's recent involvement in advancing N.Korea's nuclear capabilities (the supposed mini nuclear reactors etc)....

    3. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

      Re: No comment from China - hmmm....

      I thought the North Korean leader was the "only leader I like" according to the President and "America's best friend"

      So if this is an attack on a Chinese crypto company by NK, it was presumably at the behest of the FBI

  2. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    but, but blockchain

    Isn't blockchain meant to be this super duper ledger of all transactions and why it was "the future" and you can trace every transaction ?

    yeah, tumblers - just seems so easy to bypass what was meant to be so good

    Not got Crypto and my knowledge of this is somewhat basic at best

    1. Irongut Silver badge

      Re: but, but blockchain

      > Isn't blockchain meant to be this super duper ledger of all transactions and why it was "the future" and you can trace every transaction ?

      No, it was supposed to be untraceable. Hence it gives you freedom from "the man" and enables you to buy drugs, guns and hitmen.

      It is in fact very traceable.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: but, but blockchain

        Incorrect, it was supposed to be unstoppable*. Total transparency, total control by the individual owner. For the majority of cryptocurrencies, only the alarmist, the ignorant and the ignorant alarmist were making claims about anonymity.

        *that is, no government or other external force can seize your funds or prevent you from using them as long as you maintain control over your keys.

        1. Charlie Clark Silver badge

          Re: but, but blockchain

          Anonymity was a key advantage pushed by many enthusiasts, along with "protection" from government seizure. Fiat money its their problems, and the banking system routinely screws investors, but on the whole, deposit insurance covers most losses. You might expect the volatility alone of cryptocurrencies to put people off, but "stable coins" have come along to move some of that risk to other investors. Gee, thanks!

          1. Anonymous Coward
            Anonymous Coward

            Re: but, but blockchain

            Stable coins really are the worst of both worlds and, while conventional PoW/PoS currencies could be described as a pyramid scheme, stable coins really are set up to easily be Ponzis.

            1. simonlb Silver badge

              Re: but, but blockchain

              It's all a Ponzi scheme, so only gamble what you can afford to lose.

              1. Anonymous Coward
                Anonymous Coward

                Re: but, but blockchain

                It's really not, it's a highly volatile, tradeable token. For a Ponzi scheme, the value of the sold asset needs to be misrepresented by the seller over the duration of the asset being held. The distinction is important because someone could see that they can freely transfer and sell their crypto and conclude that the person warning them it's a Ponzi is incorrect about there being any risk.

                It's just that the Ponzi had more prominence than the pyramid scheme in the media when cryptocurrencies started to become popular, so lazy writers used Ponzi without understanding how one works and/or how cryptocurrencies work.

                I do find it weird how a small number of people will doggedly insist on using the word to describe standard PoW/PoS cryptocurrencies even after having the difference explained. It's not as if accurately calling it a potential pyramid scheme confers legitimacy.

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: but, but blockchain

      They could have set up new wallets. If you want to do anything with ill gotten crypto, in the fullness of time, it can become more challenging to maintain anonymity but, as far as dumping it somewhere, it's relatively easy to keep ownership a secret, no tumblers or other methods needed.

      The neat part is that, unless an illicit cash flow is completely separated from known cash flows , there's always a risk of getting caught, even with a tumbler, because each transaction can be audited by anyone.

      1. renniks

        Re: but, but blockchain

        or they could just delete it all

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: but, but blockchain

          That's not really possible but destroying the keys for a wallet will have much the same effect. AFAIK, there's no way to provably signal this.

          1. LucreLout Silver badge

            Re: but, but blockchain

            Wasn't there a burn wallet for one of the coins that fell almost to zero? where the keys had been provably nuked so there was no way into it? Could they not do something similar, after of course buying legit versions of the coins - if they burn enough they get a share of the value back clean. Obvs the numbers involve could be massive and they'd need a decent slug of the entire base to be wrthwhile. Just speculating that it could be done, not that its necessarily wise to do it.

    3. LucreLout Silver badge

      Re: but, but blockchain

      Ok, I've not studied crypto in any depth. Can someone explain to me like I'm just a fucking manager, how do tumblers break the traceability of blockchain?

      Surely once a coin has entered such a thing it is forever dirtier than clean crypto that's never been stolen or obviously laundered? Logically a price differential should emerge?

      I could be missing something very basic here, so rather than just downvote 'cos thick, please downvote 'cos thick and provide an explanation why thick. Thx.

      1. lglethal Silver badge
        Go

        Re: but, but blockchain

        I'm also not a crypto expert, but my understanding of how a tumbler works is this:

        100 coins comes into account 1. 20 coins comes out into account 2 40 coins in a different coin type comes out in account 3. But then 200 more coins comes into account 1, and more coins are going out to accounts 3, 4, & 5. Some of them in other currencies, making it hard to track exactly how much is going where.

        This is not 100 coins in, 100 out, but maybe 85 out. In different currencies and to new and unknown wallets.

        It's effectively a shell game, where the only person who knows where the money is going is the Tumbler. The crim hands over a percentage, in order to get back currency to new and clean accounts, that is almost impossible to track.

        A very profitable business as you can imagine...

        1. LucreLout Silver badge

          Re: but, but blockchain

          Thanks for your response.

          The bit I'm struggling with is this - the crims can locate the tumblers who are essentially advertising to a competitive market for laundering. Eventually all tumbler addresses become known and so trivial to track what happened after the fact. Even if they turn all their profit into a float of ostensibly clean coins, the throughput on them vs the rest of the market must be tiny, making it even easier to determine what went in and what came out.

          The only disrupting factor would be some sort of random time lag, but that seems like a larger risk for the thief to take.

          I feel like I'm missing something here that everyone else sees, but for a forensic accountant, this seems trivial to unpick?

      2. doublelayer Silver badge

        Re: but, but blockchain

        You're not wrong exactly. There are two factors that contribute to this.

        Tumblers don't announce themselves. You see coins entering wallets with opaque ID numbers, so knowing whether a coin has gone through one isn't straightforward. We will get some tumbler addresses but mostly because we know the Binance wallet IDs the funds came from. Think of this like serial numbers on banknotes. You know the serial numbers when it was stolen, don't know what happened in the middle, and you then see it again. Do you assume the thief is still the same, that the spender knows the thief, or that they paid someone who doesn't know and they're innocent in the matter? You have no information that tells them apart. The mechanics are different for cryptocurrency, where the coins don't have serial numbers but the account IDs do, but you end up in the same place because all you can answer is whether the account you see has ever transacted with an account that has ever transacted with an account ... at the time coins were stolen from it.

        The other factor is that people don't treat coins that have been through a tumbler as worth less. Possibly they don't care because they consider tumblers neutral with legitimate uses. Possibly they don't care because money's as good as other money. So to the extent that they could do as you suggest, they're choosing not to.

        1. LucreLout Silver badge

          Re: but, but blockchain

          Thanks very much for your response.

          Tumblers must announce themselves somewhere - they have to attract clients in what logically would be a competitive market? I imagine it must work a little like how everyone knows how to find a drug dealer?

          Tracking the account transactions seems childs play, given they're public record on the blockchain? In the real world, if you found a bank account doing this, all transacting bank accounts would be frozen pending investigation - CIFAS markers are so easy to get and so hard to remove, for example. I get that freezing blockchain isn't entirely possible across many coins, however tracking the wallet owner should be easy enough because after a sufficient amount of fragmentation and layering, all the money is going to come back together in one place or just a couple, not hundreds or even thousands of wallets that its passed through.

          At some point the crypto needs an offramp in order to be worth anything. They surely are mostly already regulated?

          1. doublelayer Silver badge

            Re: but, but blockchain

            They do, but they don't have to announce their wallets. Creating a new wallet takes a few seconds of time. They can create fresh ones for every customer, and in fact they create many new ones for everyone, and those IDs don't get announced as connected to that tumbler. If I run a tumbler, you'd know that I do it, but you wouldn't know who my clients were or how much crypto I had tumbled in total.

        2. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

          Re: but, but blockchain

          >Do you assume the thief is still the same, that the spender knows the thief,

          No but if you are the US government you can promise that you will "terminate with extreme prejudice" anyone who owns those serial numbers and not care about who or what

          It's like being a simple family in Argentina who had no idea where Großvater obtained all those European art treasures before he emigrated in 1945 and claim they are totally innocent

  3. Rol

    No brainer - false flag waver.

    I find it hard to believe that a country that keeps the majority of its citizens like farmers keep battery hens could ever cobble together enough brains to pull off these stunts. Rather, the ease with which the pointing finger can be broken twisted and reset to implicate anywhere in the world, seems more like what happened.

    Although I'm also willing to accept that the hermit state isn't as dumb as the jingoism suggests.

    1. Charlie Clark Silver badge

      Re: No brainer - false flag waver.

      There have been quite a few instances of documented action by Nork hackers over the last few years. The income is significant to a country with virtually no external trade.

    2. doublelayer Silver badge

      Re: No brainer - false flag waver.

      North Korea has specialized in cryptocurrency and bank theft for many years. That should be unsurprising since money is one of the things they lack most. They have lots of motivation to find people who could be good with computers and assign them, and they have many schools and universities dedicated to that task with those scoring well on mathematics being the indication that you might have a golden goose to separate from the other livestock.

    3. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: No brainer - false flag waver.

      NK is proven to be really good at cyber.

      But yes, I agree other intelligencies might be doing the dirty and blaming NK.

    4. Sproggit Silver badge

      Re: No brainer - false flag waver.

      North Korea has a population of a little over 26 million people... but they also have a state-backed cyber army that includes thousands of specialized operatives working for elite state intelligence units and sponsored crime groups.

      The state recruits top science and math students at an early age and sending them to specialist institutions for training - including abroad, to Russia and China, for real-world experience. Bear in mind that Russia has an incredibly extensive cybercrime industry, with dozens of wanted criminals remaining within the country, effectively untouchable. Meanwhile, China's focus has been less on financial crime and more on intellectual property theft. But... all three nations have a common interest in offensive hacking capabilities.

      Recently NK have reportedly been using AI real-time video generation to impersonate caucasian job candidates for remote work, embedding them in western companies... where of course they gain a great deal of experience about technology defenses and also the mindset of the defenders they look to outwit.

      In short, they are much more capable - and dangerous - than their reputation would suggest.

  4. VoiceOfTruth Silver badge

    Meanwhile

    The USA has stolen all of Venezuela's oil.

    1. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

      Re: Meanwhile

      How charmingly retro - I do hope they send out some chaps in Pith helmets to explain that to the locals

  5. Winkypop Silver badge
    Devil

    Money, it’s a hit

    Don’t give me that too safe to steal bullshit.

  6. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    "Published a list of crypto wallet addresses"

    So all they need to do is setup a string of new wallets, and move the crypto around a few times before exchanging it?

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon