The Register Home Page

back to article Frozen part II: Hackers remotely defrost produce in Euro supermarkets ... again

The cyberattacks on commercial refrigerators and freezers in Europe continue, as a slew of grocery stores in Belgium, Ireland, Luxembourg, and Sweden report widespread food wastage as a result of miscreants raising the temperatures to highs of 50ºC (122°F). In Belgium, around 40 Delhaize stores were affected after the attackers …

  1. Jou (Mxyzptlk) Silver badge

    Oh no.... Trying to resist... The cringe... Loosing control...

    let's go bad

    let's go bad

    don't freeze it up any more

    let's go bad

    let's go bad

    turn away and melt the door

    I don't care what they're going to eat

    let the heat rage ooooon

    their food never bothered me anyway...

    1. MyffyW Silver badge

      Re: Oh no.... Trying to resist... The cringe... Loosing control...

      Some people are worth melting for....

    2. Gavsky

      Re: Oh no.... Trying to resist... The cringe... Loosing control...

      "Excuse me, Sir - Spelling Police, here. You're in control of a comment & have committed an offence: 'Loosing' should be 'Losing'. On this occasion, I shall give you a written warning"...

      1. Jou (Mxyzptlk) Silver badge

        Re: Oh no.... Trying to resist... The cringe... Loosing control...

        I had to loose my control to lose my control. You should loose your grammar interpretations or you lose authority. Written warning lost due to loose door of the transport.

  2. that one in the corner Silver badge

    We can't have anything worse in our line of work

    WTF is wrong with these people?

    > he arrived to work on Monday morning and was greeted by a puddle of water and freezers set to 55 degrees C – a tale echoed by other managers across the country.

    They MUST have heard about the earlier attacks and they KNOW how destructive this is. They haven't disconnected their freezers (wire cutter FTW). They aren't even MONITORING? Yes, paying for some schlub to walk around at night and weekends is a cost, but worse than their current situation (immediate loss of stock, loss of business, loss of credibility)?

    1. NXM Silver badge

      Re: We can't have anything worse in our line of work

      It's clearly a who, me? story.

      1. NoneSuch Silver badge

        Re: We can't have anything worse in our line of work

        I suppose it's a testament to everyone else toughening their environments that the only things left are commercial freezers.

        Hospitals, emergency services, Power grids. Could be much worse.

    2. Piro

      Re: We can't have anything worse in our line of work

      The absolute moment the first ones were "hacked" (which they weren't, people just logged freely on to systems that were public and had determinisitic credentials), every single supermarket should have immediately audited their systems. Even ones that aren't very IT aware, should have just disconnected their cooling systems from the internet.

      I mean, they weren't even using them to monitor the temperatures, which is the whole damn point of having them connected in the first place! So they had insecure systems directly online, whose only real purpose is to monitor the temperatures, and they didn't even use them for that.

      1. find users who cut cat tail

        Re: We can't have anything worse in our line of work

        I hope commercial cooling systems are better in this regard than tellies (for example). But do some constantly complain if they are not connected to the wide internet? I would not bet against it.

      2. Wellyboot

        Re: We can't have anything worse in our line of work

        Given the fridge/freezer contents I can't see any valid reason to need 24/7 active online control, once the thermostat is set manually the worst that can happen is a compressor failure and that needs a screwdriver fix.

        There must be sensible companies out there using simple SBCs (PI, Arduino etc) to monitor dumb fridge/freezer temps and connect via VPN (on another SBC?) back to a central monitoring system.

        1. user555

          Re: We can't have anything worse in our line of work

          But then the stores would have control. Can't have that when those stores can be duped into handing that control over.

          1. jdiebdhidbsusbvwbsidnsoskebid Silver badge

            Re: We can't have anything worse in our line of work

            The freezer suppliers will say to the shops "our products will save you money because we will monitor them remotely 24/7 for you, so you don't have to hire real people to watch them, with all the management hassle and costs that entails. Your security is our prime concern and is very important to us. Blah blah blah blah..."

            The shop just says "stop, you had us with 'save money', where do we sign?"

            Some bright spark probably pipes up with "I've read about something called cyber security, do your freezers do that?"

            Someone more senior says "Bob, shut up, didn't you hear the sales team say 'saves money'?"

            1. MachDiamond Silver badge

              Re: We can't have anything worse in our line of work

              "The freezer suppliers will say to the shops "our products will save you money because we will monitor them remotely 24/7 for you, so you don't have to hire real people to watch them, with all the management hassle and costs that entails. Your security is our prime concern and is very important to us. Blah blah blah blah..."

              Another shining example of swapping convenience and risk.

              "Here's this very insecure payment app that's dead simple to use." Nevermind that the fine print in the EULA tells of how the service is not responsible for anything at all. That's saves loads of money since Jonny kant reed and will sign up regardless. Fraud protection costs money. I don't have anything financial on my phone. I drilled a tiny little hole in my debit card that killed the NFC functionality. The chip still works just fine. After I found out that the code on the back of my driving license also has loads of other information such as my Social Security Number, that got some attention so it won't read correctly anymore some shops want to scan it when buying bevvies. I don't shop at those place, but I don't want to risk somebody making a quick scan when I hand over my ID without me knowing they were going to do that.

        2. MachDiamond Silver badge

          Re: We can't have anything worse in our line of work

          "once the thermostat is set manually the worst that can happen is a compressor failure and that needs a screwdriver fix."

          For a grocery, having a redundant compressor/cooling loop is good insurance. If the primary fails or needs to be shut down for service, the backup can turn on and take over. None of that needs online controls. A completely separate temperature monitoring system that can send out notices if temps get too close to a set point or are rising too quickly aren't uncommon if that's what's needed.

          After the first round of incidents, I'd find out the particulars and take some precautions. It's not just the frozen/refrigerated foods. Somebody needing to buy some food will go elsewhere if they hear that the shop has lost all it's cooled inventory. (just some insult to pile on top of the injury). That leads to a bigger loss than just the cost of the food and the disposal/cleanup.

      3. user555

        Re: We can't have anything worse in our line of work

        It's way worse. The stores won't have control at all. The equipment supplier does it all on behalf. It's like the Flock cameras, where the city councils attempt to cancel the contract and have the cameras removed but the company just puts then back up because the company says the cancelled contract hasn't expired.

        1. dave 76

          Re: We can't have anything worse in our line of work

          It's way worse. The stores won't have control at all. The equipment supplier does it all on behalf.

          I can well believe this is the case, so surely the equipment supplier should be getting a bill for all the wasted food.

          1. CrazyOldCatMan Silver badge

            Re: We can't have anything worse in our line of work

            so surely the equipment supplier should be getting a bill for all the wasted food.

            "Check the contract. We haz lawyers. We don't owe you nuffink"

            (I suspect that the liability of the 'management' company is strictly limited and, given that the chain management don't seem to have actually learnt from the clear lesson of last week, I wouldn't have much confidence on them actually thinking about such things either).

        2. MachDiamond Silver badge

          Re: We can't have anything worse in our line of work

          "where the city councils attempt to cancel the contract and have the cameras removed but the company just puts then back up because the company says the cancelled contract hasn't expired."

          The initial contract paid for the hardware and cancelling the contract only severs access by that city/county. The data can still be sold to many others at phat profit. I wouldn't be surprised if data from cameras that are left in cities that cancel their contracts would be charged at a premium level and called "extended insight" or something now that the sponsor is gone.

      4. phuzz Silver badge

        Re: We can't have anything worse in our line of work

        I guarantee that today there are IT folks going to their manager to say "You know that request I made to firewall all our fridges but you turned it down because of 'budget'? Well, it's too late now."

      5. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: We can't have anything worse in our line of work

        "The absolute moment the first ones were "hacked" (which they weren't, people just logged freely on to systems that were public and had determinisitic credentials), every single supermarket should have immediately audited their systems. Even ones that aren't very IT aware, should have just disconnected their cooling systems from the internet.

        I mean, they weren't even using them to monitor the temperatures, which is the whole damn point of having them connected in the first place! So they had insecure systems directly online, whose only real purpose is to monitor the temperatures, and they didn't even use them for that."

        Even worse is, the same companies (Carrefour, Groupe U etc ...) were hit AGAIN, after being hit last month, even if in another country, and the publication of the VCE by Claroty group 8200 in august !

        This is like, no-one seems to give a flying f*ck in those companies.

        I'd be the attackers, I'd save the attacked IPs and give it another try next week. I bet you many would not have been patched, or, better, taken offline already !

        They'd only act after half a dozen of the same incident on the same asset, me think.

        Absolute morons !

    3. Doctor Syntax Silver badge

      Re: We can't have anything worse in our line of work

      Explanation is simple: "It couldn't happen to us."

      1. Korev Silver badge
        Coat

        Re: We can't have anything worse in our line of work

        The French supermarkets need to be more Carrefore with their freezers

      2. Terje

        Re: We can't have anything worse in our line of work

        From what I understand many were about to upgrade / change the systems after the first attacks, it's just that it takes enough time to do that many had not managed it yet.

        1. Piro

          Re: We can't have anything worse in our line of work

          That's not how any of this works anymore. There can be no waiting or approval period. Things need to be fixed immediately. In this case, simply disconnected until proper opsec could be implemented. Insecure old systems weren't the problem; the fact that they were publicly addressable was. Put them behind a vpn with mfa and suddenly things are manageable. Have them send alerts for monitoring so remote access is largely unnecessary.

          1. BrownishMonstr

            Re: We can't have anything worse in our line of work

            I understand your concern, Steve (there's always a Steve), but our systems require you to create a request, which is then approved by your manager, who doesn't understand why you want to disconnect the fridge/freezers from the national grid and needs the same answer several times before it sticks. Once he approves it then the district managers need to be made aware of what needs to happen and they are all confused why you want to disconnect the fridge/freezers, and "won't everything melt". Then the local managers need to be alerted and it's much easier to do that on the all-hands meeting. But Expect the same questions again and again...why are we taking the WiFi off, I need to watch YouTube..I mean work. Won't everything melt?

            Then by the time most of those people have a vague understand of what's going on, you put in the support ticket and the supplier responds after a month, it turns out if you unplug the fridge/freezers then they effectively become dead units, anyway. But before we even get to that response, we've just been hacked, Steve!

            ---------------

            Enterprises have silly policies. We buy from Amazon, but not directly, no. We only want to pay Amazon once the products are delivered, so we hire a middleman to buy it for us, then we pay them every few months a nice service-fee for acting as our creditor. But doing so takes weeks, needs approvals from your manager, finance, and possibly even the King, himself, the whole process taking like a month for a next-day delivery from Amazon. Oh, you found somewhere cheaper? They're not an approved supplier, so no can do.

            1. MachDiamond Silver badge

              Re: We can't have anything worse in our line of work

              "Then the local managers need to be alerted and it's much easier to do that on the all-hands meeting."

              But a few managers won't be back from holiday until next week, so they'll schedule the meeting for that time so "everybody is on the same page".

          2. phuzz Silver badge
            Unhappy

            Re: We can't have anything worse in our line of work

            How things should work, and how things actually happen in most businesses, are unrelated.

        2. MachDiamond Silver badge

          Re: We can't have anything worse in our line of work

          "From what I understand many were about to upgrade / change the systems after the first attacks, it's just that it takes enough time to do that many had not managed it yet."

          Fixin' to do something isn't the same as doing something. Were the accountants and MBA's "exploring the most cost effective method of mitigating the risk" and got caught with the trousers at half mast? All of a sudden, trying to find the way to do something cheaply just got very expensive. As a Scot, I know this well. I've had to try and learn that in plenty of cases I should just spend the money.

    4. TonyHoyle

      Re: We can't have anything worse in our line of work

      > Yes, paying for some schlub to walk around at night and weekends is a cost

      Precisely. To a bean counter it's pay someone minimum wage to stop it or pay nothing and hope you get away with it.. and if you don't, it's covered by insurance.

    5. Groo The Wanderer - A Canuck Silver badge

      Re: We can't have anything worse in our line of work

      I thought much the same. After the first attacks, I'd have unplugged all ethernet cables from my freezers and fridges.

      But I have a functioning brain cell, which management at these companies apparently lacks completely.

  3. The Dogs Meevonks

    Fuck Around Find Out.... that freezers DO NOT need to be connected to the internet and left unmonitored.

    'But it's so they can be monitored and we get alerts if they go wrong'

    How'd that work out...

    Morons doing moron things... and I bet it has nothing to do with a manufacturer trying to exert control over sold systems... is the manufacturer going to cover the losses?

    I'm now at the stage where I think the internet just needs to be burned to the ground... rebuilt with encryption, security and privacy at the core.

    1. The Man Who Fell To Earth
      FAIL

      More importantly

      They don't need to be remote controlled, especially if they are unmonitored. But just making them "send data to server only," with no remote control capability, would suffice to tell if they are working without allowing the possibility of them being hacked and turned off or having settings changed. An awful lot of industrial equipment is great to monitor but doesn't have a need/risk/reward profile in favor of remote control. And if some tiny fraction of the equipment does & you don't want to manufacture two versions, build it so remote control can't physically happen without a physical switch or jumper being set to physically connect the control signal to where it needs to go.

    2. Sproggit Silver badge

      But It's Worse Than That

      These units are connected to the internet - clearly so, since they have been hacked... yet they are *NOT* being monitored.

      On what planet does a company connect equipment *to the internet* and then not monitor it?

      The technologists who agreed to connect these devices to networks should be sacked.

      1. DrewPH Silver badge

        Re: But It's Worse Than That

        Those technologists would have been sacked if they refused. It's the PHBs who gave the orders that should be sacked. A story as old as time.

    3. Mickey Porkpies

      Obession with cloud first

      funded b tech companies and now with AI good luck building secure platforms you can control that are not wide open to all and sundry. this was inevitable and still IT managers push on with someone else's computer strategy without considering all of the options. Sure it great for some systems but if it can kill your business you are negligent in not protecting it.

      1. Tron Silver badge

        Re: Obession with cloud first

        The usual: Detach your infrastructure, intranet and data stores from the internet entirely. Only connect a disposable system for internet-facing activity. Do it now, and then rebuild a safer tech architecture. SaaS, Cloud and AI are over. Get back on prem, and remove as much from the net as you can. Don't plan to do it some time in the future. Design out risk, or just play whack-a-mole until you are pwned.

        I may have to put pasting that on a function key. Or hire a van, put it on the side and park it outside the House of Commons.

        It's presumably why Gove told us all to stock up on 3 days of supplies - 3 days to mop up and restock - assuming that there is anything to restock with. There isn't so much fresh stuff in our supermarkets any more, even without a hack.

        Surely these things have manual controls and they can just unplug the net connection. Nobody would be stupid enough to have them only work with an online connection.

        1. Will Godfrey Silver badge
          Facepalm

          Re: Obession with cloud first

          <-Surely these things have manual controls and they can just unplug the net connection. Nobody would be stupid enough to have them only work with an online connection.->

          You think?

          I'm pretty sure they would... and do!

    4. spuck

      If it's like most organizations I've dealt with, the whole situation can probably boil down to one thing: "No one told me to do it."

      It's not like the paid-hourly stock boy is going to unplug anything they don't fully understand. Even the branch manager has probably endured enough beatings from corporate over the years to know that no good deed goes unpunished; they sure as hell aren't going to take it upon themselves to be proactive in a way that could result in them being asked to explain why they went against policy.

    5. Joe W Silver badge

      Yeah, that's what I find so crazy / stupid: The thing can be controlled via the internet but nobody wants to monitor the state of the system.

      I know a person working for a pharmacy that prepares chemotherapy drugs in their sterile lab. They have lots of the most common drugs in their fridges, worth a fuckton of money. The fridges are set to a certain temperature and then they have a monitoring system that checks the temperatures in the fridges and the state of the fridge and everything. I know that they are on call at night and sometimes have to drive in to manually check equipment. Not often, but it has happened.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        yeah similar to -80 sample freezers in labs, Unis etc We use ICEspy to monitor ours

    6. Dwarf

      If the manufacturer or some other middle layer was monitoring them, how come the monitoring tools didn't alert that something was wrong ?

      After all, I can't imagine any normal use case where a freezer being at 50C might be seen as a good thing, even when it goes from -5 to say +5 the alarms should be going off.

      This looks to me, to be failures on several levels

      1. Why is it connected to the Internet

      2. Why is it not secured in the normal manner against bad actors

      3. If its not being monitored, then why ?

      4. If it is being monitored, who failed to alert that something was wrong.

      5. As the vulnerability has been know about for a very long time, why was something not done to mitigate the risk.

      I've read that the manufacturer said it needed a hardware upgrade, well I'm sure that a software upgrade, even if it were to dump some of the things that were not needed, to make room for things that were needed, then a software fix could be made, even if someone had to go to each unit and manually firmware upgrade them, that would cost a lot less than the current mess.

  4. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Sloppy

    So Ahold Delhaize after the last attack went into cyber audit mania after the dutch super markets got hit a few weeks ago...... but they forgot to audit all the other refrigeration units they run in all their other stores in other countries????

    1. Jou (Mxyzptlk) Silver badge

      Re: Sloppy

      Citing the article:

      Other retailers, such as Coopérative U, confirmed they were not Danfoss customers.

      This is not limited to that one which was affected last month. So quite a number of the could not "forget" to audit all other fridges.

      But it should have rung a bell at all other manufacturers to check their own fridges. It will ring louder now for the rest of them, 'cause TWICE within less than 30 days is a big warning.

      (Why didn't they hack that in June and July?)

      1. ITS Retired

        Re: Sloppy

        How many refrigerators/freezers were connect to the Internet, but no one at the store was responsible for, or knowing anything about how they were hooked up, or why?

        1. Jou (Mxyzptlk) Silver badge

          Re: Sloppy

          Asking for an audit? In a "lowest price wins" world?

      2. oldandgrey
        Flame

        Danfoss and Copeland

        Not just Danfoss from Denmark but also Copeland from the USA, as per: https://noslite.nl/l/2637775.html

  5. tiggity Silver badge

    You do wonder

    Must admit that when supermarket shopping recently (Lidl, UK) and a big refrigeration unit was out of action with an engineer busy working on it my initial thoughts were "I wonder if that's another hack victim" - given whole unit was emptied, as ( if it was just a hardware / firmware upgrade to fix a vulnerable fridge you would hope that would be a quick & easy job that would not need much time & effort*

    * If it does need a lot of time / effort then it implies very poor design in terms of fridge "uptime" / maintainability.

  6. TimMaher Silver badge
    Facepalm

    Our local CostCutter…

    …always has water on the floor.

    But that is just because their chilled cabinets are poorly maintained.

    1. Gavsky

      Re: Our local CostCutter…

      Well, the clue is in their name! Cost Cutter's full, company name is 'Cost Cutter For Everything, Including Equipment Maintenance'. But, it wouldn't all fit on the sign...

  7. ICL1900-G3 Silver badge

    Waste

    What an absolutely appalling waste of food. All responsible should hang their heads in shame.

    1. frankvw Silver badge

      Re: Waste

      All responsible should hang their heads in shame.

      Fixed that for you...

    2. brainwrong

      Re: Waste

      Stuff is cheap. Good engineering isn't. This is the result.

      People want cheap stuff, in part because for at least 3 decades they've been told that cheap stuff is only a good thing, in complete ignorance of the supplier half of the transaction.

    3. stiine Silver badge

      Re: Waste

      The pig farmers should be rejoicing, but very quietly. Any store that doesn't already have a spoilage-to-pig-farm process should really re-think their priorities.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: Waste

        They're not allowed to feed pigs on general waste, these days, for food safely reasons.

        1. Swedish Chef

          Re: Waste

          True, but they can probably still rejoice for other reasons. Sales are expected to be spiking this week.

        2. CrazyOldCatMan Silver badge

          Re: Waste

          They're not allowed to feed pigs on general waste, these days, for food safely reasons.

          Indeed.

          The spoiled food is likely mostly headed for the nearest methane-producing digester. Or bio waste disposal furnace. You can't landfill it (in a civilised country, the rules would prevent that to stop vermin and disease), you can't give it to homeless kitchens (illegal) and you certainly can't fire-sale (!) it.

          So the only two viable methods are methane-digester or burning.

          1. MachDiamond Silver badge

            Re: Waste

            "you can't give it to homeless kitchens (illegal) and you certainly can't fire-sale (!) it."

            In this instance, those would be bad things. If the freezers had just been switched off and the inventory was defrosting as one might do by taking a joint out of the freezer and putting it in the fridge for tomorrows dinner, that would be ok. Instead, the defrost cycle was put on infinite and the food heated to temperature many pathogens find quite nice. It's similar to people setting food out on a park table a couple of hours in advance of lunch where it heats in the sun and makes everybody sick.

            Pigs have a very similar immune system to humans. This is why heart valves and other tissues are harvested from pigs for transplant. It's also why cleanliness is super important when it comes to butchering pigs. Feeding them spoiled foods can lead to issues. Most surplus food they get is just stuff that isn't nice and shiny the way markets want it and from prepared food that has been cooked. I expect there was loads of processed food that's not healthy to eat in the first place.

    4. Mr Dogshit

      Re: Waste

      Putin?

  8. frankvw Silver badge
    Megaphone

    Hackers providing a community service

    Whoever these guys are, kudos to them for educating those who need it.

    So now that we've all learned the unwisdom of connecting vital kit to the Internet (in this case part of the food supply chain) it's time to pass legislation to that effect, and make sure electricity, water and food supplies, traffic infrastructure and what not is all properly airgapped. With severe penalties for those who are responsible for seeing to that but fail to do so properly, of course.

    1. alain williams Silver badge

      Re: Hackers providing a community service

      I am wondering if said hackers are enlightened members of GCHQ or their equivalents around Europe.

      Why ?

      It has been known for many years that industrial control and SCADA systems are vulnerable, having been designed in an era that cyber cracking was unknown. No one did anything. There have been several systems attacked; this has been reported; still no one did anything.

      So carrying out these high profile attacks might make those who look after these systems wake up and do something. The cost in lost frozen food of €1 million or so is tiny to the cost if real attacks hit wider and more critical infrastructure.

      I have no idea who is behind this but if it is our spooks I applaud them. If it is not our spooks I encourage them to start hacking and cause damage until the idiots responsible for this infrastructure do their job properly.

      1. MachDiamond Silver badge

        Re: Hackers providing a community service

        "It has been known for many years that industrial control and SCADA systems are vulnerable,"

        They are perfectly fine if they aren't connected to the internet. Many aircraft are loads of SCADA systems, but kept offline, that makes no difference. You must have physical access to do bad things to them. A lot of IoT crap is extremely vulnerable due to zero security consideration AND also connected to the world at the same time. The same unit on my separate home network is no big deal since that isn't allowed to play on the motorway.

  9. Locomotion69

    In NL a limited number of retailers was hit by this hack.

    Indeed, after the previous hack, what was the reason to not act? Ignorance? Incompetence?

    1. Piro

      People waiting for someone else to do something.

      1. Gavsky

        "People waiting for someone else to do something" - & THIS is why I lost my job as a coach driver: the canyon was ahead, I waited for someone else to brake...

        Poor orphans, they didn't leap to safety - like I did.

    2. CrazyOldCatMan Silver badge

      what was the reason to not act? Ignorance? Incompetence?

      Corporate inertia and bureaucracy. And not wanting to spend money because "it's only happened once so we should be OK".

  10. JWLong Silver badge

    You Have No Ideal........

    .......the size of these systems, thousands of pounds of refridgerent gas, 10-15 hp compressors, thousands of feet of copper piping, control valves(mechanical, electrical/electronic),sensors, air handlers, hundreds of amps of power distribution. All controlled by a 1990's controller that was never programed for secuity!

    The controllers handle all functions concerning the operation of the system. They log/graph temps/time, and do have local alarms at panels located through out the facility, and to remote locations.

    Obviously the remote notification system is not functioning, yet the internet connection is still plugged in(WTF).

    I use to work on retail systems in stores because I was the only one that could get a 800lb compressor up 60ft and across the roof without destroying the building or roof.

    As far as remote adjustment/service of the system is concerned, I know of NO serviceman that would use it because they want to be on site/hands on to evaluate the machinery and any changes made. They need to watch/see the operation of valves, contactors, sensors, fans, drive systems. They want to verify temps and pressures and total operation(like oil seperation/levels).

    Why this shit is still connected to the internet is the question of the day! If corporate isn't going to pay someone to monitor these systems there is no need for the connection, it is not for servicing or diagnosing problems that's for damn sure.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: You Have No Ideal........

      Refrigerant

    2. user555

      Re: You Have No Ideal........

      They weren't connected historically. This is new feature of the "smart" era of new equipment. Primary function is to take control away from the customers (store owners).

    3. cyberdemon Silver badge
      Devil

      Re: You Have No Ideal........

      It's not necessarily "on the Internet". If someone is stupid enough to plug the fridge's Ethernet port into a switch that's connected to the office WiFi network, then any phone app on any staff member's phone can potentially bridge the "firewall". Even a webpage can potentially do this, thanks to the horror that is JavaScript.

      E.g. my bench power supply has an Ethernet port, but I don't use it. The USB port is fine. And I would be very paranoid about connecting the Ethernet if anything expensive is attached to the power supply's output, because there is no authentication whatsoever, and anyone can open a TCP connection on Port 21 (Telnet) and send something like ":VOLT 60\n" to set the output to its maximum 60V.

      Scarier still, my former employer had "bench power supplies" of the kind that came in a 16U rack frame, weighed a quarter ton and plugged into a 125A 400V 3-phase socket and were capable of sourcing (and sinking) 1500V DC @ 30A (45kW) or more amps at lower voltages. They had a very similar control protocol, but my boss refused to budge when I explained that they should not be on the office network. His response was somnething along the lines of "Well, it's not like they're on the Internet" and "We can't mitigate for bad actors"

      1. stiine Silver badge

        Re: You Have No Ideal........

        With the correct adapter and driver, your USB port is an ethernet port, or worse.

      2. sabroni Silver badge
        Facepalm

        Re: thanks to the horror that is JavaScript.

        What the fuck has JavaScript got to do with it?

        The problem is the freezer allowing external connections to tell it to defrost.

        You could use any number of languages to do that, even C++! (though that implementation would probably leak memory and have uncountable vulnerabilities....)

        Oh, the horror!

    4. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: You Have No Ideal........

      "I use to work on retail systems in stores because I was the only one that could get a 800lb compressor up 60ft and across the roof without destroying the building or roof."

      Mr. Magnus Ver Magnusson, I presume?

  11. may_i Silver badge
    Facepalm

    Coop

    Ah, the Swedish Coop. The company which had every single store in Sweden closed when their completely outsourced IT at Kaseya got hacked in 2021.

    You'd think they would have been better prepared, but no.

  12. JoeCool Silver badge

    Danfoss needs to be a little more proactive

    If these interfaces are there for support/maintenance, surely one such maintenance is updating the firmware for security patches ?

    Or at least flagging a store for follow up ?

    It's easy to say that the store staff should know the tech. But the reason the systems are in the internet is because they do not.

    1. Uh, Mike Bronze badge

      Re: Danfoss needs to be a little more proactive

      "I read the manual and got it working."

      1. Dwarf

        Re: Danfoss needs to be a little more proactive

        Yep, that's one of my go-to lines about developers

        Developers stop once the code works, not when its secure.

        Generally with observations that security is someone else's problem.

    2. Spazturtle Silver badge

      Re: Danfoss needs to be a little more proactive

      This issue is only present if you run the Danfoss controllers in ‘Backward Compatible’ mode which switches from HTTPS to HTTP and disables most security, as well as allowing setting to be changed by uploading an XML file. In 'Strict' mode you have to use HTTPS, use newer crypto, and requires XML files to be signed with a certificate.

      In 2024 Danfoss send out a software update that automatically switched all controllers to Strict mode, end uses needed to manually switch back to Backward Compatible mode if they wanted to use it.

      1. FirstTangoInParis Silver badge

        Re: Danfoss needs to be a little more proactive

        > Danfoss send out a software update

        Hmm, wonder how that went?

        1. Installed and technician told to revert to old ways.

        2. Not installed as this would mess things up / mean downtime / means having to send technicians to sites with travel expenses and all.

        1. Locomotion69

          Re: Danfoss needs to be a little more proactive

          3. Made it incompatible with the cheapass solution engineered by an nunidentified PFY who left no documentation whatsoever, running on a Windows 98 computersystem.

        2. JoeCool Silver badge

          Re: Danfoss needs to be a little more proactive

          4. There is no micro usb port on this media drive.

  13. Uh, Mike Bronze badge

    Low Tech Solution

    Night guards could come back into fashion.

    They're not just for burglars anymore.

    (They never were.)

  14. Sproggit Silver badge

    Lest We Forget

    There has recently been a marked up-tick in sabotage across Europe, with much of the suspicion falling on Russia:-

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c5y4g6meekro

    https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2026/10/29/russias-alleged-sabotage-campaign-in-europe-raises-fears-of-escalation

    https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/sep/20/baltic-spy-chiefs-warn-moscow-is-preparing-for-more-decisive-action-in-europe

    https://edition.cnn.com/2026/09/17/europe/russia-attacks-europe-misstep-analysis-intl

    https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/cia-drone-europe-russia-ukraine-b3055605.html

    In parallel, European governments are warning citizens to maintain food reserves in their homes, to safeguard against food supply disruption caused by cyber attacks:-

    https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/uk-government-preparedness-emergency-kit-stock-up-food-b3076133.html

    The attacks on freezers have all the hallmarks of someone "test firing" attacks against common food supply infrastructure. The drones at airports would disrupt air freight of food... It would not take much to attempt something similar by compromising the main distribution centers used by major supermarket chains.

    It is more than a little disconcerting that we don't seem to be taking this seriously.

    1. jdiebdhidbsusbvwbsidnsoskebid Silver badge

      Re: Lest We Forget

      I wonder how comfortable anyone with an internet connected heating thermostat, smart meter, car charger etc. is feeling right now.

      I've got nothing connected like that, but I can't feel smug. I'm still at the mercy of the infrastructure providers. I could keep my broadband connection and phone going but what's the point when noone is able to answer. My friend is pretty much self sufficient in electricity with their solar PV fit ... but the control unit is internet connected for billing and monitoring.

      1. FirstTangoInParis Silver badge

        Re: Lest We Forget

        Anyone getting into Ring or similar could annoy users by issuing constant alerts.

        Hacking into home thermostats such as Hive will cause bigger bills.

        Wasn’t Yale hacked or did their front door locks just stop working?

        1. jdiebdhidbsusbvwbsidnsoskebid Silver badge

          Re: Lest We Forget

          "Hacking into home thermostats such as Hive will cause bigger bills."

          That's the least thing to worry about. More serious will be the bad actor (let's face it, Russia is our number 1 worry) shutting down the thermostats on the coldest day of the year. Optimum time would be after midnight once most people are asleep, only to wake up to an already cold house in the morning.

          At best it will lead to emergency services being overwhelmed by calls to vulnerable people suffering in the cold, local authorities housing such people in leisure centres etc. and a run on the shops as people panic buy electric heaters and cup-a-soups.

          The worst (that I can think of) will be all of the above but with added mass panic buying and stockpiling toilet rolls followed by riots in the streets, most likely triggered by a government spokesperson saying there is no need to panic. Personally, I'm prepping already with 40 pints of best brewing in the shed. Soon I'll be 'stilling to provide for the other half too. You can prise my homebrew out of my cold (very), dead (not yet) hands.

          1. Anonymous Coward
            Anonymous Coward

            Re: Lest We Forget

            The more nefarious action would be to switch them all off and on, repeatedly, and in a synchronised manner, until they blow, or the grid blows.

            You're welcome.

    2. CrazyOldCatMan Silver badge

      Re: Lest We Forget

      It is more than a little disconcerting that we don't seem to be taking this seriously.

      I suspect that, in the quiet back room of GCHQ et. al., it's being taken *very* seriously. Whether our elected Lords and Ladies listen is another matter.

  15. VoiceOfTruth Silver badge

    They did it once

    They won't do it again.

    Oh. No lessons were learned. Security was not improved. Doors were left open. Passwords, if any, were reset to password1.

    1. RM Myers Silver badge
      Unhappy

      Re: They did it once

      What are you doing! Don't tell everyone my password! Geez, some people.

  16. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    A lot of comments from people who obviously have no clue about industrial systems.

    1. Boris the Cockroach Silver badge
      Meh

      We do have

      a clue about industrial systems.

      Thats why our shop floor network is air gapped to the front office network and general internot, so that our industrial robotic cells and 5 axis machining centers dont have a funny 5 minutes when the hackers find out they can control them (also steal a lot of NDA covered data).

      But I'm just as puzzled as to why the controllers can receive commands from the internet, rather than only send data to a fixed IP, and that computer has the job of formatting and emailing people who need to know stuff. and in the case of defrosting stuff, they have to be emptied first, so the manager should be able to physically set a switch to allow commands in from head office to set the system to 'defrost' and once the maintenance cycle is complete, set the system back to send only.

      But what do I know.... I'm just robot programmer with a side interest in keeping our system secure... ish

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      re: A lot of comments from people who obviously have no clue about industrial systems.

      How dare you downvote me for that! I'm just hiding my identity because that was business sensitive snark!

  17. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    CSIRT CRA ENISA faiure

    this shows all the european CSIRTs failed and the CRA is an ineffective paper-law failure. this should never have happend, the fridge manufacturer is 100% responsible for firmware updates under the CRA, but if customers dont update the CRA is. of no practical or effective use

    1. Dan 55 Silver badge

      Re: CSIRT CRA ENISA faiure

      Of course it is. Insurance companies can point to updates from the manufacturer which were not installed in a timely manner ("supermarkets' claims could be affected if they lacked the latest software updates, four insurance brokers told Reuters") and say, sorry, you're on your own here.

      1. CrazyOldCatMan Silver badge

        Re: CSIRT CRA ENISA faiure

        supermarkets' claims could be affected if they lacked the latest software updates, four insurance brokers told Reuters

        Like most 'cyber' (I loathe that word. It's generally used by people who don't understand the first thing about computers or security to make them sound clued-up) insurance specifically has clauses about applying updates in a timely manner.

        No updates? No payout. It's about the only lever they have for reducing the risk.

  18. The man with a spanner

    Why has a fridge got a 50 degree setting? What posible use would this be and how do you get fridge technology to act as a heater?

    1. POKE 23692,255

      It's for rapid defrosting.

    2. Eric 9001 Bronze badge

      Fridges and freezes utilize a heat pump - heat pumps can be driven in forwards (cool) or reverse (heat) if designed so.

      Older fridges used heating coils for defrosting, but it's far more energy efficient to just drive the heat pump in reverse.

      Even if there's no specific setting for cooking the food, if an attacker can just login to the remote interface with hardcoded credentials, the temp can be manually set to 50°C (it's not like the software enforces a time limit on the defrost length) and the heat-pump hardware will make that the temp.

      1. JulieM

        [I]f an attacker can just login to the remote interface with hardcoded credentials, the temp can be manually set to 50°C (it's not like the software enforces a time limit on the defrost length) and the heat-pump hardware will make that the temp.
        Why does the remote interface allow the temperature to be changed? What good did anyone imagine that was ever possibly going to do?

        1. Eric 9001 Bronze badge
          Boffin

          Inspecting the GNU/Linux OS that the "sm800a" control unit runs, it looks like the temperature can be set with a SNMP, PI200 or a web interface, or by logging in via ssh (over wired ethernet and of course Wi-Fi).

          A web interface still wouldn't necessarily be a problem provided the unit isn't connected to the internet (for example, you have 1000 units and a LAN that an offline computer can access for monitoring and control).

          A sane design would be to have a control unit that refuses to work over the internet (although such safeguard would be easy to bypass) and if there must be internet monitoring, for the monitoring unit to only have the ability to read (a RS-232 or UART or RS-485 read-only interface is not hard).

          Even the online interface isn't programmed to allow setting the temperature, making a control unit accessible over the internet is a terrible idea, as a skilled attacker could likely exploit the software to set the temperature (while exploiting a monitoring unit would only allow setting false monitoring values).

          I certainly hope that /danfoss/certs/cert.pem & /danfoss/certs/privkey.key are randomly generated per unit (it seems the units would be vulnerable to emudra TLS MiTM, due to cross-signing, unless they import TLS revocation certs, as the latest possible version of ca-certificates would be the current version on 2025-09-30).

          https://sm800a.danfoss.com/sw_shared/

          https://sm800a.danfoss.com/Danux_shared/

          (There's a massive lack of written offer or source code for the GPLv2 and GPLv3 software contained within (or any attribution for the software under weak licenses))

    3. MachDiamond Silver badge

      "Why has a fridge got a 50 degree setting? What posible use would this be and how do you get fridge technology to act as a heater?"

      Every so often, the evaporator coils are heated to melt ice that accumulates on them which makes them inefficient. The cycle doesn't last that long and has a barely measurable impact on the temperature of the freezer. Now, if you set the controls to run the defrost cycle continuously, the freezer can get quite hot as the compressor is shut off at the same time the defrost heater is running. In the case of a heat pump arrangement (which isn't common for large scale freezers), the cycle could just be run backwards until the ice drops off the coils. It's tunable to match the local conditions. It's very dry where I live, but someplace such as Florida can be very humid and ice will build up more quickly. It can all be handled with local controls rather than centrally managed by Bob in another country.

  19. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Eek

    Many European cyber security guys probably about to stroke out after a month of begging manglement to let them run updates and put additional controls in place and being told no due to 'can't afford downtime', 'no money for resources to update', 'it won't happen twice' etc etc.

    I hope they all have offline copies of the warning emails they sent.

    But they should know the first rule of cyber security = 1# Cover your arse

  20. JulieM
    WTF?

    Whiskey Tango Foxtrot?

    Why the hell did they make it possible for anyone to change the set temperature, or initiate a defrost cycle, remotely?

    There are plenty of reasons why you might want to read the temperature of a refrigerator remotely; but there is absolutely no reason for temperature set points not to be read-only. At all. If the temperature is higher than it should be, and there is not an automatic defrost cycle in progress, there is clearly something amiss; and whatever it is, it can only be sorted out by sending someone to the site.

    It has been known since the days of analogue control systems that you never put anything adjustable in a place where it is accessible to members of the general public.

    1. MachDiamond Silver badge

      Re: Whiskey Tango Foxtrot?

      "If the temperature is higher than it should be, and there is not an automatic defrost cycle in progress, there is clearly something amiss; and whatever it is, it can only be sorted out by sending someone to the site."

      And if one is talking about a large freezer stuffed with food, the cost of sending somebody to have a look pales in comparison to mucking out a load of half-cooked biohazard. Obviously, something will need to be done and done quickly before trip points are hit that requires the food to be written off and disposed of.

  21. Dan 55 Silver badge

    Frozen Part III

    Now showing in the UK

    Linked to Russia of course. Couldn't they be disconnected from the Internet? Nothing of worth would be lost.

  22. Sp1z

    I've solved this, and it's REALLY easy

    https://bsky.app/profile/sp1z.bsky.social/post/3mzgjapkq422i

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon